12 Ridiculous Sunderland Transfer Rumours That Never Happened

A Chiellini biter, Dutch master, French dwarf, and THE Swedish icon. If only...

The Premier League season is rapidly drawing to a close, with Sunderland's top flight status still in jeopardy. It's a sentence the fans have heard countless times before, but regardless of which league they'll be in next season, you can guarantee transfer drama on Wearside. With very little to get excited about during each season, the transfer window is a brief respite for the locals who get to spend their summer fantasising about securing top class talent that could fire them to some form of glory. No matter how significant or obscure the deal is, fans agonise over every transfer that goes through, and mourn the death of some broken-down transfers. There was the obsessive #PeruzziWatch which saw fans explore cyberspace to track down Argentinian full-back Gino Peruzzi's plane and monitor its progress. He was eventually spotted at the Marriott Hotel but the deal didn't happen. There was also a tense wait for confirmation that then-England star and Premier League champion Adam Johnson and talisman Steven Fletcher, with a slight delay sending Twitter into chaotic meltdown, and who can forget Darren Bent's infamous social media rant at Spurs chairman Daniel Levy, and the equally acrimonious reaction to his shock departure. Transfer windows offer a morsel of hope in the bleakest of situations, but while some coups have been pulled off by the club in recent years, some transfer rumours accredited to Sunderland have simply been off-the-wall insane. Here is a rundown of some of the most staggering, baffling, and ultimately ridiculous transfer rumours that have surfaced about Sunderland AFC.


12. Klaas Jan Huntelaar

Let's start with the latest rumour in this collection of craziness. Klaas Jan Huntelaar's name has been thrown around in the Dutch press, linked with a move to Sunderland if they survive another scary season. The link came about through rumours that temporary manager Dick Advocaat has recommended that the club sign the 31-year-old fellow Dutchman who has bagged enormous amounts of goals across Europe, with 105 in 174 games for current club Schalke 04. It's not happening, it won't happen, it will never happen.

11. Jan Koller

While Jan Koller may not rank anywhere near the top of this list if it were judged on talent, the infamy surrounding a potential deal for the 6'8" Czech tower, who played at Dortmund around the time the rumours started to surface. With Niall Quinn deteriorating towards the end of his Sunderland career, every tall striker in Europe was touted, and while there was never even a shred of truth in the Koller rumours, they resurfaced virtually every single year until he retired. He's the greatest Sunderland cult hero never to have actually signed for the club.

10. Mathieu Valbuena

From one end of the height scale to the other, as French wizard Mathieu Valbuena was linked with a switch from Marseille to Sunderland in a reported £8 million deal following a fantastic World Cup for the diminutive midfielder. At 5'4", Valbuena wouldn't have added any muscle to the midfield, but what he lacks in height, he more than certainly makes up for with sheer skill. There was never a chance Sunderland were realistically going to land a player like him, though it was surprising to see him pen a deal with Dynamo Moscow soon after.

9. Ariel Ortega

Ariel Ortega swims in the same pool of names as Jan Koller, Robbie Keane, and Charles N'Zogbia. They've all been spotted at Seaham Hall, a luxury spa/hotel in Sunderland, even though it's almost certain none of them have actually been there, with the club never actually using its facilities to thrash out deals with players. Barcelona and Manchester United had both been credited with interest in the Argentine international Number 10, yet rumours of an £11 million bid wouldn't die down, more out of pure hope and desperation than anything official. Ortega came to the Stadium of Light in 1999 with Sampdoria for Kevin Ball's testimonial, but the way the rumours circled, it would seem that he never left and instead continues to live out his days underneath a Jacky White's Market stall.

8. Edinson Cavani

In years to come, people will look back and reminisce about the carnage of Paolo Di Canio's reign. Key incidents to be recalled will include his ketchup ban, sketchy links to European fascism, the dislodging of Davey Miliband from the Sunderland board, and destroying his suit after breaking Newcastle United football club. But if you want a true representation of how wacky those days were, the perfect tale to tell will be the involving beleaguered Director Of Football Roberto De Fanti. One of his very first moves was to lodge an ridiculous enquiry about Napoli's sensational striker Edinson Cavani. That was an actual thing that actually happened. Of course the conversation with his agent didn't last long and Cavani promptly signed for PSG. Sunderland ended up with Jozy Altidore. You decide who won out of that situation...

7. Fernando Llorente

Nicklas Bendtner was strangely brilliant. His head was the size of a small island, and often found himself aimlessly wandering around in defence when he was in fact the lone striker, but he did actually finish his Sunderland loan season with a not-too-shabby 8 goals in 28 games record (yes, that's actually a phenomenal return for a Sunderland striker). One fateful day he missed the team bus and was on his way out of the club, probably aiming for a Barcelona, Madrid, Munich move. One replacement was then-Atletico Madrid targetman and Spanish international Fernando Llorente. He racked up 111 goals for Atletico across eight years, but he offered far more than goals. He was the complete package, and there was genuine substance to the rumours. Llorente quickly moved onto Italian giants Juventus...

6. Ruud Van Nistelrooy

Ruud Van Nistelrooy is criminally overlooked when people look back through the Premier League greats. Thierry Henry, Alan Shearer, Didier Drogba and Dennis Bergkamp will all come to mind when looking at incredible strikers to grace the English top flight, and Van Nistelrooy deserves to be in that elite group with his goal tally for Manchester United resting at 150 in 219 games. Rumours were floating around that Peter Reid took the Dutchman on trial for Sunderland when he was a teenager, though no confirmation was ever made, though Sunderland did make a move to sign him in 2011 on a free transfer after leaving Hamburg. A deal never transpired, and even though the 34-year-old may not have shone in the Premier League like he had before, a Van Nistelrooy Sunderland shirt would've been a tremendous keepsake.

5. Diego Forlan

Van Nistelrooy was a Manchester United great, though Diego Forlan certainly wasn't, registering just 14 goals in 92 games, although his career has seemed to happen in reverse. United were his biggest employers, but since leaving them early in his career, he went onto Atletico Madrid and exploded with 96 goals and 32 assists in 198 games. The 2010 World Cup Golden Ball winner reinvented himself and became one of the most talked about strikers in Europe for a spell. Yes, Sunderland were heavily linked with a move, largely down to the Roy Keane connection, though it never came true. Thankfully we got to enjoy Daryl Murphy and Anthony Stokes up front instead of Forlan... *tear rolls down cheek*

4. Joey Barton

How many games have Sunderland beaten Newcastle in a row, Joey? Oh, yes. Joey Barton is comfortably the worst player on this list, not fit to lace any of the others' boots, nor any professional players' boots for that matter. The egotistical thug's career has ridden on the waves of controversy he's caused, with a string of violent and venomous incidents somehow rewarded with millions of pounds and a platform to speak on the supposedly-respectable BBC. Fraud manager Steve Bruce was once genuinely interested in taking Barton to Wearside, with the 'footballer' himself claiming that he received and declined a genuine offer from Sunderland. Mackems are an accepting bunch, and can tolerate far more than their fair share of trauma, but signing Barton would've produced some vicious scenes.

3. Paul Scholes

Now we approach the top three most ludicrous Sunderland transfer rumours of all time. Paul Scholes is without a doubt one of the greatest English footballers of the modern era, even though we criminally didn't see enough of him donning the Three Lions on his chest - despite making 66 appearances, he could've offered far more. Roy Keane brought a massive influx of Manchester United cast-offs and loanees with him, but some say Scholes was the one he really wanted. He'd stupidly been linked with a move to Sunderland back during the Reid era, and under Keane one particular whisper suggested that the fiery Sunderland boss had played tennis with the flame-haired midfield maestro while discussing a move to the North East. Others say he was merely playing tennis with his old-teammate... Because that's what old teammates are allowed to do... You know, socialise... Rumour-mill nonsense at its finest.

2. Luis Suarez

Forgive the photo, any opportunity to get Lionel Messi into a Sunderland piece will be pounced upon with enthusiasm. But this particular entry focuses on the cannibal behind him, Luis Suarez. The Barcelona goal machine with a taste for goals and human flesh. Back in 2010 - which really doesn't seem like a long time ago - Sunderland chief scout ran scouting missions to check up on Suarez, playing for Ajax at the time. He was also being considered by other top continental teams, but Sunderland were seriously looking at him. However, one year later he was jetting into Liverpool. The Uruguayan has had a fairly quiet, low-key career since then, saving a World Cup Quarter-final goal with his hands, only biting two players after sinking his teeth into his first at Ajax, and signing for Barcelona to play alongside Messi and Neymar. Bet he wishes he came to Sunderland now...

1. Zlatan Ibrahimovic

Of all the players on this list, not only is Zlatan Ibrahimovic the greatest, he's also the most underrated (yes, UNDERrated), and his transfer was actually more substantiated than any other. He truly was the one that got away. Zlatan could easily have been Sunderland-bound. Twice. Again, as Quinn began to wind down, the most important replacement search in Sunderland's history got underway. Peter Reid was left with two options. Big-name Rangers goalscorer Tore Andre Flo, and 20-year-old Ajax prodigy Zlatan Ibrahimovic. There were rumours that Sunderland tried for him after leaving Malmo, and years later Peter Reid himself totally confirmed that the Black Cats had tabled a bids for the Swedish talisman. He said: "When he was at Ajax, I went to Amsterdam and offered £7 million for him. It was the second time I had tried to take him to Sunderland - we were also in for him when he was at Malmo. Imagine what a signing he would have been, everywhere he goes his team wins the league." Ibrahimovic's representatives gave no immediate comment at the time of the bids, though Zlatan himself was quoted as saying: "At the moment I am leaning in the direction of staying at Ajax, but you never know what will happen." He actually acknowledged the bid...... Just pause for a second and imagine a strikeforce of zero-time European Golden Boot winner Zlatan Ibrahimovic and one-time European Golden Boot winner Kevin Phillips? That is quite literally the greatest thought imaginable for fans in red and white. Crushingly, it's time to fall back into reality. Zlatan stayed with Ajax for a while longer before dominating league-after-league with Juventus, Inter, Barcelona, AC Milan and now PSG. Sunderland signed Tore Andre Flo and broke the lowest ever Premier League points tally. Twice. Damn you, reality.

Contributor
Contributor

What Culture contributor. NCTJ accredited Sports Journalist. Regret-filled Sunderland AFC season ticket holder. Optimism-filled NFL fan. Lover of all things Game Of Thrones, Breaking Bad, Walking Dead & more.