10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2009
"Piggy James" was a disgrace, Donald Trump plummeted WWE stock and more 2009 nightmares.
The Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania XXV will forever be regarded as one of the greatest WWE matches of all time. No question. It was a highlight of 2009, sure, but it was also a banner moment for company output historically. Both veterans put on a classic show that night, one so good that people still talk about it like the bell just sounded to signal 'Taker's win 5 minutes ago.
There was a breathlessness to 'Taker vs. HBK that's unmatched, but their genius wasn't the only thing leaving people short of breath in '09. Indeed, WWE got 'Mania's main event slot badly wrong, made a mockery of the entire women's division, and forced fans to slog through some uninspired build heading into the biggest pay-per-view of the year.
Away from the bright lights of WrestleMania, injuries and personal issues had a negative impact on an already weary roster. Physical pain stopped the writers from penning a brilliant chapter of the tag-team wrestling book, whilst one star's majesty faded due to a potentially deadly combination of substance abuse, battle wounds and contractual problems.
Then, there was Donald Trump. Not quite President, Trump was a media mogul who accidentally helped WWE's stock market value plummet due to an ill-advised (and frankly unwanted) storyline on Raw. If all of that isn't enough, then the flagship began obsessing over celebrity guest hosts, so-called comedy matches and more too.
Over on SmackDown, backstage bullying made air in one of the cruellest stories to ever beam in front of cameras. Everyone involved in that saga should honestly be ashamed of themselves.
Their calculated cruelty blighted 2009.
10. Kizarny’s Debut Flops
Imagine a character called 'Powderz' debuted on WWE today. The general premise? He was prone to rolling out of the ring after taking a move, or to avoid punishment before it happened. In other words, he'd 'take a powder' and get out of dodge. Hardly sounds thrilling, does it? That kind of backstage/internal wrestling terminology has no place within the context of the show unless it's carefully placed.
Kizarny, WWE's latest creation back in late-2008 into early-2009, was clumsy. He showed up in a bunch of vignettes before a proper in-person debut on the 2 January 2009 SmackDown. There, Kizarny beat MVP in a match few cared about. It was on the longer side for what was supposed to be an impactful debut, it was boring, and it just didn't really play before any noticeable interest from the live crowd.
The character's name played on insider 'carny' lingo, but even that was far too niche to really register with a casual audience. That's why Kizarny's debut match tanked (or part of the reason, at least), and WWE didn't hang around to see what'd happen next - the dude playing this new guise was gone by March. So much for that. Experiment over.
It was failing from the moment he stepped foot through the curtain.
Kizarny's erratic movements, bizarre facial expressions and quirky gimmick didn't jive with his plodding ring style at all. WWE started 2009 off on a duff note with this character. It wasn't the worst idea on paper to have Kiz go over an established name like Porter, but fan apathy couldn't have been more obvious had everyone held up signs saying: 'We Don't Care About This Guy'.
9. The Boxing Sideshow Nobody Asked For
Hornswoggle and Chavo Guerrero had an interminable feud in 2009. Together, they worked a ‘Blindfold Match’ that made everyone long to have something shielding their eyes instead, Chavo dressed up as a cow for a ‘Texas Bullrope Match’, and Mark Henry even became “Markswoggle” for the night. Not many were amused by any of this; at least not anyone over the age of 12.
The 24 August 2009 Raw stands out though. Chavo and Swoggle worked a comedy boxing match compete with oversized gloves for Guerrero. These skits got less and less funny by the week. Look, there's nothing wrong with booking things that'll make children laugh or entertain them, but this was the same gag over and over again.
Chavo would make grand promises about catching Hornswoggle to give him a thrashing, then the lil' devil would find a way to escape like he was some Looney Tunes cartoon character come to life. It was way more endearing when Bugs Bunny did it, guys. Wee Swoggle just lacked the likeability of that rabbit.
Guerrero clearly didn't mind clowning himself, and this was a million miles better than the racist Kerwin White gimmick he'd played in 2005, but still...it sucked. Diminishing returns are rubbish for everybody when something's hot but people lose interest. They're way worse when something is crap from the get go but everyone's forced to sit through effectively the same flimsy booking on repeat.
WWE should've told the announcers to bow out so they could play some Benny Hill music with an added laughter track instead. The whole thing was way too try hard.
8. “Summerfest”
WWE's 'Raw Guest Host' era was sometimes inoffensive/sometimes painful depending on how switched on the celebs coming in were. Bob Barker was one of the best, because he put his all into the performance and understood that he was there to be part of the wacky wrestling world for a few charming hours. Crucially, Bob also did his homework and came armed with some product knowledge.
Then there was Jeremy Piven. He was the celeb host on Raw's 3 August 2009 episode. Ken Jeong was there with him to promote a movie, and he spent most of the time hamming it up like he was auditioning down at the soon-to-be WWE Performance Center a few years later. Being fair, someone had to, because our Jeremy blatantly had no clue what he was really doing inside a wrestling ring.
When setting up a ‘Lumberjack Match’ between The Miz and John Cena, Piven said that Miz would be “banned from the summerfest” if he lost. Thinking on his feet, Cena quickly corrected the actor by saying Miz would be banned from SummerSlam. You've got to give one thing to Jeremy, at least: He poked fun at himself for the error by saying: "Yes, SummerSlam...and the summerfest, whatever that is!".
It was too little, too late. One clanger proved that Piven hadn't been briefed properly on WWE's upcoming tentpole pay-per-view. Somehow, this guest host thing ran all the way up until May 2010 when Vince McMahon mercifully put a red pen through it and stopped leaning on celebs to pop a rating from people who wouldn't normally watch wrestling.
Hey, it's a small mercy that Piven didn't get WrestleMania wrong and call it 'Colossal Tussle' or something.
7. Edge’s Injury Wrecks An All-Timer Tag Run
The tag-team ranks were pretty much plodding along without making waves when Chris Jericho and Edge teamed together to win the Unified Tag Titles from The Colons at The Bash on 28 June 2009. Legacy duo Cody Rhodes and Ted DiBiase were also in that match, but the night belonged to a pair of Canadian heroes who'd surely go on to dominate the doubles conversation for the rest of the year.
That's when fate intervened.
Less than a full week after winning the belts, Edge was struck down by a nasty Achilles tendon tear during a house show match vs. Jeff Hardy on 3 July. Rather than stripping he and Jericho of their newly-won titles, creative pivoted towards a sub and had 'Y2J' bring out Big Show as a 'Rated-R Replacement'. At first, fans were annoyed, but then Jeri-Show actually proved themselves to be rather handy as champs.
Still, what could've been. People were robbed of seeing an all-timer run from Edge and Jericho. Who knows? They might've turned into one of the greatest tag-teams of all time and held the straps for years. Probably not, but it'll always be one of WWE's biggest 'what if?' moments from that era.
Jericho kicked off a feud with Edge once his would-be pal returned. That was...fine. Nowhere near as satisfying as seeing them combine to become an all-conquering super team, but fine. If only Edge and Hardy hadn't gone full pelt in their non-televised live event bout. Curse those high standards!
'Rated-Y2J' could've been amazing. Bring it back, maaaaaaaaan.
6. Jeff Hardy’s Downfall
Timing is everything in wrestling. For Jeff Hardy, ascending to main event status again in late-2008 was ideal. He became WWE Champion after righting the wrongs of his prior stab at a singles run in the company, and all seemed right with the world. Everyone and their granny figured that daredevil Jeff would be a permanent fixture at the top of cards for years to come.
Sadly, Hardy's own personal demons got the best of him. By mid-2009, he was letting his WWE contract lapse and looking for a much-needed physical and mental break. So, writers put him in a 'Loser Leaves WWE' cage bout with CM Punk on the 28 August SmackDown, and Jeff lost. That was a cover story. In reality, his contract was due, he had several painful injuries, and he wasn't in the best frame of mind personally.
By 11 September, Hardy had been arrested for drug trafficking and possession. It was a sad and sudden downfall for somebody who seemed to be on top of the mountain as a main event star in the biggest promotion going. Thankfully, despite other legal problems since, Jeff has managed to largely clean up his act and is in a much, much better place.
Fingers crossed that mindset sticks.
Watching him go from a vital cog in the headline pack on SmackDown and winning WWE/World Heavyweight Titles to arrested and then showing up in TNA was depressing to his fans. Industry critics reasoned that Jeff was content to throw everything he'd worked for away. Harsh? Maybe, but there was overwhelming evidence supporting his repeated patterns of behaviour.
5. WWE Gets WrestleMania’s Main Event Wrong
Traditionalists would say that a top title match needs to close WrestleMania every year. Naturally, the rules have changed on that a little in more recent years since WWE started running weekenders rather than a one off Sunday night show, but most would agree that the second night should end with a blowoff championship showdown people have been waiting months to see.
In that sense, there was nothing wrong (in theory) with Triple H vs. Randy Orton going on last at 'Mania XXV. The build, which saw a wickedly evil Orton torture Hunter's family and Trips invade Randy's home for some payback, was solid and flashy. Unfortunately, they had 2 things working against them in Houston: The bout's stipulation and another match that stole the show before them.
In execution, Hunter vs. Orton bored everyone to tears and had no business going on after Shawn Michaels vs. The Undertaker. Granted, nobody knew that HBK vs. 'Taker would be as epic as it was, but Triple H vs. Randy turned out to be an unfortunate repeat of 'The Game's' humdrum effort with Chris Jericho back in 2002.
Again, tacking on a stip that meant Triple H would lose his title if he got disqualified was silly too, because it meant the vengeful babyface couldn't smash Randy's skull in for attacking his wife/other family members. Without that violence, the main event was neutered and had to go with a slower pace.
In retrospect, it was obviously 'Taker vs. Shawn that needed to go on last. They had the best match on the show, and their outstanding chemistry was all anyone could talk about once the night was done.
4. Trump “Buying Raw” Plummets WWE Stock
In 2007, Vince McMahon decided to kill off his onscreen character with a dramatic limo explosion storyline that was only halted by the very-real Chris Benoit tragedy. In 2008, he tried to take himself off TV again with the whole 'Million Dollar Mania' fiasco. That didn't work either. Perhaps 2009's Monday Night Raw sale was Vince's latest bid to scale down his appearances in front of the cameras.
On the 15 June 2009 Raw, a pensive Vince announced that he was selling off the rights to his flagship show Raw. He described it as a business opportunity he simply couldn't say no to, then revealed that none other than Donald Trump was the buyer. It was all fictional, of course, but the company put out a press release to try and legitimise the storyline anyway.
Apparently, some people bought it as real, because there was some panic amongst investors when Trump also claimed he’d make the next week’s episode “commercial free”. Within hours of that press release, WWE’s stock reportedly dropped as much as 7% on Wall Street. Panicking, McMahon fielded advice from others on the board and stopped the 'Trump buys Raw' tale.
On TV one week later, Donald agreed to sell Raw back to Vince for double the price he'd paid for it. Then, everyone quietly moved along like nothing had ever happened. It was a disaster, and an ultimately pointless one due to the stock problems. All WWE accomplished here was costing themselves some money and stock value.
All of that for what amounted to a few extra minutes of TV sans ads.
3. Shawn Michaels “Needs” JBL’s Money
Here's one storyline that made no sense whatsoever.
Shawn Michaels claimed that the global recession had forced him to spend the last of his family savings, so he needed to seek employment from JBL and do the heel’s bidding to make money. Wait, what? So WWE weren’t paying one of their top stars to wrestle? How on earth did they think anybody was going to believe a word of it?!
Technically, this all started in December 2008, but the story continued into ’09 and peaked with HBK beating Layfield at No Way Out in February. He immediately went from that to a feud with The Undertaker heading into ‘Mania XXV, which was a vast improvement. Honestly, what was this all about? It simply wasn’t believable that a multi-millionaire like Shawn Michaels was struggling to pay the bills.
Everyone reading will understand that WWE were trying to exploit a relatable real-life situation, but it was daft. There was no feasible way that Shawn, who was still under company contract and had been competing for World Titles in pay-per-view main events mere months ago, was strapped for cash. Even so, he turned into Layfield's lackey before breaking free just in time for another money spinner against an old foe come 'Mania.
The idea that Michaels "needed" JBL's money was laughable. Financial uncertainty was a real concern for many tuning in, so it was a tad insulting to see multi-millionaires pretending they couldn't put food on the table. Hell, Shawn's pyro budget alone would've kept a family of 4 fed and watered all year.
At least make it plausible, please.
2. Santino Marella Is “Miss. WrestleMania”
Before WrestleMania XXV, WWE bragged about how they'd shine a spotlight on the women's division with a 25-strong Battle Royal that'd crown the first ever 'Miss. WrestleMania'. Iconic Diva of yesteryear Sunny was going to be there, and it'd be a thrill for fans to see her mix with modern day favourites in a bid to earn the tiara.
This was going to be the only women's match on the show, so it was of utmost importance that they do things properly. That's what made the end result so difficult to reconcile come crunch time. Santino Marella dressed up as his "sister" Santina to win the whole thing, and he'd eliminated Beth Phoenix last of all to win this women's division showpiece. That was slap in the face after slap in the face for the often-overlooked roster.
If you want to see how far women's wrestling in WWE has come since, then revisit this match and watch the nonsense unfold. The commentators barely mentioned that Sunny was involved, and the cameras failed to focus on her due to the number of bodies flying around the place. That wasn't the only negative. Presenting a Battle Royal as WrestleMania's celebration of women, then putting Santino f'n Marella over instead?! It was too much.
As if it wasn't bad enough that the women's division often received paltry ring time on major PPVs. Now, on the biggest of them all, their own showpiece match was won by a member of the men's locker room. Someone was having a laugh at the women's division's expense here, surely.
Beth should've gone into Daniel Puder-style shooting mode and rebelled.
1. Piggy James Is Thinly-Veiled Bullying
Mickie James has managed to brave face this and look at things through a different lens in years since, but she was 100% hurting back in late-2009 when WWE pulled a cruel stunt. On the 20 November '09 SmackDown, Layla introduced a parody of 'Old MacDonald Had A Farm' starring her heel tag partner Michelle McCool. What happened next left Mickie in tears.
McCool called out for "Piggy James", and said that she owned a farm perfect for "Piggy". In-ring, James did her best to sell the moment as wicked. Backstage, Michelle (in particular) had told Mickie how uncomfortable she was with the whole idea, but they'd been told to repeatedly poke fun at her weight in segments and during matches. It was outright bullying.
Listen, wrestlers work storylines that sometimes make light of their real personal lives. That's nothing new, but this wasn't something James was happy to sign off on. It's the fact that this was something coming from the top of the tree that sucks too. WWE management were publicly shaming Mickie because they genuinely thought she was overweight.
It was ridiculous, and shameful.
Later, Layla also wore a fat suit and pig nose whilst pretending to play the "Piggy James" character. The story prolonged into 2010, so it was a problem for a while. Again, wrestlers are encouraged to have thick skin because they're playing TV personalities who are there to be verbally torn down, but this was blatant bully boy behaviour from higher ups and the creative team.
It's mind-boggling that Mickie James from 2009 was deemed overweight. Eye tests all round.
What other moments from WWE's 2009 belong here? For more wrestling, check out 10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2008 and 10 Wrestlers That Got BANNED From AEW!