Newcastle United 2-2 Southampton – Player Ratings

Georginio Wijnaldum makes his mark while Aleksandar Mitrovic could have seen red.

Steve McClaren's competitive Newcastle United career has started with a spirited draw against Ronald Koeman's Southampton. The Magpies came flying out the blocks against the Saints with a point to prove and pressed, counter-attacked and dominated possession for a good 15 minutes. Their new-season adrenaline rush was squashed by Graziano Pelle's towering header in which Chancel Mbemba - who jumped to his optimum height - was nowhere near even making a challenge. But, unlike many of the matches under Alan Pardew and John Carver, the positive passage of play returned to the Magpies after going a goal behind and a chested finish from Papiss Cisse and a bullet-header from Georginio Wijnaldum either side of half-time put the Magpies deservedly in front. From there, Newcastle battled every second ball and a refreshing tenacity swept across St James' Park as they searched for an opening-day win. Unfortunately their relentless pressing started to waiver and the Saints dominated a 10-minute second-half spell ending with Dusan Tadic's cross finding Shane Long's head and then the back of the net. From then, both teams looked happy to settle for a point and the game finished 2-2 despite Sadio Mane going extremely close in stoppage time. Here at WhatCulture.com/NUFC we rate all of the Newcastle players performances and analyse how they did against an extremely competent Southampton side. See how new boys Mitrovic, Wijnaldum and Mbemba all got on...

1. Tim Krul - 6

You could argue that Tim Krul could have saved both of Graziano Pelle's and Shane Long's headers but they were both fine finishes and, besides conceding those two goals, the Dutch keeper was relatively solid. His kicking was woeful once more but we all knew that would be the case prior to kick-off.

2. Daryl Janmaat - 6

A solid performance from Daryl Janmaat on Sunday, with the Dutchman strong going forward and he also looked comfortable defensively throughout the entire first-half. In the second 45, he struggled slightly with the pace of Sadio Mane and was left exposed when Southampton broke quickly on the counter attack.

3. Massadio Haidara - 5

Massadio Haidara has rightfully earned that spot at left full-back after a string of good pre-season performances but the step-up to Premier League level is still someway off for the 22-year-old. His first touch needs a lot of work and let him down on numerous occasions as well as slowing the team's play. His saving grace was his ability to put high-level crosses into the box and he grabbed the assist for Papiss Cisse's first goal.

4. Fabricio Coloccini - 4

My pre-match concerns were almost all demonstrated by Fabricio Coloccini on Sunday. The Argentine was woefully slow, positionally awkward and painfully unfit. The defender did not challenge for a single header and seemed to have no relationship whatsoever with Chancel Mbemba (of who he should have been mentoring better).

5. Chancel Mbemba - 6

Chancel Mbemba's aerial ability is going to be a concern if he is going to be paired with Fabricio Coloccini, as was demonstrated for Southampton's first goal. He is a like-for-like for his Argentine teammate - rather than a Mike Williamson replacement - and the pairing were disorganised throughout the match. On the ground, Mbemba demonstrated his class and made a number of high-quality interceptions and passes from the back.

6. Vurnon Anita - 6 (Replaced By Cheick Tiote After 66 Minutes)

Vurnon Anita was replaced after 66 minutes after falling awkwardly and damaging his back. The midfielder had played reasonably well before being stretchered off but still needs to improve his basic passing after misplacing three square balls in the first-half that could have led to a dangerous Southampton counter attack. His positional skills also need polishing as both he and Jack Colback as the central pivots didn't look comfortable at times and they were both slightly ill-disciplined.

Chieck Tiote - 5

Chieck Tiote replaced Vurnon Anita after 66 minutes and looked tidy on the ball. The Ivorian has had a staggered pre-season and looked well off the pace of the Premier League.

7. Jack Colback - 6

Jack Colback was solid in midfield but his partnership with Vurnon Anita needs to be perfected. The duo lacked a symmetry and the English midfielder will have to add more to his game going forward. Defensively he was industrious and he made some crucial interceptions towards the end of the game.

8. Gabriel Obertan - 7

Gabriel Obertan was a constant outlet for Newcastle on Sunday, with the central-midfielders looking for his movement on many occasions. The Frenchman's passing was more accurate than we have seen throughout pre-season and he grabbed a brilliant assist for Georginio Wijnaldum's headed goal.

9. Moussa Sissoko - 7

Moussa Sissoko started the game with a vengeance and his striding runs were crucial in helping Newcastle keep possession and in terms of causing problems for the Southampton defence. There were also absolutely no signs of him not wanting to play for the club as he gave 100% effort throughout the entire game. One problem (considering he is playing on the wing) is he can't cross the ball particularly well...

10. Georginio Wijnaldum - 8 (Replaced by Siem De Jong After 81 Minutes)

Georginio Wijnaldum would certainly have been the name on everyone's lips as they left St James' Park on Sunday. The new signing moved the ball well, retained possession and scored a fantastic headed goal after making a typical box-to-box run at the beginning of the second-half. He was replaced by Siem de Jong after 81 minutes.

Siem De Jong - 5

He replaced Wijnaldum after 81 minutes and didn't get a chance to make any kind of impact as Newcastle tried to hold on to a draw. Will be interesting to see how much game-time the Dutchman gets this season.

11. Papiss Cisse - 7 (Replaced by Aleksandar Mitrovic After 75 Minutes)

The striker had to prove that he was worth a starting place on Sunday and he did that by scoring in the 42nd minute. He looked fit, lively and, despite scoring from just one yard out, he was a constant presence in the Southampton area and was always in the right positions on the field.

Aleksandar Mitrovic - 4

The Serbian striker who was booked after five seconds and will need to be careful going forward. The 20-year-old then elbowed Matt Targett afterwards and should have been shown a red card. CLICK HERE to read the Match Report from Newcastle United 2-2 Southampton.For all the latest NUFC News, Views and Transfers make sure to follow WhatCulture.com/NUFC on Twitter and Facebook.

Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-accredited football writer with an MA in Sports Journalism. What Culture football editor. Write for the official Newcastle United programme. Former video reporter at North News. Featured and published in the Sunderland Echo, Shields Gazette, Mail Online, The Mirror, The Sun and others.