12 Times WWE Buried Itself
WWE: The recognised symbol of excellence in letting people know when it absolutely sucks
There's a difference between a good WWE and a bad one, and the lines aren't as blurred as some would have you believe.
There will never be a perfect edition of Raw or SmackDown. There have been some that have ran it close - there have been nights where the absolute hottest angles and matches are so memorable that they account for every recollection you'll have of a specific time, but perfection - while a worthy target - is always beyond reach thanks to at least one thing that has you itching for a fast-forward. It's the nature of the 52-week television churn but also the business itself. Even when wrestling television was structured entirely differently and more in service of house shows, a week without a big angle, a double-star match or even one great worker was commonplace.
What does remain consistent - particularly when assessing WWE as the recognised market leader for just about all of the last 40+ years - is a sense of certainty about the quality of the creative process. A business boom historically lasts longer than a creative one because rewards are reaped for a period after the bubble has burst. But it also starts before the cash starts rolling in - there are hardcores that love the obvious run-up to a peak than the summit itself.
1985-1990. 1996-2001. 2022-2025. Imperfect times, but very obvious periods of creative cohesion. As for the two decades between hot spells though...
12. The McMahons Apologise For WWE Being Bad And Change Nothing
In a segment that transpired to be rooted in a belief Triple H had that WWE were about to sign The Elite and stop AEW ever existing, all four McMahons took the ring at the start of the December 17th edition of Monday Night Raw to acknowledge that they hadn’t been producing a particularly good show for a while.
Already, the concept of the speech was flawed. “A while” wasn’t really fleshed out, and nor could it be - by admitting that the creative machine hadn’t really been well oiled since the year 2000, the company stood to risk alienating various TV paymasters that had only just agreed to make SmackDown the first ever billion dollar wrestling show thanks to an eye-watering new rights fee deal.
Furthermore, while Paul Levesque, and both McMahon children remembered the point of the peace offering and tried to show a modicum of contrition for a rotten period, Vince had already forgotten/ignored the brief before they’d even got to the apology. Long into his senile/disaffected troll era as a creative “force”, McMahon was bollocking the fans for their reactions throughout, and didn’t have any of the enthusiasm faked by the other three in the ring.
The message was anything but clear - we are going to make WWE better, but it’s already the best and you shouldn’t complain so much anyway. Get It?
11. Shane McMahon Wants To Fix A Broken WWE In 2016
Shane McMahon’s return to WWE in 2016 was a remarkable success story, all things considered.
The pop for his shock comeback on the February 22nd edition of the show was one of the louder ones all year, as was the response that greeted the bizarre news that he’d take on The Undertaker inside Hell In A Cell at that year’s WrestleMania. A WrestleMania that subsequently sold thousands more tickets following the above, which presumably fuelled the egotistical run in the years that followed.
Back in 2016 though, Shane was a welcome presence in contrast to his family members, and his placement alongside Daniel Bryan on SmackDown was nowhere near as suffocating as Stephanie McMahon’s own role with Mick Foley on Raw. More on that elsewhere in this article. Ultimately, ‘Shane-O-Mac’ was once again occupying what most considered to be an un-occupy-able space - the likeable McMahon.
One of the big reasons why was because of how his return was framed - he was the latest to say out-loud just how much WWE sucked. It was all in vague references to ratings, audience numbers and stock prices going down (no lies detected), but the fact bled over to the fiction easily enough for audiences to see his character as a life raft. He wanted control of Raw, of WWE’s short-lived “New Era”, and was going to drive change hitherto unseen for a generation. He ostensibly had to win it by beating 'The Deadman' on 'The Grandest Stage', but as if to prove his point, he lost and then was given the reins anyway before a rebooting of the brand split shunted him to SmackDown before the end of the year.
10. Steve Austin Says Nothing & Says Everything At Raw 25
Smart - Stone Cold Steve Austin delivering Stone Cold Stunners to Vince and Shane McMahon as Raw's 25th anniversary special kicked off live from Brooklyn's beautiful Barclays Center in January 2018.
Stupid - 'The Texas Rattlesnake' not even managing to say his monosyllabic and infuriating catchphrase for the packed and jacked crowd, let alone cut the sort of promo that stood to be the best thing the audience would get all night.
This was 2018 WWE. This was 2002-2022 WWE in many respects, but it was a tone-setter for a stinker of a night, and if you choose not to believe just another critic on the internet, maybe ask one of the biggest stars in industry history himself.
Speaking to Mike Rome for WWE.com (!) in the immediate aftermath, Austin went in kicked the cat but it did with an almighty two-footer on whomever had the temerity to take the microphone out of his hands earlier in the night. Pointedly noting that he 'drew money' alongside all his kayfabe accolades, Austin abandoned the party atmosphere in making a very serious and almost scary point about what he rightfully saw as total negligence from the bookers.
For a change, he held his tongue when it came to the curses, but the he wanted viewers to know that the feeling of frustration was mutual. We'd had our own time wasted in watching, just as 'The Bionic Redneck' had in jumping on the plane from the West Coast.
9. Edge Beats Up A Laptop
The symbolism of a wrestler smashing a machine/inanimate object in exasperation and desperation wasn't lost on the discerning fans that actually remained with WWE during some of the leanest creative years in company history.
Edge's destruction of the laptop Michael Cole would read aloud from during the chronic "anonymous Raw General Manager" era of the flagship show was designed as catharsis for a character getting wound up by the mysterious boss' decisions, particularly those weighted against him.
This wasn't a GM Vs Babyface storyline (more on those elsewhere) though, because Edge was a heel and the general manager wasn't real. Not really real, anyway. By this point a disembodied hackneyed robot voice, the "GM" seemed mostly intent on winding up the 'Rated-R Superstar' to the point of derangement. The reasons why were never explained, much in the same way most of the decisions weren't until the company pissed away the conclusion with another Hornswoggle payoff.
Edge was asked to do some of his best angry actTING just half a year after making a heroic return from injury to win the Royal Rumble and begin enacting revenge on former tag team partner Chris Jericho. Based on what we've come to learn about Adam Copeland's pro wrestling preferences post-2020 return, he probably enjoyed flexing his range, at least.
8. Wrestlers That LEAVE To Move Forward
Wrestling is rock hard.
It's a cool way to get rich and famous if you get rich and famous, but nobody that watches it and thinks "I want to do that!" should go in assuming that will actually be the end result. WWE is Sports Entertainment in every respect, including how rare it is to make it in either of those fields, and how damaging it can be to the body and mind despite being the envy of billions the world over.
Physical decline is a natural reality and risk of the job, independent of wherever a wrestler works. But what about the emotional and intellectual engines of the talents that ply their trade?
The rise in discussion of mental health over the past decade certainly redefined AJ Lee's time with the market leader. "Crazy" was once the shorthand used to describe anybody that didn't conform to every single neurotypical checkbox, and the label attached to her persona for the bulk of her time as a top star. She had a career that inspired future generations, wrote a book that encouraged others to open dialogues with themselves, and returned in a generation where she could speak freely on the challenges she faced what feels much more than a decade ago.
Conversation on such matters was presumably rife in the Mendez/Brooks household for all the years CM Punk was absent from the game following his enormously well-publicised acrimonious 2014 exit. Punk's recent on-screen rival Drew McIntyre had to physically and mentally rebuild when he got let go from the company that same year. Cody Rhodes spearheaded the formation of AEW alongside Tony Khan and The Elite, but his story was much the same beforehand. And on and on the list goes.
There's nothing wrong with independent contractors going elsewhere to earn a living, but when so many do so because they need to, it speaks volumes about where they've been before.
7. Gameshow Era NXT
A show so terrible that WWE have yet to find a way of glorifying any of it beyond Wade Barrett's jokes at his own career's expense on commentary, the original incarnation of NXT replaced WWE's version of ECW and somehow made the time slot even more unbearable.
It was classic monopoly-era arrogance from Vince McMahon at the time. For all its many, many faults, "WWECW" had become a reasonable quasi-developmental show in terms of how it soft-launched wrestlers by programming them with more experienced workers. The characters were less outlandish than CW-era 2020s NXT, but a lot of the actual performers didn't really have the acting chops anyway. If WWE was rolling a dice with the re-purposed initials, it was rolling a three most weeks with ECW. By comparison, the NXT gameshow dice got thrown off the table in a huff before the game started and never picked back up.
To call it dysfunctional would be an understatement. Wrestlers were given a host of games, tasks and other non-wrestling related activities to do in order to prove their readiness for life as a WWE Superstar. Said activities were typically awful, as were the performers forced to engage with them, but the in-house spin put the blame on the people rather than the format and everyone involved was left to rot. Main roster regulars installed as "Pros" often looked disgusted to have even been included, while the "rookies" never knew what unwritten rules they might be breaking because they were changed on the fly anyway. Matt Striker was insufferable presiding over it all, mostly because he was the kicked cat getting to lash out at the few select stars even lower on the totem pole.
A nadir for talent development, it remains a remarkable achievement and a credit to the best years of the black-and-gold brand that the very initials weren't mothballed with various other all-time lows.
6. The Ruthless Aggression Speech
The speech, not the era, because it wasn't an era.
"Ruthless Aggression" wasn't an era. Ruthless Aggression was the subject of a promo, some filler nonsense parroted by browbeaten commentators for a few weeks, the first hammy line John Cena ever delivered and finally the adopted term for the period where WWE got the F out. Unfortunately, they left every other gross Attitude Era shortcut in, and business circled the drain until PG saved the day.
The aforementioned promo itself was classic Vince McMahon disaster deflection, and all at the expense of the remaining talent that hadn't yet been completely buried by a catastrophic Invasion storyline and botched first attempt at a brand split. A middling attempt at tough love, this was McMahon outright screaming about how much his product sucked now, but that it wasn't his fault. No, rather than looking in the mirror at the only person in the entire company with any autonomy, he instead looked and Chris Nowinski and wondered aloud why he wasn't Stone Cold Steve Austin or The Rock.
Useless garbage that foreshadowed the many, many years to come, McMahon's meaningless drivel was one of the only times his obvious nostalgia for the late-1990s came out of his own mouth. Typically, he'd just force the talent to express it instead...
5. “The Gratitude Era”
Credit to Dolph Ziggler for coining "Gratitude Era", or at very least credit to him for wearily verbalising it when the mindset was effectively crushing the careers of him and all of his colleagues.
One of a generation of talents middled by Vince McMahon's failure to let go of the past, 'The Show Off' was only allowed to show ass if anybody from the 1998-2001 period rocked up for increasingly regular nostalgia editions of Raw and SmackDown during the rudderless 2010s.
This was star destruction in an era of star depletion into total contravention of star depletion. If you were from a hotter time period, you meant something. If you weren't, thanks for the 51 regular weeks of the year but it's once again time to sacrifice yourself at the altar of Attitude and be grateful for the opportunity. The messaging was loosely "WWE sucks now, especially compared to the show you love, and here's some fictional proof" on a never-ending loop.
One of the most telling moments from the early days of Triple H taking a tighter grip on the main roster creative by 2023 was the critically acclaimed Raw Is XXX 30th anniversary edition of the flagship. 'The Game' donned his DX colours for the night, but rather than decimating some gormless heel, they cowered in fear from the dangerous Gunther and his Imperium group.
4. The Constant Burial Of Top Babyfaces By Heel Authority Figures
When WCW closed out a phenomenally successful 1996 with the reveal of Senior Vice President and lead announcer Eric Bischoff as the newest member of the New World Order, the promotion inadvertently created the template for its own demise.
Heel boss nakedly abusing power was a fresh take on authority figures in wrestling - a bending of the rules that gave babyfaces even higher walls to climb narratively. Key to Bischoff's early success in was logical motivation - Bischoff wanted the respect his power was supposed to bring him, and was now using force and numbers to get it. Likewise, when Vince McMahon took on his Mr McMahon persona by the end of 1997, he was a man so determined to not have a Bret Hart-scale fallout again that he'd do anything to suppress the growth of a Stone Cold Steve Austin character that stood to give him just as many headaches.
Iconic, era-defining and industry-altering storylines. Followed, sadly, by bad photocopies of bad photocopies that didn't mercifully cease until the mid-2020s. Vince McMahon, at one point or another, hated and feuded with The Undertaker, Shawn Michaels and Roman Reigns. As a TV character, Raw General Manager Eric Bischoff had a massive problem with John Cena. The two men best at playing the roles a generation earlier had very literally lost the plot. Why were they against these money-makers exactly? Not least when, by now, we knew McMahon in particular was responsible for every push. Either they themselves were total idiots, or the wrestlers sucked. It could only be one or the other, both options were terrible for business, so the question simply went unanswered.
It trickled down to a pathetic extent too. Vickie Guerrero and Brad Maddox (amongst others) browbeaten in their middle-management positions on TV, almost always hated the goodies and almost always never really bothered to explore why that might be. As it turned out, they formed part of another self-own...
3. The Constant Burial Of GMs By Heel Authority Figures
Not to over-simplify a scenario with a well-worn take, but really how many pay-per-views were sold thanks to on-screen management squabbles as opposed to the more traditional tales of a wrestler trying to settle a grudge or win a big gold belt?
There are notable rule-proving exceptions, but "exception" remains key; a philosophy constantly misunderstood by Vince McMahon at his creative worst.
Less about the quality of the segments (they were invariably poor) or the shoddiness of the performances (the material was abysmal), the biggest downer about segments featuring various underlings being bollocked by those slightly higher up the food chain was how often they occurred, and how long they went on for. It started with McMahon himself gleefully bullying Eric Bischoff at every opportunity. Other examples included John Laurinaitis bossing Teddy Long around, Stephanie McMahon's cruelty towards Vickie Guerrero and just about everybody hating Brad Maddox. Often there were assistants who took more grief from their browbeaten bosses, providing another level for the muck to slide down towards.
Never was the chief authority figure in the situation blamed for their own negligence, nor did they ever draw the line between why the actions of a fictional GM were supposedly making the show so terrible. Upward blame was a total no-no, while a creatively finished McMahon was repeatedly saying the quiet part loud without realising he was confirming what we all knew.
2. Triple H Says John Cena Can’t Wrestle
Route One stuff from Triple H in a "reign of terror" epilogue, this infamous burial of John Cena as WWE's Champion and undisputed top star was a bizarre way to build a WrestleMania main event and an even wilder act of self-flagellation by the market leader a mere four years after the closure of World Championship Wrestling as its own viable competition.
Cena was the first true top guy of an era unlike any other in the company's past. Hulk Hogan was used as Vince McMahon's elevator pitch for his entire product as the territories were decimated in a hunt for global domination. Stone Cold Steve Austin (and to a lesser but still-significant extent The Rock) was the wrestler that helped overcome a rivalry with World Championship Wrestling and propel to WWE to even greater financial highs than the 1980s boom. The company was just about bust-proof by the time WCW closed its doors, but the wheels couldn't stop turning, and between 2001 and 2004, the need for the next Guy grew apparent even without true wrestling competition to work against.
John Cena was that Guy by the end of 2003, but his successful babyface ascension in 2005 had generated a vicious backlash by 2006. This time though, McMahon had no rival nor reason to listen to the boos or disdain. He was proven right to hold the wheel with the push in the end, but when a character with credit in the bank like 'The Game' validated near-unanimous takes about Cena's flaws ("excuse me if I'm not afraid of the guy whose one big move is pumping up his Reeboks", "you happen to not be a very good wrestler") it asked much larger questions about what exactly 'Big Match John' was even 'The Champ' of.
1. NXT’s Golden Era
WWE NXT - the developmental brand designed to feed the main roster monster by the time Triple H up and moved the initials to Full Sail University in Orlando Florida - rarely made money, often struggled to crack the top 10 of most-viewed shows on the WWE Network, and, before an aggressive 2021 retooling, ultimately became little more than a sacrificial lamb to the slaughter when All Elite Wrestling launched in 2019.
And yet it remains a beloved chapter point in the hearts and minds of many a millennial fan. With the 2013-2019 (and particularly 2014-2016) run of the show, Paul Levesque very carefully and competently booked a one hour weekly wrestling show that kept continuity, booked heels and babyfaces in compelling programmes, protected the integrity of its titles and titleholders, and took countless names from a multitude of sources and made them beloved within a system that was fundamentally the sort of wrestling WWE was meant to be, rather than the patched-up zombified version being peddled by an increasingly megalomaniacal Vince McMahon on Raw and SmackDown.
The difference was stark enough for NXT to almost feel like a protest vote by certain fans, despite never shying away from the fact it was a WWE property. It spoke to how far the top shows had fallen that this super-indie operating out of a Floridian university filming space was able not just to run arenas on the weekends of major pay-per-views, but steal every conversation and bit of praise too.
By making a version of WWE so clearly better than the main show but also one that couldn't win a wrestling war, Triple H effectively signed his own corporate death warrant before unforeseen and unexpected circumstances propelled him back into the hot-seat.