7 Inherent Problems That Exist At Sunderland

Why it's always bleak times for the Black Cats.

A couple of weeks ago, Sunderland fans were gearing up for the start of the season with characteristic optimism. Everything would be better this year, under the watchful, experienced eye of Dick Advocaat. Weak elements such as Liam Bridcutt and Will Buckley were gradually being phased out of the squad, while new signing Jeremain Lens was all set to be the brightest prospect at the Stadium of Light in years. Now two games in, and the Black Cats' season is already threatening to self-destruct. A promising start at Leicester soon gave way to three quick goals, from which Jermain Defoe and Steven Fletcher could only salvage a 4-2 loss. The next game, at home to Norwich, was even worse, a performance lacking in both quality and (more distressingly) effort. It finished 3-1 to the Canaries, leaving Sunderland rock bottom of the table already, after a supposedly "easy" couple of opening fixtures. Needless to say, this has set off alarm bells across Wearside. Most Sunderland fans know that these two results aren't simply freak accidents; they're the result of long-standing issues with the club that have to be addressed. Should Advocaat and co. fail to do so, relegation is surely inevitable. Here are the seven main problems with Sunderland AFC. It doesn't make for pretty reading.

7. A Lack Of Quality

Sunderland's lack of quality has been evident for several seasons now. Getting thrashed by an (admittedly decent) Leicester side was a sickening enough start to the season, but losing at home to newly-promoted Norwich has really set off alarm bells with regard to the team's actual footballing ability. You could almost see Jeremain Lens looking around thinking "what the hell am I doing here?" as another wild shank from Sebastian Coates drifted horribly into touch. Defensive errors are the most glaring issue with Sunderland's performance so far, but all areas of the team could do with serious improvement. The midfield trio of Larsson, Cattermole and Rodwell are far too defensive-minded, and the introduction of Yann M'Vila has added precisely zero attacking impetus - as highly-rated a player as he may be. Up front, the situation is similarly dire. Steven Fletcher, Jermain Defoe and Danny Graham, as occasionally acceptable as they may be, can't be relied upon to lead the line for a whole season. There's no player on the team with the quality needed to shoulder the bulk of the goalscoring responsibility. Simply put, Sunderland don't have enough good players, and even if members of the current squad raise their individual performance levels, they still don't mesh together well at all.

6. A Lack Of Effort

Sunderland's lack of quality was certainly frustrating for fans in those defeats to Leicester and Norwich, but not as much as the apparent lack of effort by the side. In both games (but especially the latter), Patrick van Aanholt drifted out of position far too many times, making astonishingly little effort to get back in time to repel an attack. Simple one-twos were played around the lacklustre van Aanholt so much it became the norm, but even players such as Lee Cattermole and Seb Larsson looked off the boil. Distressingly, Sunderland fans often pride their team on being a hard-working outfit, despite their regular lack of star quality - yet this determination may be falling rapidly by the wayside. The past few seasons have seen the Black Cats get off to incredibly slow stars, only dragging themselves out of their haze when things look drastic (or for the occasional derby). The players can't keep riding their luck year after year. Sooner or later Sunderland will get relegated - unless they make hard work the norm, rather than a late season trend.

5. A Tendency To Collapse

Both games so far have seen Sunderland concede a relatively early goal, and go on to immediately lose all composure and confidence. The Black Cats have found themselves at 3-0 down in consecutive matches, leaving them with a virtually unassailable mountain to climb. Could John O'Shea's shift to the substitutes' bench be a factor in this? A player of his seniority and experience may perhaps deserved to be given more of a chance to retain his place in the starting line-up, rather than being demoted in favour of Sebastian Coates (who was only convincing at the end of last season, but looked incredibly poor in the months before) and new boy Younes Kaboul. Whatever the cause, it's the most urgent of Sunderland's many issues. Relegation is an inevitability if the team's heads drop as soon as a goal is conceded, particularly against teams of Leicester and Norwich's less-than-intimidating defensive prowess.

4. No Identity

Much has been made in recent months over Sunderland's lack of an "identity", or more specifically, the lack of an effective one. Every manager since the departure of Steve Bruce has attempted to implement their own style of play upon the team, and each has proven effective only in the short term. Martin O'Neill was, surprisingly, the most negative of all, shutting up shop and praying for draws at home against fellow relegation-battling teams, while Paolo Di Canio prized relentless pressing over all - frequently leaving the side hopelessly exposed at the back. Poyet's obsession with passing out from the back led to far many basic errors from a team lacking the quality to play in such a way, and his unwillingness to change ultimately led to his downfall. Now Advocaat simply has to establish a successful style of play, or face the same fate as every one of his recent predecessors. The problem remains finding such an identity in a team of such mixed abilities. He remains the most likely manager to do so, based on his years of experience - but that doesn't necessarily mean he will.

3. Overlooking Youth

Sunderland's neglect of their own youth system (and young players brought in from elsewhere) could arguably be the major reason for their current defensive shortcomings. Refusing to evolve from an ageing centre back pairing of John O'Shea and Wes Brown has led to panic-buying, a direct result of their inevitable deterioration. Players such as Charalampos Mavrias and the now-departed David Moberg Karlsson were given barely a sniff of senior action, languishing on the bench - or entirely out of the matchday squad - despite their teammates constantly dragging the team closer to relegation each season. The most recent example of overlooked young promise is Duncan Watmore. His involvement was the sole bright spot of an otherwise catastrophic defeat to Norwich last week, one which saw a 21 year old show the rest of the team how to play with ambition and desire. The youngster embarrassed far more established names with his willingness to attack, and hopefully his positive influence on the game will encourage Advocaat to give other prospects more of a chance.

2. Poor Transfer Policy

If you recognise the player in the picture above, you're almost certainly a Sunderland fan who watched with horror as the signings of Roberto De Fanti's reign slowly fell by the wayside. The sporting director made a series of bemusing (but supposedly ambitious) purchases from a variety of foreign leagues, only to see almost every example phased out of the squad. Cabral, Moberg Karlsson, Roberge and Diakite will all go down as footnotes in the history of Sunderland AFC, players who made only the slightest impression upon a club in desperate need of a talent boost. This transfer window naivety could finally be coming back to bite Sunderland where it hurts most - results. This summer€™s transfer window appears to have been ambitious on the surface, but the squad hasn€™t developed to the extent many were hoping for. The Black Cats' signing of Jeremain Lens sparked initial excitement, but Younes Kaboul, Adam Matthews and Yann M'Vila (yet another defense-minded midfielder) hardly demonstrate the growth fans were clamouring for. There's still time before the window closes, but several players are still needed - a fact stated by Advocaat time and time again in press conferences. Whether Ellis Short sees fit to open his chequebook again, however, remains another matter entirely.

1. Something Else?

A source of endless debate among Sunderland fans in recent years has been the notion of a "poison" within the club, an inherent unprofessionalism which prevents the side from escaping its existence as permanent relegation candidates. Rumours have abounded since the reign of Di Canio regarding a severe lack of discipline, and even a destructive drinking culture among several key members of the senior squad. Exactly how "rotten" Sunderland's dressing room is remains to be seen, but something certainly is wrong at the very core of the club. The never-ending cycle of managers is a testament to that, especially given the variety of their philosophies and experience levels. It seems that no man, however astute, intelligent or passionate, can guide Sunderland out of their current mire, and that's a huge worry. Whether there really is one main reason for the Black Cats' inability to succeed, or the problem is merely a combination of factors, the fact remains that something has to be done. Sunderland can't keep escaping relegation by the skin of their teeth; sooner or later they'll run out of luck, and there's no guarantee of a quick promotion from an incredibly competitive Championship division.


Content Producer
Content Producer

Highly overrated 23 year old from the North East of England. Hanging off of your gangster car.