Cardiff 1-0 Swansea: Player Ratings

Cardiff City beat bitter South Wales rivals Swansea in the two sides' first top flight meeting. Steven Caulker headed home a corner to settle it. Who impressed us in the WhatCulture office? Here are out player ratings.

Cardiff

David Marshall: Saved from Michu and an offside Bony. Not a great deal to do, but what the Scottish stopper did was decent enough. 6/10. Kevin Theophile-Catherine: Crosses blocked time and again. A baffling summer signing, but physical enough to limit little Routledge from getting forward. 5/10. Steven Caulker: Good set piece threat from the former Spurs and Swansea man. Got on the end of Bellamy corner to score. Great defending to deny Bony thereafter. A towering presence in both areas. Our man of the match. 7/10. Ben Turner: A good partner for Caulker. Forced Michu and Bony to go deep in search of the ball. Overshadowed by his fellow centre half though. 5.5/10. Andrew Taylor: Frustrated Dyer throughout. With Swansea's wide threat nullified this was an accomplished performance from ex-Middlesbrough man. 6/10. Don Cowie: Always looking to exploit space. Mackay's faithful retainer was as industrious as anyone in the middle. 6/10. Jordon Mutch: Heard he was one to watch. Left wondering what all the fuss was about. Never got his foot on the ball in midfield long enough to make an impact. Subbed. 4.5/10. Gary Medel: More retriever than pitbull. England midfielders will hardly be quaking in their boots ahead of the Chile friendly based on this performance. More effective at passing from deep than his destructive reputation suggested. Subbed. 6/10. Peter Whittingham: Good corner deliveries as ever, but kicked out at Chico Flores for no apparent reason. Deservedly booked for an uncharacteristic outburst. 5.5/10. Craig Bellamy: Saw a free kick deflected over by Britton in first half. Got the assist for Caulker's winner. A consistent wide threat. Old habits die hard though as he got into a verbal exchange with Rangel. 6.5/10. Peter Odemwingie: Toiled away leading the line, but to no avail. Must do more to justify his wages. Campbell contributed more within seconds of coming on. 4.5/10. Subs: Aron Gunnarsson: Took over from anonymous Mutch and the Iceland captain always looked to break forward. Decent cameo in midfield. 5.5/10. Fraizer Campbell: Much better threat than Odemwingie in attack, but Mackay only gave him 15-20 minutes off the bench. Harried defenders all the time. 6.5/10. Kim Bo-Kyung: Only got on late. Rating N/A.

Swansea

Michel Vorm: Saved from Campbell, but shot straight at him. Sent off for bringing down Campbell when way out of his area. 4.5/10. Angel Rangel: Had to go in goal late on, tipped over Whittingham free kick. Tried to get up Bellamy's nose but failed. 4.5/10. Chico Flores: At fault for Cardiff's winner. Let Caulker get the jump on him and blame squarely at the Spaniard's door. 4/10. Ashley Williams: Campbell gave him problems when he came on. Williams just about got away with it, but on this form reports that linked him with Arsenal earlier this year now look laughable. 4.5/10. Neil Taylor: Did nothing to justify his place ahead of young Ben Davies. 4.5/10. Jonathan De Guzman: Pulled up on a rash, sliding tackle on Whittingham and lucky to escape punishment. Worked Marshall with late free kick, but JDG needs to hope Dutch national staff didn't watch this one. 5/10. Leon Britton: Headed Bellamy's first half free kick over his own crossbar. Diminutive pass master did not impose himself in the hostile cauldron of the Cardiff City Stadium. Subbed. 5/10. Nathan Dyer: Shot blocked by Whittingham and otherwise kept quiet by Cardiff fullback Taylor. One of his poorest performances in a Swansea shirt. 4/10. Jonjo Shelvey: His usual all-action self, could have stayed tighter on the post though from Cardiff goal. Best of a bad Swansea bunch today as he injected urgency and drive to an otherwise slow moving team. 6/10. Wayne Routledge: An off-day for the former Cardiff winger. Rather disappointing display from Routledge. Subbed. 4.5/10. Michu: Led the Swans threat, but blazed over from early Shelvey cross and worked Marhsall with another opening. Faded after picking up a foot injury that required treatment. Subbed. 5.5/10. Subs: Wilfried Bony: Got half an hour, but struggled to stay onside and passing was poor. 4.5/10. Alejandro Pozuelo: Drew a stop from Marshall in a 20 minute cameo. 5/10. Alvaro Vazquez: Only came on for ten minutes. Rating N/A.

Contributor
Contributor

Jamie Clark is a qualified Web Journalist after undergoing professional training at the University of Sheffield. A prolific and accredited sports writer, he also enjoys classic comedy, historic fiction, 80s music and heritage.