10 Notable Absentees From England’s World Cup Squad
These players have got to be feeling disappointed at missing out.
On Wednesday, Gareth Southgate announced his England squad to mixed reactions. Some fans said that it was more or less the best squad we could hope for, while others argued that Player X should have been included at the expense of Player Y.
World Cup squad announcements are always a source of controversy, and fans will never be in total agreement on this issue, but the general consensus seems to be that Southgate has played it pretty safe with his selections, not taking any major risks or springing any unexpected surprises.
A few former stars have been left out, while cases could have been made for several other players who didn't get on the final list, so let's take a look at ten English players who would have been hoping for a call-up and might be feeling a little hard done by.
In a few weeks, we'll see how England get on when the big event finally kicks off, and if it all ends terribly, Three Lions fans will look back to the squad announcement and perhaps suggest that one or two of these players could have made a big difference, had they been included.
10. Jonjo Shelvey
If you browsed social media in the wake of the England squad announcement, one name kept popping up time and time again: Jonjo Shelvey. Many Three Lions fans and football pundits argued that the Newcastle midfielder would have provided the creativity that seems to be sorely lacking in England's midfield.
Southgate himself has come out and said that Shelvey didn't have the right style of play to fit in with the system he wants to use in Russia, while questions have also been raised about Shelvey's temperament, with the 26-year-old well-known for picking up unnecessary yellow and red cards from time to time.
In Shelvey's defence, he's already played for England on six occasions and has proven himself to be one of the most forward-thinking midfielders available for selection. He's had a great season, creating a lot of chances for his teammates and consistently impressing fans with precise through balls and impressive long distance shots. If England find themselves struggling to score goals in Russia, they might rue not gambling on Shelvey's creativity.
9. Daniel Sturridge
It's hardly surprising that Daniel Sturridge missed out on the England squad. The Liverpool forward has had a shocker of a season, with an ill-advised loan move to West Brom only confounding his misery after suffering a hamstring injury in February.
He only scored two league goals all season, and won't be looking back on 2017-18 as a particularly memorable year. With the likes of Harry Kane and Jamie Vardy scoring many more goals and having far better seasons, there can be no doubt that Sturridge simply can't be classed among England's first choice forwards anymore.
However, the fact that Danny Welbeck still got in the squad, despite not having a particularly great season either, could frustrate Sturridge, who has proven himself a reliable performer at past tournaments, scoring in both the 2014 World Cup and Euro 2016. He also scored a couple of good goals during England's World Cup qualification run and might have hoped that his past successes and individual skill would be enough to buy him a ticket to Russia.
8. Adam Lallana
Another player whose injury troubles and poor domestic form have seem him ousted from the national side, Lallana can feel a little aggrieved to be left out of the World Cup, having scored a couple of goals and played well during qualification.
He's only played a handful of minutes for Liverpool since the start of 2018 but, at the age of 30, this was probably one of his last chances of appearing at a major tournament for his country, and it's a shame to see that England's Player of the Year for 2016 has fallen out of favour so quickly. He is, however, on Southgate's stand-by list, so could still be called up if another player pulls out.
One of England's most consistent and versatile performers, Lallana is capable of playing in multiple positions and has often demonstrated a real sense of pride at pulling on the shirt of the national side. If he does end up in the final squad, his experience could prove beneficial to the younger players.
7. Jermain Defoe
At 35 years of age, this was Defoe's final opportunity to demonstrate his skills on the grandest stage of all, but it just wasn't meant to be. The former Tottenham and Toronto FC man has had a substandard season with Bournemouth and was never too likely to get a ticket to Russia, but had openly stated his desire to play for England again and was clearly doing his best to convince Southgate of his qualities.
Sadly, his best wasn't quite good enough. He only scored four league goals in two dozen appearances this year, contributing to his team's efforts with some decent hold-up play and solid performances, but lacking the pace and firepower that once made him such a lethal finisher in the past.
In spite of his poor form, an argument could have been made to include Defoe. For England, he's been very reliable down the years, scoring 20 goals in 57 appearances, and his experience and knack for getting in good positions could have been handy in the last 10-20 minutes of tough games.
6. Chris Smalling
Manchester United fans were confused by the news that one of their regular starting defenders wouldn't be on the plane to Russia. Smalling has, after all, played a part in United's second-place season, being a key cog in Jose Mourinho's solid defensive machine, and even contributing with 4 league goals, which is his best ever return.
Smalling helped England qualify for the World Cup and has long been regarded as a solid if unspectacular central defender for the Three Lions to rely on. Gareth Southgate, however, has a different opinion of the Red Devils man, openly saying that he respects Smalling as a player but doesn't believe that he fits in with the system he wants to play.
Southgate has put a lot of emphasis on playing out from the back, preferring to pick defenders who are a little more comfortable on the ball and capable of picking out passes like John Stones and Phil Jones. However, if the going gets tough and England find themselves playing one of the bigger teams, Smalling's solidity could be missed.
5. Nathaniel Clyne
It doesn't seem like that long ago that Nathaniel Clyne was one of England's most exciting full-backs, but the former Southampton and Crystal Palace man hasn't actually turned out for the Three Lions since 2016. In his place, fellow Liverpool full-back Trent Alexander-Arnold has been called up, despite never appearing for England before, and it remains to be seen if this risky pick will pay off.
A big injury left Clyne out of action for most of the latest Premier League season, but he did have an outside chance of making the squad after finally pulling on a Liverpool shirt again and playing in a few games over the last few weeks.
Some great players miss large parts of the season but still end up getting picked for international tournaments because of past successes, but Gareth Southgate has put a lot of emphasis on his philosophy of only picking players who are in form and playing regularly, so Clyne's hopes of going to Russia were never much more than a pipe dream.
4. Ryan Bertrand
Ryan Bertrand played a big part in England's qualifying campaign for the 2018 World Cup and will probably be feeling very disappointed to not have been called up for the finals. Southgate said that choosing not to take the Southampton full-back was one of the toughest decisions he had to make, but explained that the full-backs he settled on had been more impressive over the course of the domestic season.
Bertrand has been ever-present for Southampton this season, contributing with four assists in the Premier League as the Saints narrowly avoided relegation. At 28 years of age, he would have been one of the Three Lions' most experienced players, had he been chosen.
Instead, he'll be watching the games on TV like the rest of us. Bertrand hasn't been as impressive as Manchester United's Ashley Young, but could be aggrieved to see Danny Rose, who has only played in 10 league games for Tottenham, selected ahead of him.
3. Joe Hart
What a terrible couple of years it has been for Joe Hart. Ousted at Man City by Pep Guardiola, who clearly had some kind of sixth sense about the England stopper's imminent demise, Hart went on to have a terrible time in Torino and then couldn't even hold down the number one spot at West Ham.
It's no surprise, therefore, that he hasn't been selected to accompany the Three Lions to Russia, with Jordan Pickford, Jack Butland, and the excellent Nick Pope chosen ahead of him. Only a few years ago, Hart was celebrating his fourth Golden Glove award in the Premier League and had consistently proven to be a real rock for both Man City and the national side, but his form took a major dip in subsequent seasons.
Few would argue that Hart should be England's starting stopper, but an argument could be made in favour of him going to Russia. He has a lot of experience at international level and is clearly a big personality in the dressing room. His strong mentality and confident attitude could have played a part in encouraging the younger players.
2. James Tarkowski
It's tricky to understand exactly why James Tarkowski, who has been one of the most impressive Premier League defenders of the last year, hasn't earned his spot on the plane. Tarkowski is on the back-up list, but many fans and pundits had expected him to be on the plane by default.
Tarkowski's stats speak for themselves. He's helped Burnley to a Europa League place in the Premier League and contributed with countless clearances and interceptions in almost every game. Linked with several high profile clubs, Tarkowski's performances haven't gone unnoticed, but clearly weren't enough for Southgate to select him over the likes of Gary Cahill, Phil Jones, or Harry Maguire.
Southgate gave Tarkowski a chance in a friendly earlier in the year, with the Burnley man impressing overall but ultimately giving away a soft penalty, which must have worked against him in Southgate's mind. Since he's on the back-up list, he might still get to go to Russia and could surely contribute to the Three Lions' defensive line if so.
1. Jack Wilshere
Once regarded as one of England's brightest prospects and Arsenal's most exciting players, the stock of Jack Wilshere has tumbled spectacularly over the last couple of years. Arsenal fans still rate him highly and appreciate his work rate and attitude, while many England fans wouldn't have been upset to see him in the final squad, but the player can't have too many complaints about being left out.
Constant injuries have repeatedly interrupted Wilshere's career, and he hasn't been able to pull on an England shirt since 2016. He was called up for the last set of friendlies, but once again picked up an injury and was unable to play any part in the games. He started 12 league games for Arsenal this season, contributing with one goal and three assists, but it's just not enough.
Wilshere has talent, that much is clear, but his physical fragility has consistently held him back. Unfortunately, despite a promising start to his career that saw him compared with the likes of Andres Iniesta, Wilshere will probably go down in history as a player who was always one step away from true greatness but never quite made it.