5 Biggest Winners & Losers From AEW In 2025

Who in AEW is walking out of 2025 having had a great year, and which ones were more of a bust?

The Young Bucks AEW Max and Jeremy
AEW

Over the course of 2025 in All Elite Wrestling, a handful of wrestlers separated themselves from the pack, both for better and for worse.

In some cases, they proved why they're in the company that boasts it's "where the best wrestle" by scoring big wins, collecting championship gold, and building on their legacy. Those among the top tier really shined, took the company to some great new heights, and deserve a lot of praise for keeping the ship sailing throughout the year, likely rolling into 2026 as some of the top names to look out for to continue building on that momentum.

Unfortunately, there were also talent who did the complete opposite, falling short of expectations, putting on bad performances, having a losing record, or suffering some other setbacks. Injuries, bankruptcy, a lack of relevance, losing their mystique and just flat out not being able to win a match plagued some members of the roster.

Let's spotlight five examples of both the highest highs and the lowest lows by breaking down the biggest winners and losers from AEW throughout 2025.

10. Loser: Jeff Jarrett

MJF Jeff Jarrett
AEW

At the very beginning of 2025, Jeff Jarrett made an announcement regarding his future at AEW Dynamite: Fight for the Fallen. He stated that he was re-signing with All Elite Wrestling and would go on one last run, aiming to win the AEW World Championship in the process.

A single win on Collision over the company's resident jobber, Aaron Solo, was all he managed to actually accomplish, losing a Casino Gauntlet match and a match against Claudio Castagnoli before no longer wrestling at all the entire rest of the year.

To say you're going for the top prize in the company, only to be pushed completely out of the title hunt less than a month later and do nothing but Zero Hour and Saturday Tailgate Brawl pre-show panel analysis for the next eleven months is as much of a failure as one can get.

If this were done due to injuries, that one be one thing, but Jarrett has wrestled four other times this year for other promotions, meaning AEW just quickly decided not to do that storyline, even with the retirement angle.

Is this just the end for The Last Outlaw?


9. Winner: Mercedes Moné

Mercedes Mone AEW
AEW

Mercedes Moné didn't just start calling herself "Ultimo Moné" out of nowhere this year—she earned the nickname by going on one of the biggest "belt collector" gimmicks that has ever happened in pro wrestling.

Coming into 2025, she was already on her eighth month for her AEW TBS Championship reign, which she still holds onto today. Throughout this run, she's surpassed Jade Cargill's prior record of 508 days to cement herself as the best with that belt so far.

In January, Moné won the RevPro Undisputed British Women's Championship and the Queen of the Southside Championship titles, which was only the start of getting more and more gold.

In May, she won the 2025 Owen Hart Cup Tournament to earn one of her multiple shots at the AEW Women's World Championship—one belt she's been unable to capture.

But in the meantime, she managed to win the EWA Women's Championship and CMLL World Women's Championship in June, followed by the Bestya Women's Championship and Prime Time Wrestling Women's Championship in July, and the Discovery Wrestling Women's Championship in August.

She then also won the BODYSLAM Women's Championship, the interim ROH Women's World TV Championship (later the lineal title as well, which she's since lost), the WPW Women's Championship and the APAC Women's Championship


8. Loser: Jon Moxley

jon moxley3
AEW

How does someone start off the year holding the AEW World Championship as the top of the company in the most dominant heel faction and somehow end up on the list of the biggest losers? Just look at how Jon Moxley's 2025 panned out and you'll see.

While holding the biggest prize in AEW, Moxley was consistently booked as a coward. He spoke highly of himself fixing the company and ridding out the weak, only to constantly require help from an increasing number of allies like Marina Shafir, Claudio Castagnoli, Wheeler Yuta, PAC, Gabe Kidd, Daniel Garcia, and even bringing in The Young Bucks and more at times to bolster the ranks.

Upon losing the title to "Hangman" Adam Page, Moxley has picked up victories, but he's also failed to get back in the title hunt properly for two main reasons.

First, he's been running from Darby Allin and suffering tons of punishment as a result of that feud. Second, he's been tapping out consistently to Kyle O'Reilly, who was rather firmly several lowers down beneath him in the midcard.

Moxley's downward spiral is ending his year with a flop instead of being on top.


7. Winner: "Hangman" Adam Page

Hangman Adam Page
AEW

"Hangman" Adam Page entered 2025 a bit lost, fighting with Jay White and Orange Cassidy to try to position himself back atop the food chain, but unable to find a way to get the job done.

He retired Christopher Daniels at Maximum Carnage in January and became motivated to win the Owen Hart Foundation Tournament. Throughout that process leading up to his eventual win of the cup over Will Ospreay at Double or Nothing, Page started to get back to being what many refer to as "the main character" of All Elite Wrestling and the top babyface.

That was a position that was in danger of being usurped from him by people like Ospreay and Swerve Strickland, but he managed to turn those competitors into allies who were instrumental in helping him defeat Jon Moxley at the biggest event of the year, All In: Texas, to once again become AEW men's world champion.

Page held the title for 134 days before losing it to Samoa Joe at Full Gear, who he had beaten the event prior and only truly lost to because of outside interference.

Hangman is finishing the year with one of the best win-loss records overall, with an over 80% success rate.


6. Loser: Wardlow

AEW Forbidden Door 2025 Wardlow
AEW

Wardlow cannot catch a break in AEW, unless it happens to be an injury.

Since August 2019, he has been hyped up as a top prospect, and was heading toward that direction at the start of his career. Eventually, some injuries got in the way and started a cycle of setting him back every time he returns.

In October 2023, Wardlow had one of his many returns to start reheating him toward a title shot, joining The Undisputed Kingdom in December. By April, he was injured again, missing the rest of 2024 and over half of 2025. At Forbidden Door on August 24, 2025, Wardlow made another return to attack Prince Nana and start a storyline with Swerve Strickland, joining The Don Callis Family in the process—but also getting injured in that very same segment.

Come September 8, Wardlow was already written off television and is currently recovering from a torn pectoral that has him on the shelf indefinitely, and obviously into 2026.

You're more likely to see Wardlow on your television via American Gladiators before you'll see him back in an AEW ring.


5. Winner: Samoa Joe

AEW Full Gear 2025 Samoa Joe
AEW

Samoa Joe boasts one of the best win-loss records in the company for 2025, losing only four times and winning over 25.

Three of the wrestlers with similar records are Hook, Eddie Kingston, and Adam Page. Hook is not only Joe's ally, stablemate, and protege, but he's also been instrumental in helping Joe beat Page to win the AEW World Championship and to retain that title over Kingston!

But not only is Joe back on top with the men's world title, which already is enough to put him on this list - especially for being the guy to beat Page after such a big victory for Hangman to win the title in the first place - Joe is also in the rare camp of two-time champions and on top of that, is still holding another championship at the same time!

Back in April, The Opps took a loss of Hook's injury and turned it around into one of their biggest strengths by replacing him with Powerhouse Hobbs, who has been an instrumental part of their success, helping Joe and Katsuyori Shibata win the AEW World Trios Championships, which they've held ever since.


4. Losers: The Young Bucks

Jobber Entrance Young Bucks
AEW

The Young Bucks are an interesting pair of losers, as Matt Jackson and Nick Jackson are one of the cases where they were literally booked to be made fun of as such throughout the year.

They've not had a bad win-loss record, and they've remained prominently featured and major parts of some big angles like siding with The Death Riders and fighting with Jurassic Express, Kenny Omega, and now turning on The Don Callis Family.

However, all of this was wrapped in a package of them having lost their money and operating on a limited budget, which was the subject of their ridicule on a weekly basis and the great motivator in them desperately trying to win back some more funds.

Refusing to swallow their pride, they spent most of 2025 in stints where they had no entrance music or pyro, were being referred to on lower-third graphics and announced by the wrong names, and having to beg Tony Khan for big money bouts to try to offset their gambling problems.

No tag title reigns this year for The Young Bucks, either, but they did win back some of their Elite brethren.


3. Winner: Bandido

AEW Dynasty 2025 Bandido ROH World Title
AEW

In many people's eyes, the best wrestler of the year not just in AEW and ROH, but in pro wrestling as a whole landscape, was Bandido. It's hard to argue against it, considering the caliber of performances he's put on consistently throughout 2025.

It isn't just the high quality of the matches, either, but the quantity of them, wrestling over 80 fights this year after sitting on the shelf from June 2023 until February 2025.

Making up for lost time, Bandido knocked off Chris Jericho to win the ROH World Championship in a title vs. mask match at Dynasty in April. He also won the RIOT Championship from Erik Ortiz in July, both of which he still holds.

At Forbidden Door, Bandido teamed with Brody King to win the AEW Men's World Tag Team Championship titles, too. Brodido would go on to hold those titles for 90 days up until Full Gear on November 22.

Along the way, Bandido has beaten prominent stars like Konosuke Takeshita, Kazuchika Okada, Mistico, The Young Bucks, The Hurt Syndicate, and more, rising his star power and living up to his potential to become perhaps the top breakout star of the year.


2. Losers: Max Caster and the Worst Win-Loss Records

Max Caster
AEW

You might think someone like "The Best Wrestler Alive" Max Caster had a terrible year, as he lost 22 of his 25 matches in 2025, but he at least has a better record than a whopping 145 other wrestlers.

Of those, 144 didn't score a single victory in the entire year. AR Fox gets the distinction of being able to say he won a single time, but still ended up with a 19-1 record for a 95% overall loss statistic. This is nothing to be proud of, but he's still a tier above the collection of pure enhancement talent.

Granted, most of them weren't signed talent and were brought in specifically to job. But for every unknown, there are still names who are interesting to point out.

Technically for AEW itself, nobody's had a worse 2025 record than Blake Christian, who lost 14 matches. Interestingly enough, when he's in Ring of Honor, his record shoots up to 42-20 and he was just in a world title match at ROH Final Battle.

Mason Madden and Mansoor would be next, with Lee Johnson, Matt Menard, Johnny TV, Lady Frost, Grizzled Young Veterans, The Frat House, Adam Priest and Aaron Solo being among the names who should theoretically be better than this.


1. Winner: Kazuchika Okada

Kazuchika Okada AEW Unified Champion
AEW

Kazuchika Okada checks off essentially every box to be called a winner in 2025 above nearly the entire rest of the roster, arguably.

If you're talking pure numbers, few have a better win-loss record, and they're names talked about on this list already. Okada sits at an 85% success rate, with Samoa Joe at slightly higher at around 86%. Eddie Kingston and Hook are at around 87% and 89%, with Hologram at a perfect record, but Okada had more overall wins and matches than those others save for Joe.

On top of that, those losses largely came about due to tag team matches where Okada couldn't get along with his teammate Konosuke Takeshita, with whom he also scored some victories. On his own, he nearly always got the job done.

Among those wins were walking into the year with the Continental Championship and still technically holding it now within the Continental Classic tournament, but even if he loses that, he'll still hold the International Championship, which he won from Kenny Omega to capture the AEW Unified Championship at the biggest show of the year, All In: Texas.


Contributor
Contributor

Founder of pro wrestling site Smark Out Moment (https://www.smarkoutmoment.com) and geek culture site Fanboys Anonymous (https://www.fanboysanonymous.com).