10 Players Who Probably Regret Joining Leeds United

When Elland Road becomes Deadend Road.

bill paynter leeds
Jon Buckle/EMPICS Sport

Despite spending over a decade outside of the Premier League, Leeds United are still considered one of the biggest clubs in English football and most players would relish the opportunity to represent them at some point in their career.

However, while playing for the Yorkshire giants looks an attractive proposition on paper and anyone would be hard pushed to reject a transfer to Elland Road should the club show serious interest, it does not always work out for players who decide to make the switch.

Given the club's frequent changes in manager or ownership and the varying levels at which they have played their football, it is easy to see why players have been left regretting their decision to wear the famous white shirt but in some cases, some signings have just failed to live up to the hype and have paid the price for the rest of their career...

10. Paul Green

paul green leeds
© Simon Bellis/ZUMA Press/Corbis

Paul Green's four years at Derby County were spent competing for mid-table positions in the Championship table so it is difficult to dispute his decision to depart the Rams for Leeds United.

However, at a time when he was looking to make the next logical step to advance his career on both the domestic and international scene, his time at Leeds United was relatively short-lived and he has spent the past two years at Rotherham United.

The Republic of Ireland international would have had hopes of contributing to a playoff bid but as the team only mustered 13th position in his first campaign, Green found himself failing to replicate the form he had previously shown in the East Midlands.

He scored four goals in his first 14 games for the Lilywhites but he would not find the net again throughout the following year. Although he has never been prolific, this was one of the main reasons why he was farmed out on loaned to Ipswich Town and his last appearance for Leeds came on October 5 - nine months before he finally left Elland Road.


9. Anthony Elding

anthony elding
© Peter Fitzpatrick/Demotix/Corbis

Anthony Elding has had more clubs than Tiger Woods but his football career began to go on a downward spiral after he secured what would have been a dream move from Stockport County to Leeds United.

No-one can blame the forward for jumping at the opportunity to leave Edgeley Park for Elland Road and after scoring 26 goals in 52 games for Stockport, he was full of confidence.

However, the 26-year-old would score just one goal in nine games for Leeds before he was deemed surplus to requirements without ever being given a sustained run in the first team.

His one goal came off the bench against Cheltenham Town and he did not complete a game for Leeds, making just four starts before he was sold to Crewe Alexandra.

During his first six months at Gresty Road, he scored just one goal and was eventually shipped out to Lincoln City. Since that temporary move, he has made as many as 11 separate permanent or loan transfers.

Bizarrely, Elding was a success in the Hungarian Premier League with Ferencvaros in the 2009-10 but he would never enjoy another good spell in England and now competes in the League of Ireland Premier Division.


8. Seth Johnson

Italy's Gennaro Ivan Gattuso tangles with England's Seth Johnson
Jon Buckle/EMPICS Sport

At the turn of the Millennium, Seth Johnson was regarded as one of English football's brightest talents and he almost marked his England debut against Italy in 2000 with a goal with his very first touch.

Two impressive years with Derby County led to a big-money transfer to Leeds United but it is at Elland Road where the injury problems started that would eventually lead to retirement at the age of 28.

All was well in his first campaign until he suffered an injury at Chelsea and he was unable to enjoy a prolonged spell in the team as Leeds dropped down to the Championship and while he remained at the club for their first year back at the second tier, making just six appearances led to the Yorkshire giants allowing him to depart on a free transfer.

To his credit, Johnson resurrected his career back at Derby and helped them to promotion to the Premier League but his four years at Leeds were uncomfortable when you consider the wage he was receiving on the sidelines when the club were facing financial catastrophe and unrewarding given he would never play again in the top flight after a serious injury to his knee.


7. Darren Huckerby

darren huckerby
© Daniel R. Harris/Icon SMI/Corbis

After three excellent years at Coventry City, Darren Huckerby found himself targeted by a number of high-profile clubs and in the summer of 1999, he made the decision to join Leeds United.

The attacker would have had high hopes of helping the club build on their fourth-place finish in the standings the previous year but while Leeds would go on to become Champions League semi-finalists within two years, Huckerby spent much of the transition on the sidelines.

Despite costing a reported fee of £6m, Huckerby made just 14 starts in all competitions during his season-and-a-half at Elland Road. He made a further 43 appearances from the bench but it wasn't what he had in mind when he looked to take the next step of his career.

Huckerby did have a couple of positive moments - most notably a goal in the Champions League against Besiktas - but all in all, he endured a disastrous time in Yorkshire and would eventually be sold to Manchester City.

He would still enjoy a respectable stint in English football but his best form came at the second tier where he won the First Division title with both City and Norwich City.


6. Michael Duberry

michael duberry leeds
Adam Davy/EMPICS Sport

For four years, Michael Duberry was a first-team regular at Chelsea but during the 1998-99 campaign, he faced increasing competition in the centre of the Blues defence after the arrival of Marcel Desailly.

To his credit, Duberry still made 25 appearances in the Premier League and 33 in all competitions but at the age of 24 and with ambitions still lingering to represent England, he decided to take his chances elsewhere.

A transfer to Leeds United was, in theory, a progressive career move with David O'Leary beginning to build something special at Elland Road and Duberry still made a positive impact upon his arrival by helping Leeds to three wins at the start of the 1999-00 season.

However, injury restricted him to 16 appearances in all competitions and the same occurred the following year after regaining his place in the team as he helped Leeds beat AC Milan in the Champions League before missing the remainder of the season.

Duberry would only regain his place in the side when players began to leave due to their severe financial issues and with the defender unable to settle alongside a number of different partners at centre-back, Leeds would be relegated.

Stoke City would become his new home soon afterwards but he would only ever play 21 more times in the top flight.


5. Billy Paynter

bill paynter leeds
Jon Buckle/EMPICS Sport

During the 2009-10 season, Billy Paynter partnered Charlie Austin at Swindon Town and the pair joined forces to score 49 goals between them as the Robins almost secured promotion from League One.

Paynter had the option of extending his stay at the County Ground alongside Austin but while his strike partner continued at the third tier, Paynter made the leap to the Championship with Leeds United and it was a move that only brought disappointment.

An injury in pre-season delayed Paynter's debut but even though he would make his bow in October, it would take him until March to net his first goal for the club and that would remain his only effort in 23 outings in all competitions.

He made an appearance off the bench on the opening day of his second campaign but another injury would restrict his availability and after a goalless loan spell with Brighton & Hove Albion, he would score his only other two goals for Leeds against Peterborough United towards the end of the season.

In August 2012, the club would cut their losses and allow Paynter to join Doncaster Rovers on a free transfer after a period of just three goals and 11 starts in two years. Paynter helped Doncaster to promotion that season but he again failed in the Championship and was subsequently loaned out, leaving him with a combined record of three goals in 46 second-tier matches.


4. Michael Ricketts

Michael Ricketts, England
Mike Egerton/EMPICS Sport

The form of Michael Ricketts while he was plying his trade for Bolton Wanderers famously won him an England call-up but a big-money switch to Middlesbrough proved a disaster and when he was on the move again in 2004, he needed to find the right club to relaunch his career.

It soon became evident that Leeds United was not that club. The Lilywhites had just dropped down to the Championship and were looking to put together a squad to reclaim their place in the top flight, but while the season was disappointing for Leeds, it was a disaster for Ricketts.

In 22 league appearances that season, he failed to score a single goal and his only strike of the season came in a League Cup tie against Swindon Town. Even when he was subsequently loaned out to Stoke City, he made just one start and 10 substitute appearances without troubling the goalscoring charts.

It continued the sad demise of a forward who had rose to prominence at the Reebok Stadium and he spent the remainder of his career moving from club to club trying to recapture his form. Failure to do so led to his retirement at the age of 32.


3. Lee Sharpe

lee sharpe leeds
Simon Wilkinson/EMPICS Sport

There was no shame in losing his place in the Manchester United side to a young David Beckham but at the age of 25, Lee Sharpe needed to find a club where he could fulfil the potential he had shown at Old Trafford.

When he was made Leeds United's joint record signing in 1996, everything looked promising for Sharpe who also had ambitions for a return to the England squad but just a month after his arrival, the Yorkshire giants changed manager and George Graham replaced Howard Wilkinson.

Sharpe still played on a regular basis during his first campaign at Elland Road, scoring a total of six goals in 30 appearances in all competitions, but his performances were largely average at best and Graham was not getting the most out of him.

That may have been down to Graham's managerial style which did not focus on attacking intent - Leeds scored just 28 Premier League goals that season - or it was Sharpe's own doing but regardless, his second season would be decimated by a serious knee injury and that all but ended his time at the club.

From then onwards, Sharpe never recovered. He spent time at Sampdoria and Bradford City before ending his career at 32.


2. David Robertson

david robertson leeds
Matthew Ashton/EMPICS Sport

David Robertson spent six years winning trophy after trophy at Rangers but the success led to him requiring a new challenge and he opted to joined Leeds United in 1997.

The move was supposed to lead to the left-back spending his peak years at Elland Road but after a solid first year with the Lilywhites where he made 26 appearances in the Premier League, disaster struck as the defender suffered a string of injuries that kept him on the sidelines for three years.

He may well have sustained the same fitness issues had he remained at Ibrox but Robertson must wonder how many more trophies he could have earned if he had avoid the temptation of attempting to prove himself south of the border.

Robertson retired in 2001 before returning to represent Montrose while player/assistant manager at the Scottish club. However, after playing regularly at the start of the 2002-03 season, his career was ended for a second time when snapping an Achilles tendon in a game against Greenock Morton.


1. Tomas Brolin

thomas brolin leeds john beresford newcastle
John Giles/PA Archive/Press Association Images

Having starred for Parma between 1990 and 1995, Leeds United supporters thought that they were getting a new star when Tomas Brolin moved to Yorkshire but his time at Elland Road quickly descended into a farce.

His first couple of months were solid enough as he netted in victories over Bolton Wanderers and West Ham United but a disagreement with Howard Wilkinson over his defensive duties was the beginning of the end to his time at the club.

He made 12 more appearances that season and even featured in the League Cup final defeat to Aston Villa but he never scored another goal or added anything of note in the final third as Leeds finished that campaign in 13th position - eight places lower than their previous two efforts of fifth.

Brolin's last game for Leeds would come on April 13, 1996 - just six months after he had penned a two-and-a-half year deal. He would spend the next year on loan at FC Zurich and Parma before his contract was finally terminated eight months before it was due to expire in the summer of 1998.

The Swedish attacker would retire from football less than a year later at the age of 28.


In this post: 
Leeds United
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A degree-educated, dart-throwing, non-smelling sports journalist based in a small Staffordshire town that has just become Floyd Mayweather's answer to the question: "What's the strangest place you have ever visited?"