The WORST Moment From Every WWE WrestleMania
21. Big Show Goes Sumo (WrestleMania 21)
Nobody asked for this, and nobody deserved to see it.
Seeing Big Show in sumo gear and having to pay for the privilege was an insult. Yes, Vince McMahon wanted to put on another midcard attraction for ‘Mania 21, but did he need to choose this?! Akebono won in just over a minute, and that short timing was a mercy killing. It was too late for everyone's eyeballs though. Way too late.
Incredibly, this sumo exhibition proved to be the middle stinker in a trio of matches for Ake. He worked a SmackDown taping before ‘Mania, then teamed with Show on a house show that July. By all accounts, none of those matches clicked with audiences. Backstage, WWE bosses realised that the big sumo grappler didn't have a lick of pro talent, so they cut their losses on hopes of turning him into a crossover star.
If you're a masochist and enjoy checking out the worst of wrestling, then some of the moments in this collection may tickle your fancy. Don't be tempted to watch Show vs. Akebono, whatever you do. If you absolutely must see what horrors await, then absolutely never check it out in polite company with those who think this WWE stuff isn't for them.
The 'Mania 21 calamity will put them off for good.
On his day, Show could do some superb stuff against non-wrestlers. His 2008 match with Floyd Mayweather went off without a hitch. Unfortunately, the brief altercation with Akebono went off without a stitch. Well, almost. Did anyone actually cry out to see Paul Wight in Rikishi-style gear?
20. The Boogeyman Beats Booker T (WrestleMania 22)
Ponder something collectively for a second, if you will: Booker T's crud-drenched feud with The Boogeyman occurred the same year he won King Of The Ring and randomly turned the royal gimmick into a sensational piece of business. It was a throne-sitting show of defiance from Book. Give him all the rubbish you wish, WWE writers. He'll make the most of it.
Or erm...not.
That's likely unfair on T. Both he and Sharmell were shoved into one of 2006's worst moments by warring with a clock-wearing Halloween character who ate worms for a living. No, he really ate worms for a living. Creatively, the storyline was worm food from the off. Fans sighed their way through every interaction, then asked one simple question as April approached: 'What? They're actually putting this in the ring at WrestleMania 22?!'.
"They" most certainly were. Booker was so directionless before that iconic KOTR win, man. He hadn't even been on the 'Mania card 12 months prior - Book won a pre-show Battle Royal before 21 went live. In truth, he'd been slipping down the ranks for a while. Becoming 'King' would change all of that, at least.
Not even Charles Robinson's Hollywood-worthy facial expressions (you were a year out for an Oscar, Chuck) could save the day. Boogeyman could be effective when used as a lower tier scaremonger, but he had no business beating someone the quality of Booker T at WrestleMania. No business at all.
Poor Sharmell had to close her eyes and lock lips with he who munched invertebrates too. Some people get all the luck, huh? Yuck.
19. Donald Trump’s Punches (WrestleMania 23)
WrestleMania 23's Bobby Lashley vs. Umaga match was framed as a ‘Battle Of The Billionaires’. Realistically, neither full-timer was the star attraction. They were around ringside - Vince McMahon was in Umaga’s corner, and Donald Trump was in Lashley’s. You've got to give WWE credit for getting everyone hyped for the thought of Trump clocking Vince though.
At one point, having seen more than enough of his enemy's attempts to interfere, Trump speared (if you can call it that) Vince and rained down (ahem) some of the weakest punches known to man. This writer simply cannot believe he's about to type these words, but they're true: Donald's rabbit punches made Shane’s flurries look like they'd win UFC gold by TKO.
This was such a poor moment in an otherwise drama-fuelled match.
Trump's punches were that bad. It was an embarrassment. What? They couldn't get him down to a training facility ahead of time or pull him aside and say: 'Show us what your strikes are like' before the show kicked off? That would've been the smart thing to do. God, the future President's blows even paled in comparison to those his impersonator would inflict on fans when jousting with a fake Rosie O'Donnell. OK, maybe that's stretching it, but go with the hyperbole just to stick the boot in.
Looking back, it might've been better had Trump stuck the boot in on McMahon. Vince should've pulled his pal to one side backstage and said, 'Just f'n hit me or I'll yank that hairpiece clean off'.
18. The ECW Title = Afterthought! (WrestleMania XXIV)
'Mania XXIV "retired" Ric Flair with a heart-wrenching bout vs. Shawn Michaels, and it saw the likes of CM Punk arrive on the map as somebody WWE planned to take seriously (for a while). Those were undercard highlights. Chavo Guerrero losing the ECW Title to Kane in a mere 11 seconds defo wasn't. If anything, it'd be a lowlight.
The 'Big Red Machine' had won a 24-man Battle Royal on the pre-show to earn his title shot. In total, Kane worked 2 matches across as a grand total of 6 minutes, so it was an easy night's work for him. However, his win proved to be the latest stain on the once proud ECW belt, and it was further proof that the McMahons were never going to take the thing seriously.
It was the European Title slapped with Paul Heyman branding. Sorry, but it's true.
A year prior, ECW had received some lustre at 'Mania 21 by putting hardcore favourites up against WWE's 'New Breed'. That wasn't perfect by any means, but it was better than this Chavo vs. Kane guff. Watching the ref hold both arms in the air during Kane's chokeslam almost made it seem like he was chuffed that Guerrero was dropping the strap too. It was weird.
If you're being charitable, you might suggest that 11 seconds is nothing to worry about on a bloated 'Mania supershow. Every second counts though, and all 11 of the ones on tap during the ECW segment tanked. Kane had no business being on ECW, and he was another example of Vince's apparent need to nullify the legacy of Heyman's operation.
17. The ‘Miss. WrestleMania’ Nonsense (WrestleMania XXV)
Oh, how WWE's attitude towards women's wrestling has changed since 2009. Back then, the Divas (as they were known) broke up more serious segments on shows elsewhere. They were rarely treated with much respect, and titillation or comedy seemed to be the general rule. Case in point: The division's lot at WrestleMania XXV.
Santino Marella, posing as his sister Santina, won the match to be crowned ‘Miss. WrestleMania’. That was only one of the problems with the match, to be fair. None of the women involved meant anything outside maybe Beth Phoenix (who was there near the end and was eliminated last as part of the story with Marella). Also, the Kid Rock mini-concert stuff with the Divas went on too long beforehand, and Sunny was involved but no-one thought to mention her!
The legend was barely even shown on camera, and the commentary team didn't seem to know she was in there trading punches, kicks etc. If they did, then they must've been instructed not to talk about her part in the match. Admittedly, it was brief, but...what an odd call.
Santino, as Santina, was the top story anyway. He was booked to gush with glee as Candice Michelle put the tiara on his head, and the whole thing was a send up of the importance of women's wrestling. Think about it: This was 'Mania, and a chance for the division to showcase its wares in front of millions. Instead, WWE saw fit to put Marella out there for a laugh.
He tried his best, but the Santina gimmick was dire to sit through.
16. Bret Hart Can't Bump (WrestleMania XXVI)
True masters of their craft often use various shortcuts or tricks to minimise bumping. Bret Hart was a pro wrestling genius, no doubt, but he was also physically knackered by 2010. Not limited, knackered and frankly incapable of delivering when it mattered. It was heartbreaking (Hart-breaking?) to see the 'Hitman' wobble wonkily around the ring whilst peppering Vince McMahon with shots.
Vince was expected to be the workhorse at 'Mania XXVI. That says it all. Bret couldn't take any bumps himself, so McMahon had to carry the load. Unfortunately, the bout came too late to really work as a 'Montreal Screwjob' revenge mission for the 'Hitman', and the story of the Hart clan tricking Vince almost turned him into a sympathetic babyface by accident.
Oops.
It's true. The one sided beatdown threatened to rally fan support behind McMahon (of all people). Together, both old enemies tried everything they could think of to add bells and whistles, but the match turned out to be miserable. It's worth saying that fans got over Montreal long before WWE did too; almost 13 years had passed, after all.
Bret can’t be blamed for not bumping due to health reasons, but why on earth did WWE bother to book this match knowing that?! They backed themselves into a corner with a match that was never going to live up to the hype, and it was sad to watch a firm favourite strive to even lock on his Sharpshooter hold and maintain his balance near the end.
Some will argue that WWE had to book this match, but it might've been better if they hadn't. It was a blight on the WrestleMania XXVI lineup.
15. Michael Cole Gets Too Much Time (WrestleMania XXVII)
Even Michael Cole has poked holes in WWE giving him so much time at 'Mania XXVII.
The then-heel commentator and Jerry Lawler went 13:48 in their match, but the whole segment was 20+ minutes when including entrances and shenanigans. Steve Austin and Jack Swagger were involved in proceedings too, but even the box office swagger of 'Stone Cold' couldn't offset the fact that this was Mikey Cole in an orange singlet hoovering up plenty of ring time on the biggest show of 2010.
Incredibly, WWE decided that 2 announcers should get more minutes inside the squared circle than guys like Edge, Cody Rhodes, Rey Mysterio, Trish Stratus and more. Even more unbelievably, Cole vs. Lawler was just a minute shorter than Randy Orton vs. CM Punk, and only a few mins less than than John Cena vs. The Miz in the main event slot.
To his credit, Cole did his best to ham it up for the fans, and Lawler was clearly loving every second. This was Jerry's first actual match at WrestleMania. Sure, it was against a non-wrestler, but the 'King' had to be buzzing inside anyway. That doesn't mean he needed to be out there for longer than some full-timers, right enough.
Despite his best efforts (he was only following instructions), Cole's heel commentator gimmick had become insufferable on WWE television. He trolled babyfaces, literally called segments/matches boring etc. It all seemed counterproductive, but putting him inside the ring for as long as they did was the worst moment of his heel run by a mile.
Previously, this same writer has defended it. Then, he sat through the WrestleMania match again!
14. Daniel Bryan Lasts 18 Seconds (WrestleMania XXVIII)
If the plan was to humble both Daniel Bryan and Sheamus by booking them in back to back non-events at WrestleMania XXVII and XXVIII, then WWE's mission was accomplished. The duelling pair were bumped to the pre-show in 2011, then went a paltry 18 seconds in a World Title showdown the following year whilst kicking off the main card. It wasn't exactly the best use of them as a combo.
This was surely an exercise in humiliation for a wrestling machine like Bryan, but it didn’t work. Fans rallied behind him harder, then eventually turned him into a top babyface. The 'Yes Movement' would irritate higher-ups until they were forced to give in and book him properly. Behold the power of your voice as an audience, people.
For the record, a full 2 minutes were gifted to Mick Foley, Santino Marella and some dude from TV show The Deadliest Catch so they could punch crabs later in the night. Cross-promotional dollars matter in big business, but this was 'Mania not Raw/SmackDown, and there was no reasonable excuse for giving Captain Keith Colburn more time on the show than Bryan Danielson. None whatsoever.
WWE wouldn't have bothered trying to explain it away. If anything, they'd have doubled down at the time and called Bryan a "B+ player at best". He wasn't. He was always an A grade piece of talent, and one of the best pro wrestlers on the planet. Dan vs. Sheamus II deserved more respect after XXVII's pre-show berth.
They would've smashed it as well.
13. Twice In A Lifetime (WrestleMania 29)
The Rock vs. John Cena worked as a one off, then WWE told quite the fib.
Listen, multiple matches would’ve been fine and dandy, but it was the company that pushed the ridiculous ‘Once In A Lifetime’ gimmick in the first place, and they were never going to stick to it. They had no intentions of booking Rock vs. Cena once then calling it quits, so why bother with the branding?
Those 'Twice In A Lifetime' memes cheapened the rematch at WrestleMania 29. Worse, The Rock tore his abs, quads and more mid-match, so he couldn’t even enter a top performance that improved on the original. Yikes. Maybe that's the biggest villain here: Rocky's rotten luck early in the match. He was visibly in agony as the headliner progressed, but powered through to return the favour and give JC back his win.
WWE likely knew they planned to put a sequel on at 'Mania 29, so they shouldn't have told that 'Once In A Lifetime' lie at all. Deep down, Rock also probably realised that he was pushing his body to the limits by trying to work another lengthy headliner, but...the money (not that he needs it!) was staggering and there was business to be handled.
Cena and Rock were willing to do their part as foes, because they didn't fully detest one another by 2013, but WWE's overblown hype train couldn't behave. The company will 100% go back on such definitive statements again in the future. It's a wrestling problem, not just their problem.
12. Hulk Hogan’s “Silverdome” Flub (WrestleMania XXX)
Admittedly, this was funny and almost charming in a way, but Vince McMahon would’ve been tearing his hair out behind the big curtain at WrestleMania XXX. Every aspect of WWE’s product was meticulously micromanaged by the boss at the time, so Hulk Hogan referring to the New Orleans Superdome as the “Silverdome, brother” wouldn’t have gone down well.
Steve Austin and The Rock, who were sharing the ring with a fellow company icon, found it hilarious, but this was slightly embarrassing for Hulk. The fact there isn’t much else to moan about shows how strong ‘Mania XXX was. It was a night that belonged to Daniel Bryan - the whole card was a love letter to those who'd hated how he'd been treated at 'Mania XXVIII a couple of years beforehand.
By 2014, even WWE's ignorant approach couldn't withstand fan demands. They wanted Bryan on top, and that was that. Earlier, just before racist comments leaked and wrecked his public image, Hogan botched the venue's name and had everyone either laughing or cringing.
Get it right, Terry. Come on now, dude.
Elsewhere, there wasn't much to moan about. Triple H put Bryan over in the opener, Cesaro won that Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal, Brock Lesnar ended The Undertaker's streak and more. OK, so some reading this would rank Brock beating the streak as a "worst ever" moment, but it was historic and made headlines.
Meanwhile, Hulk thinking he was right back in 1987 a few times took the biscuit. He was all over the place.