10 Players Who Completely Failed At Manchester United

For every Eric Cantona there's an Anderson lurking around the corner...

Chelsea fans' reactions to the news that Falcao has signed for them
Richard Sellers/EMPICS Sport

As the world's most valuable sporting club, a lot is expected of Manchester United's players, management and even the fans. Disappointing positions in recent years have threatened to take much of the shine off the club, even with Sir Alex Ferguson's huge successes still fresh in the memory.

By the look of it, it seems things aren't going to improve until even more money is invested in so-called 'World Class Talent'. And unfortunately, the Red Devils have a far from unblemished record when it comes to spending big to bolster their squad.

Despite signing some of the world's top players, United simply haven't gotten value for money on other deals. Looking back on some of the more notorious examples, it's hard not to agree with Arsene Wenger that price and billing with the press don't always count for much when it comes to signing the RIGHT players.

And while fan backlash has often been the downfall of players at Old Trafford, sometimes the toxic reactions are entirely warranted.

Even Sir Alex dropped a few transfer clangers over the years, chasing a new generation of great stars, but he definitely wasn't the only one to waste money on failures...

10. William Prunier

William Prunier Man United
Neal Simpson/EMPICS Sport

28-year-old, experienced French defender Prunier arrived at Old Trafford on trial in 1995 and big things were expected of him. After all, he was a former team mate of United's midfield talisman Eric Cantona.

Prunier was thrust into the first team almost immediately after his arrival as Sir Alex was without his three first-choice centre backs: Bruce, May and Pallister. And to his credit, the Frenchman rose to the challenge of the Premier League very ably and partnered a young Gary Neville against QPR. His distribution and interceptions caught the eye and Ferguson kept faith with him for the following game against Tottenham.

The game got off to a terrible start when both Denis Irwin and Peter Schmeichel joined the injury list, and it didn't look like things couldn't get much worse. Sadly they could as Prunier completely forgot how to play football and stood by and watched as United conceded four goals.

Bizarrely, Sir Alex offered Prunier another month's worth of a trial but the Frenchman opted against remaining with the club. Probably a wise decision overall as the fans recently voted him the sixth worst United player in history.


9. Alexander Buttner

Alexander Buttner Man Utd
Mike Egerton/EMPICS Sport

When he signed, Dutch full back Alexander Buttner was expected to act as understudy to the ageing Patrice Evra and was one of Sir Alex Ferguson's last signings for the club before his retirement at the end of the 2012/13 season.

Buttner seemed to have everything Ferguson wanted from his full backs: pace, skill, vision and a very capable left foot but looks were deceiving as the Dutchman failed to impress when given his chance to shine.

Even David Moyes didn't take a liking to Buttner and the Dutchman found his playing time limited but it wasn't until Louis Van Gaal was confirmed as the incoming Manchester United manager that Buttner held his hands up and declared he wanted to leave.

Apparently, he and Van Gaal have a long-standing, personal rift that would've made any further time in Manchester torturous for the left back. Luckily for him, Dynamo Moscow paid £4.4 million to end his United nightmare, which actually turned a small profit for the Old Trafford club too.


8. Anderson

Anderson Man Utd
Neal Simpson/EMPICS Sport

Just like Kleberson before him, Brazilian midfielder Anderson is widely believed to be one of the worst players ever to play for Manchester United. Unlike his predecessor, Anderson was well known in Europe thanks to his time at Porto but he never managed to perform to any similar standard at United as he had in the Portuguese League.

Youtube videos were passed around pubs, playgrounds and anywhere else people would pay attention when United were linked with Anderson. He had garnered fame for his supposed mastery of the 'Hocus-Pocus' manoeuvre and his antics drew the attention of Sir Alex amidst whispers that he could be the "next Ronaldinho."

But then the midfielder rocked up at Carrington alongside Carlos Tevez in a very busy transfer window for Manchester United, as the club pre-empted the loss of Cristiano Ronaldo.

The Mail suggest the fee was close to £26 million pounds and every single penny was wasted as Anderson looked clueless in possession, always seemed to be one step behind play and showed slightly less mobility than the goal posts during his time on the pitch.


7. Massimo Taibi

Massimo Taibi, Manchester United goalkeeper
Neal Simpson/EMPICS Sport

The saddest thing about Taibi's time at Manchester United is that it actually started rather well before sliding into complete and utter failure. Brought in after Peter Schmeichel left and both Mark Bosnich and Raymond Van Der Gouw succumbed to injury, he cost £4.5 million.

A man of the match award in his first game against Liverpool suggested Taibi could actually live up to, what was then, a large transfer fee and might even challenge Bosnich for the number one place in the squad.

Obviously, it didn't pan out that way and Taibi committed one of the most shown goalkeeping errors in Premier League history. Matthew le Tissier sliced a speculative strike at the Manchester United goal from range and watched his effort bobble towards the oncoming Taibi for what should have been an easy collect.

Taibi proceeded to scoop the ball up off the ground and throw it between his legs into the open United goal and the game ended 3-3 as a product of this !*$% up.


6. David Bellion

David Bellion Man Utd
Mike Egerton/EMPICS Sport

When you think of great Manchester United strikers, there's precisely no chance that your mind ever goes to French Fancy David Bellion. The pacey striker had great natural aptitude for sport and was a gifted sprinter in his youth but speed alone doesn't make for a great footballer.

His arrival at Old Trafford was mired with controversy as he opted to run his contract down at Sunderland rather than press for a move that would financially benefit the club. Compensation was ultimately agreed between the Red Devils and the Black Cats and while United looked to be getting a steal, it turned out to be Sunderland who robbed the Red Devils blind.

Bellion had a nasty habit of running himself ragged as soon as he came onto the pitch but seemingly deliberately away from play. He was the archetypal headless chicken player, and somewhat inevitably he eventually left the club without really making a real claim on a first team place.


5. Eric Djemba-Djemba

Eric Djemba Djemba Man Utd
Mike Egerton/EMPICS Sport

Former Cameroonian international Eric Djemba-Djemba was so bad they named him twice, according to the bulk of the Manchester United faithful.

Billed as a successor to the combative Roy Keane, Djemba-Djemba made his debut against Arsenal in 2003's Community Shield and marred the occasion with a horrific challenge on Sol Campbell - not a good start.

Just two goals and plenty of terrible tackles in his 18 month spell left Sir Alex, the fans and Djemba-Djemba's team mates seriously unimpressed with the midfielder and he was moved on in January 2005 at a loss.

As far as overly physical, clumsy midfielders go, Djemba-Djemba is one of the finest examples ever in the Premier League but he simply didn't fit into United's mould given the club's desire for talented players rather than useless ones.


4. Jonny Evans

Manchester United's Jonny Evans
Nigel French/EMPICS Sport

Jonny Evans was approached by Manchester United's academy at just nine years old. The defender was scouted along with his brother Corry and friend Craig Cathcart and the Evans family relocated to Manchester to allow Jonny to train with the club ahead of his acceptance on a professional deal as a 17-year-old.

Evans was fortunate that Sir Alex had a fondness for youth players in his United squad as he was drafted in on several occasions to cover for Rio Ferdinand and Nemanja Vidic when one or other of the first choice pairing were unavailable - a chance Evans should never have been given.

Successes with the team aside, Evans never really showed anything more than average ability and his real downfall came courtesy of MK Dons and the League Cup Second Round. Louis Van Gaal fielded a young side with Evans, Hernandez and Welbeck offering the experience in the team - really it should've been a simple task for the Red Devils.

The game ended 4-0 in favour of MK Dons and United were embarrassed all night long - Evans was responsible for at least three of the defensive errors that led to converted chances. How he ever played again is beyond me.


3. Radamel Falcao

File photo dated 31-01-2015 of Manchester United's Radamel Falcao celebrates scoring during the Barclays Premier League match at Old Trafford, Manchester.
Martin Rickett/PA Wire

Conspiracy theories might suggest that Monaco owed Manchester United the transfer of Anthony Martial after they allowed the formerly prolific Radamel Falcao to join the club on loan. United had an option to buy Falcao come the end of the season but even Louis Van Gaal wouldn't have been daft enough to accept such a deal after the Colombian's nightmarish season.

Having only just recovered from an incredibly serious ACL injury, it was understandable that Falcao might be somewhat rusty from his long lay off but no-one could've predicted just how much the former Atletico man would struggle in the Premier League.

A grand total of four goals in 29 appearances for Manchester United simply isn't good enough for a player who was earning nearly £300,000 a week. Somewhat bafflingly, pundits and experts declared Van Gaal's decision to drop Falcao to the Under 21's in response to his less than impressive performances a disgrace.

Would they rather he'd cantered around doing nothing for the first team instead?


2. Liam Miller

Liam Miller Man Utd
Mike Egerton/EMPICS Sport

In a similar vein to Eric Djemba-Djemba, Liam Miller signed for Manchester United in the hopes he would develop into the role of midfield general to fill the void left by Roy Keane but the Irish midfielder was simply too meek to step up into Keano's mould.

Opportunities in the first team proved limited for Miller even right after he had signed for the club as Sir Alex Ferguson quickly realised he didn't have the physicality needed for immediate Premier League action - he even played poorly against non-league Exeter City in the League Cup being substituted in the second half.

A journeyman career ensued as Miller batted from Sunderland to QPR to Hibernian to Perth Glory to Brisbane Roar to Melbourne City to Cork City and currently plys his trade in the semi-professional American league for Wilmington Hammerheads.


1. Wilfried Zaha

Wilfried Zaha Man Utd Hatem Ben Arfa Newcastle
Barrington Coombs/EMPICS Sport

To some this will seem unfair as Wilf Zaha is performing week in, week out for Crystal Palace but he is the embodiment of Manchester United failure no matter how you look at it. The Ivorian winger was Sir Alex Ferguson's final signing for the club but the great Scot doesn't consider him his worst purchase - that honour falls to Ralph Milne.

So why was Zaha such a failure? Well, United paid an initial £10 million for Zaha and he only played twice for the Red Devils in his single season at the club. Despite his wealth of dribbling talent, obvious pace and inevitable international credentials - Zaha made an enormous mistake signing for Manchester United.

Rumours spread around the player, including of him having a poor attitude, but David Moyes still proceeded to include him in the matchday squad for the Community Shield. One further appearance and Zaha's United career was over before it began.

Back at Crystal Palace, Zaha is now rated fairly highly by experts, pundits and Ivory Coast natives but is easily Manchester United's biggest modern failure.


Contributor
Contributor

Probably the only person ever to see all the endings of the awful Shadow the Hedgehog video game. Professional proofreader, football fanatic, lion tamer and occasional liar.