11 Greatest Cut-To-Black Moments In TV History
Ahh, the good old cut-to-black: the quintessential element of TV-tropedom. It keeps us glued to our screens, hearts palpitating on the edges of sofas across the globe. Its most common application is as a cue to cut to a commercial break; it's a friendly reminder from The Advertisement Company that your kettle needs boiling and you should leave the room with all haste, carefully averting your eyes from the hypnotic flashing images draining your bank account. Over at the Fox network, the good folk there use an automated prompt that cuts to the commercial feed as soon as the picture is completely black for more than one second. Cult show creator Joss Whedon got in trouble for using the technique heavily in his shows, prompting unwanted commercial cues for the confused computers. Somebody needs to send these guys more money. But what is it about the cut-to-black that leaves you hanging on for more? Well, almost invariably it is used to cut on a cliffhanger, either pre-commercial break, or at the end of an episode, leaving you frantic in anticipation for the resolution of whatever drama has unfolded. Cut-to-black is used so often these days that it is pretty difficult to identify any that you could class as truly 'great', but hell, I'm going to give it my best shot and see what I come up with. Obviously, there will be others unmentioned, or simply overlooked, but here is a list of the best eleven (OK seventeen including honourable mentions) that came immediately to mind. Oh and by the way, clearly, a SPOILER WARNING is in effect. You've been warned.
11. River Song Revealed Doctor Who ('A Good Man Goes To War')
This cut was the ending to the midseason finale during season six of 'Doctor Who'. The Doctor has failed to rescue Amy and Rory's baby daughter from the nasty baddies, but all hope is not lost, when River Song whispers her secret into the Doctor's ear and he runs of in the TARDIS, giggling with delight. Amy is confused, but River clears things up (sort of) with a massive bombshell: she is Amy and Rory's daughter! Whaaaa? It's a time travel show, so this sort of thing is to be expected. Amy's reaction then cuts-to-black, and a message that "the Doctor will return". Of course, this is not the only instance of cut-to-black in 'Doctor Who', especially in the modern series, but it stands out as being of particular impact, considering the mystery of River's true identity had been taunting us for two seasons already! Such a shame that it was all downhill from there...
10. Frank Underwood's Missed Call House Of Cards ('Chapter 13')
The Netflix Original Series 'House of Cards' ended an intriguing first season of cutthroat Washington skulduggery on a good old-fashioned cut-to-black cliffhanger. Spacey's character, Frank Underwood, has just been offered the nomination for the Vice Presidency. As it turns out, this was his goal from the beginning, although that was never really clear up to this point. He's been wading his way through the bile and filth of congress to weasel his way into the President's trust, and he's gotten there by lying, threatening, defaming, and downright murdering. No longer on Underwood's meal ticket, shamed reporter Zoe Barnes is edging closer to uncovering the whole conspiracy with her colleagues at Slugline.com; they're about to blow the lid off the apparent suicide of Peter Russo, Underwood's hapless pawn in the proceedings. Yet oblivious to the oncoming storm, Frank goes for a late night jog with his wife, and misses a call from his aide Doug Stamper warning him about Barnes and her story. The cut sets up a great lead-in to season two, making us prepare for considerable fallout and a whole lot more covering up.
9. Sherlock vs. Moriarty Sherlock ('The Great Game')
Everybody's favourite British sleuth (and in my opinion the best incarnation of the character in any medium) comes face to face with arch-villain Moriaty in the first season finale. Having just solved a series of tantalising cases in a game of wits against his most fierce nemesis, Sherlock and Moriaty meet in person for the first time at the scene of Sherlock's first ever case. Watson gets thrown in wearing a live bomb jacket for extra tension, and there are also sniper dots trailed on our heroes. The scene de-escalates once Moriaty warns them off prying into his good work, and Sherlock removes the bomb jacket from Watson, sliding it away along the floor. Alas, Moriaty comes back, he's "so changeable" and can't allow them to go on. In the final standoff, Sherlock aims his gun at the bomb jacket between them. Moriarty smiles, and before Sherlock fires, the credits role and the season ends. You could argue that the cliffhanger ending in season two has more 'wow' to it, and that also ends on a cut-to-black, but I went for season one because I think the use of the technique is more appropriate here, it's all part of the same scene (the climax ends on a cut) where as the climax of season two (Sherlock jumping off the building) is then followed by closure scenes, before the cut-to-black is made after the reveal at the cemetery four minutes of screen time later. An honourable mention for season two though.
8. Who Shot Mr. Burns? The Simpsons ('Who Shot Mr Burns? Part 1')
Not all great cut-to-black moments involve high stakes drama, and not all cut-to-black moments appear to be cut-to-blacks. In fact, you might be forgiven for thinking that this particular example is a fade-to-black, and you would be right. I'm sticking it in on a technicality though because this is another one of those genius moves by Fox where they place an artificial fade over the footage to prevent the auto-commercial prompt. So instead of a carefully timed cut on the punch line of the gag, you get a slightly premature fade out. It's still a great Simpson's moment though, because pretty much every character on the show has a good enough reason to shoot Mr. Burns, and this cut broke up a very memorable two-parter. Although why they would care who shot him after he tried to block out the sun is still up for debate... The episode is a parody of the famous season three finale of 'Dallas,' where the similarly malicious J.R. is shot, and pretty much everybody is a suspect.
7. The Cut-To-Title It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia ('Dennis And Dee Go On Welfare')
Keeping with the comedy theme, everybody knows that the most important aspect to a joke is how you tell it, and especially, the timing. Comedic timing is so important for comedy actors; it's what separates the Steve Martin's from the Dane Cook's of the world. Equally as important to the actors timing, is the editors timing. Great comedy on TV is often defined by the quality of the editing; knowing exactly when to cut from a gag and how long to leave a scene hanging. This example is neither a cut to a commercial break nor the ending of an episode, but the cut-to-title after the cold open of each episode. In the FX network's long=running comedy series, 'It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia', the show always begins with a scene that sets up the plotline for the episode. The scene will then cut to the title card, and the name of the episode is usually the punch line for the gag in the opening scene, or a pun on the gag. OK, so it's not technically a cut-to-black since there's text on the screen, but it is the same technique using a cut to end a joke. And the title card is mostly black, so there. Sunny uses this cut consistently throughout the series, so I'm not citing a single specific example (or am I?), but giving a general example of how great comedy cut-to-blacks can be.
6. 'We Have To Go Back!' Lost ('Through The Looking Glass')
ABC's hit drama 'Lost' pretty much takes the cake for most use of cut-to-blacks. Ever. I mean they literally use it for every major or minor cliffhanger, which in 'Lost' is about five times per episode. Despite its over use, they are often still pretty good, and there are several examples I could have chosen for this list. The ending to season one, when Locke opens the hatch, or the ending to season five, when Juliet smashes the nuclear bomb with a rock although to be fair, here they break the mold and cut to white. All great moments, but the one I'm listing here has got to be the "We have to go back!" cut at the end of season three, the first time they used the 'flash-forward' plot device. After the tear-jerking drama of Charlie's tragic death, the survivors are sundered over whether or not to trust the people from the ship that has landed offshore. In our first glimpse into the future we see Jack, now a broken man, back in the real world. He tries to convince the other's who've returned with him that they made a mistake. Cut-to-black, and we're left wondering how they got home in the first place; what's up with these crazy flash-forwards; and why in the name of TV would they want to go back?! Oh, so that the show keeps going I guess...
5. Rick Shoots Sophia The Walking Dead ('Pretty Much Dead Already')
Things are about to go pear-shaped down on Hershel's Farm. Glenn has revealed to the group that Hershel is keeping walkers trapped in the barn, and Rick is trying to convince Hershel to let their group stay because Lori is pregnant. Meanwhile Shane isn't helping anything by being, well... Shane he wants to arm everybody, and he's angry because Dale has hidden all the guns. Shane steals them back and hands them out, against Rick and Hershel's orders. When Hershel tricks Rick into bringing back some captured walkers, Shane snaps and breaks open the barn, forcing the group to shoot all the walkers as they stumble out. The carnage ends and everyone is traumatised, only for little walker Sophia to emerge from the barn. This is Carol's daughter, whom they've been searching for all season. Rick steps up as the leader and shoots her in the head. Cut-to-black. I watched this first half of season two back-to-back, leading up to this ending, and then the wait for the second half of the season. It was a pretty heavy way to go out, and gets my nod for fifth place.
4. Boomer Shoots Adama Battlestar Galactica ('Kobol's Last Gleaming Part 2')
A lot'a folk gettin' shot in these... Syfy's 'Battlestar Galactica' re-imagining (hands down the greatest show of all time, anywhere, I don't care what you say) takes fourth place with the gripping finale to the show's first season. By this point, we're all well and truly aware of the fact that Lt. Sharon 'Boomer' Valeri is a fracking cylon, and she's just starting to discover that fact for herself. Her fears are confirmed on a mission to destroy the Cylon Base-Star, where she runs into multiple copies of herself, but why they are all naked is a discussion for another time. Having succeeded in destroying the enemy ship, she and her co-pilot/navigator return to Galactica as heroes. Adama goes to shake her hand, and BOOM; she pulls her side arm and empties a few rounds in his chest. Never mind us, even she didn't see it coming. Yet happen it did, and we're left with the pretty gruesome and show-stopping sight of Adama bleeding out on the CIC war table. Then suddenly, cut-to-black. See you in six-to-eight months, suckers!
3. The Red Wedding Game Of Thrones ('The Rains Of Castamere')
OK, so it's pretty much common knowledge now that HBO will push just about every boundary they can in terms of how much profanity is acceptable on TV, and God love 'em for it! The wedding massacre at the end of episode nine, season three, of 'Game of Thrones' pretty much shocked everybody though. I think extra credit goes to the episode's director, David Nutter, who pulled off capturing one of the most important scenes in the whole series, stunned the uninitiated viewers, and wildly impressed those viewers who knew what was coming, assuring them that they 'got it right' aesthetically. It's just unrelenting and unsentimental to the end, concluding with the brutal, quiet throat-slashing of Catelyn Stark after her son is killed in front of her. Bloody powerful cut-to-black. A special shout-out goes to Jaime's hand, swiftly detached from his arm at the end 'Bear And The Madien Fair' of the same season. The acting in this scene is terrific, especially from my main man Nikolaj and Charlie's dad from the Charlie And The Chocolate Factory remake. It's often appropriate to frame a moment of shock with comedy as well, and there's a punk rock rendition of one of the shows folk songs over the credits following the cut-to-black. One thing's for sure it definitely knocked the wind out of you.
2. The Cut-to-Black to End All Cut-to-Blacks The Sopranos ('Made In America')
It's probably the most talked about and controversial editing decision in television history. Who knew that an innocent little cut-to-black could divide an entire fan-base, as well as critics and film-theorists alike? Did they mean to do it? Was it just lazy because they didn't know how to end the show? Was it a stroke of pure genius? Did Tony die? Did he get shot? Why do you torment us with these questions Mr. Chase?! Whatever your opinions/theories about it, it lands on the list as the second greatest cut-to-black in television history. As the sixth and final season of the show that cemented HBO at the top of cable TV comes to an end, the Soprano family business is in jeopardy. Tony's position at the top is tenuous there have been several carefully orchestrated hits against his captains. He goes about putting things right, and at the end he stops for onion rings with Carmella and A.J. They're sitting in the diner, waiting for Meadow to arrive; Journey is playing in the background. Meadow pulls up, but she has trouble parking. A guy in a 'members only' jacket goes into the diner bathroom, and Meadow enters the diner; Tony looks up, and then nothing. We don't know what he saw, whether it was Meadow, or a potential hitman. Confusing? Yes? Infuriating? Obviously. Memorable? Definitely. It's the only cut-to-black moment that's utterly, utterly unexpected, effectively blind-siding you before the dramatic resolution. Whether you liked it or not, you've got to admire the chutzpah for doing such a thing.
1. Hank 'Gets It' Breaking Bad ('Gliding Over All')
So 'The Sopranos' didn't get number one, as that would be too obvious. This means the honour has to go to everybody's favourite cooking show, 'Breaking Bad'. There are actually three cut-to-black moments, all from season five, that I found difficult to choose between. The first is at the end of 'Blood Money', the first episode back from the mid-season break, when Walt confronts Hank in the garage and delivers the best line of the series, "If you don't know who I am, then maybe your best course, would be to tread lightly." Classic. The second great cut-to-black is in 'To'hajiilee', during the standoff in the dessert. There's so much tension building up to this that I was actually shaking when I watched it. The slow motion and sound design during the gunfight is brilliant, and the cut-to-black when Walt is in the car is almost perfect. Almost perfect, because there has to be a number one, and for me, the greatest cut-to-black moment in television history has got to be Hank's 'eureka' moment on the toilet at the end of the mid-season finale. Hank is taking care of business, picks up some light reading material, and finds the old chemistry journal that came up as evidence in the Heisenberg case way back in the series. The initials 'W.W.' on the journal's first page trigger a flashback to the scene when Hank first jokes that 'W.W.' could stand for 'Walter White'. Walt is all like, "You got me!" and Hank is all like, "Cut to black." I'm pretty sure that's the line. Hell, even if it isn't, this was a fantastic cut-to-black cliffhanger which deserves its place at the top of this list.