8 Worst Premier League Manager Sackings From The Past 10 Years

Over the years, the insecurity of the football manager position has risen exponentially, and is regarded as probably one of the most unstable job titles in the world, let alone the sports and entertainment business. The manager of a football team is the first person fans look to when things go good or bad; whether people can justify that sentiment or not, the manager is the media's favourite person to talk to. The media usually portray football managers having the responsibility for absolutely everything that the team is doing at one point. To a degree this is true and I assume many of you probably think that would be in the job description, but there are many other staff that are responsible for a team's results. The back-room staff (first team coaches, positional coaches, fitness coaches etc.) all have as much contact with the players and responsibility for teams' results as the manager himself, and while I understand that the manager can pick and choose their back-room staff, sometimes they have to make-do with who they have. Then there are the players themselves. There is only so much that a manager's motivation and instructions can do, it's the players that have to fulfil them. Meanwhile, owners of football clubs have been gaining more attention. They are the true dictators of what goes on and fans are starting to see that, the reason being that the insecurity of a managers' job position has been dwindling due to these very people, and not always for the right reasons. Clubs in England especially have been acquiring mega rich owners who adopt a 'dictatorship style' approach to running a football club, as if they themselves are the be-all and end-all of the club and, well, with that attitude it's correct that they would have that influence. I am going to take you through 8 incidents from the past 10 years where a football manager has been sacked for all the wrong reasons, most of which have resulted in the club's performance fall rather than rise. These will be in rank order, with number one being what I believe has been the worst decision. Here we go!

8. Sam Allardyce - Blackburn Rovers

Allardyce is an experienced manager who has managed many clubs in England, including a very successful period with Bolton, however it is his Blackburn stint that may have given him his most damaging experience. He took control of a struggling Blackburn side in early 2008, at which he began with a flourish - a nine game unbeaten run to boost them up the table. His team finished in 15th position at the end of that season, safely away from the relegation zone. In the 2009/10 season, he managed to finish 10th, much higher than what most expected of Blackburn at the time, as well as reaching the semi-final of the league cup and maintaining an unbeaten run against the 'top four' (Arsenal, Chelsea, Man. United and Liverpool). Then came the Venkys. The V H Group bought Blackburn Rovers for £23 million, promising to spend big money to land future silverware. It was an exciting time for Blackburn fans, until they sacked poor Sam Allardyce. The decision to sack Big Sam was slandered by many figures of the media, other managers (particularly Sir Alex Ferguson) and even the club's players. His team were lying in a strong 13th position at the time. Making matters worse, the Venkys appointed Steve Kean as manager, who ended up being perhaps the most unpopular manager of all time. The anger, I have to say, was a bit unfairly proportionate towards Kean, as it was the Venkys' decision to appoint him and stick with him for an unwelcome length of time. Meanwhile, Big Sam had to leave all the momentum gathered with Blackburn and start again with Championship side West Ham United.

7. Avram Grant - Chelsea

Avram Grant was one of the strangest manager signings I think I have ever witnessed as a football fan, but what was even stranger was the way it ended for him. Grant was employed as director of football by Roman Abramovich at Chelsea, before then being promoted as manager when Jose Mourinho left his first Chelsea stint (by mutual consent, another horrible decision). Amazingly, Avram Grant did not even hold a top-flight coaching certificate by the time he took the job, increasing the curiosity why this relatively unknown character had suddenly came out of the blue to take charge of such a high profile team. The opportunity was given to him basically because he was Abramovich's close friend. Roman must have gained a lot of trust in Grant given his credentials, but that was soon to be justified with some surprising success. After a 2-0 loss to Manchester United on his managerial debut, Grant's team went on a 16 game unbeaten run. However it was not a complete success story, as Grant's Chelsea were beaten by Spurs in the league cup final, and then were knocked out of the FA cup by Barnsley shortly after. What made up for all of this, though, was the Champions League run. It was a remarkable Champions League campaign for England, as all four semi-final teams were English - a very rare achievement. To add to the drama, Avram Grant managed to steer Chelsea into the Final after beating Liverpool 4-3 on aggregate. Not even Jose Mourinho was able to do this while at Chelsea, and certainly no-one thought it was possible for Avram Grant. Grant's opposition in the Final were his biggest fear, Manchester United - the only team that Chelsea couldn't touch in the league. Chelsea lost the final, but the manner of their loss was not a case of Chelsea playing worse. Their loss was decided by penalties, and if it hadn't been for John Terry's monumental slip, they would have won the trophy. Avram Grant lost his job because of this. For him to lose his job because of a 6-5 penalty shoot-out loss, that's a kick in the teeth. Just getting to the final in his first and only season as Chelsea manager surpassed everyone's expectations of the novice manager. Since his sacking he has retreated to Israel to manage much smaller clubs - he graced world football's biggest stage, and then retreated back into the wilderness to reflect. Someone should probably make a movie about it, its Hollywood material.

6. Nigel Adkins - Southampton

Nigel Adkins had a remarkable time as manager of Southampton, and they simply would not be where they are today without his service. Adkins joined League One Southampton on a three-year deal. Right from the start, Nigel Adkins had Southampton playing football that their fans had been dreaming of since their club's quick and crippling decent into England's third tier, due to the club falling into administration. His appointment saw Southampton become consistent match winners and high goal-scorers after a shaky start in League one, and in return they climbed up the table very quickly to become promotion pushers. Since then they won back-to-back promotions to return to the Premier League beyond all initial expectation. In their first season back into the Premier League, it was clear that their speedy journey back to the top flight brought with it some heavy jet lag, as Adkins was unable to produce the same sort of winning runs that he had accumulated in the lower tiers. Despite this, Nigel's future with the Saints seemed fairly secure, purely down to how much he had already achieved with the club. No one was expecting him to be sacked after a 2-2 draw with Chelsea. Just like with Big Sam, the football world responded with quite some anger about this decision, and the Southampton fans were rightly shocked at how their owners decided to treat a man who had just became one of the most important managers in their history. Adkins even had to begin legal proceedings against the club as the 'pay-off' clause on his contract was not met by the Saints board, adding even more undeserved misery for poor Nigel. Now, this entry would have been a lot closer to the top spot if it were not for the exceptional job that Adkin's replacement, Maurucio Pochettino, has done since his appointment. Pochettino's performance as manager has had everyone perplexed, as he arrived not even being able to speak English (and still can't), but has managed to take Southampton even further.

5. Harry Redknapp - Spurs

This is quite a strange one for me to document, mainly due to the fact that its unclear who exactly was in the wrong. Harry Redknapp is the man that provided the longest service on this list at 4 years, and the whole period was very successful indeed. The league finishes 'Arry managed to achieve were 8th, 4th, 5th and 4th respectfully, from his tenure between 2008 and 2012 (the finish of 8th in 2008/09 being the 'odd one out' due to the fact Redknapp had to pull Spurs out of the relegation zone first). Redknapp was also successful in Europe with Tottenham, guiding them into the quarter-finals of the European Cup for the first time since 1962 in 2010/11, where they fell at the hands of Real Madrid losing 5-0 on aggregate. So, the success was being delivered to Tottenham by Redknapp at a consistent level, why on Earth did Spurs sack him? Well, this is where the debate of 'who's to blame?' comes in. It had been reported in The Guardian soon after Harry's sacking that club chairman David Levy had become annoyed with 'Arry for several reasons. One of the reasons that struck me as quite important was the notion that Harry had paused his willingness to sign a contract extension due to the huge speculation surrounding the England vacancy, of which Redknapp was at the centre of attention. After Hodgson took it from under his nose, Harry then began to demand an immediate contract extension with his own terms, of which the board were reluctant to meet. This notion is backed up a bit further due to the fact that Redknapp came out to say that the decision to sack him may have been political. The meaning of this is vague, but could mean that the decision was made due to his conduct rather than the team's performance. If this is true, it is certainly a much more reasonable decision rather than basing it on results. Of course It was also speculated that the sacking was influenced by the fact that Chelsea managed to take Spurs' Champions League spot due to the fact they won the trophy. As far as I can see it, Harry did enough to get into the Champions League, it wasn't his fault that Chelsea managed to freak their way into it at their expense.

4. Malky Mackay - Cardiff City

What a sickener for Malky Mackay. During his very successful, yet quite brief spell with Cardiff, he managed to take his Championship side to the League Cup Final, where they were only beaten in a penalty shoot-out with Liverpool, and then ultimately into the Premier League for the first time in the club's history, making it the first time there has been two Welsh teams in the English top-flight. Like Adkins, you would have thought that would be enough for him to keep his job for the foreseeable future - we all thought wrong. Vincent Tan, the clubs new owner, decided after a few games into their first top-flight season, that he did not like the way Mackay was operating. He questioned his style of play, his transfer budget, his signings and even the results (which weren't even that bad). Unlike what happened with Adkins, rumours that Malky would be sacked started to emerge days before as he had apparently been told to resign or be sacked, sparking a fan-campaign by the Cardiff faithful to prevent Tan from executing the deed. Unfortunately, Tan's dictator-like ownership and personality resulted in him going against his own fans to sack Malky Mackay. This decision sparked a huge cry from the Cardiff stands for Tan to leave the club. He did not really help matters when he appointed the fairly unproven Ole Gunner Solsjkaer, who's tenure up to now has seen their form dramatically dip, as well as their league standing. Malky's Cardiff were sitting in a respectable 15th position upon his sacking, now they sit in a bleak 19th position, 2 points from safety.

3. Michael Laudrup - Swansea City

It was a tough decision for which way round Laudrup and Mackay should be in the middle of this list, but Laudrup's sacking just edges it. Michael Laudrup replaced Brendan Rogers at Swansea before starting their first ever top-flight season in 2012/13 - the first ever Welsh entry into the English top-flight. It was easy to think that they had no chance before the league had even began; the thought of a new manager taking over a debut top-flight club was not a very positive one. It turned out much differently. Laudrup adopted a very particular style of play that appealed to Swansea completely. The style was pass, pass, pass. Brendan Rogers used simlar tactics while he was at Swansea, but with emphasis on the wings especially. With Laudrup, it was not just the wings that mattered; creating space for the pass was done all over the pitch and it was clear to see how much of a difference it was making. His team's play was instantly eye-catching, refreshing and most importantly, successful. Swansea began their debut Premier League season with a 5-0 win over fellow new guys, QPR. This set the tone for what was to come from Swansea, and after a few weeks they were dubbed the 'Barcelona of Wales' by much of the media for their extremely attractive and elegant play. Laudrup's team continued to flourish throughout the season, and they astonishingly won their first ever silverware, beating Bradford City 5-0 in a memorable league cup final, making the 2012/13 season even more historic for the Welsh club. They continued to defy the odds set before the season, and ended up finishing in an incredible 9th position. However, this season has not been so smooth for Swansea. They started off quite shaky, languishing in the relegation zone for much of the first month of games, but then turned it around to climb the table. Nevertheless, it was the month or two prior to his sacking that ultimately determined his fate, losing 6 from 8 games. The unfairness of it all doesn't just come from the fact that 4 of those teams he lost to were both the Manchester clubs, Chelsea and Tottenham - expected outcomes as they are much better teams, but like so many of the other unfair incidents of manager sackings, the owners were very quick to forget the things Laudrup had just achieved in the previous season with Swansea. They had obviously expected that they would maintain their form into the new season, which, for a club new to the top-flight, is extremely hard. Laudrup proved how successful he could be at Swansea, but their owners cheaply threw his services away just because of a small run of easily recoverable bad form - a very dismissive way of operating a football club.

2. George Burley - Hearts

To those of you reading this in England, this name may come as quite a surprise. This is the only entry into this list from Scotland, but it is as every bit deserving of 2nd place on the list as much as Leonardo DiCaprio deserves an Oscar. Burley was the first manager to be appointed by the controversial owner of Hearts, Vladimir Romanov, in 2005, and he got off to an absolutely incredible start. They won their first 8 matches in the league, including a 4-0 victory over Hibernian and a 1-0 win over Rangers. Burley was beginning to set the tone for what Romanov wanted to achieve at Hearts (which was basically world domination), but it all turned sour extremely quickly and unexpectedly. Hours before a home tie against Dunfermline, it was announced that George Burley had been sacked by Romanov due to irreconcilable differences (it was technically by mutual consent, but we all know that that means anyway). The friction between the two Hearts men was sparked by several actions from Romanov and the way he operates - a similarly dictating fashion that Vincent Tan has demonstrated recently with Cardiff. It's believed that Burley became angry that Romanov began signing players behind Burley's back. When Burley demonstrated his frustration, he was let go. In the aftermath, several members of the board resigned in protest to the way the club was being run, and Romanov replaced the club chairman with his son, Roman Romanov (what a name). The dictatorship notions of Romanov's tenure crept in ever-after. Now, the reason this is so high on the list given the length of time Burley had is because it was widely speculated that Hearts would have won the league in 2006 if it weren't for Burley's sacking, breaking the endless two horse race between Celtic and Rangers (now reduced to one horse, of course). The way his team were playing was frightening compared to the majority of the league, looking unstoppable against every team they came up against, including the teams from Glasgow. With a top spot finish, Hearts would have gained automatic entry to the group stage of the Champions League, bringing in huge money that they could have used for long-term stability. It could even be suggested that they may have avoided administration this season if they would have made those millions last. It was then shown at the end of the season what a chance they had to challenge for the title with Burley in charge, as despite his sacking early on, they came second in the league due to a poor season's performance by Rangers, who came third. I realise that this entry relies on a lot of 'what ifs', but the notion of Hearts being title challengers was so utterly important to Scottish football's future. Who knows what shape Scottish football would be in now if Hearts had managed to do the unthinkable, and then build upon their success to create a 3-horse race! TV broadcast money would have multiplied, meaning more money for the smaller SPL teams to spark their own challenges, and could perhaps have saved Rangers from their crippling journey through administration and liquidation in 2011/12. It really was that significant.

1. Roberto Di Matteo - Chelsea

dimatteo I'd imagine this is perhaps the name that Chelsea fans, as well as many others, would have guessed would top this list, and with good reason. Di Matteo was appointed caretaker manager of Chelsea after the sacking of Andres Villas Boas, and went on to enjoy a roller-coaster ride in the process. Roberto's first three results were wins against Birmingham, Stoke and Napoli, in the latter of which they overturned a 3-1 first leg defeat by winning 4-1 at home to win 5-4 on aggregate - basically putting right AVB's wrong from the first leg. That result created European form that just did not stop. After getting through against Napoli, Roberto's team eased into the semi's with a 3-1 aggregate win over Benfica. It was now beginning to look rather serious, but no-one gave them much hope seeing as the remaining teams alongside them were Barcelona, Real Madrid and Bayern Munich. Then came 2 of the most extraordinary results I have ever witnessed. Chelsea's 3-2 aggregate win over Barcelona, while playing most of the second leg with 10 men at the Nou Camp, was the most gripping game I've watched for some time. The audacity that scene throws up - Barcelona, who at the time were possibly the greatest team there has ever been, getting knocked out at home by 10-man Chelsea who were not even close to finishing in the top-four in the Premier League. Madness. And it was all down to tactical brilliance from Di Matteo. He read Barcelona's manual, he knew how to stop them, and losing a player didn't even matter because the game plan was just executed so perfectly. The madness continued as Chelsea managed to beat Bayern Munich in a penalty shootout to win the Champions League, their first ever. The match was played in a similar fashion, Roberto opting for the tight defensive ruthless, counter-attacking approach that got his team there. Di Matteo achieved Chelsea's most historic moment, dubbing him the greatest caretaker manager of all time by pundits, and it couldn't have been done by a more humble gentleman. Abramovich was delighted with this, as he is well known to be a man obsessed with the Champions League. But it didn't stop him from sacking Di Matteo after just a few games the following season. This decision was rightly met with the most robust of protests not only from Chelsea fans, but by the whole football world. Honestly, how can you sack a manager that has just brought back the European Cup, it boggles the mind. Furthermore, a kick in the teeth for the fans turned into a Chelsea smile (in a much darker, violent context than some might think) as Abramovich appointed Rafael Benitez as Roberto's replacement, the last person any Chelsea fan wanted to see at their club due to his historic clashes with him and the London club through the media while he was at Liverpool. It was a truly astonishing order of events in such a small space of time, and I believe it the worst manager sacking of the past 10 years and perhaps in the history of football. Do you agree with these entries? Is there any other sackings that you would have listed here that you would like to share? Please share your opinions and thoughts in the comment section below.

Contributor
Contributor

As a recent university graduate and a huge supporter of Celtic FC, what better way to use my inevitable free time to write about my favourite football team? I'll cover most things that the supporters are talking about at the moment, which includes things that directly and indirectly involve the club. At times I may also stray into matters concerning English clubs.