Man Utd Transfers: 10 Replacements For Scholes

yoan gourcuff Over the last 20 years, Paul Scholes has more or less been a mainstay of the Manchester United central midfield barring a six month spell where he called time on his career and decided to retire. That period from August 2011 to January 2012 saw a couple of attempts to try to replace him, but no-one seemed to exert the influence on the midfield like he did, and of course the midfield dynamo chose to rethink his decision to quit. Many pundits were constantly noting the lack of creativity and the lack of finding a ready made replacement for when that day would eventually come. It did and no-one came, so what better way to replace the creativity and severe influence of Paul Scholes... with the creativity and severe influence of Paul Scholes. His decision to come out of retirement galvanised the team and plugged the gap left by himself. When that day eventually comes (again!) for Scholes to permanantly call it a day, then United will be bereft of his talent he has shown since his debut in 1994. So, Sir Alex Ferguson needs a shortlist and I've come up with 10 potential players to step up and give them a lasting legacy. Like most of Ferguson's signings my list is made up of players under the age of 27, and furthermore it is not in order of personal preference... So, let us see who can do it?!

10. Christian Eriksen

A Danish breakout star at 16 with FC Copenhagen and in a World Cup squad at 18, Eriksen attracted a lot of plaudits and impressive comparisons to the Laudrup brothers by Johan Cruyff and many awards recognising his considerable talent. Like Paul Scholes, he is known for his incisive passing and link up play with team mates, as 48 assists in his short career shows. The prospect of Robin Van Persie, Wayne Rooney and/or Javier Hernandez in front of him is a mouth-watering one, considering how valuable his approach would be for their goal scoring records. As always with Sir Alex Ferguson, Eriksen's signature would be completed with one eye on the future: Sir Alex invariably looks to the future and to building a team who could mature beyond the limit of his own tenure.

9. Jack Wilshere

jack wilshere An Englishman in a top PL side has become a rarity in recent years especially with first Abramovich at Chelsea and then Sheikh Mansour's takeover of Man City. However, everyone wants to be winning trophies to compliment themselves and to make them feel like they have achieved a lot. This is where United come in; Wilshere continues dictating the pace of a game and showing off his intricate passing skills drilled into him throughout his Arsenal youth and supplements his talent with a sizeable amount of trophies. This is what Scholes has mastered in the last 15+ years at Old Trafford and with that hole soon to appear with his- second- retirement, Ferguson needs to find someone who can act as a like for like change, as such. With Wenger under the usual mid-season pressure, may there be a time in the next couple of years where he snaps and leaves the club he loves? May that be a time where Wilshere leaves at the same time? Certainly, for an effective working relationship with his future CM partner for England, Tom Cleverley, he may be tempted.

8. Mario Gotze

As part of the never-ending (it seems) production line of immense German talent, Mario Gotze looks to have made his impact at Dortmund contributing heavily to their back to back Bundesliga titles. Gotze, at 19, has shown himself to Joachim Low, German national coach, who selected him in his Euro 2012 squad, managing to get himself a starting place in 1/4 final win over Greece. Touted as the next best thing by Dortmund director of football Matthias Sammer, he's established a good partnership with all around him in the Dortmund midfield allowing a fluid style of play and passing (a trait Ferguson and many others for that matter, like their teams to play like). However, if he could be tempted from his role in the Dortmund team and all their possible future success, it'd certainly hard to prize him away from his role there and go to Old Trafford. Having said that, Sir Alex has produced a transfer coup or two in his 26 year tenure so far.


7. Yoann Gourcuff

yoan gourcuff A versatile player who has proven his worth at various French clubs since making his debut at the age of 17 in 2003, Gourcuff has been touted as being the next Zidane and the best player of his generation by David Ginola. His assist and goal record at club level are in close proximity with 49 assists and 40 goals, suggesting that he will be of value to United linking up well with teammates as well as chipping in, something Scholes has regularly done over his time here. However, one blot on his career came at Milan where his temperament and attitude came under fire by then-manager Carlo Ancelotti and Milan legend Paolo Maldini where his work ethic, temperamnet and his refusal to speak the native language caused friction bewteen the players. This however shouldn't be a problem, as Sir Alex has a history with those types of players and man managing, so he should be able to fine tune this problem and get people talking about the football If he does make it, he can become a hero among the Stretford End diehards and become the next French footballer, after Eric Cantona, to be worshipped.


6. Isco We now go over to Spain for our next candidate, not yet a winner of any trophies (potential for transfer), howver he's in the same class as Cesc Fabregas and Lionel Messi... by winning the Golden Boy Award for the most promising young European player, as voted for by L'Equipe readers. Buoyed by this and La Liga Breakthrough Award both in 2012, he has shone in his role as CM at Malaga, while sometimes operating as a winger. Instrumental in helping them reach their debut season in the Champions League, he has become hot property and has now been given a platform for primetime viewing by top European managers. Still only 20, he has a lot of developing to do, as a player, but this versatility shows that he is adept as multiple positions and will be able to cover in times of injury crisis, but primarily he is a CM and a good one at that scoring 8 goals in the 2011-12 season. However, with Malaga financial crisis clasping the club and forcing it's hand with regards to expenditure and add that to a European ban for 3 years, United may swoop for the playmaker.


5. Nick Powell

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M1YEaeNqYPo Perhaps given the success of nurturing talent at Old Trafford, a potential replacement comes from within? Currently, Powell is being gently integrated into the first team, as well as gaining good exposure on a lower scale with an extended run in the central midfield of Man United's U-21 team, scoring goals to help his star rise (scored his debut senior Man United goal v Wigan on 15th September, as well as a couple of goals in a recent win v West Ham in U21 Premier League game). Add that to a sharp rise to making his debut England U21 earlier this year, he looks to have got a surety and calmness on the ball about him, characteristics that set Paul Scholes out from the ordinary. Attributes look to be the same as Scholes, goals out of the ordinary can be scored, like Scholes and he's only 19, so he has plenty of years ahead of him to make himself a modern great, both for club and country.

4. Sami Khedira

Sami Khedira With 285 club appearances (as of March 8th 2013) he is the most experienced midfielder in this list, however he is yet still young at 25, so he has plenty of playing time left in his career. With leagues and cups under his belt in both Spain and Germany, he has proved his worth to Real Madrid and Stuttgart respectively, proving that his technical skills are competent, an asset that can benefit the Premier League and more specifically United. He is characterised and praised by his ability to cover vast swathes of the pitch, whether it be breaking up opposition attacks or dictating the pace of his team's forays into their attacking third. Now, this may evoke images of Paul Scholes' terrior-like tenacity in his younger years, something that United and their loyal followers feel that they lack at the moment, so this plugs the gap. Along with other foreigners mentioned, they aspire to play in the Premier League; to play alongside and against worldwide stars already settled in there. The pace and the fierceness after all will benefit and enhance his game.

3. Marco Verratti

verratti Italians are particularly well noted these days for the quality of Central Midfielders that have graced the Serie A, the European and the World stage (Daniele De Rossi, Francesco Totti and Andrea Pirlo among them). Marco Verratti has already gone abroad as part of the Qatari revolution at PSG, to allow him to gain mass exposure at a media-heavy club. A potentially shrewd move, if he is to consolidate his place in the national team, and with David Beckham gaining much attention from the French and international press, Verratti can allow himself to get on with his game, as the spotlight isn't as glaring on him, as it might've done if he remained in Italy. Most often found in a deep-lying position, he is in a position to emulate these greats with his powers of passing and his positional sense on the field seen to be his best attributes. His development is being enhanced by playing around world class stars such as Zlatan Ibrahimovic and David Beckham which can only be a huge plus, so the fact he will be used to not be the centre of attention in the team will aid the transition from Ligue 1 to the Premier League, where all the stars come out to play, week in and week out.

2. Will Hughes

At 17, Will Hughes is the youngest replacement-elect on this shortlist. He seems to show a maturity far beyond his years and has been able to cope well with the high demands of the Championship. The best part is that he is English, so all the more reason to join United! He has received high praise from both his club manager Nigel Clough and England U-21 manager Peter Taylor regarding his creatvity and his teamwork characterised by mazy runs to aid team mates or the occasional blaster from 30 yards. He is currently being rested by Clough to reduce the stress on his body, which will benefit him in the long run, allowing a relaxed and refreshed Hughes to take the field next season or possibly sooner in Sweden at the U21 European Championships. Exposure of him, has got the scouts working overtime on him at top clubs and this rest may give those at United a chance to approach Clough for a deal to be penned between the two clubs. At this current moment, a quartet of English CM€™s is rising, giving hope to the fans of the national teams. It is just left to give Hughes a platform to match his vast talent like Wilshere, Cleverley and Powell, who are the other three.

1. Barry Bannan

Barry Bannan Sometimes a team's position does not reflect the individual talents within it. A poor Villa team has had their moments in the season and Bannan has been a heartbeat of the team able to link defence and thread killer passes through to Christian Benteke, who along with Bannan has provided the magical moments and hold the key to their team's survival in the Premier League. The multiple sides of his game have endeared himself to the Holte End faithful and he, in return, will give 100% to the cause, no matter the hardship. If the worst comes to fruition and relegation ensues, Villa will have to do a lot to persuade that his services are needed at Villa Park and not elsewhere back in the Premier League, where his talents can be nurtured and enhanced in another club. As mentioned earlier, his knack to pick out the right pass has undone the hardiest of defences as well as his long ball delivery that certain individuals would thrive on receiving. He is also a competent crosser, if he is required to fulfill that role. The division in which Villa end up in come 6pm on the 19th May, may shape his long-term future with regards establishing himself as a real British talent and gaining sufficient exposure to gain a constant spot in future Scotland squads. Maybe there are other players that can step up, use the comment section below to add to this list.


Contributor
Contributor

I'm an aspiring sports journalist, with a keen interest in football, cricket and some other things too. If you would like to follow me on twitter: @wscarter95