10 Best Newcastle United Debuts Ever

Jonjo Shelvey just joined a very talented bunch.

They say changing the personnel of a beleaguered team can often be the final nail in their coffin: the destabilisation of the dressing room can be a fatal blow that actually sets the team back. But Newcastle have once again had to twist in the January window after a disappointing first half of the season, which has seen them trapped in and around the bottom three for the majority of the term. They've already spent an impressive amount in bringing in Jonjo Shelvey and Henri Saivet and fans will be looking for more. When and if they come in, the club will no doubt be hoping for an impact similar to the arrival of Sir Bobby Robson in 1999 and his emphatic reinvigoration of the team, rather than the impact of signing David Batty in 1996. Luckily, there's a long history of new players making stunning debuts for the Toon, from beyond even the Premier League years. So for all the concerns over players needing time to gel and the call for experience, we should remember that several of the best Magpies debuts - including a very brief cameo by Tino Asprilla - were incredible no matter how used to English football the players in question were. With Jonjo Shelvey's brilliant bow against West Ham fresh in the memory, it's time to explore the greatest first appearances by new Toon players over the years...

10. Papiss Cisse

Vs Aston Villa (5th February 2012) It feels like decades ago now, but the signing of Papiss Cisse just under four years ago was a hugely impactful moment in Newcastle's recent history. Slotting into the front three alongside Demba Ba and Hatem Ben Arfa, the Senegalese striker was an immediate success, scoring for fun - including some unbelievable hits - as Newcastle sprinted to a 5th place finish. He started with a bang too, coming off the bench against Aston Villa after just 14 minutes when Leon Best went off injured. It wasn't exactly an eye-catching game, in all honesty, but Cisse showed the first glimpse of what he'd offer over the remainder of that incredible season by taking Jonas Gutierrez's early cross down with his chest and thumping a half volley into the top corner. Did It Last? For that season, undoubtedly, but the rumoured complaints in the summer of Demba Ba - unhappy with playing out wide - forced Cisse back into a front two and turned Ben Arfa into an unthinkable scapegoat. Thanks Pardew. Since then, Cisse has scored 36 goals in 109 appearances for the club - many of which have been absolute rakers - but his form has been patchy and wrong-headed tactics have left him isolated and frustrated too often. He came to Newcastle an instinctive genius and had it taught out of him by Pardew's idiotic training regimes.

9. Cheick Tiote

V Everton (18th September 2010) Back when he signed from Twente for the impressively modest sum of £3.5m, it looked like Newcastle had signed an absolute steal of an enforcer. He was strong, terrifying and composed on the ball, and with more creative players around him, he could and should have gone on to form the foundation of a great team. That much was clear immediately from his debut against Everton following his move in August. He managed an incredible 100% pass completion rate, from 64 passes, made two interceptions and completed all five tackles he attempted. Shockingly (for anyone who has witnessed his shooting since), he also got his only shot on target. So that's three 100% ratings in one match. Did It Last? For the first two years, Tiote was a colossus - albeit with a frustrating knack for getting booked - but as persistent rumours rose that he wanted a big money move elsewhere, his form faded unless playing against the big boys, and his yellow card rate became the only thing close to 100%. He is undoubtedly a talented defensive midfielder, but it says a lot about him that any great performance is met with suggestions that he's "rolling back the years".

8. Jonas Gutierrez

V Manchester United (17th August 2008) Another player who laughed in the face of Newcastle fans' odd fetish for "proven Premier League experience", Jonas was signed from Mallorca and faced the admirable task of facing Manchester United on his debut. Brilliantly, he flourished. He famously impressed the fans as his side earned a point against the Champions with a 1-1 draw, and earned himself the tag of Alan Hansen's most impressive debutant of that opening day of the season. That's no small feat. Did It Last? In that first season Gutierrez was a solid enough player, but his assist rate in Spain was noticeably absent, and fans didn't get to see the famous Spider-Man mask celebration nearly enough times. None of that was his fault, as he played with a group of disaffected, badly managed players who looked like they'd accepted relegation long before it was ever a certainty. Since then he's grown to cult status, scoring some key goals and earning himself a reputation as a grafter. Whether you loved him as a player or not, his personal triumph over cancer - and poisonous club politics - and his relegation-battling goal against West Ham in 2015 have cemented him as a Magpies hero.

7. Les Ferdinand

V Coventry City (19th August 1995) After proving to be one of QPR's most talented players (along with Trevor Sinclair), Kevin Keegan brought Sir Les to St James Park as part of a busy summer that also saw the arrivals of David Ginola, Warren Barton and Shaka Hislop. He was an immediate success and went on to form two stunningly successful partnerships upfront, first with Peter Beardsley and then with Alan Shearer. His debut was a fairly easy affair: both Rob Lee and Beardsley had scored already before Lee played a delightful ball through to Ferdinand in the 83rd minute who rounded the keeper and finished expertly. It was a signed of exciting things to come. Did It Last? Ferdinand is one of the biggest ones that got away too quickly in Newcastle history. That season he scored an incredible 29 goals, and the next he took himself to the 50 mark (41 in the league) in just 81 games, picking up two league runners-up medals in the process. He was and is a legend, and the idea that he was sold after only two seasons is still a kick in the gut.

6. Georginio Wijnaldum

V Southampton (9th August 2015) Signed in the summer of 2015 for an eye-catching figure with glowing endorsements from Dutch pundits and PSV's captain's armband to back him up, Gini Wijnaldum has proved already to be one of Graham Carr's more welcome signings. He's scored a huge number of goals for a midfielder in a struggling side, and his ability on the ball was evident from his first competitive game in black and white against a talented Southampton side. He was excellent on the ball, retaining possession and passing beautifully and he made the headlines with a debut-capping goal to become the seventh Newcastle player to score on their Premier League debut at St James Park. His header from Gabriel Obertan's incredible cross was the best moment of the game. Did It Last? In a mostly terrible season, Gini has so far proved a revelation. Even when the team's performance has meant he has taken a back seat to action, his touch and vision have proved sublime. With Jonjo Shelvey and Henri Saivet hopefully now changing the make-up of the midfield and an agenda to play him in his more successful number 10 role, we could now see even more from the supremely talented Dutchman.

5. Jonjo Shelvey

V West Ham (16th Jan 2016) Some eye-brows were raised when Newcastle brought the enigmatic but temperamental Englishman from Swansea City just a few days after his performance against Oxford City in the cup went viral, but he is clearly a prodigiously talented player. Having promised he'd give 100%, the exciting prospect - still only 23 - lit up his debut against fifth place West Ham, looking classy on the ball, tenacious in the talent and with an eye for a creative pass that has been conspicuously absent from Newcastle's recent teams. Not only did he manage 92% passing accuracy, he also won 3 of his 5 attempted tackles (another of which was incorrectly flagged as a foul) and played a creative part in both goals. Few who were there will have ever seen as stunning a pass as he laid on for Daryl Janmaat to set up Gini Wijnaldum for his goal, either. Did It Last? Who knows, but let's all hope so. He looks like one of those players who could be as good as he wants to be.

4. Kevin Keegan

V QPR (28th August 1982) To paraphrase Moneyball, it's hard not to get romantic about football. After winning the European Footballer Of The Year award twice and starring in Liverpool and Hamburg, Kevin Keegan made a spiritual homecoming, giving up his last professional football contract to a struggling Newcastle United side who needed confidence and star power. They got that in spades, starting immediately with Keegan's debut against QPR in 1982, which saw almost 40,000 people inside St James Park to see him just months after the crowds hit as low as 9,419. He was already a hero by virtue of his decision to sign, but he made himself an even bigger one by scoring in front of the Gallowgate against the Londoners, who went on to win the league as Newcastle finished 5th. Did It Last? As a player, Keegan was the shot in the arm the Magpies needed to get out of the second division at the end of his second year. And while his time in black and white was frustratingly short, he was so instrumental in dragging them back to top flight football with 48 goals in 78 games that his hero status was always assured. Obviously what he did next also helped.

3. Tim Krul

V Palermo (2nd November 2006) Having signed from ADO Den Haag at the age of just 17 years old, Tim Krul found himself thrown in at the deep end just a year later when injuries to both Shay Given and Steve Harper forced him into the team for the UEFA Cup tie against Palermo. The Italians - not doubt buoyed by his appearance - were stunned when the teenager pulled off two stunning saves to keep a clean sheet and earn himself the game's plaudits. His shot-stopping ability was there for all to see, and it was obvious Newcastle had unearthed a gem. Did It Last? Having only been brought in as cover, Krul found himself down the pecking order again after injuring himself in the warm-up to the return leg against Palermo, and went out on loan to Falkirk and Carlisle before Shay Given's departure and Newcastle's relegation pushed him first to back-up and then to number one. He's been there since - with stints out injured breaking up his command of the shirt - and while there are questions over his distribution and occasionally his decision-making, he is a hugely talented 'keeper who Newcastle would do well to keep hold of. Inevitably, he's also one of the club's most saleable commodities, so his future remains to be seen.

2. Duncan Ferguson

V Wimbledon (28th November 1998) After the ludicrous waste of money that was Stephane Guivarc'h was somehow sold to Rangers, Ruud Gullit realised he needed another striker and brought in Scottish wildcard Duncan Ferguson from his beloved Everton. He wasn't exactly thrilled to leave, but he didn't show any lack of effort in his debut against Wimbledon at St James Park that November. The big Scot was explosive up front alongside the mostly ineffectual Andrea Andersson, scoring two goals with the game poised at 1-1 to emphatically take the points. His first came in the 59th minute and the follow up came in injury time at the end of the game. He looked some signing. Did It Last? Unfortunately, Ferguson's unhappiness at leaving Everton came out in some of his performances, and though he has become a cult figure at the club (who was unfairly dropped alongside Alan Shearer by Gullit), he scored only 8 goals in 30 games and saw his time at Newcastle ravaged by injuries before Sir Bobby Robson sent him back to Everton. He could have been great, but his injury record was just too poor.

1. Mick Quinn

V Leeds United (August 19th 1989) There's a good reason that Scouse striker Mick Quinn is talked about in the same breaths as Alan Shearer, Jackie Milburn and Supermac from some Newcastle fans who know how to correctly value footballers: he knew, effortlessly, how to score a goal. He might not have been the most elegant of strikers, but the mighty Quinn was lethal in the box and a powerful handful for opposition defenders who had no answer to his movement or tenacity. That much was clear from his debut, when he scored 4 goals to put Leeds to the sword at St. James Park and earned himself instant hero status among Newcastle fans. Did It Last? That season, Quinn scored 34 league goals (and 39 in total) as Newcastle lost in the play-offs to Sunderland, and followed it up the next year with 20 as the club slumped to mediocrity and a 10th place finish. The following year he was out for three months injured and managed only 7 goals in 20 games as the Magpies survived relegation by the skin of their teeth, and his career at Newcastle was all but over when he clashed with Kevin Keegan and fell down the pecking order. But even with that fragmented time at the club, the man affectionately known as Sumo scored 59 goals in 115 performances, and he deserves the label of greatest Newcastle debutant ever. Which other notable Newcastle United debuts do you think belong on this list? Share your own favourites below.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.