The X-Files Revival: 10 Things We Learned From The Season Finale

The season finale raised more questions than answers

The final episode of The X-Files revival (or season ten, if you prefer) has come to pass. The shortened, six episode season seemed to fly by, for obvious reasons, and with the tally of monster of the week to mythology episodes being four to two, really, not a lot of progress was made in the overall storyline between the first and final outings of the year. My Struggle Part 2 sought to change that - but it was no easy task. As far as the episode itself was concerned, it picked up where the season opener, My Struggle, left off. Tales of alien colonization were mostly, at least for now, dropped in favour of a world domination plot where men within the government schemed to use alien technology to take over America, and then the globe. Behind it all? The nefarious Smoking Man, still alive though far from well and scheming as always. The added twist? His plan to unleash a global plague. Set against him? Why Special Agents Mulder and Scully, of course, as well as returning rookie agents Miller and Einstein (Robbie Amell and Lauren Ambrose), with Miller on the hunt for an AWOL Mulder, and Einstein questioning Scully's scientific method while they frantically sought out a cure for the Cancer Man's plague. When all was said and done, what did we learn?

10. Paranoid Mulder Doesn't Password Protect His Laptop

When most people even close their laptops, they have things set to go to a lock/login screen. Not so Fox Mulder. The man who once used TrustNo1 as a password can't even be bothered to put a password on his laptop, apparently - which is why both Agent Scully and Agent Miller were able to easily access his personal files. Of course, this was to further the plot - Miller uses Mulder's laptop, which has a cellphone tracking program, to locate his phone, and Mulder himself, after Fox has gone missing - but it's so far out of character for Fox Mulder, it lands squarely in the realm of complete disbelief. No, Mulder would have a password. A strong one. A long passphrase, and at least 256bit encryption.

9. Skinner Is Apparently An Afterthought

Walter Skinner (Mitch Pileggi) was one of the most popular supporting characters in the show's history, probably right after the Lone Gunmen. In fact, he even made the credits in the final season of the show, and it was a great surprise to see him in those credits once again in season ten. However, he was totally wasted throughout the revival. Despite Pileggi's prominent billing, he was almost nowhere to be found, eliminating one of the strongest talents the show has in favour of newcomers both of the guest star and recurring character variety (Robbie Amell and Lauren Ambrose, for example). It's clear that this revival is (well, mostly likely, especially given the strong ratings) not the show's last hurrah, so let's hope this is corrected in future installments.

8. Mulder Can Still Throw Down

When the Smoking Man summons Mulder, presumably to save him, he does so by way of a goon who looks somewhat like an Alex Krycek clone. Sadly, Nick Lea does not return in My Struggle Part 2, but someone else does: kick-ass Mulder. For all his jokes and complaints about age and "not doing stairs anymore" earlier in the season, Mulder definitely holds his own in the fantastic fight sequence that ensues. It's some of the best action from the shortened season ten, and it's a shame there weren't a few more action sequences during the revival, because this one was very, very entertaining. Of course, as he so often does, Mulder winds up looking worse for the wear - but for once, he wins a fight.

7. He Just Can't Pull The Trigger

In My Struggle Part 2, for the third time in X-Files history, Fox Mulder held a gun to the head of the Smoking Man. And once again, he failed to pull the trigger. Say what you want about Mulder being the "good guy" and above such things, but it's not as if he hasn't killed men before. He's more Han Solo (Han Shoots First version) than superhero, yet he continually lets the bad guy live. Maybe it's just that hard to shoot the devil when you're looking right at him. Maybe he really thinks that the Smoking Man can somehow stop the plague he has set into motion. In any case, he couldn't shoot him over Scully's abduction, he couldn't shoot him when colonization was set to start, and he couldn't shoot him over a plague that was shutting down everyone's immune system, including his own. Weak, Mulder.

6. Reyes Sold Out

So for the past ten years, Special Agent Monica Reyes has been the Smoking Man's keeper. This apparently took place after he was badly wounded by a missile attack, and summoned the FBI agent to his (well protected) hospital bedside. This particular development actually made some sort of sense, and might have been the best plot twist, and return supporting character appearance, of the season. Back in the sixth season, it turned out that Agent Fowley (Mimi Rogers) was in cahoots with the Smoking Man, so there's precedent for him utilizing Mulder's "inner circle" - or at least those he considered friends/trusted co-workers - to his own end. While it's a bit of a retread, Reyes was the true believer type that would have instantly accepted the man's tale of an oncoming plague, and joined up with him perhaps to secretly derail his plan. At least we hope so. Otherwise she joined to save her own skin. And either way, she pretty much sold out, but we'll forgive her for it.

5. Doggett Is Totally MIA

Where goes Reyes, so goes John Doggett, or so we thought. For all the grief Robert Patrick took for filling in for an increasingly absent David Duchovny in the eighth and ninth seasons of The X-Files, his performance as Agent Doggett was fantastic, and bolstered a flagging show that had hit creative rock bottom during the seventh season, when the show opted to produce more and more quirky comedy outings and fewer examinations of the paranormal. When the show went off the air, it was sort of assumed that Doggett and Reyes would stick together. Not so, apparently. While Reyes was playing nursemaid to a badly burned Smoking Man, Doggett was... well we just don't know. While it was known early on that Robert Patrick would not be in the new season, you would have expected at least a mention of his character, especially with Reyes appearing. No such luck. Though it does leave the door open for him to turn up down the line. Frankly, he has earned it, though it doesn't seem like Patrick himself is all that interested.

4. Cancer Man Was A Little More Damaged Than We Thought

Underneath that molded synthetic skin, the Smoking Man is looking a little worse for wear. A lot worse for wear. Actually, he looks a fair bit like Two-Face from Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight. Okay, not quite that bad, but you get the idea. He has a hole in his face, and it's not the one he smokes through. Other than that, however, he seems in good shape for someone who seemed to be sewn back together after being blown to bits. And this for a man in his (presumably) seventies. And even after the events of My Struggle Part 2, he lives to haunt Mulder another day.

3. The Smoking Man Saved Scully

One of the interesting tidbits of the early X-Files episodes was how the Smoking Man seemed to have a soft spot for Dana Scully. "I like her too, that's why she was returned to you" he told Fox Mulder in the show's second season, after Scully reappeared following her abduction. And here, all these years later, it seems the Smoking Man set Scully up... to live. "He saved you" Mulder tells her, and he's right. It was the experiments on Scully that made her immune to the plague witnessed in My Struggle Part 2, experiments that were ordered no doubt by the Cancer Man. Interestingly, an ongoing gag has been the idea that Scully never dies, something first mentioned in Cylde Bruckman's Final Repose. It seems to be reinforced in My Struggle Part 2 when it's learned that her alien DNA makes her immune to what otherwise looks like the apocalypse. So, umm, thanks, Smoking Man. You're still evil though.

2. In A Mass Epidemic, Only Obscure Websites Will Know The Truth

CNN, NBC News, Fox News, none of them seem to have the scoop Tad O'Malley has on his YouTube... Oops, sorry, MindQuad show, Truth Squad (which, by the way, is a terrible name). Airing throughout the episode, O'Malley gives continual updates on the spread of the plague when even he is suffering from it. And while part of this was no doubt due to budgetary concerns, previous episodes featured clips with (fictional) newscasters. A look at the disease through the eyes of another news source would have added to the overall scale of the outbreak, something that didn't really set in until the final scene of the episode, which featured Scully rushing to Mulder's aid on a jam-packed bridge full of panicked citizens rushing to get out of town. Speaking of which, how she was even able to navigate onto the bridge is beyond belief, but that's a minor quibble in the end.

1. More Questions Than Answers

What did we really learn from My Struggle Part 2? Far from the whole story. Oh, we learned a few details, like how the Smoking Man survived, that Scully really does have alien DNA (the Scully-to-alien morph scene in the teaser was chilling), and that she is able to replicate it in the lab to cure at least one disease. We learned that Monica Reyes has been the Smoking Man's keeper for years, lighting his cigarettes and no doubt aiding in his schemes. Other than that, we learned very little, and there was absolutely no closure, just a cliffhanger ending with a UFO appearing over Scully and dying Mulder (who, Scully claims, needs his son's stem cells to live) on a crowded bridge. We didn't learn the whereabouts of William, or anything to do with his fate. We didn't learn if the Smoking Man really was just out to rule the world (he made a few apologies for his schemes when he mentioned man-made calamities like global warming and species extinctions), or if that was just a smokescreen for the onset of alien colonization. We didn't learn whether the alien presence seen during the revival was here to help humanity, or harm them. We didn't learn Mulder's fate. There was no happy, or tragic, ending. In short, in true X-Files fashion, we didn't learn much. My Struggle was actually a decent episode, and would have made a better season finale than most of the latter seasons of the show, but at some point soon, Chris Carter and company will need a solid ending. The revival might have given them some breathing room, but just a little. Be it in follow-up episodes next year or a third movie, the tale needs to end. The fans deserve closure. Add your thoughts on the season below!

In this post: 
The X-Files
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Primarily covering the sport of MMA from Ontario, Canada, Jay Anderson has been writing for various publications covering sports, technology, and pop culture since 2001. Jay holds an Honours Bachelor of Arts degree in English from the University of Guelph, and a Certificate in Leadership Skills from Humber College.