Arsenal Transfers - 10 Dream Replacements For Thomas Vermaelen

Arsenal could be in the market for a new centre-back following Vermaelen's transfer to Barcelona.

Arsenal manager Arsene Wenger has been handed a defensive conundrum ahead of this weekend's Premier League opener against Crystal Palace. The Gunner's impressive 3-0 dismissal of English champions Manchester City in last Sunday's Community Shield final was undermined by injury to Laurent Koscielny, leaving Wenger with a shortage of options at centre-back. Koscielny is expected to miss the clash with Palace with an achilles problem meaning Per Mertesacker is the only remaining senior centre-half for Wenger to select from. Koscielny's injury came on the same day club captain Thomas Vermaelen joined Barcelona for £15 million and combined, these issues could put the Gunners bang in the market for a new centre-back before the transfer window slams shut in under three weeks. As it stands, only rookie new signing Calum Chambers forms a credible option to partner Mertesacker at the heart of the defence and Wenger may opt to examine the market for someone with more seniority to the 19-year-old former Southampton defender as he looks to ease his mini-crisis at Emirates Stadium. With the new season set to start in four days' time and with only a few more weeks left to run of this summer's transfer window, we take a look at 10 Dream Replacements For Thomas Vermaelen to solve Wenger's woes at the back. Click 'next' to get started.

10. Toby Alderweireld

Toby Alderweireld only joined Atletico Madrid 12 months ago but could be looking for a second move in the space of a year following his disastrous debut season in Spain. The former Ajax star has been deemed surplys to requirements under Diego Simeone and spent most of 2013-14 on the bench, making a paltry 12 league appearances. And Arsenal could rescue him from his Madrid hell by bringing him to England this summer. Alderweireld has impressed in the few instances he has been given an opportunity and starred for native Belgium at this summer's World Cup, playing four games and helping the Red Devils to a surprise quarter-final berth. The multi-functional defender's arrival would also kill two birds with one stone. Alderweireld can play centre-back as well as right-back, meaning Arsene Wenger would not only be signing a replacement for Vermaelen but would also be providing extra cover for Mathieu Debuchy at right-back as well. The Belgian would provide a variety of options in defence and would certainly make a sensible acquisition.

9. William Carvalho

Arsenal have been tracking William Carvalho for much of the summer with manager Arsene Wenger keeping tabs on the in-demand Sporting Lisbon star. Wenger is also keen on Sami Khedira but sees Carvalho as a cheaper alternative to the Real Madrid man. Though usually a defensive midfielder by trade, Carvalho's secondary position is at centre-back meaning like Alderweireld, the multifaceted 22-year-old's versatility would allow Wenger a variety of options this season. The Gunners are in the market for a dominant holding midfielder of the ilk of club legend Patrick Vieira, but also need cover at centre-half following Koscielny's temporary set-back and Vermaelen's sale. Carvalho could play both roles when required and has a £35 million buy-out clause. He's by no means cheap but he definitely represents a less-expensive alternative to Khedira, who would want a four-year contract worth £150,000-a-week. Signing Carvalho would be a shrewd move on Wenger's part in that he could shore up two key areas in one fell swoop.

8. Jan Vertonghen

A controversial option, but one of which most Arsenal fans probably go to bed dreaming about. Tottenham centre-back Jan Vertonghen put a number of interested suitors on red alert earlier this year by suggesting he could quit White Hart Lane should Spurs fail to qualify for this season's Champions League. The Lilywhites didn't qualify for Europe's premiere competition meaning by his own admission he could be willing to move this summer. Spanish heavyweights Barcelona are keen on signing the Belgian defender while Arsenal too would be keen on poaching the centre-half from their fierce north London rivals, though Vertonghen has since distanced himself from his previous claims and revealed he has been offered a new five-year deal at the Lane. Nevertheless, the Gunners could test the waters with a bid and may turn the defender's head with the offer of Champions League football this season. Should such a dramatic transfer come to fruition however, it would prove just as combustible as Sol Campbell's switch from Spurs to Arsenal in 2001.

7. Benedikt Howedes

Alternatively, Arsenal could sign a World Cup winner this summer. Benedikt Howedes may well have endured a difficult spell with Schalke last season, with injury limiting the centre-back to just 19 Bundesliga appearances, but he bounced back from his treatment room nightmare in style by playing all seven of Germany's games at the finals in Brazil to help his country to glory. Howedes was one of many stars who excelled for Joachim Low's men this summer and he could star for Arsenal, too. The Germany international could offer Arsene Wenger a variety of options at Emirates Stadium in that he can also play at right-back meaning not only would he be a suitable replacement for Vermaelen and cover for Koscielny, but could also deputise for Mathieu Debuchy. There are a few sticking points to consider however. Howedes has been with Schalke his entire career and extended his contract at the club back in March. The Bundesliga side are also notoriously difficult to do business with as well, as the Gunners found out to their dismay during their failed attempt to sign Julian Draxler last year.

6. Matija Nastasic

How sweet it would be for Arsenal fans if their club could 'do a Manchester City' and snatch away a player from Etihad Stadium. City have notoriously made a habit of signing players from the Gunners and have done so five times over the last few years with Bacary Sagna following the likes of Gael Clichy, Kolo Toure, Emmanuel Adebayor and Samir Nasri to the Citizens earlier this summer. So it would be refreshing if the boot was on the other foot for a change and Arsenal took a leaf out of their rival's book. Matija Nastasic is on the fringes at City at present with the centre-back making just 13 Premier League appearances last season, of which he started only 10. And with Eliaquim Mangala arriving from Porto this week, first team opportunities are again expected to be scarce for the Serbian in 2014-15. It's difficult to envisage a future for Nastasic at the Etihad beyond this summer and Arsene Wenger would be wise to make a swoop for the 21-year-old, who has crucial Premier League experience having been a part of City's title winning team last season. The former Fiorentina man would provide experienced cover for Koscielny and would be a more than able replacement for Vermaelen.

5. Raphael Varane

Another on-the-fringes star Arsenal could target at the back this summer is Raphael Varane. The Real Madrid defender is a top class player but struggled at times last season to shift Pepe and Sergio Ramos from their centre-back positions. The 21-year-old found himself down the pecking order as such and made only 11 full appearances for the European champions in 2013-14. And now, both Chelsea and Arsenal are keen on the Frenchman, who has already been capped 11 times by his country. Strong, fast and good on the ball, Varane is in high-demand this summer and Real could be tempted to sell if they consider him surplus to requirements and an enticing-enough offer comes in. Better yet, reports suggest the starlet would come cheaply this summer, with Arsenal hoping to snap the classy centre-half up for as little as £23.5 million. With Madrid looking at signing Real Sociedad's Inigo Martinez this summer, Varane would fall further still out of contention under Carlo Ancelotti and a move to the Emirates could become all the more likely.

4. Mehdi Benatia

Arsenal are also rivaling Chelsea for Mehdi Benatia this summer if reports are to be believed with both British clubs keen on the highly-rated Roma centre-back. The Gunners could have a distinct advantage over their Premier League rivals in the race for the French-born Moroccan international in that the Blues cannot sign another foreign player this summer without exceeding their allowed quota under Premier League rules. Benatia has been earning rave reviews of late having joined Roma from Udinese last year and has earned a reputation as a goal-scoring defender, netting five in Serie A last season. His pace, power and strength also make him ideally suited for the Premier League, however his excellent performances, coupled by the fact he only joined Roma 12 months ago, means he will cost close to £50 million. Such a fee would mean the purchase of the 27-year-old would set a world transfer record for a defender and dwarf David Luiz's £40 million move from Chelsea to Paris Saint-Germain earlier this summer. That's clearly a blockbuster expenditure for the usually-frugal Arsene Wenger, meaning Arsenal fans may have to settle with dreaming about their club loosening their purse-strings on Benatia.

3. Neven Subotic

Could Arsenal revive their interest in Neven Subotic this summer? The Gunners have a long-standing interest in the Borussia Dortmund centre-half that dates back to 2009 with Arsene Wenger linked with a £12 million deal for the then-20-year-old. Nothing came to fruition but a move could feasibly be rekindled this summer. Subotic has just returned to first team action at Dortmund having sat out virtually all of his side's Bundesliga campaign in 2013-14 due to a knee injury but is raring to go again following eight months on the sidelines and could be tempted with a fresh challenge at this stage in his career having spent the last six years at the Westfalenstadion. A strong and dependable centre-half, Subotic comes with a wealth of experience having marshalled his side to back-to-back Bundesliga titles in 2010-11 and 2011-12 as well as helping them reach the Champions League final last year. In that final, he made an amazing goal-line intervention to prevent Bayern Munich's Arjen Robben from scoring a certain goal which shows you exactly what he's capable of when fit. If the Serbian can stay clear of injury, he is one of the world's best in his position and would be a fantastic addition at the Emirates.

2. Daniel Agger

Arsenal have been put on red alert this summer with Daniel Agger looking certain to leave Liverpool before the transfer window clangs shut. Agger was last week reported to have been reduced to tears as he begged Reds manager Brendan Rodgers to let him go after becoming frustrated with a lack of first-team opportunities. The Denmark international made only 14 Premier League stars last season after falling down the pecking order behind Martin Skrtel and Mamadou Sakho while the recent acquisition of Dejan Lovren at Anfield has sounded the death knell for his career at the Kop. And now, Arsenal could be set to rescue the centre-half from his Merseyside misery. Agger would be a quality signing for the Gunners as he has a wealth of Premier League experience under his belt and is already established in England, meaning unlike other defensive options on this list, there would be little to no transitional period. What's more, the player is desperate to leave, meaning it should be a cinch for Arsene Wenger to persuade Liverpool to sell - even if they would be strengthening a league rival in the process.

1. Mats Hummels

The biggest coup Arsenal could pull off this summer in terms of defensive signings is landing Mats Hummels. The in-demand Borussia Dortmund centre-half is one of Manchester United's biggest transfer targets while the Gunners too are interested and could hold a key advantage in the race to sign the Germany World Cup winner in that they could offer Champions League football. Hummels has been excellent recently and put in a series of stand-out performances at this summer's World Cup, playing all seven of his country's games at the finals in Brazil to inspire them to glory against Argentina. He has bags of experience at the highest levels of the game and helped his side win back-to-back Bundesliga titles between 2010-12. The defender would likely cost about £25 million which is a reasonable sum given his abilities although Dortmund are determined not to lose another star having already seen Robert Lewandowski slip through this fingertips, and have made Hummels this captain for the new season in a bid to ward off interested parties. Still, should the Gunners come in with a big enough offer, they may enjoy success in their efforts to land the centre-back and would be signing he perfect replacement for Vermaelen in doing so. Who do you think Arsene Wenger shroud sign to replace Thomas Vermaelen? Let us know in the comments thread below.

Contributor
Contributor

Joseph is an accredited football journalist and has interviewed nearly all of the current 20 Barclay's Premier League managers. He is also a correspondent for Bleacher Report and has written for Caught Offside and Give Me Football.