10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2006
WWE shamefully exploited Eddie Guerrero's death and went love/hate with ECW in 2006.
2006 was a year of mixed emotions.
On one hand, dynamic high-flyer Rey Mysterio achieved what most would've realistically considered the impossible by ascending to WWE main event status and winning the old World Heavyweight Championship. Mysterio also bagged a Royal Rumble triumph and paid tribute to his fallen friend Eddie Guerrero. Then, there was the other side, and it proved to be a bitter experience.
The company shamelessly exploited Guerrero's death and left a bad taste in the mouths of many with one specific line by a future great. Elsewhere that year, the revived ECW brand (which proved popular at One Night Stand 2005 and '06) became a standalone third option next to Raw and SmackDown. Sadly, it really didn't take Vince McMahon long to scuff then pull the whole thing apart.
He quickly turned people off by giving them an extreme offering very much unlike the product that seemed so fresh and exciting under Paul Heyman in the 90s. Hardcore fans who had adored ECW's blood, guts and profanity approach were disheartened by some of the things they witnessed from this new version of the brand.
2006 also saw topsy turvy moments for stars like Kurt Angle (what a story), Rob Van Dam, Kane, Lita and The Undertaker. That's before we even get to McMahon's ridiculous religious publicity stunt, his bizarre decision to push an undercard attraction over a headline one, and a gimmick match that was more outright hell than Hell In A Cell.
What a 12 months this was. Let's dig in and examine the worst it served up.
10. The ECW Zombie
As the intro states, both One Night Stand events in 2005 and 2006 proved successful for WWE. The pay-per-views showed that there was still a market for Paul Heyman's claret-soaked product, and DVD units were flying off the shelves faster than distributors could stock them. By mid-2006, Vince McMahon had decided to rubber stamp an ECW comeback. It'd be the third brand next to Raw and SmackDown.
WWE's version of ECW played before a ton of hype, so much so that hardcore hungry eyeballs tuned in on 13 June to see the first slice. It wouldn't be long until those eyeballs were rolling harder than RVD in the back. The episode opened with a hot segment involving Van Dam, Heyman, Edge, Lita and John Cena, but then came time for the first match. What did WWE pick for that spot? Van Dam vs. Jerry Lynn, perhaps? Maybe a dazzling lucha-style showcase or a hardcore brawl?
Nah, they debuted "The Zombie".
Seriously. The first bout of this "new ECW era" was some dude shuffling around like he was from Resident Evil 2's sprint to the police station, then The Sandman caned the crap out of him. In total, the match lasted 19 seconds. Nobody's suggesting it should've gone on for 19 minutes, or anything, but this was an insult. It was a clear slap in the face to ECW'ers who thought this weekly would honour the past.
Suddenly, hopes were dashed that Vince understood what ECW should be. Those One Night Stand cards were thunderous and excellently produced, but the TV show? Man, it got rough in a hurry, and things would only get worse for the brand from there.
9. ECW’s December To…Forget!
Paul Heyman's facepalming really spoke volumes about the horror show that was December To Dismember '06. It was a shocking pay-per-view, one WWE should've been taken to task for charging hard-earned cash to see. They might as well have stormed into fan homes, tipped them upside down, chanted "E-C-DUB! E-C-DUB!" and then left with whatever fell from their pockets.
Matches like Balls Mahoney vs. Matt Striker, Kevin Thorn and Ariel vs. Mike Knox and Kelly Kelly, and Daivari vs. Tommy Dreamer had no business being on PPV. They really didn't. Most of the hate, however, was reserved for a weak "Extreme Elimination Chamber" main event. The 4,800 fans in attendance for the show agreed with Heyman's sentiments.
This was rubbish.
It didn't help matters when original ECW favourite RVD and popular newbie (who'd made a name for himself in beloved indy outfits like Ring Of Honor) CM Punk were eliminated way too early. That left the likes of Big Show, Hardcore Holly, Test and Bobby Lashley to slug it out for the right to be ECW Champ. WWE went with Lashley, someone who felt like a poor fit for the brand's atmosphere.
WWE’s ECW brand wasn't exactly off to a hot start. The first 6 months had some highlights here or there, but the hardcore danger once bursting into living rooms via Hardcore TV and events like Anarchy Rulz or Guilty As Charged was replaced with a more saccharine 'ECW lite' feel.
This was a real, '...but we've got ECW at home, honey' time period. December To Dismember 2006 is undoubtedly one of the worst WWE-produced PPVs ever.
8. The Boogeyman Squashes Booker T
He's The Boogeyman, and he's coming to get...Booker T's credibility.
Book would go on to make the best of a bad situation when he was saddled with the passé King Of The Ring gimmick a few months after this, but he surely doesn't look back on WrestleMania 22 fondly. There, Booker and Sharmell lost to Boogey in a handicap match that went less than 4 minutes and was played for horror-tinged laughs more than anything else.
In comparison, maybe fighting over a Japanese shampoo commercial with Edge at 'Mania X8 wasn't the worst thing in the world. The Boogeyman squash was a real low point in T's WWE career. During the bout, Boogey kissed Sharmell with a mouth full of worms, which sent her fleeing in terror. Left on his own, a terrified Booker lost to his undercard foe like their rightful roles on the roster had been reversed.
Worse, this was coming hot on the heels of Booker's series over the United States Title with Chris Benoit. They'd already produced the goods in WCW years before, so WWE smartly programmed the pair against one another and bellowed, 'GO WRESTLE' at them. How we got from that to this Boogeyman nonsense is anyone's guess.
Being fair, their handicap effort was in a rough spot following the fiery (literally) hardcore bout between Mick Foley and Edge at 'Mania 22. People were still talking about Edge's flaming spear off the ring apron by the time Boogey vs. Book and Sharmell was rushed out bell to bell.
WWE pushing Boogey over established main-eventers was the drizzling you-know-what.
7. Punjabi Prison Plummets
Originally, The Great Khali was supposed to work with The Undertaker at Great American Bash '06, but he wasn’t able to compete. So, instead of moving away from the new Punjabi Prison gimmick bout, WWE slotted Big Show in as a late replacement for no good reason other than he's huge.
Khali did interfere in the match, but it made no sense to have his personalised gimmick bout with 2 other wrestlers, and the occasion suffered for it. No, Khali vs. 'Taker wouldn't have won any Wrestling Observer 'Match Of The Year' awards or played before a bevy of stars, but it would've made more sense due to the Punjabi Prison effectively being Khali's bespoke match type.
There is a slight positive to this "worst moment" though. If one's being completely fair, WWE would've caught an awful lot of flak had they just scrapped an already-advertised gimmick bout from the lineup entirely. They had to deliver something - it's just a pity that Show vs. Undertaker was about as thrilling as it sounds.
If you've ever wanted to see 'The Deadman' swinging on ropes towards Paul Wight like some sort of supernatural, undead version of Tarzan, then this was the pay-per-view for you. The big bamboo-style double cage design made the match harder to watch than it should've been too. Nothing about the Punjabi Prison really worked or felt equal to faves like Hell In A Cell or Elimination Chamber.
Plaudits for trying to give Khali his very own match, but this was a flop; and it was a flop he wasn't even a big part of!
6. Vince McMahon Beats “God”
Anyone who watched the extensive Vince McMahon documentary series on Netflix will know firsthand how...unique (ahem) the guy is. For example, McMahon claims he has multiple brains working at the same time. He brags about this, and the fact that one of them is sexually obsessed. That's clearly a regrettable statement considering the grim controversies that have surfaced about his personal life since.
In 2006, Vince was still trying to shock the wrestling world and garner his company some mainstream press by ticking off anyone he could think of. At Backlash, he decided to capitalise on Shawn Michaels finding religion by teaming HBK with "God" in a bumper tag bout vs. himself and his son Shane. Yep, WWE promoted that an actual deity would be performing on pay-per-view.
They missed a trick by not riffing on the whole "[Mick] Foley Is God" craze.
Seriously though, this was the pits. Naturally, "God" no-showed the event (how unprofessional!), so the McMahons beat Shawn in a handicap effort. In reality, “God” was a stage spotlight and nothing more. Everything about this was just ridiculous, and it didn't endear WWE or Vince to the religious community whatsoever. He likely didn't give much of a toss about that though.
Fans who bought the event expecting to see Michaels pull a fast one on McMahon by introducing a new tag partner for the night certainly did. The spotlight gimmick was another cuff across the chops. Ironically, you can thank the creator of your choosing for bouts like John Cena vs. Edge vs. Triple H and RVD vs. Shelton Benjamin, because they saved the show from being appalling.
5. Cosplay Retro Kane Debuts
That's...that's gotta be 'Fake' Kane, and he's attacking the former 'Fake Diesel'.
On the 29 May 2006 Raw, Luke/Doc Gallows debuted under the retro mask with an unconvincing wig to attack Kane. This was a clear repeat of The Undertaker’s doppelgänger storyline in 1994, and it was every bit as bad. In fact, scratch that. This was worse. To add extra cool points (jokes), WWE referred to Gallows as "Imposter Kane".
This cosplay act beat the real Kane at Vengeance, then WWE abruptly scrapped the story on the following Raw. They'd realised something the core audience already had: This was bad, and it was going nowhere. Gallows had the height, but he generally resembled a knock off version of the character from one of those goofy old UK tribute act shows that were once big business.
Side note: They exist/existed in the US as well, and likely worldwide, but this writer remembers the British versions and attended a few himself. He even got "Chris Jericho's" autograph, then had his heart broken when that same underpaid indy worker wrestled later in the night as Edge, Christian, Shawn Michaels and more. How could he?! He would've got away with it had it not been for a pesky bandage on his injured leg following a nasty table bump.
WWE fans in 2006 weren't buying what the promotion was selling. They'd embraced Kane's new unmasked psychopath persona, and they didn't need somebody else assuming his role from the late-90s. It's definitely a good thing that WWE corrected their mistake ASAP and never looked back.
Also, where was dress-up Paul Bearer wannabe in all of this? So that's what was missing.
4. Lita’s Run Ends On A Low Note
In hindsight, workers like Lita and Trish Stratus in their prime could never hold a candle to the excellence of WWE's female ranks since 2015-ish. Becky Lynch, Charlotte Flair, Sasha Banks/Mercedes Mone, Bayley, Stephanie Vaquer, Bianca Belair, Tiffany Stratton and others have all taken women's wrestling in the company places Trish and Lita could've only dreamed of a generation ago.
Despite that, Lita defo deserved a more pleasing send off than the one she was handed at Survivor Series 2006. She lost the old Women's Title to Mickie James on that PPV, which wasn't the bad bit. Mickie was one of the next-gen hopefuls at the time, and she was a worthy final opponent for everyone's favourite moonsault-giving Diva.
Post-match, Cryme Tyme duo Shad Gaspard and JTG came out and sold off some of Lita’s stuff they’d stolen earlier to the live crowd, including her underwear. They even had yeast infection medication and fans chanted pretty unsavoury things in her direction. Yikes. This was a really rotten send off for one of the greats, and it doesn't make for good viewing today.
Sure, WWE likely argued that they were only making light of things and gently ribbing Lita, but yeast infection medicine?! Come on now. Today's women would play before chants like, "Fight Forever" or, "This Is Awesome", not some of the things fired Lita's way approx 20 years ago.
There was no need to humiliate somebody who was reinventing the wheel for the women's game in a promotion that 100% didn't care about it until Trish and Lita forced everyone to pay attention. What a mean-spirited call from Vince McMahon/WWE creative.
3. Suspension Ends RVD’s Title Reign
Rob Van Dam couldn't have been higher in the summer of 2006, and that was part of the problem. After winning the WWE Title at One Night Stand on 11 June, RVD was subsequently handed the restored ECW Championship by Paul Heyman 48 hours later on TV. He was on top of the world, then everything came crashing down in the blink of an eye.
The double champ and Sabu were pulled over by cops and busted for drugs mid-reign. As a result, WWE had RVD drop the WWE Title to Edge on the 3 July Raw, then his ECW Title to Big Show on 4 July. As if that wasn't enough of a blow to his pride, they announced that Heyman had suspended him for 30 days. This was an unfortunate moment in Rob’s career, and it sucked for fans who had revelled in his win over John Cena at One Night Stand '06.
WWE moved on like nothing had happened (as they're prone to doing - today's focal point could be tomorrow's trash), and full spotlight was put on Edge feuding with Cena over the the top prize. Meanwhile, over on ECW, Show held the hardcore brand's biggest strap until losing it to Bobby Lashley in that duff "Extreme Elimination Chamber" match at December To Dismember.
Heyman acted like Big Show was the new face of ECW and deserved to be, but fans called BS. Fittingly. Without RVD, ECW struggled. Admittedly, the same can't be said for the WWE Title, but it's a real crying shame that Rob's actions on the road cost him and his fans a longer run with the top belt.
What might've been.
2. Substance Abuse Forces Kurt Angle To Leave
Joe Rogan's mind was once blown when Kurt Angle opened up about his heavy pain pill usage on a podcast. His story about overdosing mere hours before working Brock Lesnar in a 60-minute 'Iron Man' match in 2003 is astonishing, but drug use wasn't the only pain Kurt was living. His sister had passed away and caused the episode, so he was dealing with that agony too.
The final hurdle of Angle's first run with WWE is depressing. He met with Vince McMahon to discuss his pain pill habits. McMahon wanted to send Kurt to rehab, but the Olympian wouldn’t go. So, instead, he wound up leaving the company and heading to TNA. This is something Angle regrets from a wrestling perspective, but he’s since said that he might not still be with us had he stuck around working the WWE schedule.
Wow.
It's difficult to watch some of his later work in WWE's ECW brand knowing he was barely holding it together mentally. On top of that, several broken necks and painful surgeries forced Kurt to grit his teeth and literally fight through the pain whenever he was wrestling. That puts a new spin on some of his final bouts in the company before departing.
The upshot of this is that Kurt decreasing his heavy schedule might well have saved his life, but there's no doubt going to rehab would've been the best thing for him at the time. He'd eventually do that, but not at Vince's behest. On WWE's side, losing somebody who had been such a reliable soldier halfway through 2006 was a real blow to the roster.
1. Randy Orton’s “Eddie’s In Hell” Line
Urgh.
Eddie Guerrero's passing in late-2005 was a hammer blow to his family, friends and the entire wrestling community. WWE honoured his memory with a touching tribute show, and paying homage to Eddie became a go to for Rey Mysterio, Chavo Guerrero and others during matches. Rey dedicated his Royal Rumble 2006 win to 'Latino Heat', and Guerrero's memory became part of his feud opposite Randy Orton afterwards.
Fair, but they really didn't need to go as far as they did. On the 3 February episode of SmackDown, Orton was making light of Mysterio’s repeated tributes to Guerrero and said: “Eddie ain’t in heaven. Eddie’s down there...in hell”. For context, this promo aired 82 days after Eddie's death. It was designed to put some more juice behind the upcoming Randy vs. Rey match at No Way Out.
That was it. It was a cheap heat device from guys who should've known better. They'd likely argue that 'Eddie would've wanted this', and they absolutely knew Guerrero better than some internet writer/wrestling fan, but still. There was just no need to go there and outright say that Eddie was in hell rather than heaven. It was a shameful line, and there would've been tasteful ways to skirt around things to be more sensitive.
Some would say that Randy's heel character was vicious enough to make such brutality essential, but it still classes as one of 2006's most unsavoury moments for sure. All of that for a quick, 'Oooooooooh' response from the live crowd in Orlando? Yeah, something about that doesn't sit right.
What other moments from WWE's 2006 belong here? For more like this, check out 10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2004 and 10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2005!