10 Liverpool Players Who Fell Out With The Manager

Beneath the surface of the 'family' club lies friction, arguments and bust-ups.

It's normal for bust-ups to occur at a football club - players can become disillusioned and disgruntled waiting on the sidelines for an opportunity, and tempers can flare due to a risky challenge in training. Fall-outs and bust-ups are certainly not a novelty in this sport, but at Liverpool, there have been quite a few bust-ups over the years which have led to a subsequent departure. For such a harmonious club which plays on its' emotional ties and title as a 'family' club, it may come as something of a surprise to learn how many players have actually fallen out with their managers in recent years. Interestingly, there is a common theme in this list, with one man's distant and harsh demeanour seemingly alienating most of his squad during his tenure, which consequently led to some friction. In more cases than not, when a bust-up occurs, either manager or player has to make way, and usually it is the manager who wins out. Take a look at the ten players who fell out with their managers during their stay on Merseyside.

10. Daniel Agger

Daniel Agger was a stalwart at Anfield for eight and a half years, but for one reason or another, he and Brendan Rodgers just did not click. The 29 year old has since admitted that were it not for the Northern Irish boss, that he would probably still be at Liverpool, and not back at Brondby whom he transferred to for £3 million in August.
''Let me put it this way: me and the manager were perhaps not on the same page for all of last season. For most of last season at least. There was some distance between us and for me that was enough. I didn۪t feel that he appreciated the things I contributed. And when I feel that, then it is time to move on. Maybe where it went wrong between me and him is that I am very direct. I say things as they are, and also expect that people are to me. Maybe it۪s wrong to expect that.۪۪ - Daniel Agger, September 2014.
The Danish centre-half probably has a point, having made only 20 league appearances for the Reds last season, as Rodgers leant towards the partnership of Martin Skrtel and Mamadou Sakho.
''I think Dan gave his reasons for leaving when he left and we wished him well when he went. Out of respect to him, I don۪t really want to say any more on it. We wished him well and he is a Brondby player now - he has moved on.۪۪ - Brendan Rodgers, September 2014.
Has he though, Brendan? He could have fooled us.

9. Pepe Reina

When Pepe Reina wrote a goodbye letter to Liverpool supporters following the club€™s decision to loan him to Napoli at the start of the 13/14 season, he was intimating that it was Brendan Rodgers who was ending his eight-year Anfield career, but in reality, writing that letter was the final nail in his coffin on Merseyside.
''He۪s already written his letter, hasn۪t he? He wrote a goodbye letter, didn۪t he? I was surprised at the letter - when you a re a loan player, I would expect that he should come back, but obviously Pepe made it very clear when he went to Napoli that he was looking to move. He penned a great big letter saying he was going to work with the best manager that he۪d worked with and thanked him for his time for Liverpool. So, for me, it probably sounded like he۪d made his decision there.۪۪ - Brendan Rodgers, February 2014.
What was the reason for the souring of Reina€™s relationship, which now sees him destined to seeing out the next few years of his career serving as Manuel Neuer€™s water-carrier? In a similar fashion to when Harry Redknapp flirted with the England job while assuming his Spurs job would be there as a fall-back option, Rodgers was unimpressed with the Spaniard€™s constant attempts to secure a move to Barcelona in the summer of 2013, and decided to give him the boot.

8. Jerzy Dudek

The hero in Istanbul, it€™s probably understandable that Jerzy Dudek found himself frustrated at having been completely frozen out of the Liverpool side the following campaign, following the arrival of Pepe Reina from Villareal. Flaring tempers finally came to a head at the turn of the year, when the disgruntled Pole hit out at Benitez for refusing him a transfer away from the club.
''It۪s the latest lot of rubbish from Benitez. Even if he wants to play me in a Liverpool match, I don۪t want to play for this club any more. I can۪t see any point talking further with Benitez. It۪s a waste of time. I have decided to leave Liverpool whatever the cost and I won۪t change my mind. Benitez just makes the frustration deeper. I didn۪t go to Luton last Saturday to make it clear that I۪m not interested in being second-choice keeper. Why doesn۪t he behave like a decent person for once in his life and start treating me in a proper way, like I always have him?۪۪ - Jerzy Dudek, January 2006.
To demonstrate his insistance on becoming a first-choice goalkeeper again, Dudek subsequently signed for Real Madrid in the summer, where he subsequently had front row seats to Iker Casillas€™ performances each week for the remaining four years of his career.

7. Nicolas Anelka

Nicolas Anelka wasn€™t ordained with the nickname €˜Le Sulk€™ for nothing. He has fallen out with more people in football than he would care to mention, culminating in bans from football and expulsions from the national team. The stroppy Frenchman doesn€™t stick around at clubs for too long, such is his volatile demeanour - indeed his longest stint was a meagre four-year spell at Chelsea. However, were it not for one of his trademark bust-ups with the coach, might he have stayed at Anfield for a little longer than the solo season he spent on loan from PSG in 01/02? The pair had always had a tetchy relationship dating back to the mid-90s, when the former Anfield boss was in charge of the French u-17 side. Initially, Anelka was reluctant to even sign on loan to play for the manager who had chosen David Trezeguet and Thierry Henry ahead of him, and these old sparks came to the fore during their time together on Merseyside.
''I honestly think an English coach would have signed me permanently, but because he was French, he had too many preconceived ideas about me and so didn۪t want to sign me. I was happy at Arsenal with Arsene Wenger, but then he۪s a different type of Frenchman. Everybody wanted me to stay. Everyone except Gerard Houllier, and he made the decision not to keep me.۪۪ - Nicolas Anelka, August 2002.
Not bitter about his forced move to Manchester City in the slightest then, Nic?

6. Ronnie Whelan

As everybody knows, Graeme Souness has often struggled to keep a lid on his temper in the past, especially when dealing with the rambunctious sort ala Andy Cole, Dwight Yorke and Craig Bellamy. Perhaps it€™s why he hasn€™t managed a football team in almost a decade. During his failed stint as manager of Liverpool during the early 90€™s, the volatile Scot was feeling the pressure due to a string of poor results during the 92/93 season, and decided to take it out on members of the Liverpool squad. Ronnie Whelan describes how it was a 4-1 reverse at Ewood Park where he decided to challenge his manager.
''Souey started ranting about €˜the older players€™ in the Ewood Park dressing room that day. I took exception. He didn€™t name us but he was referring to me, Nicol, Barnes and Rush. Souey€™s accusation was that we weren€™t doing enough to help the younger lads along. I was fuming inside, because, number one, there was no acknowledgement from him that he might be at fault too. And number too, it wasn€™t true. I said to Souey, €˜Look, it€™s not as simple as that. You try talking to them and they tell you to f*** off€™. He was losing it now. It just descended into a shouting match. He kept challenging me. So I snapped back at him. €˜Ah, just f*** off and leave me alone.€™ You can imagine the silence around the room. I was getting shot down completely and no one backed me up, which was a bit of a sad situation really. Nine months after that bust-up at Blackburn, Graeme resigned.€™€™ - Ronnie Whelan, August 2011.

5. Yossi Benayoun

Not many knew about it, as Yossi Benayoun seemed like a quiet, affable chap, but even the Israeli fan favourite was at the centre of a bust-up with Rafa Benitez. Such was the Spaniard€™s apparent cold, robotic and distant demeanour, alienating members of his squad, this list could have been filled purely with players who became fed up of the former Valencia boss€™ antics. There always did seem something amiss about Benayoun€™s transfer to Chelsea in 2010, such was his popularity on Merseyside, but according to the former West Ham playmaker, there was only one man responsible for that heavy-hearted decision.
''Everyone asks me why I left Liverpool. There is only one reason - Rafa Benitez. If I played well, I never felt he gave me credit. When I scored, I still expected to be out of the team the next game. On two occasions early last season, against Fulham and Lyon, the fans booed when I was subbed. They thought I was playing well but Benitez told me he was surprised the fans booed because i was not good enough. He tried to destroy my confidence. You can۪t treat a player like this and expect him to be happy. Benitez tried to break me like he broke Riera. Chelsea made an offer, and the deal was done before Benitez left.۪۪ - Yossi Benayoun, July 2010.
Needless to say, Benayoun must have been crying into his porridge when news broke that Benitez had taken over as Chelsea interim boss during the 12/13 season.

4. Albert Riera

Rafa Benitez was known to be a cold manager during his time at Anfield, keeping the players at an arms€™ length. It was this impersonal approach that led to the Spaniard falling out with several members of his squad, including Spanish winger Albert Riera. Having signed from Espanyol in 2008 for £6 million, the Spaniard grew weary of Benitez€™ lack of communication, and his struggles for game-time with a World Cup on the horizon.
''He۪s never sorted out a situation with a player by talking with him. I would like to spend my whole career here, but we players live to play. My aim is to go to the World Cup and for this I have to be playing. When the coach says nothing to you and you are well, with no physical problems and training well, you cannot help but think it must be something personal. If I۪m doing something badly and you are my boss, and you value me, then you are going to come and tell me what I have to do to play again. This is what hurts me. He thinks he۪s in charge and everything else falls on deaf ears. His dialogue with the players is practically nil.۪۪ - Albert Riera, March 2010.
This scathing attack resulted in the former Espanyol winger being suspended and fined by the club, before being offloaded to Greek side Olympiakos at the end of the season.

3. Djibril Cisse

It€™s worth remembering that while Djibril Cisse€™s first season spent at Liverpool was working under the guidance of Rafa Benitez, he wasn€™t actually signed by the Spaniard. The Frenchman would pick up a horrendous broken leg during his debut season at the club, restricting him to just 25 appearances in all competitions, although the following season he played in nearly 60 games, scoring 19 times including a goal in the FA Cup final. It wouldn€™t stop Benitez from attempting to wield the axe on his Anfield career, however, much to the £14 million man€™s outrage.
''I have a coach who doesn۪t want me. Benitez doesn۪t use me, so I۪ve taken a step backwards. He doesn۪t like me. You can۪t please everyone. But I don۪t think I could stand another season like the one i۪ve just had.۪۪ - Djibril Cisse, May 2006.
Benitez subsequently offered Cisse zero sympathy for a situation which found him slipping down the pecking order, blaming his work ethic.
''At Auxerre, he didn۪t have any responsibility for defending or the tactics of the team; he could do his own thing. At a big club like Liverpool, he needs to learn that he has to work for his team-mates. He has to understand the difference between a club that plays to win games and a club that plays to win trophies.۪۪ - Rafa Benitez, May 2006.
Three months later, the Frenchman was once again taking to the media to share the latest titbits in the Benitez feud, having been irked by the Spaniard€™s recent claims that he was a troublemaker.
''I€™m a troublemaker? So why did Harry Kewell dedicate his goal to me in the World Cup? How can I be a troublemaker if someone like that thought of me ahead of his family, his children and his wife? Everybody likes me, I am not scared to say that. I have kept my cool. The manager put me on the bench five times, six times, he put me right side, then left side and I never moaned. Now he has asked me to leave. It is too much. It is too easy to make it look like I want to go, but he should be man enough to admit that he wants me to leave.'€™ - Djibril Cisse, August 2006.
He never played for Liverpool again.

2. Paul Ince

As his illness grew more severe throughout the following years, Anfield boss Gerard Houllier became the pale imitation of the man who tore strips from Paul Ince - €˜The Guv€™nor€™ who was perceived as being the most powerful person at the club at the time. Liverpool had been leading an FA Cup fourth-round tie at Old Trafford in 1999 against their bitter north-west rivals when their captain meekly limped off with an injury, allowing Manchester United to fight back and win the game 2-1.
''Ince was the unwitting victim of the most brutal exhibition of management I have seen at Anfield. There was a team meeting a week later, and Ince decided, as club captain, it was time to take Houllier on. He questioned training methods and the response was furiously impressive. Fixing Ince with a stare, Houllier asked: €˜Since the day I arrived, how many five-a-side have you won? I€™ll tell you - four in six months.€™ Ince was bewildered, as we all were, by Houllier€™s memory and grasp of detail, and it didn€™t end there. €˜Now perhaps you can explain to the lads what happened to you against United. When my team are 1-0 up at Old Trafford in a cup tie, I don€™t expect my captain to limp off with an injury. If he has to come off, I expect it to be on a stretcher.€™€™ - Jamie Carragher, September 2008.
Ince had been well and truly put in his place, but the indignant England international was always going to try and take down the man who had humiliated him so, following a move to Middlesbrough in 1999.
''I want Houllier to get the sack and take (Phil) Thompson down with him. If they think people are no longer any use to them, they treat those people like dirt. It۪s disgraceful the way Houllier has treated me and other players at the club. He comes from France and I can۪t even believe he۪s managed a team before because he certainly doesn۪t seem to know how to.۪۪ - Paul Ince,
Judging by Ince€™s efforts at Blackburn Rovers nine years later, the same could be said for him.

1. Robbie Fowler

Life was made so much harder for Gerard Houllier at Anfield when he decided to take on €˜God€™. Despite Fowler€™s abundance of goals plundered for the Reds, and his Messiah-like stature amongst the Kopites, Houllier was still prepared to push him through the exit. Having dropped him for the first leg of a Worthington Cup semi-final meeting with Crystal Palace, the Frenchman simply offered the reason that he €˜decided he was not€™, although he did hint that it may had something to do with Fowler€™s late night antics the week before.
''Robbie would acknowledge that being outside a city centre bar at two in the morning is at the wrong place and wrong time for any professional footballer. I feel strongly about that and have pointed it out, but there was no punishment in playing him in the reserves on Monday.۪۪ - Gerard Houllier, January 2001.
While the Scouse icon captained the side to victory in the Worthington Cup final, he was restricted to cameo appearances in the finals of the FA Cup and UEFA Cup, before being dropped completely for the following season€™s Charity Shield encounter with Manchester United following a bust-up with assistant boss Phil Thompson. It would prove to be his last season for the club - until he was brought back as a 29 year old on a free transfer - and Fowler maintains that he never wanted to leave in the first place.
''I know I should still be at Liverpool now. It۪s easy for me to blame Gerard Houllier for what happened, easy for me to say that I made a huge mistake in allowing his underhand campaign to force me out. Houllier did what he had to do, I guess he did what he thought was in the best interests of the club. However, I still wish he hadn۪t walked in that door at the start of the 1998 season. Houllier never gave me any respect.۪۪ - Robbie Fowler, February 2004.
So, that's a wrap - what do you think? As always, feel free to leave your thoughts and opinions in the comment section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Recent Journalism & New Media graduate. Insatiable thirst for all things football, and hopes to break into the field of sports journalism in the near future. Have made a significantly insignificant playing career out of receiving several slaps around the head for not passing the ball.