8 Reasons Why Newcastle Should Sell Fabricio Coloccini

The Argentine's seven years at the Magpies will be looked upon fondly but it's time to move forward.

Fabricio Coloccini signed for Newcastle United from Deportivo La Coruna in 2008 for £10.3 million and has been an almost ever-present feature at the very heart of the Magpies' defence for the past seven years.

Despite another 32 league appearances last season, it has been a long time since we have seen the same Coloccini who captained Newcastle United to a fifth-place Premier League finish during the 2011-12 season. Yes, there are glimpses of that form now and again; the famous feathered touch that prompted Alan Pardew to liken the defender to Bobby Moore is still in the 33-year-old's locker - but it's currently squashed beneath a pile of fitness question marks, memories, arguments, managers, a fraying captain's armband and a tourist guide to South London.

The problem with having such a colourful past with a club that - aside from the aforementioned near-podium finish - has continuously underachieved, is that the Argentine has become synonymous with the recent failures, bust-ups and management changes. Newcastle United are starting a new era this season under the guidance of Steve McClaren - and unfortunately this is Coloccini's cue to leave. His beautiful golden curls are dropping out of his head like toxic debris, slowly tarnishing McClaren's freshly-vacuumed Berber carpet.

During a cagey interview with BBC Newcastle on Tuesday, McClaren said that Coloccini will carry on as captain. Rather than boldly announcing his decision he used a series of rhetorical questions combined with some paper-thin filler that certainly did not sound convincing. The Magpies boss said to the radio station:

"Do I need to change the captain? Why do I need to unsettle everything and everybody? He's our most experienced player and he carries on."

To answer your questions Steve: "Do I need to change the captain?" Yes, desperately - did you not see Newcastle United last season? "Why do I need to unsettle everything and everyone?" Well, giving the captaincy to someone new would implement a fresh start and be less disruptive than leaving it with a player who nearly got the side relegated?

Here, WhatCulture.com/NUFC take a look at some of the reasons why Newcastle United should sell their centre-half and how it would benefit the side going forward...


8. His Sale Would Represent A New Era

Sometimes change is good. Change is always good if the person that you're changing is John Carver. This season, Newcastle United need to represent a positive new era with their appointment of Steve McClaren and pry themselves away from the harrowing emptiness of last season. Unfortunately Fabricio Coloccini has those scornful memories embedded in his captain's armband. If you look closely into the Argentine defender's retinas you can see Joe Kinnear's arrival, the St James' Park sign being taken down and Yohan Cabaye on a flight to Paris. He's in too deep and it was evident he was starting to crack towards the end of last season as Newcastle desperately fought to avoid relegation. Newcastle United have a new head coach, have overhauled their backroom staff and have made three very decent signings - now it's time to replace the captain.

7. His Form Has Plummeted Over The Past Two Years

The argument that Chancel Mbemba and Jamaal Lascelles would improve playing alongside Fabricio Coloccini is no longer valid. The Argentine's form has diminished rapidly (aside from a few decent cameos) over the past two years and a stronger argument is that Mbemba would benefit from being the prime leader of the back four. Coloccini's pace, marking and aerial ability is no longer at the standard where he can lead the line and, although offering vital experience, he will struggle to maintain a first-team place over the entirety of a Premier League campaign. Newcastle would make further progress if they were to sell the 33-year-old and sign a commanding centre-half who is strong in the air and could form a solid partnership with the Magpies' new Congolese signing.

6. His Transfer Would Force Club To Buy New Defender

Fabricio Coloccini is reportedly on around £80,000 a week at Newcastle United. The figure would suggest he is just about the highest earner at Newcastle United and something doesn't feel right about this being the case, does it? His performances last season do not validate him receiving such a handsome wage and, if he was to leave the club, then it is a figure that could entice a first-rate defender to move to Tyneside. Marseille's star centre-back Nicolas N'Koulou is reportedly on £75,000 per week to put things in perspective - meaning even he would get a wage bump if he moved to Tyneside.

5. He Made Hatem Ben Arfa Leave

Some fans will think otherwise. Many - despite fundamentally disagreeing with everything else he ever said - seemed to side with Alan Pardew€™s belief that Hatem Ben Arfa didn€™t track back or give enough for the team. They were brainwashed into thinking that Newcastle are not a team that can afford to have luxury players and need 11 workhorses to collect three points. An argument, reportedly led by Fabricio Coloccini, along with a small section of the Newcastle United squad, told Pardew that they did not want the player anywhere near the first team. The former Magpies boss had been prepared to give the Frenchman another chance but after the discussion the talented midfielder was permanently isolated from the first XI and eventually loaned out to Hull City and then released.

4. He Hasn't Played A Single Minute Of Pre-Season Football

Steve McClaren has not been able to use Fabricio Coloccini during Newcastle United's pre-season campaign as the Argentine has been suffering from a sore Achilles (either that or an unbelievably strong urge to leave the club). This would mean that he would need to play a handful of competitive fixtures before he would be operating at his highest level (something that we have already established isn't good enough anyway) and reach something even close to match fitness. Time is not something Newcastle have on their hands with the new Premier League season almost upon us - so Coloccini cannot be given it to reach peak fitness.

3. He Certainly Should Not Be The Captain

Fabricio Coloccini hasn't demonstrated the leadership qualities that make him indispensable as captain of the club and I believe that Newcastle United should start their 2015-16 campaign with a new man wearing the armband. Steve McClaren admitted during his interview with BBC Newcastle that the captaincy was "one for debate" and that he always knew there was a "question mark" hanging over the role. The Argentine remained as gutless as John Carver when it came to taking responsibility for a number of shambolic performances last season and has on a number of occasions expressed his desire to leave St James' Park. Newcastle have recruited Georginio Wijnaldum this summer who was PSV Eindhoven's captain last year and also have experienced first-team players such as Daryl Janmaat, Jack Colback and Tim Krul who could easily step up to the mark (and who are more far more valuable to the side). This season is all about Newcastle United establishing themselves as a freshly rejuvenated footballing unit and appointing a new captain is essential if they're going to achieve that goal.

2. The Here And Now Is What Counts... Not Previous Form

It's easy to get nostalgic about Fabricio Coloccini - he is undoubtedly a Newcastle United legend and possibly the best centre-half the Magpies have had this decade. He has played for the club for a longer period than Jonathan Woodgate (who was brilliant but only played two seasons) and chose to stay on numerous occasions when he could easily have departed, most notably when the Magpies were relegated in 2008-09. However, Coloccini simply isn't an integral player to the Magpies anymore. His performances are slow, ill-disciplined and careless and for a player who reportedly earns £80,000 a week - put simply, he is no longer Premier League standard. Yes, he's better than Mike Williamson but that really doesn't indicate very much. It's like saying Ipswich Town's Christophe Berra is better than Queens Park Ranger's Clint Hill...

1. He Always Wants To Leave

I don't begrudge a man for missing his wife and children but it has become a regular occurrence that Fabricio Coloccini decides that he wants to leave Newcastle United. It doesn't look good when your club captain is frequently pining for pastures new and doesn't set a good example to the rest of the side. Ever since the reports were made back in 2013-14, the Argentine defender hasn't looked settled on Tyneside - and now it is time to grant him his seemingly long-held wish... For all the latest NUFC News, Views and Transfers make sure to follow WhatCulture.com/NUFC on Twitter and Facebook.

Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-accredited football writer with an MA in Sports Journalism. What Culture football editor. Write for the official Newcastle United programme. Former video reporter at North News. Featured and published in the Sunderland Echo, Shields Gazette, Mail Online, The Mirror, The Sun and others.