10 Most Messed Up Deaths In Star Trek: Lower Decks

In our series of messed up deaths, have we seen anything as horrible as the black mountain?

Star Trek Lower Decks USS Solvang
CBS Media Ventures

In Star Trek: Lower Decks, the stakes tend to be fairly low. It's a comedy, after all! Who wants to see the characters that make them laugh explode into smithereens, or even disappear up the chimney of a transporter accident? No one, that's who! End of list, thanks for joining.

Although.

Lower Decks still is a Star Trek series and, as such, features the same kinds of danger that one might find in Discovery or Deep Space Nine. The Jem'hadar may be lying in wait while a giant anomaly slices its way through the galaxy, hoovering up all of the particles in its wake. Standard Tuesday in the final frontier.

While this show is admittedly a little lighter on the horrific body count, it still contributes a few examples for our series. Things may seem grim at TrekCulture towers when we concentrate on the grizzly demise of our favourite heroes but then what's life without a bit of balance? And what's death without the chance to come back, hiking boots and all?

Lower Decks gave us the great get out of jail free card that is the black mountain, but how many officers and crew have passed over it? And, more pointedly, how many of them were junior officers, or just those exalted senior staff? 

Join us as we take a look through the obituary section of the USS Cerritos and beyond.

10. The Genesis Of Locarno

Star Trek Lower Decks Nick Locarno
CBS Media Ventures

In 1982, audiences were treated to the awesome power of the Genesis Device. As it detonated, exploding the USS Reliant, Khan, and any remaining survivors aboard, it began to reshape all of the matter in the Mutara Sector while the Enterprise escaped at warp. It was a beautiful sight, watching a new planet form in the stars, even if it didn't have a long shelf-life.

Jumping forward one hundred years and, wouldn't you know it, the Ferengi had managed to get their hands on this technology, despite bans from Earth to Qo'Nos. Tom Locarno, disgruntled with his place in society, sought the means to bolster his 'Nova Fleet' and hold the quadrant to ransom.

He acquired a Ferengi Genesis Device as insurance, but activated it during a fight with Lt. Jnr. Grade Mariner, having badly misjudged his former Academy classmate. While she was beamed away, he attempted to deactivate the device, only to discover that the Ferengi had installed a paywall in front of any deactivation commands. Out of time and out of latinum, Locarno was vaporised in the resulting explosion, though it didn't end there. His atoms, molecules, and every part of him were reshaped and reformed, becoming the basis of a new world - Locarno.

While an explosion to the face isn't the best way to go, having your atoms reform into a world that would be used for refugees to resettle is, actually, a bit of a consolation.


9. The Black Mountain

Star Trek Lower Decks No Small Parts Shaxs Funeral
CBS Media Ventures

When Lt. Shaxs met his bitter (or triumphant, depending on who you ask) end in No Small Parts, one would be forgiven for believing that was the end of the road for the Bajoran security chief. This man had lived his life in service to the Prophets (and explosions) so he was on the one-way ride to the Celestial Temple, easy.

Suddenly, Ensign Rutherford started to notice some strange things aboard the Cerritos. Who was the hulking Bajoran walking around the ship in gold? Why was there an officer who bore a striking resemblance to the dearly departed Shaxs still serving on the bridge?

It was true! Shaxs was back - and he didn't come via the easy route. 

Star Trek: Lower Decks took fine aim at those times characters popped back from the dead in the rest of the franchise. Spock had taken a siesta in The Wrath Of Khan and Harry Kim may even be a record-holder in death standings, but both of them came back. Why not Shaxs? Why not everyone?

It involves a Black Mountain and a large Koala. When Rutherford confronted Shaxs, the latter whispered the truth into the former's horrified ears, warping his very understanding of reality and the universe. Some things are better left unsaid, as Rutherford would surely agree.

But hey, at least we got Shaxs back! 


8. Death By Neck Break

Star Trek Lower Decks Terminal Provocations Badgey
CBS Media Ventures

When you're an AI being with a heart full of digital hatred for you creator, is there anything worse than having that same creator lay his hands on your head and twist it violently around? If you want to know what that feels like, it's best to ask the original version of Badgey, if one can get in touch with him on the higher plane.

When Rutherford's errant AI started to show its true maniacal leanings, things were looking grim for the young ensign and his friends. Trapped on the holodeck, surrounded by a frozen tundra and running out of time, Rutherford tried to reason with the charmingly-murderous Starfleet Delta. Having run out of options, and with diplomacy rapidly failing, he tried the only option left - a little mercy killing.

Rutherford snapped Badgey's neck, despite the anatomical questions raised, killing him, and saving the ship. Things obviously didn't end there, as Badgey was directly responsible for Shaxs's death later in the season, and is currently an omnipotent being travelling the very highways of reality, but in the moment it was a fairly brutal way to go. 

Death by parent has got to be grim, Delta shaped body or not. 


7. Pakleds, Really?

Star Trek Lower Decks No Small Parts USS Solvang
CBS Media Ventures

Captain Dayton and the crew of the USS Solvang had one of the more tragic endings in Star Trek: Lower Decks. Long before they took over the fresh-out-of-the-wrapped USS Solvang, they were faced with the loss of their previous ship, the USS Rubidoux. That ship was the birthing site of a large space organism, so at least there was life from lifelessness. 

The Solvang was not so fortunate.

In one of the more shocking twists of Lower Decks's first season, the Pakleds had begun to gather pieces of other technology together, forming huge 'clumpships'. Though they weren't burdened with an overabundance of intelligence, they were suddenly in possession of fairly devastating ships. 

The USS Solvang is ambushed by these Pakleds and quickly overpowered. Captain Dayton is horrified, naturally. She had just been chiding the crew not to wear their shoes on the carpet on the bridge, then here comes some of the galaxy's dumbest villains, ready to ruin her day. 

The shields are quickly depleted so a quick escape would seem to be the best course of actions. Dayton gives the order to warp away, not realising that the Pakleds had grabbed the ship with giant claws and tendrils. As the Solvang engages the warp engines, a nacelle is torn away from the rest of the ship, causing a devastating explosion and destroying the Solvang, Dayton, and the entire crew. 

It is bad enough to lose the ship and her crew. But to lose them to the Pakleds? That's just sad. 


6. Harry. Again.

Star Trek Lower Decks Fissure Quest Harry Kim
CBS Media Ventures

Though it took more than twenty years, as well as two guest spots from his podcast co-host, Garrett Wang returned to Star Trek in the fifth season, penultimate episode, Fissure Quest. The catch was that it wasn't the original Harry Kim on our screens. Though, to be fair, the original Harry Kim's body was still floating in space somewhere in the Delta Quadrant, so who's to say?

Harry, Harry, and a group of Harrys, found themselves aboard the USS Anaximander, commanded by Captain William Boimler. The ship was tasked with closing quantum fissures, all of which were damaging reality, one tear at a time. Though the cause of the tears was benign, the impact was anything but.

One of the Harrys, tired of being the brunt of most jokes, took his second pip and the rest of the Harrys, hijacked the Beagle, and made straight for one of these fissures. Though he was determined to take his tribe somewhere to get a bit of respect in the universe, the rest of them were having none of it, trying their best to overpower him before causing yet another explosion. 

In the end, Harry was flying solo, with only his lieutenant's bars to keep him company. Engaging the drive, he pushed forward, heading straight into the mouth of a massive explosion. The result was another dead Kim and the potential end of reality as we knew it.

The promotion was a mistake. 


5. Killer AI In The Face

Star Trek Lower Decks The Stars At Night Admiral Buenamigo
CBS Media Ventures

Vice-Admiral Les Buenamigo is very much responsible for his own demise, to be clear from the outset. His ambition and his hubris resulted in not only his own death, but the deaths of many other officers and crew in Starfleet. He is yet another cautionary tale of putting too much trust in entirely automated ships, a lesson one would think had been well-learned by 2381.

His plan to implement the Texas-class ships into Starfleet was part of his long-term ambition to advance. Though he began the project as a lieutenant commander, by the time he'd reached Vice-Admiralty, he felt that he had hit the ceiling in terms of promotion. The Texas-class was then to be his legacy, though as things turned out, it wouldn't be a legacy he would particularly want.

He had been responsible for then-Cadet Rutherford's Vulcan implant, leading to a complete personality shift. Rutherford had been an errant and troubled young man and had designed an artificial intelligence program that Buenamigo would use, though as the future would show (in the form of Badgey), it was not suitable for autonomy. 

In 2381, Rutherford recognised his own work, corrupted and controlling the USS Aledo, but it was too late for Buenamigo. Fearing exposure by Captain Freeman and the USS Cerritos, he gave the Texas-class ships full freedom to control themselves, and ordered the destruction of the California-class ship. The Aledo instead turned its phasers on the Vice-Admiral, vaporising him and destroying his office aboard Douglas Station. 


4. Decapitation By Mugato

Star Trek Lower Decks Mugato Gumato Patingi
CBS Media Ventures

It's quite a thing to see a cheerful Tellarite, yet Patingi was exactly that when Ensigns Boimler and Rutherford encountered him on the surface of Frylon IV in 2381. He claimed to be a biologist of some reknown, with five whole books on Mugatos. 

Boimler and Rutherford had just encountered several such Mugatos, herded by Ferengi in an illegal trading mission, and had watched them break free. Mugatos, not well known for their calm nature, escaped into the forest, full of rage at having been captured.

Patingi, bursting with confidence, assured the young men that he knew enough to keep everyone safe. Something about his story began to confuse the boys. Though he had implied that he had written five books, he had, in fact, read five books on the wild animals. Adding to this, he didn't seem entirely sure what they were called. Were they Mugatos, or moo-goes? 

Brushing any uncertainty aside, he stepped out of their hiding place, confident that he had learned how to communicate with an angry Mugato, looming overhead. Before he had a chance to do anything about it, the Mugato lifted him up, opened its mouth, and chomped down on the Tellarite's head. He was decapitated, leaving only his ponytail behind. 

Perhaps he should have read a sixth book after all. 


3. Moopsy!

Star Trek Lower Decks I Have No Bones Yet I Must Flee Moopsy
CBS Media Ventures

A cuddly little murderer is a fine description for a beloved, deadly ball of squish. The Moopsy may have been Narj's favourite, but the problem was, the Moopsy fancied Narj too. In particular, it fancied his bones. 

In Narj's Miraculous Menagerarium, Mariner, Ransom, and Ensign Gary are assigned with retrieving some humans who have wound up in an alien zoo. The zookeeper, Narj, is a kindly sort who is more than happy to answer questions, give them a tour, and show them the various species on display. One such species is the Moopsy, all cute and smiling, locked tight in its enclosure.

Naturally, the Moopsy gets out. What could be wrong with that? Well, the Moopsy has a certain diet that might not be the most fun for vertebrates, as Narj quickly demonstrates.

Despite their efforts to hide from the creature, the Moopsy manages to find a way past locked doors and winding air ducts, dropping down with a grin onto Narj's shoulder. In one swift move, the Moopsy bears its razor sharp fangs and sinks them into the unlucky zookeeper, liquidising and drinking his bones. As the empty corpse sinks to the floor, the Moopsy squeaks in happiness, while Mariner, Ransom, and Gary run away, screaming.


2. Vaporized By The Breen

Star Trek Lower Decks Trusted Sources Breen Weapon
CBS Media Ventures

The Ornarans and the Brekkians were introduced in The Next Generation's first season episode Symbiosis. There, they were presented as two worlds engaged in an uneven exchange, with the Ornarans addicted to Felicium, while the Brekkians kept them supplied.

Captain Picard refused to help either side repair their ships, eventually leading the Ornarans to be cut off from their supply of the drug. A dark time of withdrawal followed, with the entire population struggling with the effects of Felicium leaving their systems. Thankfully, that time passed, and the population began to thrive again.

Over on Brekka, things were less rosy. By the time the Cerritos arrived in orbit, the Breen had taken control of the planet, subjugated its people, and killed anyone who got out line. One poor local spotted the arrival of the Starfleet crew, signalling them to be quiet to stay safe, but to no avail. After a period of occupation, the woman was mercilessly killed by the helmeted-hardasses, who then proceeded to chase the Cerritos in their own ships. 

Even a show as light as Lower Decks can sometimes surprise with a shocking death and this was on full show in the third season episode Trusted Sources. 


1. Reman Torture

Star Trek Lower Decks I have No Bones But I Must Flee Reman
CBS Media Ventures

We're not saying that the Remans are the nicest species in the galaxy but they sure have experienced their fair share of strife in their time. Forced to work under the heel of the Romulan Star Empire, the Remans were trapped, for the most part, on the dark side of Remus. There, they mined dilithium and were often drafted as soldiers for war.

The events surrounding Shinzon's coup on Romulus probably did very little to bolster Reman reputations in the Empire, whether they were directly involved in the plot or not. Long before the Hobus Supernova destroyed, presumably, both worlds, the Scimitar was destroyed with all hands thanks to Lt. Commander Data's sacrifice. Whichever Remans were left behind were not in for a happy future.

In the early 2380s, there was enough ill will toward them that Romulan soldiers tortured several of them to death, dismembering them and tossing their bodies into a waste bag. Malok, one of the Romulans tasked with cleaning the room, wryly comments that Remans leave the biggest messes for them to clean up. 

Though hardly a noble ending for a Reman soldier, perhaps they could take slight solace in the fact that Malok, and Sub-Commander Vrek, both had to deal with stains on their uniforms from the pieces of Reman that were left behind. 


In this post: 
Star Trek
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Seán is the host and head writer/presenter for TrekCulture, as well as a writer/presenter on WhoCulture and WhatCulture Horror. He has authored two novels, dozens of short stories, and hundreds of articles for WhatCulture. He holds a Master of Arts in Creative Writing from University College Dublin. As part of his work with TrekCulture, Seán has been invited to participate in collaborations with Roddenberry Entertainment, as well as contributing to several Star Trek community projects. An avid fan of Star Trek, Doctor Who, and the horror genre at large, Seán's expertise has helped develop these channels to the successes they are today. As host of the Ups & Downs series on TrekCulture, Seán has become internationally recognised for his positive yet critically informed approach to reviewing every episode of modern Star Trek, ensuring he is one of the go-to voices in the Trek community. Favourite Quote to describe himself: "I'm serious about what I do, just not always about the way that I do it"