Newcastle 0-1 Man Utd: Tactical Deconstruction

Ashley Young grabbed a last minute winner to keep United in the top four ahead after an interesting tactical shift from Louis Van Gaal.

United Starting XI It was just the one change from the side that defeated Sunderland 2-0 at the weekend, Wayne Rooney who bagged a brace against Gus Poyet's men was selected as a lone striker to the pleasure United fans. This meant Falcao dropping to the bench, paving the way for Marouane Fellaini to return to the starting XI playing in the position of 'shadow striker' just behind Rooney. Although the Belgian midfielder may suggest that his best position is as a ball winning midfielder in the centre of the park, most will agree that due to his aerial prowess he is much more effective further up the field causing havoc as he did so well for Everton a few seasons ago. United XI v Newcastle United maintained the same basic shape that achieved success at home to Sunderland and although it must be noted that a formation is forever changing throughout a match as the team shifts in and out of transitions, they generally lined up in a 4-2-3-1 system. The last two games have seen United reintroduce wingers to the starting XI to address their much criticised attacking problems. This has meant a recall for Ashley Young who still remains a superb crosser of the ball, despite his challenging time at United. In addition, Di Maria has been pushed out to the right flank in the position he played in for Real Madrid. This tactical shift has also been beneficial for Ander Herrera who was struggling to break into the team but is now required to add numbers to the midfield.

Wing Play

United Wing Play United's plan was simple and traditionally English - get the ball wide and deliver inviting crosses into the box for the strikers to attack. There are a few reasons why it was clear this was their game plan. Firstly lets look at the positions of Young and Di Maria. Both wingers were playing on the opposite flank to their preferred foot so naturally their tendency would be to drift inside into the number ten position and attempt incisive through balls or deliver in swinging crosses. Since this was not the case, it was clear that both players had been given strict instructions to stay as glued to their touchlines as possible. Despite this when one of them had the ball, the other was then given the license to roam inside towards the edge of the box or join Fellaini and Rooney in the box. With Fellaini in the position of shadow striker rather than a traditional number ten, he wouldn't occupy the area outside the box like a Juan Mata would for example, leaving the space open for either Young or Di Maria to exploit. This is exactly what happened leading up to the chance Rooney chipped wide in the first half. Di Maria was in possession of the ball on the right wing and delivered infield to Young, who had arrived in the number ten position vacated by the roaming Fellaini and his pass through to Rooney almost brought about the opening goal. The selection of Fellaini and Rooney as a partnership also suggests that United were aiming to dominant aerially in an attacking sense. As mentioned, Fellaini excelled playing just off the main striker at Everton as he could cause chaos in the box and it is often forgotten that Rooney is very able in the air. Reflecting back on his season in 2009/10 when he was tasked with being a lone striker following the departure of Cristiano Ronaldo, many of his goals came from his head. Unfortunately for United, this shift away from wanting to work through the middle of the pitch didn't pay dividends as the quality of the crosses into the box weren't up to scratch, Di Maria struggled to stick to his touchline - hence his half time substitution and Fellaini didn't support Rooney well enough, instead choosing to play neat passes from deeper positions.

Defence Still Exposed

United Defence V Newcastle Despite United boasting the third best defensive record in the Premier League, United's back four is still coming under severe scrutiny and they are constantly being linked with defenders such as Mats Hummels as a result. This is due to David De Gea being credited for supposedly saving his lacklustre defence. As excellent as he has been though, it is arguable that United's midfield throughout the season haven't provided enough protection to the back four which may have unfairly received a lot of criticism. Prior to this game the problem was shape. United Attack V Swansea1 The diagram above shows how United lined up in attack in their 2-1 defeat to Swansea a couple of weeks ago. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out what went wrong for them. The team was simply imbalanced - with three forward players in the diamond midfield as well as two strikers on the pitch, Daley Blind was the only player mopping up in front of the back four. Analysing the diagram at the top of the page now, it is clear that Van Gaal has attempted to address this problem in the last two games by switching to two holding midfielders and only selecting one central striker. Although he'd picked the correct system to address his defensive issues, the same can't be said for personnel. Herrera was the player selected to partner Blind at the base of the midfield and form a double-pivot with. However, due to his natural inclination to support attacks and to rush out and close the ball down by leaving his position, once again Blind had the job of marking multiple midfield players and, as the diagram demonstrates, he was constantly overloaded by Sissoko and Abeid in that area. With these things considered though, they may still be having problems but have managed to keep two clean sheets in the last two games playing this way.

Conclusion

This quite fortuitous win against Newcastle displayed a few tactical advancements from Louis Van Gaal's men but still a few short comings. The decision to play a more balanced 4-2-3-1 as opposed to a 4-1-3-2 is certainly paying dividends defensively as United have kept two consecutive clean sheets and only allowed Newcastle two shots on target in the entire game. Despite Herrera's defensive positioning still being an issue, they are certainly making strides in this area. The idea of playing wider in the last two games hasn't done anything to effect United's slow attacks. The fact still remains that their tempo is still too slow, they play too many passes backwards and are overly obsessed with possession statistics. It doesn't matter whether their intention is to penetrate through the middle or out wide, if the transition to the final third is as sloppy as it has been, clear cut chances are difficult to come by. This game has gone to show that tactics can quite simply be thrown out the window when it comes to individual errors. Ashley Young's winner can't be explained with reason, it's just one of those things.

Contributor

Having recently graduated from university, I have joined WhatCulture as a contributor to cover sport, WWE, TV and film. Formerly published nationally in the Guardian and Independent.