10 Newcastle Rejects Who Got A Second Chance

Who says you should never go back?

They say you should never go back, and it seems that the mantra hangs high in Alan Pardew's Newcastle office. Very rare are the moments when the manager admits fallibility, or sufficiently accepts blame, and even rarer are the times he changes his mind on any of the decisions he has made as manager. Tactically as well as personally, he is a stubborn manager, and while commitment and fortitude can be applauded in successful managers, when things are going bad, there are inevitable calls for the former West Ham boss to change his approach. To his credit, he has already given one written-off player a second chance this season, and fans will inevitably hope he does again. As Pardew consciously ignores calls to give both Hatem Ben Arfa and Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa a second chance at the club and not let them join their loan clubs permanently, we look back at the players at Newcastle who survived being dropped, sold or unfancied to get a second chance in black and white. And unfortunately for some fans of Ben Arfa, not all of those second chances were a good idea...

10. Rob Lee

When Ruud Gullit dropped Newcastle legend Rob Lee, conspiracy theorists lined up to suggest he was the victim of the Dutchman's committed agenda to destroy Alan Shearer. As the England captain's friend, Lee would inevitably be in the firing line. But in truth - according to Lee himself - he and Gullit clashed on how the team should be run, and he was dropped for standing up to the manager. That saw him cast off without a squad number, and forced to train with the kids to the astonishment of the fans.
"At the start I thought Ruud liked me, we seemed to get on, but he didn't like being disagreed with and, as captain, my job was to put forward the players' viewpoint. By the end, he didn't speak to me at all. He didn't want me anywhere near the training ground."
Ultimately, thankfully Gullit walked away and Sir Bobby Robson reinstated Lee, who responded by putting in performances that made him a strong contender for player of the season. Which goes to show exactly what Gullit knew about Newcastle.

9. Shola Ameobi

The fact that Shola Ameobi managed to get to almost 400 appearances for Newcastle is a sour of no end of embarrassment to his most vocal critics, but if Kevin Keegan had remained at the club, the Nigerian Geordie would never have stayed. Over the course of his 19 year association with the club, only Sam Allardyce and Keegan seemed to realise that Shola wasn't that great, and it was the latter who tried hardest to get rid of him. First he sent him on loan to Stoke, who decided against permanently signing him after 6 unimpressive games, and then he only failed to sell him to Ipswich because he failed a medical. Had Keegan stayed, it's clear Shola would have gone, but thanks to the former manager walking out, Ameobi was given a stay of execution and managed to stick around for almost 6 more years.

8. Lee Clark

Football can be a game of massive regrets, and Lee Clark is a particularly good poster boy for that fact having admitted that his decision to wear an SMB t-shirt while playing for Sunderland was his biggest regret. For their part, Newcastle should have regretted putting him in that position in the first place, as he should never have been sold to Sunderland. It was his removal from the first team in 1996 and the signing of David Batty that cost Newcastle the league (not the signing of Tino Asprilla), and the decision to get rid of him was a ridiculous one. Clark should have stayed in the first team, and Newcastle might well have won the league, but instead after 7 years at the club he was let go. Eight years later, he returned at the age of 33, with unfinished business to settle and in that second period, as player-coach, played 22 times (thanks in part to Nicky Butt's lack of form) before leaving again in 2006.

7. Nile Ranger

In hindsight, the decision to sign Nile Ranger at all has to be viewed as a disaster: he was a source of way too much controversy and never repeated his youth team form and potential in the first-team, throwing away opportunities thanks to a bad attitude and poor off-field decisions. By 2011, Ranger was appearing in the front of newspapers far more than he was in the back pages, and he was rightly sent out on loan - first to Barnsley and then to Sheff Wed - but both times he returned to the club. At that stage, his contract should have been ripped up, but Newcastle persisted and he was unthinkably handed 2 first team appearances in 2012/13 to the annoyance of most Newcastle fans. Thankfully the second chance proved short-lived and he was released in March 2013 after more scandal.

6. Joey Barton

Having squared up to Alan Shearer, calling him a terrible manager and a pr*ck and openly admitting to despising him, it's not surprising that Joey Barton hasn't always been a beloved figure at Newcastle. During the relegation season, the former Man City midfielder clashed with caretaker manager Alan Shearer and Ian Dowie after being sent off against Liverpool, and Shearer admitted it was a mistake to have returned him to the first team. He was suspended indefinitely by the club and looked to be on his way to Blackburn. But then, as beggars can't be choosers, Barton was returned to the first team in the Championship and though he was injured for most of the season, he played a big part in the first-team throughout the 2010-11 season, despite Shearer's angry criticism. Thanks to some all-action displays and a refusal to lie down, Barton won the fans back, but he ruffled a few too many feathers and found himself basically given away to QPR.

5. Nicky Butt

When the former Man Utd player was signed by Sir Bobby Robson, he was seen as the ideal solution to replacing Gary Speed, who had just moved on to Bolton. His experience looked like a massive boost to a relatively young squad, and he had enjoyed a pick up in form towards the end of his Man Utd career, before handing in a transfer request. Unfortunately for Butt, his first season at Newcastle was pretty abysmal as a severe drop in form and injuries saw him replaced in January 2005 by Amdy Faye (smart move, Mr Souness). From there, Butt was deemed surplus to requirements by Souness, who moved him out on loan to Birmingham, months after fans had turned on him for his performance in the 2005 FA Cup semi-final against his former team. A year later though Birmingham were relegated and Butt returned, defying expectations that he would be sold to become a more key member of Newcastle's squad under Glenn Roeder and beyond. And while he didn't play a major part in the Championship season, as club captain his experience was vital to building morale and unity.

4. Alessandro Pistone

Rob Lee wasn't the only player to be cast of when Ruud Gullit took over at Newcastle: having been injured towards the end of Kenny Dalglish's tenure, Alessandro Pistone returned to fitness to find he wasn't wanted by the Scotsman's replacement:
"Ruud Gullit was very different, very arrogant. When he started here he already had a fixed idea about me and, whatever I did, I could not change it. It did not matter if you were a good player; if he did not like you, you had no chance. Look what he did to Rob Lee."
He was frozen out, and blanked by the manager and wasn't given a squad number, as the manager flatly refused to tell him why he had been dropped.
"Then I was told to train with the reserves. Gullit knew that in Italy you only go with the reserves if you have done something wrong; it is a disciplinary measure. I had done nothing wrong."
But then against the odds, when Gullit walked out, Pistone was restored to the first team by Bobby Robson and became a first-team regular. He wasn't the best player, but he didn't deserve the treatment he endured at Gullit's hands.

3. Andy Carroll

Despite making the club £35m in transfer fees, and being linked to a return to the club almost every six months since, if it wasn't for the interference of one legendary scout and a Newcastle coach, he would never have had a chance to play for the club's first team. The scout was Peter Kirkley - a legend at Wallsend Boys Club - who had been head of youth recruitment at Newcastle. As the club seriously considered whether Carroll - then a winger - was good enough, Kirkley and Vince Hutton fought to keep him, and he was given a second chance as Kirkley remembered:
"A lot of people didn't want him to stay. It got to the stage in his Under 14 year when the coaches still wanted him out. He looked ungainly and untidy. I think that is what it was. For two or three years that was going on, the coaches didn't fancy him" "The day his mam and dad went in with him to find out his future, he was expecting to be released. He was 14 and he thought it would be bad news, they all did."
Were it not for him and Hutton, Carroll might never have made it.

2. Alan Shearer

Alan Shearer was legitimately rejected by Newcastle once, and looked on the verge of leaving the club another time thanks to the misguided opinion of one of his managers. And both times he bounced back to cement his position as a legend of the club. The first rejection came when the Wallsend Boys Club striker was invited to Newcastle for a trial, and someone unthinkably put him in goal. This was despite his winning a Newcastle City Schools tournament at St. James' Park. Inevitably, he didn't make the cut. But then, having lit up both Southampton and Blackburn, Shearer got his chance to show that decision up for the idiocy it was. Sadly, when Ruud Gullit joined the club, he came with an agenda to strip Shearer down, believing his perceived arrogance to be toxic for the club and his power dangerous. That led to an infamous dropping, and had Gullit stayed around, you have to feel that Shearer would have been further out in the cold. Thankfully, common sense prevailed, Gullit left and Shearer was returned, rightfully to the first team.

1. Gabriel Obertan

Of all of the second chances given to Newcastle players, the revival of Gabriel Obertan this season has been the most shocking, and if it lasts, will be a rare 2014 success story for Alan Pardew. In the past two years, the Frenchman had played only 5 games for the Magpies, and looked to be top of the scrap heap in the summer, with his only saving grace being a lack of suitors. He was roundly hated by fans, booed onto the pitch and cast as a clown. But then, thanks to a couple of impressive cameos, the former Man Utd man was given the most unlikely of second chances and his manager threw his weight behind the player. For him to go from unwanted to "breathtaking" in the eyes of his manager has been astonishing, and long may it continue. Precedent, unfortunately suggests that it may not. Which other Newcastle players deserved a second chance? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.