10 Wrestling Moments That Exploited Nostalgia (And Failed)
Don't call it a comeback!
WWE's past is killing its present, and if this has diminished your appetite to revisit it, then tough t*tties.
This awesome new era of pro wrestling, and whichever form it takes - Wednesday nights on USA (awww), Japan (awwwww), Wednesday nights on TNT (awwwwwwwww), NXT UK ("Outta the way, you!") - is, if not in total stasis, then increasingly tenuous. We will need to explore the endless depth and riches of pro wrestling's past to fulfil our bloodlust soon enough.
Perhaps it's time to challenge the legacy of ECW for a second time. Reappraised as artless and tacky in recent years, the really great, cult, influential shows were quietly added to the Network recently. If you've always wanted to revisit the dying days of the NWA, and the tragicomic transition into WCW, you will be rewarded with high art and high farce alike. Classic All Japan is as pirated on YouTube as Vince McMahon wanted Katie Lea Burchill to be in 2008, and it is incredible - a challenge, morally, but a pinnacle of the craft nonetheless.
The past exists to simply revisit, in a charming echo of a cherished memory, to educate - or to exploit...
10. The Ascension Get Buried
It's the principle of the thing.
The Ascension aren't likely to tear it up in PWG or New Japan in a bid to prove or reinvent themselves. They were limited workers, subpar in a lost generation, elevated to mild success in a winning act. A literal winning act; that they dominated a complete lack of competition in the embryonic, good NXT got them sort of over. They were on the main roster buried into the same tectonic plate that split Diamond Dallas Page's ass in half because they either worked JBL into a shoot, or the story was they had worked JBL into a shoot. It was all deeply weird and regrettable stuff.
As the Ascension mocked the nWo in a accordance with the script, JBL send these poor pricks to Wrestler's Court. On live television. "How dare you compare yourself to the Road Warriors!" he bellowed, and what do you say in response to that? "Take it up with Ryan Ward, you mark"?
JBL soaped up his arm and smashed Viktor right in his bastard face.
"Welcome to the wasteland, ya sacks of sh*t!"
9. New World Order On A Moment Of Bliss
The premise was beyond dissonant - the coolest, transformative renegades of the 1990s appearing on WWE's blandest, worst ever talk show, and think of the ground that covers.
The execution was almost unbelievably awful. So the nWo were getting inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame. Great. This was accomplished via the announcement graphic. The nWo tend to turn up whenever the lads fancy hogging the spotlight on a televised tragic boy's night, so it's not as if they are draws in 2020.
Whatever. The nWo were on A Moment of Bliss. Repeat the announcement, do some schtick, go away. No problem. It's promotion.
But this was sh*tty even by nWo-in-WWE standards. Nikki Cross marked out because the entire roster is Matt Striker in 2011 when Matt Striker was ridiculed in 2011. After mentioning that the nWo were to be inducted into the Hall of Fame about a million times, Alexa Bliss asked what name the polyonymous Sean Waltman goes by nowadays, he said "Hall of Famer, yeah!" as if it were the reveal. It didn't get a pop because it wasn't the reveal.
Kevin Nash was in full Kevin Nash mode, which is great...on Twitter or a shoot interview, and Scott Hall pissed himself every time Goldberg got booed.
WWE tried to exploit the nWo, but they got the version down there. Down where?
Down there.
8. If I Can Be Serious For A Minute
Those who followed Triple H's NXT from the start will likely cherish the 2014-15 period with an almost painful longing forever.
It was nostalgia unfolding in front itself, a glorious, upbeat, soulful period of professional wrestling from the most unlikely source, and it used the wonderful influences from said source to present itself with such big-time importance. It was an era of opportunity, of fun, of truly advanced professional wrestling - and Tyler Breeze typified all of it. He was once a future megastar, jarring as that may be to read now, but he was consigned to main roster failure after A) not getting over immediately, B) transgressing on the backstage code of conduct and C) being promoted from NXT.
After a wilderness period highlighted by the endearing as hell Fashion Files skits, Breeze returned to NXT last year. It seemed like the perfect move; the brand had accelerated into a new era of super-intense melodrama, and his levity was needed to vary the tone, but in a bizarre decision, he returned as a serious wrestler intent on proving himself amongst the best, when he wasn't and shouldn't have striven for it.
Somehow, Velveteen Dream Vs. Tyler Breeze at TakeOver: XXV wasn't fun at all. It didn't begin to maximise its dynamic; it was simply a wrestling match, one that couldn't hope to compete with NXT's stratospheric top end.
Breeze now continues to just wrestle, sporadically and seriously, though the entrances are fun. It's not the same.
7. The DXT Tank
This moment - it's always a goddamn moment with these f*ckin' guys - was pitched as epic nostalgia, but it invited widespread scorn online.
It visualised the shifting narrative surrounding NXT from cool alternative to the one WWE show with good wrestling on it. NXT hasn't felt cool in a while, and this invasion angle solidified everything. Triple H led his NXT troops into battle against the evil forces of the main roster...
...whom Triple H also oversaw in his role as Head of Talent Relations...
...by entering SmackDown on a tank.
Roman Reigns opened the door, and NXT answered, the lowly privates flanked by the Seargent Major, the Game, the Cerebral Assassin, the King of Kings, the God of f*cking War, Triple H, because the sh*t he did in 1998 was of far more importance than anything they themselves may have accomplished.
Their little legs tried to keep up with the tank, and what a not ideal metaphor that was; it looked like they were being hurried along, like obedient children, bent to the authority of Papa Haitch.
They "won" Survivor Series, but the irony of NXT formally becoming the main roster was unshakeable.
6. DX Try To Give The Revival The Rub
To the emerging talent of this present generation, the famed DX rub is as terrifying as Joe Biden's.
That was the apparent objective of RAW 25's finale. WWE genuinely thought that sharing the same ring with DX is enough to get that talent over. To them, it's a form of osmosis; these newer talents are exalted by the very presence of Triple H, which is strange, because he shakes every last f*cker by the hand and none of them have become megastars yet.
The Revival were decimated handily by Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson on the night, after which Scott Dawson grabbed Scott Hall by the shoulder. He was pissed off. He was about to get pissed off for three straight years: Hall threw a toothpick in his eye, X-Pac floored him with the X-Factor, Road Dogg got himself on a register with his foul dancing, and Billy Gunn did his finish. Dash Wilder tried to save his friend, and was hit with a one-two Sweet Chin Music/Pedigree combo for his troubles.
Seriously: how does this rub work?
If I told my old, lapsed pals that Road Dogg went over in a 2018 main event, they'd ask who Road Dogg is, faintly remember, and wonder what I'm doing with my sh*tty life.
5. That Strange Shelton Benjamin Business
No, not that two-week period on SmackDown last year in which he smiled mischievously from side to side, but, incidentally, what the f*ck was all that about?
He seemed to allude to a mystery angle of some sort. What did Shelton Benjamin know that we didn't, exactly? The identity of the person who attacked Roman Reigns? A new finishing move? That WWE would pay him millions of dollars over five years just to do four-minute jobs to Eric Young on Main Event?
Almost as strange is WWE's recent use of him: he is, essentially, Brock Lesnar's old OVW tag team partner in the Minnesota Stretching Crew every 19th Monday. Whenever it's a "Brock can't be f*cked" week, but they need to run an angle to advance one of his storylines, Shelton Benjamin is unearthed, wheeled out on television, and soundly beaten up by Seth Rollins or Cain Velasquez or something. This was paid off at the Royal Rumble at least with a quality punchline - Brock naturally didn't care about Benjamin, and likely had no idea he'd even tried to soften his opponents up - but it was cute and ineffective stuff.
The vast majority of fans don't know about their old association because, beyond the odd retrospective Network doc mention, OVW was treated as a second cousin WWE had drunkenly bucked.
4. DX Try To Give Seth Rollins The Rub
Here's that DX rub again, stretching its hand outwards, wearing massive gaudy rings, its eyes bulging wide, chomping on a gigantic, ever-present cigar.
Ricochet was meant to get the "rub" at last year's RAW Reunion before suffering an infection in his elbow/violently and repeatedly smashing his elbow into a wall to get out of it. And so the decision was made to have DX "endorse" Seth Rollins, which might have worked better had they actually endorsed him. As Karl Anderson and Luke Gallows ganged up on Seth Rollins - they were pally the last time they interacted onscreen, remember, of course you don't remember, you to them are as thick as pigsh*t, which is why WWE ran the segment - Triple H and Shawn Michaels made the save. Jerry Lawler expressed profound shock when Road Dogg's music hit, as if it were a big surprise. He was in the stable. "What?" he shrieked.
Could it...could it possibly be? Yes it was the guy who was over for a year and who will not f*ck off from conflating himself with a real legend!
After making the save, the gang allowed Rollins the solemn honour of telling disinterested members of the crowd that they could suck his c*ck, and he did it do eagerly that it was as if he were overjoyed to win a competition. And then, like a right pack of c*nts, they left him out of the group hug. Did the rub work?
Nope.
They screwed him doggy in the hizzouse.
3. WWECW
The bloody, transgressive, authentic WWECW One Night Stand events were awesome: produced by the original visionary and performed by the original crew - in improbably decent knick - each event also made tremendous use of the WWE interlopers. Our intelligence was not insulted; they were framed as the enemy, a means of getting the originals over.
And then they had to spoil it all by doing something stupid like McMahon you.
Yes, because the resulting televised reboot was firmly in Vince McMahon's purview, the resulting televised reboot was another WWE show. Where the detestable Randy Orton was cunningly used to get new ECW roster member Kurt Angle over, in a lesser of two evils scenario, this strategy didn't extend to the Big Show Vs. Batista, who wrestled a "The road agent is hungover and tired" match in the hardcore fan mecca of the Hammerstein Ballroom. Those fans despised it, anticipating every patterned, cliched story beat, knowing to the second when to make their work almost comically futile.
From this early set of tapings forward, the nostalgia died.
CM Punk got over - he performed in the idiosyncratic mould of the original promotion, where he almost certainly would have worked if the timing were different - but WWECW was otherwise a sad waste of time. The arena setting compromised the aesthetic and the atmosphere, visualising the core issue behind the very pitch. The 'Originals' had peaked in ability and relevance.
It was, in general, staid product operated in total contravention to the original company: dispassionately under a obligation to a TV station.
2. Uncooked, Uncut, Unintelligible
The ICOPRO banners. The original Monday Night RAW logo. That flashing neon WWF stage design. The Fink. WWE got everything right - visually - at RAW 25.
It looked beautiful. It was hardcore fan service loving in its detail. And then they realised they'd left the writing staff over at the Barclays Center and had on-hand Bray Bray Wyatt to script the Undertaker's promo, which must be true, because it was absolute nonsense.
"The carnage began on this sacred ground of evil 25 years ago," he began. "For 25 years I've been digging holes, and anybody who wanted to step into the dark side got buried," he continued, as a solitary tear rolled down the cheek of Diamond Dallas Page. "Stone Cold had to answer to the Reaper. Mick Foley had to answer to the Reaper. Even my own flesh and blood, my brother Kane, had to answer to the Reaper. They all tried, and they all failed."
What?
This was a boring and generously selective reading of his own Wikipedia page. Thank Christ he never won the Intercontinental Title, else he'd have droned on about bringing the prestige back to it. 'Taker signed off by saying, on an affectionate nostalgia show, the likes of which WWE will always do, that it was time for the Legends to "truly rest in peace".
He must have had to endure a meet-and-greet with British fans beforehand, because the Undertaker effectively told the Manhattan Center marks to grow up and move on in a right f*cking strop.
1. "Greatest Hits"
Well, well, well.
That isn't a rueful shake of the head with which to express disappointment in Shawn Michaels; that's just what the Kingdom threw the remains of Jamal Khashoggi into ahead of a show that WWE proceeded with, in spite of profound moral objection, because propaganda is the future of revenue.
But fans were disappointed, also, in Shawn Michaels' decision to abandon his retirement vow for this match, on this show. The idea of Michaels working Kane in Saudi Arabia wasn't quite as uplifting as an AJ Styles dream match, and even a guilt-ridden Michaels knew this. When questioned over his decision, he couldn't look his accuser in the eye.
The match was rotten, and in a mass indictment, Michaels was the best worker in it by some distance.
Kane was his usual, lumbering self, and did his usual, overexposed routine, only much more slowly. His mask and wig fell off in the hot sun, which was piss funny poetry. Greed ruined what remained of his mystique.
The same was true of the Undertaker, who must have worked on his ring rust at the Performance Center for how crap he was at catching dives. He lost a breath versus hair match. Triple H, in great cosmetic shape, suffered a muscle injury, hurling the match off the rails.
In tandem with vengeful fate, they crafted an uneven embarrassment, like sh*tting the bed on a lumpy mattress.