10 Weirdest WWE Tryout Stories

See what goes behind a WWE tryout - as revealed by these ten accomplished stars.

By Kebin Edwin Antony /

Every aspiring professional wrestler will have the ambition to compete inside a WWE ring and officially call themselves a WWE Superstar - but it's not an easy task to achieve. The company is also on the constant lookout for prospective talent, and creates several developmental systems to recruit and train wrestlers from all over the globe. Many superstars on the current roster and even legendary names came into the company from one of these platforms.

Advertisement

While WWE has platforms like NXT, WWE ID, WWE NIL, and WWE LFG at present, back in the day, they had developmental territories like FCW, OVW, and DSW, where they conducted tryout camps to find recruits.

Tryouts can be exciting and terrifying for the wrestlers, and each talent will have different stories to share. Some might share their success stories, some might share how they got rejected, some might share the valuable experiences they gained, some might share funny incidents, and some might share the humiliations they faced.

The stories of these ten accomplished wrestlers are combinations of all these aspects and will give a basic idea about what goes behind a WWE tryout and how things can get interesting and weird in an instant.

10. Trick Williams Told To Tone Down For Cutting Attitude Era Style Promo

Before he got the fans chanting "Whoop That Trick," the two-time NXT Champion once tried opening a classic Attitude Era-style can of whoop-ass during his first WWE tryout - and was asked to tone it down. Williams recalled the incident during an interview with Denise Salcedo. He talked about how WWE officials wanted him to learn to entertain people while keeping it clean.

Advertisement

He revealed during the interview that he stopped watching wrestling after the Attitude Era to focus more on his football prospects, which means he missed the Ruthless Aggression and PG Eras and didn't know the company had gone soft over the years.

When he received a WWE Tryout, he tried to make a good first impression by cutting an Attitude Era-style promo. However, the officials reportedly told him to tone things down since that's not what the company does anymore. Williams then decided to reaquaint himself with modern WWE programming, and he revealed watching Kofi Kingston win the WWE Championship at WrestleMania 35 was the moment that fully brought him back to wrestling.

With a rekindled passion for the sport, Trick Williams earned a developmental deal with WWE in 2021 and made his official in-ring debut on the 5 October 2021 episode of NXT.

9. Dusty Rhodes Told Keith Lee He Sucked On The Microphone

Keith Lee's WWE career has had its fair share of ups and downs, and similar to many of his NXT colleagues, he got his act ruined by the main roster creative team before getting released in 2021. He had his first tryout with WWE in 2008, but didn't get signed to a contract, and only got to appear as an extra on an episode of Raw in 2009.

Advertisement

The former NXT Champion shared more details on his failed 2008 WWE tryout in a WWE 24 documentary. Lee claimed the tryout was a good learning experience and recalled the late WWE Hall of Famer Dusty Rhodes telling him he wasn't ready and giving him an honest review that he sucked on the mic. Lee continued to perform on the independent circuit, and honed his skills before landing a developmental contract with WWE in 2018.

Fans hoped he'd reach his full potential in AEW after he signed with the company in 2022, but he had a mixed run in the Jacksonville-based promotion. He has been out of action since December 2023 due to an unknown injury, and underwent double surgeries in January 2024.

8. Athena Was Told To Lose Weight

WWE has always set fitness standards for the performers, and over the years, there have been numerous instances of company officials telling certain wrestlers to drop some weight. The standard applies especially to female performers, as WWE is known for using female wrestlers based on their looks over the years.

Advertisement

Current ROH Women's World Champion Athena, who holds the record for the longest singles title reign in ROH history after making the jump, is also known for her time in WWE between 2015 and 2021 as Ember Moon. She shared the same fate as many NXT superstars as she thrived in the developmental territory but was fumbled on the main roster.

Speaking about her WWE career while talking to Chris Jericho on his Talk is Jericho podcast, Athena reminisced about some of her failed WWE tryouts in the mid-to-late 2000s. She revealed that the evaluation from her first tryout stated she lacked the "Diva Look." She then worked with Natalya and got another tryout a few months later, and this time, the officials were blunt with their response when they told Athena to come back once she lost some weight.

7. WWE Offered Adam Cole A Tryout Thinking He Was Xavier Woods

Adam Cole had quite an eventful career in NXT for four years, but the rumoured prospect of cutting his long hair and becoming Keith Lee's manager/mouthpiece on the main roster drove him away to AEW in 2021. Cole signed his first contract with WWE in 2017, but his first interaction with the company took place during the early days of his career when WWE offered him a tryout at FCW. However, he wasn't the person the company had in mind, as the invitation was supposed to go out to another wrestler who shared a first name with Cole.

Advertisement

Adam Cole - real name Austin Kirk Jenkins - got the tryout invitation intended for Austin Watson, AKA Xavier Woods. Adam Cole recalled the incident during an interview with The Wrap, stating that he received email and phone confirmations from WWE and was sold on the idea that he was getting hired.

However, he noticed the name was wrong when he received the travel itinerary, and when he checked back with the WWE executive, both parties realized there had been a mix-up. Adam Cole ended up getting booked as an extra on Raw and SmackDown as consolation, but did get his tryout a few years later in 2013.

6. MJF Was Told He Was Too Young

Former (and longest-reigning) AEW World Champion MJF is one of the best mic workers in the pro wrestling business. He has delivered numerous scathing heel promos throughout his career, and the one directed at William Regal on the 18 October 2022 episode of Dynamite might've revealed a bit of history between the two in WWE.

Advertisement

MJF has never competed in WWE as an in-ring performer, but is known for appearing as an extra in a backstage segment with Samoa Joe in NXT. During the promo, MJF recalled Regal pulling him aside after a WWE tryout and telling him that he was too young for WWE. Regal allegedly told him to hone his craft in the independent scenes but asked him to continue to send him tapes so he could monitor his progress.

MJF revealed he took Regal's advice and continued to send footage of his matches. However, after a few months, MJF claimed that he received a discouraging email from Regal that almost made him quit the business. It's unclear if the story is true or part of a scripted promo, similar to his controversial car crash story.

5. Britt Baker Told To Complete Dental School First

Britt Baker's absence from AEW television has sparked rumors of Baker having heat with Tony Khan, with Wade Keller of PWTorch reporting Khan is fed up with Baker and is looking to focus his TV time on others. Fans have also started speculating that she might leave the company for WWE when her contract expires, which, according to Sean Ross Sapp's tweet, might not be up until June 2026.

Advertisement

The prospects of Britt Baker joining the WWE roster sound promising, and it wouldn't be the first time she steps inside a WWE ring, as she has competed in a few matches as an enhancement talent between 2016 and 2018.

Britt Baker talked about her attempts to get a WWE contract while talking to Chris Jericho on his Talk is Jericho podcast. She claimed WWE offered her a tryout solely based on her looks but didn't offer her a contract, since she had just entered dental school. Baker claimed Canyon Ceman, a former WWE executive, pulled her aside and told her to return once she's graduated. While initially disappointed, Britt Baker stated that she's thankful the tryout didn't work out as she got to complete her dental studies, which she might've ditched in favor of WWE.

4. Luke Gallows' Comedy Of Errors

Luke Gallows has had an on-and-off run with WWE since his first signing in 2005. He's been the Imposter Kane, Festus, the Straight Edge Society disciple, and as part of the O.C. with Karl Anderson. Apart from a few notable matches and two tag team title reigns, WWE wasn't always easy for Gallows. Talking about his time in the company, Gallows reminisced about his disastrous tryout for the fourth season of WWE Tough Enough in 2004.

Advertisement

Gallows revealed he had several humiliating moments during the tryout. He first stepped inside the ring to run the ropes, but the catch was there were no ropes in the ring, and he ended up falling head-first onto the ground in front of John Laurinaitis. Next up was the obstacle course, and even this turned into a humiliating endeavor after he fell while climbing the wall. While he thought the worst was over, he was not ready for what would hit him next.

After the wall, it was time to do the army crawl, and the untied drawstring in his shorts came back to haunt him in the worst way possible. As he continued to crawl under the netting, his shorts went down with each crawl. He had to do 25 push-ups once he finished the crawl, and by the time he reached the other side, he didn't have his shorts on - but proceeded to do the push-ups anyway. 

Long story short, he didn't make it into the final ten in the contest, but ended up getting a developmental contract in 2005.

3. Triple H & Shawn Michaels Buried CM Punk During His Tryout

CM Punk has been a polarizing figure in the professional wrestling industry from the get-go, and has frequently found himself at loggerheads with his co-workers and bosses over the years. He had the same relationship with Triple H back in the day, and according to a former WWE writer named Court Bauer, Triple H's issues with CM Punk go back to the days even before the latter became an official WWE superstar.

Advertisement

Punk signed his first WWE developmental contract in 2005 after competing in a series of tryout matches, the first of which happened in 2003. Court Bauer recounted an incident during one of the tryouts in his Bauer & Pollock podcast and revealed Triple H and Shawn Michaels buried the Straight Edge Superstar backstage as they watched his match with Vince McMahon in the Gorilla position.

Bauer stated that Triple H and Shawn Michaels badmouthed Punk based on his looks and in-ring style in front of the former WWE Chairman and former head of talent relations, John Laurinaitis. However, despite getting buried by two of the most influential figures in WWE, Punk ended up getting a contract in 2005 and made his television debut the following year.

2. Bayley Told Her Attire Was Unacceptable

Bayley has been an active WWE superstar for over a dozen years and has become one of the most decorated performers in the company's history. She came from humble beginnings, made a name for herself in NXT, overcame the odds on the main roster, and became the first-ever WWE women's Grand Slam winner. Looking back at her career, The Role Model reminisced about her initial tryout with the company and how her attire got her in trouble on an edition of The New Day: Feel the Power.

Advertisement

Bayley recalled coming in for a three-day tryout camp at the FCW facility and the writers asking her to wear something presentable when it was almost time for her to step inside the ring. She had bought this dress which she thought would help her get noticed, but the writers told her that the attire was unacceptable since she was showing a little too much skin - and urged her to change.

Bayley recalls being confused about what the company expected from her, and it was AJ Lee who helped her gain the right perspective and advised her to be herself while meeting the company executives halfway when it came to their expectations.

1. The Young Bucks Got Heat From Booker T

Before they became EVPs of All Elite Wrestling, Matt and Nick Jackson, The Young Bucks, made strides in NJPW, ROH, and other independent promotions. Like most emerging wrestlers, they attempted to get a WWE contract during their early years and attended a tryout. Unfortunately, the tryout did not go as planned, leading to an unexpected confrontation with WWE legend and Hall of Famer Booker T.

Advertisement

While talking to Booker T in episode 177 of Heated Conversations, "The Young Bucks" recalled the incident at the WWE tryout. Two incidents reportedly took place that day, with the first one being the duo not shaking hands with Booker T backstage, and the second was for inadvertently sitting on the latter's jacket.

Nick Jackson stated that he and his brother were walking on eggshells and didn't know what to do at the time, since they were in the early stages of their careers, and decided to stay out of the way to avoid accidentally disrespecting anyone. Apart from a few appearances as enhancement talent for WWE, the duo didn't get signed to a proper contract and had to hone their craft in the independent circuit to reach the position they're in today.

Advertisement