Man Utd: 5 Huge Mistakes David Moyes Keeps Making

If you're looking for Manchester United in the Premier League table this morning, you might be alarmed by the fact you have to scroll all the way down to 8th. That's how things stand for the defending champions at present, following their worst ever start to a league campaign that has seen them win just three games all season. Calamitous defeats against Liverpool, Manchester City and West Brom have interspersed with these unconvincing victories - with the Red Devils perhaps fortunate to leave the Stadium of Light with the three points against Sunderland earlier this month - while yet more points were dropped over the weekend against Southampton. That leaves them eight points adrift of table-toppers Arsenal - For United, and their manager David Moyes, this simply isn't good enough. There was always bound to be a transitional period when Moyes succeeded from the legendary Sir Alex Ferguson earlier this year, but even the most pessimistic of United fans wouldn't have feared it'd be this bad. The Old Trafford club's wretched start to the season can be pinned down to a number of reasons - tactical ineptitude from the dugout through to poor performances from the players - but it is Moyes who has to shoulder most of the blame. Here, we take a look at 5 Huge Mistakes David Moyes Keeps Making.

5. Sticking With 4-4-2

Since replacing Sir Alex Ferguson at Manchester United, David Moyes has sought to seek familiarity. He brought his own backroom team in, re-signed former player Marouane Fellaini, and even continues to stick with the 4-4-2 formation largely used during his Everton days. And while those tactics paid dividends at Goodison Park, with the Toffee's looking attacking and lively, at Old Trafford, they've made the Red Devils look static and immobile. The 4-4-2 formation is archaic, to the point that England manager Roy Hodgson was criticized by Gary Lineker for taking the side "back to the dark ages" with his preference of two lines of four. And in a way, Lineker was right, because since the Three Lions adopted the 4-3-3, they've looked far more adventurous and have started winning games again. United could also benefit from a change to their system, particularly as they appear to have a total lack of width and attacking impetus this season. Playing Michael Carrick and Marouane Fellaini in the two holding roles for example simply isn't working, with neither player keen to go past the halfway line on most occasions or even pass forward. Then there are other strange tactical decisions, such as sticking with ineffectual players and not making the right substitutions, which we will get too shortly.

4. Continuing To Partner Rio Ferdinand & Nemanja Vidic

Any football fan in the country could tell you that Rio Ferdinand and Nemanja Vidic shouldn't be played together anymore. The two veterans were paired together in all four of United's games at the start of the season and you can virtually hear their knees creaking. Given their age and respective injury record, the two should be rotated alongside Jonny Evans, who enjoyed a good campaign last season but has scarcely played this term. Then there's Chris Smalling, who also hasn't been given much of a look in under David Moyes, but should be given time to forge a relationship with youngsters like Rafael, Evans and Phil Jones. Sticking with the old guard week-in-week-out isn't the way forward and Moyes has to realise this.

3. Overlooking Shinji Kagawa

Many have complained since the closure of the summer transfer window over David Moyes's inability to bring in new players, with many pointing out that it was a creative midfielder that the champions desperately needed. Yet they have had one sitting on the bench all this time in the shape of Shinji Kagawa, who perplexingly hasn't been given a look-in under Moyes. It's frankly incredible that the Japan international has played a mere 45 minutes of football all season, hooked off at half time against West Brom. Kagawa was a part of one of European football's most vibrant sides between 2010-12, helping former club Borussia Dortmund sweep all opposition aside in their back-to-back Bundesliga-winning campaigns. And surely he's a better option in midfield than the likes of the ineffectual Nani, Anderson, Antonio Valencia and Ashley Young?

2. Poor Substitutions

Some of David Moyes's tactical decisions this season have been very strange. We've already discussed the misguided decision to play Rio Ferdinand alongside Nemanja vidic too frequently, along with the decision to haul Kagawa off at half time against West Brom. But that's not all. In that same game, Alex Buttner and Anderson were selected and both were found badly wanting, with Buttner ran ragged by Amalfitano and an unfit -looking Anderson unable to keep up with Yacob and Mulumbu. It's also odd, especially given the woeful inadequacies of United's wingers this season, that new boy Wilfried Zaha hasn't been given a chance to impress following his arrival from Crystal Palace. There's talk of the wide man going back out on loan in January which means Moyes must be pleased with what he has on the flanks - which he surely shouldn't be.

1. Ignoring Javier Hernandez

It might be stating the obvious, but what United need right now is goals. The Red Devils have only scored 11 times this season - fewer than the teams currently occupying the top 4 spots - and it is this lack of firepower and ability to finish off games (I.e against Southampton) that has led to their decline. Surely then Javier Hernandez should be playing more frequently than the mere 87 minutes he has clocked up on the pitch this season? Oh how United could have benfited from having a predatory striker in the box when they were going in search of that elusive second goal against the Saints at the weekend. Yet for some reason, Moyes, like he has done with Kagawa, has decided not to play the Mexican, despite the fact he is statistically far more potent in front of goal than the likes of Danny Welbeck. And it is ignorance's such as these that are costing United this season. How do you explain United's dreadful start to the season? Should David Moyes shoulder the blame? Let us know in the comment section, below.

Contributor
Contributor

Joseph is an accredited football journalist and has interviewed nearly all of the current 20 Barclay's Premier League managers. He is also a correspondent for Bleacher Report and has written for Caught Offside and Give Me Football.