In what has been one of the most exciting and closely run English Premier League Seasons in recent memory, the PFA Player of the Year shortlist was hardly surprising. Names from the top 4 clubs populate the lists, and whilst thoroughly deserving of their place, the constant praise heaped on players such as Eden Hazard, Luis Suarez and Yaya Toure becomes both predictable and repetitive. These great, creative players steal the headlines, week in, week out for their clubs and are instantly recognizable, but what about their team mates? What about the players that form a platform for these great players to stand on,or in some cases, compete against. What Culture has put together an alternative Player Of The Season shortlist. A combination of 6 players who have represented their club with a exceptional level of consistency throughout the season yet due to lacking flair or match winning displays, will be overlooked come awards season. This is the What Culture EPL Underrated Player Of The Season Shortlist...
6. David De Gea (Manchester United)
For the first time in many seasons, Manchester United haven't even looked like mounting a title challenge. A combination of disharmony in the ranks, lack of tactical direction and some very average performances have all led to a floundering season which may result in the most successful side in English football fail to qualify for European competition. Perhaps one of the biggest downfalls has been their inconsistent defensive line up, with multiple CB pairings and a real lack of leadership in the defense. It should be high praise then that their Spanish keeper makes the list for the most underrated players of 2013/14, with some terrific individual performances and a consistency his team mates have failed to achieve. Easily one of the stand out keepers of the season, only three sides have conceded fewer than United and De Gea's 11 clean sheets have been a huge part of that. Easily criticized at times in his early United career, his position in goal now looks secure, and David is a valid candidate for the Underrated Player of the Season Award
5. Wilfred Bony (Swansea)
When Swansea splashed out a reported £13 million on Wilfred Bony in the summer, very few would have expected him to join a team outside of the top 6. Plying his trade in the Czech Republic and later Holland, the famous Swansea scouting system that has brought through talents such as Michu and Gylfi Sigurdsson seems to have struck gold again, picking up a powerful forward whose value has potential; to skyrocket with a good performance in Brazil this summer. His numbers are slightly above average, 13 goals from 31 EPL games may not put him the Suarez or Sturridge bracket, but when you consider that these have been scored often as a lone front man playing in a struggling side, the feat becomes very impressive, What adds even more weight to Bony's claim for the Underrated Player of the Season award is the fact that whilst Swansea have changed managers and style, they have also suffered a season defining injury to their focal play maker (Michu) meaning the pressure placed on the 25 year old has been even greater. Swansea seem to be pretty close to clear of relegation now, and if they do survive, they will have Bony's goals and hold up play to thank.
4. Gareth Barry (Everton)
When Manchester City decided the let Gareth Barry go out on loan to Everton, there were probably a few raised eyebrows among the football world. Here is a versatile English player that was a benchmark of City's Championship winning season, and to be deemed surplus to requirements seemed both questionable and odd. What was Manchester's loss was Merseyside's gain however, as the midfielder has been a linchpin to Everton's success this season, and may very well see Barry earn Champions League football for his new part time employers. 30 games, 3 goals and 4 assists are far from groundbreaking numbers, but it is the little things that Barry does so well. Barry is always in the top 5 players per game for interceptions, tackles and aerial duals, numbers which allow him to create opportunities for the Barkley's and Lukaku's to go and score. He is no frills, often playing simple, but always scoring a high passing accuracy in a possession based team. Whilst it is perhaps less surprising that people are not discussing his name as a potential call up for Roy Hodgson's world cup squad, it is expected that Martinez will work hard to try and bring Barry back to Goodison Park next season, ideally on a permanent deal.
3. Branislav Ivanovic (Chelsea)
A lot of Chelsea players will get deserved praise this season. Terry and Cahill have been excellent in defense for the blues. Hazard has been an exceptional attacking outlet and Matic and Oscar have show tireless work rate in midfield. However, one player goes about his job with competency and professionalism, never rising above the other but maintaining a baseline few can aspire to. Chelsea's right back, Branislav Ivanovic was brought in as a Centre Back, and has, over the years, turned himself into one of the best defensive Right backs in world football. Bucking modern day footballing trends of the 'attacking full back', Ivanovic has kept the art of defending his number 1 priority, while evolving his game to ensure he can provide a support to attacks when required. His performance against Manchester City away this season proved how intelligent a footballer he is, and his willingness to work and play a role for his team mates. 3 goals from right back is a fair enough return, and his no nonsense performances have made him an imperative part of Mourinho's success this season.
2. Fernandinho (Manchester City)
This season, City have played with a reckless abandon. Full backs flying forwards, attacking midfield players all over the place, and scoring goals for fun. When the dust settles on this season and the outcome of Pellegrini's first campaign, the Brazilian's contribution may get overlooked. However, City fans and tactical observers will know just how good this man is at what he does. When he hasn't played, City haven;t been as good. His ability to sit in and cover team mates helps defend City against Counter Attacks. His athleticism and engine allows him to play from box to box. His technical ability allows him to dictate play and control the game from a deeper position. His confidence allows him to be an out ball no matter what pressure he is under, and his understanding of the game means that when City are on top, he has the nouse to join in and create chances. He is like Claude Makelele 2.0. Yes, he was one of City's biggest signings this summer, and yes, he is a big name within his own right, but when people are talking about Yaya Toure, David Silva and Samir Nasri's contribution to City's campaign, Fernandinho's role has been of equal importance. A valid candidate for this award.
1. Scott Dann (Crystal Palace)
Dann only signed for Palace in January, making him a strange addition to the list. However, perhaps no one player has epitimised the style of play his manager wishes to portray and has been so influential in obtaining results. (Maybe Suarez would disagree!) Scott Dann is arguably one of the best Penalty Box Centre Backs in the English Game. He has limitations. He is not quick,not great on the ball and technical par for a central defender. But when asked to defend on a deep defensive line, he is brave, composed, controlled and confident. he is willing to put his head into dangerous areas, throw himself in front of shots and dictate a line to his team mates. His Trojan like performances for Birmingham City a couple of years ago earned him a reputation for this, but this season he has cemented it. 6 wins from 11 starts with since signing for Palace is an exceptional achievement (they were all but relegated in October) and whilst Tony Pullis has worked wonders with the whole Palace quad to make them both organised and competitive, it has been Dann (and his CB partner Delaney) that should be heavily praised. There you have it. 6 Under The Radar offerings for the What Culture Underrated Player of the Season. Who have I missed out? Feel free to drop your own suggestions in to the mix!
Football mad, gaming enthusiast, wrestling purist. I am fortunate enough to work full time in the world of football, and am Senior Editor for the football video gaming site, Soccer Gaming. Love a debate!