10 Players Newcastle Gave Up On Too Soon

NUFC have too often dispensed of talented players far too soon.

As the days tick down towards the close of the 2015 summer transfer window it looks likely that Newcastle United will have discarded another talented player without really giving them an extended opportunity to impress on Tyneside by the time it shuts. Remy Cabella signed from Montpellier for a fee somewhere in the region of £12 million last summer to much fanfare having just scored 14 goals in 37 Ligue 1 games for the French side the previous season, yet he looks set to depart St James' Park in the coming days after netting just once in 34 appearances in black and white. Florian Thauvin, a player Newcastle's chief scout Graham Carr has courted for years, looks set to take Cabella's place in the Magpies squad, with Steve McClaren seemingly having decided that he would prefer a more direct winger to supply fellow summer signing Aleksandar Mitrovic, rather than a playmaker. Cabella has shown flashes of brilliance during his time at Newcastle - including a magnificent goal at Hull City and promising displays against Chelsea and Arsenal - but all-too fleetingly. The four-cap France international has also been accused of being too lightweight, and of failing to make an impact. Yet it seems harsh to have written Cabella off after only one campaign - although he is not the first player Newcastle have done that to, and doubtless he will not be the last (admittedly, however, all of these come with the benefit of hindsight). Here, WhatCulture.com/NUFC look at 10 players Newcastle United gave up on too soon.

10. Jon Dahl Tomasson

Jon Dahl Tomasson managed to claim six major trophies throughout his career - including the UEFA Champions League, the UEFA Cup, as well as the Serie A, Eredivisie and Bundesliga titles - yet the Dane was discarded after just a solitary season on Tyneside. True all of those trophies arrived during his post-NUFC career, but Tomasson's talent was undoubtedly wasted at Newcastle. After arriving from Heerenveen in the summer of 1997, Tomasson made 35 appearances for the Magpies but netted just four times. A serious injury to Alan Shearer stunted the Dane's progress, as he was asked to play regularly as a striker rather than in his favoured position as an attacking-midfielder or No 10. Newcastle tumbling from being title contenders to mid-table also-rans did not help Tomasson's cause either, and he was allowed to leave for Feyenoord in 1998 where, after being restored to an attacking-midfield berth, he claimed the Eredivisie during his first season. Tomasson also went on to play for AC Milan, VfB Stuttgart and Villarreal, finishing with a career club record of 180 strikes in 450 league games. With 52 goals from a staggering 112 Denmark caps too, Tomasson's class was undoubted - and Newcastle missed out on his best years by discarding him too quickly.

9. Stephen Ireland

Perhaps a difficult one to justify, admittedly, but Stephen Ireland proved last weekend with a brilliant cameo performance off the bench for Stoke City - when he played a part in both their goals against Tottenham Hotspur - that, when he is at his best, he really is a decent Premier League midfielder. Having impressed at Manchester City, where he came up through the youth ranks, the former Republic of Ireland international moved to Aston Villa in 2010. Just six months later though, Newcastle took the attacking-midfielder on loan to St James' Park. Due to injury and lack of form, Ireland made just two appearances for the Magpies before returning to Villa Park - and he has since found his way to the Britannia Stadium. Although a controversial character who is frustratingly inconsistent, Ireland is still only 28 and could have been an additional option for Newcastle United. It could, and probably would, still have ended in tears if he had stayed on Tyneside for longer, but the Magpies decided too quickly that they did not want to keep Ireland.

8. Louis Saha

This one is with the benefit of hindsight certainly - as with most if not all of these entries - but Louis Saha's first experience in England was not with Fulham or Manchester United, it was in fact with Newcastle. Having arrived on loan from Metz midway through the 1998-99 campaign, the French forward managed just two goals in 12 games. With the Magpies deciding not to take up the option to sign Saha, he returned to Metz and then moved to Fulham a year later - where he bagged 63 goals in 142 games. Such form convinced Man Utd to take him to Old Trafford, and 42 goals in 124 appearances there proved his class. Saha also had successful spells at Everton and Tottenham Hotspur, before unhappy moves to Sunderland and Lazio, but Newcastle missed out on having a top Premier League striker. True Saha was raw when he first arrived at Newcastle and came up through the divisions with Fulham, but it could have been on Tyneside that his powers were nurtured and allowed to blossom, and not in west London.

7. Emre

Signed from Inter Milan in 2005, Emre arrived in Newcastle with the reputation of being a diminutive but classy midfielder. During three seasons at St James' Park, the Turkish international regularly succumbed to injury but he still managed 82 appearances and six goals, including a magnificent free-kick winner in a 3-2 Tyne-Wear derby victory over Sunderland in his first campaign. Although that goal immediately gave Emre a place in Geordie folklore, he was often labelled as being too small and not physical enough for the Premier League. By 2008, his time on Tyneside appeared to be coming to an end and he moved to Fenerbahce, before heading to Atletico Madrid, and he is now at Istanbul Basaksehir FK. Another player who won a host of trophies both before and after his Newcastle career, Emre has also been capped 94 times by Turkey. He may be small, but Emre is so technically gifted that, if he had been played in the correct system, he could have been an even bigger success in the North East.

6. Aaron Hughes

Aaron Hughes had played in the Newcastle first team for eight full seasons when he was bizarrely shipped out to Aston Villa for just £1 million in May 2005, with Graeme Souness appearing to have completely lost faith in the reliable and versatile defender. A player who had represented the club in the Champions League and been a member of Sir Bobby Robson's fine early-2000s side, Hughes was versatile and was a solid performer at both full-back and centre-back. After impressing during two years at Villa Park, Hughes then joined Fulham in 2007 - and went on to become a stalwart at centre-back for seven years for the west London club. While Newcastle were struggling to find a reliable centre-back over the past 10 years, a player they let leave for £1 million was regularly performing to a high level at other Premier League sides. It was a bizarre decision to let the 96-cap Northern Ireland international leave - and they have paid the price for it over the past decade.

5. Giuseppe Rossi

On first viewing this one may seem unusual, but it was not Rossi's talent that was in question - it was the way in which he was used by the Magpies. The Manchester United youngster was signed on a six-month loan deal in August 2006 yet he made just 13 appearances and scored only once. A terrible return for a forward, no doubt, but the Italian was far-too regularly used off the bench or played out wide on Tyneside. For a player who has gone on to receive 30 Italy Caps and score 79 league goals for Parma, Villarreal and Fiorentina to get so little gametime at St James' Park is just bizarre - although again, admittedly, this is with the benefit of hindsight. Rossi's solitary Toon goal came in a League Cup tie against Portsmouth at St James' Park and he was mainly used out wide by Glenn Roeder - meaning he was unable to really showcase his talents. The Magpies should have asked to take Rossi on loan once again for the following season to see if he could cut it in the Premier League and, if he still hadn't impressed by then, they would have been fully justified in cutting their losses. One of the many examples of somebody not being given a fair crack of the whip on Tyneside.

4. Abdoulaye Faye

A solid Premier League centre-back is all that Abdoulaye Faye may have been, yet Newcastle United decided to dispense with him after only a season, in spite of their regular defensive deficiencies over the past decade. The Magpies have needed a sturdy if unspectacular presence at the heart of their defence for far too long, and Faye could have at the very least provided cover to two first-choice centre-backs. Faye was a favourite of Sam Allardyce - which may have gone a long way towards tarnishing his reputation somewhat unfairly on Tyneside - and followed the former West Ham United boss to Newcastle from Bolton Wanderers in the summer of 2007. His 24 appearances for the Magpies brought a number of decent displays - and, yes, a couple of horror shows - but Kevin Keegan allowed the defender to depart for newly-promoted Stoke City in 2008. After 81 further Premier League appearances for the Potters where, under Tony Pulis' management, he helped captain Stoke into becoming a mid-table top-flight side, Faye then moved to West Ham and Hull City. Newcastle wouldn't have exactly been pulling up trees with Faye in their ranks for a longer period, but they would have at least had a reliable if unspectacular centre-back to call upon when necessary.

3. Fraser Forster

To be fair to the club, when Newcastle allowed Fraser Forster to move to Celtic permanently for £2 million in 2012, they had an array of goalkeeping talent in their ranks - with Steve Harper still going strong and Tim Krul beginning to prove his class as a Premier League stopper. However, since leaving the Magpies, Forster has become a £10 million player and an England international - and he has kept an incredible 118 clean sheets in 234 matches, more than one every other game. With Krul having struggled for form last season, Harper having left, Rob Elliot still not looking entirely convincing, and Karl Darlow yet to prove himself at Premier League level, Newcastle could well wish they still had Forster on their books. Forster is still only 27 and could have been a Newcastle keeper for years to come - especially seeing as he was born in the North East. And, what's more, Forster is 6ft 7in and a towering presence - something that is invaluable in a goalkeeper. This is just another case of local talent being allowed to blossom elsewhere.

2. Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa

Newcastle allowed Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa to depart on loan for the 2014-15 season to Roma - a deal which soon turned into a permanent £5.5 million transfer - despite the fact they had just three out-and-out centre-backs in the squad at the time. Yanga-Mbiwa struggled during his time on Tyneside, no doubt, but he was often played out of position - and he did captain Montpellier to the Ligue 1 title, so he does have some class. While Newcastle were struggling to send out a back four comprised entirely of players in their correct positions during the 2014-15 season, Yanga-Mbiwa was playing well in the Champions League with Roma and helping them to claim second spot in Serie A. The Magpies may regret signing Yanga-Mbiwa for £8.5 million in the first place, considering he was chief scout Graham Carr's pick and Alan Pardew seemed like he simply didn't fancy him, but the subsequent sale was also premature. A France international, Yanga-Mbiwa has since moved to Lyon this summer and will likely grace Europe's premier competition once more. He should have been nurtured to become Fabricio Coloccini's successor - as, admittedly, they struggled to play alongside one another - but instead he was given up on.

1. Hugo Viana

Signed from Sporting Lisbon in the summer of 2002 for £8.5 million, Hugo Viana had already claimed the Portugese title during his debut season and had earned the Young European Football of the Year award, so he arrived at Newcastle United as a 19-year-old of who big things were expected. Yet, just two seasons later, Viana had returned to Sporting on loan having scored just two goals in 56 appearances as Sir Bobby Robson struggled to work out how to best utilise the talented midfielder. Technically brilliant and a player who is blessed with a magnificent eye for a pass, Viana has proven at the likes of Valencia and Sporting Braga that he is best suited to playing in the middle, and most often as a deep-lying playmaker. The 29-cap Portugal international is not the most mobile player in the world and struggles to beat a man, yet he was regularly deployed wide left or out of position at Newcastle by Robson, and he was accused of being too "lightweight" for the Premier League. Although he has never fulfilled the huge hype which surrounded his transfer to Newcastle in the first place, Viana could certainly have forged a decent career as part of the Magpies side if he had been deployed corrected. However, Newcastle cut their losses on Viana before that could ever be the case. For all the latest NUFC News, Views and Transfers make sure to follow WhatCulture.com/NUFC on Twitter and Facebook.

Contributor
Contributor

NUFC editor for WhatCulture.com/NUFC. History graduate (University of Edinburgh) and NCTJ-trained journalist. I love sports, hopelessly following Newcastle United and Newcastle Falcons. My pastimes include watching and attending sports matches religiously, reading spy books and sampling ales.