10 Players Nobody Expected Liverpool To Sign

An example of when managers think outside the box...

Liverpool have never been dullards in the transfer market. Under Rafa Benitez, they strived to sign as many players as they could, mostly from the continent, hoping for the best most of the time. Kenny Dalglish placed a lot of faith in young English talent, to his detriment in most cases admittedly. Brendan Rodgers has offered up a mixed bag of results in terms of transfer dealings, from luring Italian mavericks one moment to signing 32 year old Southampton forwards the next. The entertaining thing about being a Liverpool supporter is that they never know what they're going to get, and certainly not in terms of the transfer market. Their dealings are reflected in their topsy-turvy results - they can be brilliant one moment, and so frustrating the next. These are the players who nobody expected Liverpool to sign. Whether people thought the players were of too high a calibre for the club, not good enough, or simply not worth the trouble, there have always been eyebrow-raisers arriving at the Melwood training ground. Take a look at the ten Liverpool players who nobody expected them to sign - there's certainly a few shockers compiled in this list.

10. Peter Crouch

6ft 7in Peter Crouch spent the beginning of the 04/05 season serving as a third-choice striker for relegation-battling Southampton. He would end the season with a summer move to the champions of Europe. For the former Aston Villa bench-warmer, it was a dream turnaround for the hit-man. While his 16 goals for the south-coast outfit proved to be in vain, as Harry Redknapp€™s troops slipped into the second tier of English football, it was enough to grant a move to Rafa Benitez€™ Liverpool a month after their heroic exploits in Istanbul.
''I am thrilled to be joining a club as prestigious and successful as Liverpool. Once I heard of their interest in me, it was hard not to think about what it would be like to pull on the famous red shirt and play in front of the Kop.۪۪ - Peter Crouch, July 2005.
For the Reds€™ support, however, it might have been seen as something of an underwhelming signing move in the transfer market. How many European champions sign a player of the calibre of Crouch - a capable but limited player - as their marquee signing in the wake of their cup win? While it did take the target man 19 games to notch his first goal for the Reds, he managed to notch 42 goals in 134 appearances for Liverpool.

9. Craig Bellamy

It€™s usually a surprise when players rejoin sides, as one usually makes the assertion in their head that when an employee leaves, they have shut the door behind them forever. In the case of Craig Bellamy, however, he has gone through so many football clubs in the Premier League that he was bound to end up at one or two past employers before he pulled the curtain down on his career. He had enjoyed a decent first spell at Anfield in 2007, scoring seven league goals in 27 appearances, and notching a vital goal at the Nou Camp, but by the time he returned in 2011, he was 32 years old. Having fallen out of favour at Manchester City since Roberto Mancini assumed the reigns of control in December 2009, the Welshman had been courted by the likes of Spurs, Celtic and even hometown club Cardiff City, but nobody really envisaged that he would return for a second spell in Merseyside.
''I۪ve grown up with Kenny Dalglish, now to be signed by him is a massive honour. When Kenny took over, watching as a fan last season I got the buzz as well and it was great to see Liverpool end the season well. I۪m very happy. It۪s been a long couple of months, I had to be patient and believe something like this could happen.۪۪ - Craig Bellamy, August 2011.

8. Kolo Toure

As shown by the aforementioned example of Craig Bellamy, it€™s always surprising when Liverpool manage to bag a player from title-chasing Manchester City. In this case, however, it was for a whole host of reasons. In the summer of 2013, when Kolo Toure made the decision to move to Anfield on a two-year deal following the expiration of his contract at the Etihad Stadium, his reputation was in tatters. Having appeared sporadically for the Mancunian outfit since Vincent Kompany had been relocated from midfield to the centre of defence, the former Arsenal man looked a shadow of the player who had commanded a £16 million fee in 2009. Everybody knew that the player was surplus to requirements at City and would be leaving the club in the summer, but the predicted destination was somewhere in Greece, Turkey or the Middle-East - not a club with aspirations of a top four finish in the Premier League. It was certainly a move that raised more eyebrows than not, but looked a shrewd move after Toure€™s first month at Anfield, having managed to keep a steady head and produce some composed performances for the Reds. Of course, he would fail to keep the momentum going, and threw in a few calamitous errors throughout the season for good measure.

7. Joe Cole

They might have thought they had won the lottery in the summer of 2010, as they emerged top of the pile in the race to sign recently-released Chelsea winger Joe Cole. He was one of the most high-profile and expensive free agents in recent years, and was linked with a host of top clubs upon Chelsea€™s decision to toss him out of Stamford Bridge at the end of his contract. However, Chelsea clearly had foreseen his downfall in letting the stagnating winger go following the 2010 World Cup, with the likes of Arsenal and Spurs queuing up to wave hefty wage packets under the former West Ham winger€™s nose. Nobody could really have foreseen Cole ending up at Liverpool, even after Chelsea had parted ways with the £100 p/wk star, as the Reds had tumbled out of the Champions League places. Without the lure of Europe€™s elite competition, surely they had no chance of enticing the 28 year old.
''Last season was a very disappointing season for the club in every respect, culminating in a popular manager leaving. I would never want to dupe the Liverpool public by telling them all is rosy now because Joe Cole has signed.۪۪ - Roy Hodgson, July 2010.
Just as well, Roy, because things would get a whole lot worse, especially for him, before they got better at Anfield.

6. Rickie Lambert

With the club just having missed out on winning the league title for the first time in two decades, and with the future of the talismanic Luis Suarez remaining up in the air, one would have expected Brendan Rodgers to delve into the transfer market to bolster their ammunition with a proven European striker. So when boyhood fan Rickie Lambert came marching through the doors of Anfield in the first week of June, it proved a nice fairytale for a 32 year old who had worked his way up through the lower divisions, but as far as the Reds€™ prospects went, it looked a surprising move by Brendan Rodgers.
''I can۪t believe it. I۪ve loved this club all my life. I left here 17 years ago and I haven۪t stopped loving it since. I have always dreamt of playing for Liverpool, but I did kind of think the chance of playing for them had gone. I didn۪t think the chance would come. I۪ve been trying to keep it as low-key as possible, only telling close family. My mum and dad shed a few tears when I told them, my mum in particular.۪۪ - Rickie Lambert, June 2014.
Lambert was a capable striker for Southampton, but was he what was needed as far as Champions League hopefuls Liverpool were concerned? It was certainly a transfer which raised a few eyebrows, and put in motion the Saints€™ exodus.

5. Mario Balotelli

''I can categorically tell you that he will not be at Liverpool. I was asked the question about Balotelli and spoke about what a talent he is and excellent player he is. He is a wonderful player, but an AC Milan player. I just gave my opinion of him, but doesn۪t mean I will be signing him.۪۪ - Brendan Rodgers, August 2014.
It was a transfer that seemed so preposterous and ludicrous to consider that even the Liverpool manager was baulking at the prospect just weeks before the Italian maverick was presented to the media inside the Melwood training ground. When the talismanic emblem of Anfield was ruthlessly ripped out by the vulturous Barcelona in the aftermath of the third biting scandal, Liverpool were in the market for a top striker. England striker Daniel Sturridge was in a rich vein of form, but couldn€™t be relied to do it all on his own up top, and the jury was always going to be out with regards to the class of Rickie Lambert. When the news broke that Liverpool had agreed a fee of £16 million with AC Milan for the services of former Manchester City trouble-maker, the media had a field-day. Their favourite bad boy was returning to England, bringing with him skills, flair and entertaining antics which so endeared him to the British public during his first spell.
''This transfer represents outstanding value for the club and I think we have done a really smart piece of business here. I am looking forward to working with him and helping him learn more, improve and progress as a player. I۪m sure the supporters will make him feel very welcome.۪۪ - Mario Balotelli, August 2014.
So what changed your mind, Bren?

4. Robbie Keane

In February 2008, Robbie Keane stood up on the winners€™ podium at Wembley Stadium, drenched in sweat and adulation, holding aloft the Carling Cup that his six years at the club had culminated in. Having scored 117 goals for the club, the Irish national side€™s all-time record scorer looked set for the long haul at White Hart Lane, striving to win even more silverware for the North London outfit. Six months after an emotional speech to the Spurs faithful, during which he said as much, it all counted for nothing, as he held aloft a Liverpool scarf at the Melwood training ground. In a shock deal worth £20.3 million, Liverpool pounced for the former Wolves hit-man, with the 28 year old agreeing terms on a four-year contract worth around £80,000 p/wk. A prolific Premier League striker with a proven track record, it looked to be a sensible signing, if a little costly, with the Liverpool board effectively forcing boss Rafa Benitez to abandon attempts to sign Aston Villa captain Gareth Barry as a result.
''I would specifically like to thank chairman Daniel Levy for understanding that, as a fan, joining Liverpool is a lifelong dream of mine and one I couldn۪t let pass me by. I hope one day the Spurs fans, who have been brilliant to me, can understand this too.۪۪ - Robbie Keane, July 2008.
Keane and Spurs definitely did not seem like a marriage that could be broken up, but how could the Irishman turn down one of his many €˜dreams€™?

3. Fernando Morientes

During the 03/04 season, on-loan Fernando Morientes was one of the fearsome goal-poachers on the continent. With nine goals in 12 Champions League appearances, the Monaco forward€™s goals helped to knock out Deportivo la Coruna, parent club Real Madrid and Chelsea on the way to finishing runners-up to Jose Mourinho€™s FC Porto. At the close of the season, the Spanish international was instantly linked with a host of top clubs, with Real Madrid already readying bids for the likes of Michael Owen. This is why it came as such a shock when the ferocious goal-getter arrived in the Premier League, not with the Premier League€™s elite, but with Champions League-chasing Liverpool. Not only was the agreed fee of £6.3 million ridiculously low, considering the rumoured £20 million Arsenal bid that had been running through the media, but the fact that Liverpool were languishing behind cross-city rivals Everton in the race for the coveted fourth spot surely worked against them.
''I want to play and I had several offers, but I think the best for me and my family was Liverpool۪s. I am happy for that reason, but sad because it has been eight years here at Madrid and I will never forget them. This is a new stage in my life and I am excited about it.۪۪ - Fernando Morientes, January 2005.
As it happens, the Spanish international failed to settle at the club, scoring just 12 goals in 60 outings for the Merseyside outfit, before being shipped back to Spain after 18 pitiful months. Still, if nothing else, it was a morale-boosting signal of intent for the Reds during a difficult campaign.

2. Robbie Fowler

It was a transfer that simply did not make sense. Robbie Fowler, or 'God' as he was affectionately known by the Reds brigade, was a sensation for the Reds in his first spell at the club, banging in 171 goals during an eight-year spell in the first-team. One of the 'Spice Boys' at Anfield, Fowler was a celebrity at the club, heralded, worshipped and adored by the Kop. However, the former prolific hit-man has always maintained that he was forced out of the club by then-boss Gerard Houllier, who he accused of pressurising the local newspaper to use its' influence in swaying opinion of the local hero. Leaving the club in the summer of 2001 in a deal worth £12 million, the 26 year old would spend the next few years failing to replicate his blistering Anfield goal-scoring form at both Elland Road and then the City of Manchester Stadium. Having made just four Premier League appearances, and found the back of the net once before Christmas, it looked like the 30 year old's career was petering out in Manchester during the 05/06 season. Enter Rafa Benitez to make one local lad's dreams come true. ''Since I have left, deep down I have always wanted to come back and it has been a long time but I'm glad to say I'm back now. Leaving was probably one of my biggest regrets I have had in football. I'm chuffed to bits. I mean, I can't really believe it's happened again so I'm ecstatic to be honest.'' - Robbie Fowler, January 2006. The ageing forward wasn't the only one who had to rub their eyes in disbelief when news broke, with hundreds of Liverpudlian jaws hitting the floor when they learned of the Second Coming. The passionate Toxteth-born forward seemed to get a bit of urgency back into his play, finding the back of the net 12 more times over the next 18 months.

1. Andy Carroll

Andy Carroll will be lamenting this transfer until the day he dies, as his fortunes changed so drastically the moment he set foot in the helicopter that whisked him off to Melwood on the deadline day madness that was January 31st 2011. It was this extraordinary piece of business, conducted by a Liverpool board handed £50 million by Roman Abramovich in return for their talismanic Fernando Torres and tasked with replacing him with hours left on the clock. Whereas now, the public perception of Carroll is that he is an injury-plagued target-man with a woeful first choice, at Newcastle United he was seen as the club€™s heir apparent to Alan Shearer. With the north-east club refusing to budge on their statement that their number nine was €˜not for sale€™, it looked for all intents and purposes as though he would be staying on Tyneside, with bids from Spurs having been knocked back in the January transfer window.
''They can bid whatever they like. He is not for sale. I am going to say it one last time, he is not for sale.۪۪ - Alan Pardew, January 2011.
What the former West Ham boss probably was doing by issuing that statement was unintentionally goading those with money to spare, eager to shove Pardew€™s words right back down his throat. After all, every player has a price. Newcastle would then reject a huge £30 million bid from Liverpool on the final day of the transfer window - a decision that Mike Ashley would surely have rued for his remaining years, had Liverpool not returned with an improved offer of £35 million. Three years have passed now, and Carroll has since moved on, so it€™s fair to pass judgement on the transfer, and call it for what it was - a huge miscalculation on Liverpool€™s part. It was an act of sheer desperation as they frantically sought for the hottest young talent in the market. They didn€™t heed the fact that the 22 year old Geordie had only ever scored 14 top-flight goals in his career, or that he had but one international cap to his name. There was no thought for his off-field indiscretions, including several arrests, and a training ground altercation with team-mate Steven Taylor. There was no logic or reason to make him the eighth most expensive transfer of all time. It was transfers like this that raised questions regarding Kenny Dalglish€™ ability in the transfer market.

Contributor
Contributor

Recent Journalism & New Media graduate. Insatiable thirst for all things football, and hopes to break into the field of sports journalism in the near future. Have made a significantly insignificant playing career out of receiving several slaps around the head for not passing the ball.