Every Wrestling DEATH Ranked By Stupidity

11. Snitsky Murders Kane & Lita’s Unborn Child (WWE)

Gene Snitsky Lita
WWE.com

Footage from WWE Unreal on Netflix showed the company's creative team brainstorming Royal Rumble winners and all manner of other ideas for the roster. It's a good thing that documentary series came out in 2025. Can you imagine what it would've been like back in 2004 when storylines like Gene Snitsky causing Lita to suffer a miscarriage were fairly commonplace?!

Perhaps the worst thing about the whole saga is that WWE tried to turn Kane into a babyface after the fact. They did that in spite of the fact that the 'Big Red Machine' had forcibly impregnated Lita with his child, and taunted her lover Matt Hardy about it. After fending off Matt, Kane turned his attention to baby-killer Snitsky. Meanwhile, he claimed that the whole thing "wasn't [his] fault".

This was, "I did it for The Rock" levels of poor catchphrase creation. In fact, it was even worse than that.

Snitsky blasted Kane from behind with a steel chair, which caused daddy dearest to land right on top of Lita and brutally end the unborn child's shot at life. Commentary teams treated this like the soap opera story of the century, and they immediately put some sympathy on Kane over Lita (?!) whilst Gene-o wandered around the place looking for toes to suck as a follow up gimmick tweak.

Yeah, '04 WWE was so poor at times. Alarmingly, the most ridiculous thing about all of this was Kane slipping into a would-be good guy role after forcing himself on Lita against her will. Nothing screams babyface like doing that, huh? Yikes.

WWE's writing team needed a slap for even coming up with this. It was their fault.


10. Paul Bearer Gets Cased In Cement (WWE)

paul bearer wwe
WWE.com

The sound of Paul Bearer's shrill screaming as he was encased in cement at The Great American Bash 2004 haunts those who watched the pay-per-view live. Actually, seeing The Undertaker work a humdrum handicap main event vs. The Dudley Boyz just before that angle was also torture. Honestly, why this had to go on last when JBL vs. Eddie Guerrero was right there is anyone's guess.

WWE furnished the 2-on-1 bout with a simple premise going in: If Bubba-Ray and D-Von won, then Bearer would suffocate in cement. They didn't win though - 'Taker did, but he pulled the switch on Paul and told the iconic manager to rest in peace anyway. Yeah, work that one out. What was that about 2004 being a bit of a bogus year for the promotion?

The big story here is obviously Bearer's demise. It was so over the top and goofy to see and hear him scream his lungs hoarse at the thought of becoming a sub-concrete ghoul only handy for being shown off during WrestleMania fan fests in the future. What a mental image that is. 'Come and see Mr. McMahon's smashed up Corvette and Paul Bearer trapped in cement!'.

Creative ignored this angle when Paul returned in 2010 to help facilitate the latest chapter in Undertaker's feud with Kane. It was like Great American Bash 2004 had been a dream. No, a nightmare. The fact Bearer seemingly survived this stunt is preposterous. The fact WWE barely even acknowledged it after shoving the thing onto pay-per-view is even weirder.

That isn't the wind whistling you can hear. It's the sound of Paul Bearer's voice.


9. The Undertaker Is Buried Alive…Repeatedly! (WWE)

The Undertaker Mankind Buried Alive
WWE.com

Pictured above is the only singles 'Buried Alive' match that The Undertaker actually won. He defeated Mankind in October 1996 at the In Your House 11 pay-per-view, but 'The Deadman' would end the night pushing up dirt himself when a string of heels helped Mick Foley bury him in a shallow grave. To close out the show, 'Taker's hand shot out of the dirt to signify that he wasn't quite finished after all.

This fate would smack Undertaker hard (like the shovel used during the abandoned match type) several times over coming years. He lost follow up 'Buried Alive' bouts to Steve Austin in 1998, Vince McMahon in 2003 and Kane in 2010. On all 4 occasions, he ultimately cheated kayfabe death. Then, there was the 1994 Royal Rumble. That showed 'Taker "dying" after he was soundly beaten by every heel going (spotting a pattern?) and then shoved into a casket during his bout vs. Yokozuna.

The then-WWF shot footage of Undertaker cutting a promo inside the coffin, and an extra (believed to be Marty Jannetty) was hoisted up towards the heavens live inside the arena as the fed kept in-house lighting low so nobody would suspect a thing. This was the truth "death of The Undertaker", but he was back in time for a clanger of a doppelgänger clash at SummerSlam vs...himself.

Well, sort of. Undertaker collided with 'Underfaker' in a headliner no-one called for or wanted after Bret vs. Owen Hart ruled inside a steel cage. In short, 'Taker has been snuffed out countless times only to reappear like some unstoppable supernatural force. Fair play. They did say he was undead from the off.


8. Big Boss Man Serves Up Pepper The Dog (WWF)

Big Boss Man Al Snow Pepper Dog
WWE

Seeing canine friends get killed off is painful in any TV show, movie or video game. Something hits harder when it's doggo chums in the firing line, especially when those writing the script painstakingly tug at heartstrings by building up charm and love for the dog in question during the lead up to that agonising on screen death.

Nobody told the WWF's braintrust about build up in 1999.

They clumsily told the story of Big Boss Man murdering then cooking Al Snow's little chihuahua Pepper. The dog had only really been around for a short while before getting used as a plot device in the feud between Al and Boss Man. Heading into Unforgiven '99, the company planned to book a woeful 'Kennel From Hell' double cage effort between both men, so they had Boss man lure Snow into a hotel room for a sit-down meal.

Afterwards, that no good corrections officer from Cobb County, Georgia revealed the true wickedness of his plan. Al had just cheerfully munched down lil' Pepper and declared it one hell of a tasty treat. Good lord, and you thought all of those mutts pooping all over the place instead of coming across as vicious attack dogs at Unforgiven was the worst thing about this rivalry.

Pepper was the main meat (no!) of Boss Man's culinary creation. You wouldn't have seen this on Gordon Ramsay's Kitchen Nightmares, that's for sure. If anything, it would've been better had the WWF brought Gordon in to call Al Snow an idiot sandwich for falling into this super-obvious trap.

Stupid wrestling babyfaces are stupid.


7. Bael Has His Head Eaten (Lucha Underground)

The Crew Lucha Underground
Lucha Underground

Hey, has anyone tapped current WWE SmackDown man JC Mateo on the shoulder and asked him to answer for chomping someone's head off in Lucha Underground many moons ago? Leader of the pack and 'Tribal Chief' wannabe Solo Sikoa might be interested to know that one of his MFT crew is on the run for such heinous behaviour. That happened when Mateo/Jeff Cobb was playing the role of Matanza on LU.

Devious promoter Dario Cueto punished those who defied or disappointed him by using Matanza as nightmare fuel. His monster was caged up and restrained, but only when Dario said so. At one point, Bael failed Cueto, so he had to be punished. What did he get? Detention? No, this wasn't school. A written warning? Nah, Lucha Underground wasn't your standard workplace either.

He had his head eaten by Matanza.

It's said that Mateo still won't touch WWE catering because he's still full up to this day. Dario fed Bael to Matanza during one of LU's madcap episodes, as you do. It's a truly silly thought, but the henchman had his face, skull and everything else in between gobbled by JC Mateo's earlier alter ego.

This was a message sent by Cueto to anyone else working for him. Some promoters like Tony Khan add injury time onto contracts. Others, such as Vince McMahon, humiliate their own employees on screen. Not Dario Cueto. This imaginary evil owner decided it was best if any failures were quickly eaten by caged horrors. At least there'd be no mess that way.

Farewell, Bael. We hardly knew ye. His poor face.


6. The Ultimate Warrior’s Comic Book Fate (WWF)

The Ultimate Warrior WWE Comic Book
WWE

The unique thing about this strange conclusion is that it didn't even happen on wrestling TV. In the mid-1990s, Vince McMahon agreed terms with The Ultimate Warrior to bring his peculiar brand of madness back to the World Wrestling Federation's ailing product. The 'New Generation' was in full swing, but McMahon wanted to sprinkle some Warrior magic back onto things too.

Warrior said yes, but also said the WWF would have to agree to buy a truckload of copies of his new comic book as part of the deal. Once he realised the legacy star wasn't going to budge, McMahon relented and was stuck with a bulging inventory of unsold comics. After all, the storyboard for it was chaotic, and included Warrior himself being possessed, dragged to hell and tortured to death.

Yep, it had an 'RIP Warrior' moment. Most people didn't see that, because the comic books didn't sell too well, but this was presented as a natural end to The Ultimate Warrior's character arc. No grandiose casket finish or 'Buried Alive' match conclusion - just Warrior being tied up and tortured in purgatory.

Insert jokes about him no-selling the finish here.

Seriously though, this is all rather spooky in retrospect given Warrior's real passing in 2014. That was undeniably sad, especially considering he'd only just returned to be inducted into the WWE Hall Of Fame. Decades earlier, Warrior was written off in comic book form. Bizarrely, he wouldn't be seen on WWF/WWE television again until that HOF treatment.

The less said about his shortlived WCW run in 1998 the better too.


5. Ethan Page Has His Heart Ripped Out (TNA)

Ethan Page Karate Man
Impact Wrestling

Someday, the above picture will be thrust up on screen during Ethan Page's own WWE Hall Of Fame induction. Maybe. It's from TNA's Hard To Kill 2021 pay-per-view. On that show, 'All Ego' ran a Mortal Kombat-style tribute that included him having his heart ripped out by alter ego The Karate Man. He knows karate, don't you know?

Yes, it was OTT and hammier than the piggy bank from Toy Story, but Ethan somehow made it entertaining. There's no point in trying to portray this as even remotely serious though. Page himself was having the best time getting all cinematic and probably living out scenes he'd acted in his bedroom as a teenager in between rounds as badasses like Johnny Cage or Sub-Zero.

Later, Ethan referred to this experiment as "hot garbage" during interviews, and said he didn't even want The Karate Man gimmick to appear on Impact programming at all. He bemoaned the editing, and described the production as "lazy". So, Page wasn't fond of his Hard To Kill moment, but TNA fans have since held it aloft as one of the most outlandish (and fun) memories from a unique time for the company.

'All Ego' can say he "died" in TNA then inked a deal with AEW. Once he was ready, Page then jumped from AEW to WWE and has since become a success on NXT. Maybe WWE's working relationship with TNA can repair the damage caused by his latter day struggles behind the scenes with the promotion.

Bringing back Karate Man might be a stretch, right enough.


4. Erick Rowan's Spider Gets Squashed (WWE)

Drew McIntyre Erick Rowan Spider
WWE.com

"They've got a Spider-Baby".

Those words spewed by Father Dougal McGuire in beloved hit comedy Father Ted described a travelling fun fare coming to Craggy Island. That travelling fun fare likely had nothing on WWE's Raw adventures in 2019-2020, but McGuire was thrilled by the prospect of a monstrosity "with the body of a spider and the mind/head of a baby" nonetheless.

His head might've exploded had he clapped eyes on Vince McMahon's creative in late-2019. In November that year, former Wyatt Family man and Daniel Bryan disciple Erick Rowan began carting around a big cage with a cloth tossed over the top of it. Nobody really knew where the story was going, and that included WWE's writing team. They were making this nonsense up as they went along.

Eventually, on the 2 March 2020 Raw, Rowan revealed that his pet creature was a...giant spider. It was literally the worst-looking mechanical spider monster money could buy. If WWE weren't going out of their way to make this crap, then they were about to pretend that was the case.

Exactly one week later on the flagship, Drew McIntyre squashed the thing to death with the steel steps. That was that. Erick's spider creation was no more, and then McIntyre marched his way onto the weirdest WrestleMania ever to become WWE Champion. To recap, he won the Royal Rumble, bagged the WWE Title at 'Mania and spared everybody more of this tripe all in one year.

What a guy, what a hero, what a...murderer?! It's actually a slight surprise that Drew didn't use a big Claymore sword to finish the job instead (complete with swishing sound effect).


3. Dragon Dragon Is Beheaded (Chikara)

Dragon Dragon Chikara Beheaded
Chikara

This almost took the top spot. Almost.

Chikara was never known for being a serious take on the wrestling medium. Outrageously over the top characters, laughs aplenty and some spliced in spotfests were the general rule of thumb, and it worked for Mike Quackenbush's promotion before an unsavoury end. They managed to carve out a cool niche for themselves with wrestling ice cream cones and dress-up dinosaurs having their heads cut off by a 'Wild Viking Warrior'.

No, Erik and Ivar from WWE didn't take a time machine back to 2013 and introduce the world to their Viking Experience early. Oleg was a menacing brute with a comedic edge (a must in Chikara), and it was he who decided to decapitate the casually named Dragon Dragon. Not Super Dragon, not American Dragon, but Dragon...Dragon.

There were children present, Oleg. Look at the screenshot above to see an innocent little girl sitting atop her father's knee in a pink dress. She's looking on to see some cartoon dino get his head cut off by a rampaging Viking who just refuses to stop. If Daniel Bryan's meteoric rise hadn't been happening around the same time, then all anyone in wrestling would've been talking about was Dragon Dragon getting his head head chop chopped off off.

Fantastically stupid.

Check out how seriously the referee was taking things too. He's checking to make sure there's nothing illegal going on with that beheading. You don't want to accidentally apply a choke whilst doing it, after all. What a crap reason to get DQ'd that'd be.


2. Al Wilson’s Sex-Related Heart Attack (WWE)

Al Wilson
WWE

It's perhaps the most 'Attitude' into 'Ruthless Aggression' era thing ever that a pensioner died on screen due to being oversexed by one of the Divas. In 2003, Torrie Wilson's dad Al suffered a heart attack whilst romping with Torrie's rival Dawn Marie. The couple had been married (as part of Dawn's creepy fascination with getting closer to Torrie), but poor Al just couldn't keep up with the lovemaking.

He was in trouble as soon as Dawn modelled outfits she'd worn in various Divas-related magazine shoots of the day. Here's the thing: Al wasn't some actor hired in by WWE to play the role of Torrie's father. This was actually her shoot dad, and here he was being written out because a fellow Diva was making sexual demands ol' Al just couldn't live up to.

Commentators like Michael Cole and Tazz practically high-fived one another once it became clear that Al and Dawn Marie were going to become an item. This era of WWE was raunchy. Sure, the whole story was played for laughs in the end, but it's still pretty awkward to sit down and revisit today.

WWE ran one of those 'in Loving Memory' graphics for Al on SmackDown in 2003 following his storyline passing. Sadly, Torrie's father would die for real in 2019. In a spooky touch, he did so mere days before his daughter was set to be inducted into the WWE Hall Of Fame.

Al Wilson will go down in company history as one of the strangest on screen deaths ever.


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.