10 Premier League Flops Who Could Become World Cup 2014 Stars

Rubbish in the Premier League lately but potential world beaters on the grand stage?

English football audiences may like to think that they have an insight into the players likely to feature at this summer's World Cup, with 16% of all the players in the tournament playing in England. Only Italy, Switzerland, Costa Rica and Russia have no players currently playing in England, although the first three all have players with plenty of English league experience (Russia are unique at the World Cup in having all their players play in their home league). Because we see them deliver brilliant game changing performances throughout a highly competitive season, we have a sense that Luis Suarez, Eden Hazard and Sergio Aguero will star in Brazil. But will they? Might the match winning moments equally come from someone else entirely? As anybody who remembers the brief and wholly disappointing post-USA '94 English league careers of Florin Raducioiu or Tomas Brolin can attest to, performance in the high pressure, short term results environment of a World Cup is not an indicator of the ability to deliver consistently in the weekly grind of league football. During the regular season Wayne Rooney is indisputably chosen above Javier Hernandez for Manchester United, but at the last World Cup Chicharito scored half of the Mexicans' goals while Rooney did not find the net once for England. A player of Hernandez's quality may only be a fringe player at a world class club, but his national team can build around his strengths. So, while England struggle to know what to do to get the best from Rooney, Hernandez thrives for Mexico. Chicharito has, nevertheless, generally been a success at United. The following ten players, however, flopped during their time in the Premier League, but could yet surprise English fans with their performances in Brazil.

10. Gaston Ramirez - Uruguay

On their return to the Premier League after a seven year absence, ambitious Southampton smashed their transfer record to bring the highly rated 21 year old Bologna winger to the club for an enormous £12 million (before that summer £4 million for Rory Delap back in 2001 was the fullest extent of the Saints' transfer ambitions). In two seasons since then, Ramirez has shown occasional flashes of brilliant skill or technique in running with the ball that only serve to make his more typical failure to keep up with the pace and pressure of the Premier League game more of a disappointment. Rapidly eclipsed by Jay Rodriguez, who arrived at the same time for half the price and has become one of Saints' key players, Ramirez has become less and less a part of the Southampton set up under Mauricio Pochettino. In the 2013/14 season, the former record signing started all of three Premier League games, provoking rumours of an imminent return to Serie A. Despite all of this, Ramirez remains a key part of Uruguay manager Oscar Tabarez's plans for the World Cup and started on the right wing in both of their recent warm-up friendlies against Northern Ireland and Slovenia. At the 2012 Olympics, Ramirez was one of the standout players in a weak Uruguay side, scoring one of their only two goals in the tournament before they were eliminated by Great Britain and Daniel Sturridge. Who's to say the same could not happen this month?

9. Bryan Ruiz - Costa Rica

Whether cutting in from the right wing or playing as a second striker, Bryan Ruiz had always scored crucial goals wherever he played, whether back home in Costa Rica or in Belgium and Holland. In 2009 Steve McClaren paid 5 million Euros to bring him to FC Twente and Ruiz repaid that faith as his 24 goals pushed the team to their first and only Eredivisie title. With rumoured interest from Arsenal, Ruiz eventually ended up in London but with the somewhat lesser Fulham as Martin Jol made him one of his first signings for £10.6 million. In that first season Ruiz, who had managed more than a goal every two games for Twente, hit the net twice in 27 appearances, ending the season with a broken foot. In all Ruiz scored just 8 times in his entire 74 match Fulham career. His last game for Fulham was the humiliating 6-0 defeat away at Hull City just after Christmas, during which Ruiz, who had had no positive impact on the game, was substituted after an hour. A transfer window loan move to PSV Eindhoven seems to have reinvigorated the Costa Rican star, however, and he has already managed to score almost as many for the Dutch club in five months than he did in three years at Craven Cottage. In the World Cup Qualifiers Ruiz's goal to beat Mexico was a key moment in the 5th seeded Costa Ricans qualifying second from the CONCACAF group. In the absence of star striker Alvaro Saborio, Ruiz could be even more important to his national team and, with Uruguay, England and Italy all looking a little shaky defensively recently he could spring a surprise on Premier League defenders who underrate him.

8. Kostas Mitroglou - Greece

As Bryan Ruiz was on his way out of Craven Cottage, new manager Rene Meulensteen sought to recruit new players to bring the goals that Ruiz never could and keep Fulham in the Premier League. To that end the Cottagers broke their transfer record to spend £12 million bringing Greek striker Kostas Mitroglou to the club. Mitroglou seemed like the perfect goalscorer. In his time at Greek Super League club Olympiacos Mitroglou had netted 41 times in 92 games. Even against top class opposition in the Champions League Mitroglou was a regular scorer, with 3 in 5 Champions League games last season, 4 in 6 the year before. By the time Mitroglou got to play Meulensteen had already been replaced by another new manager, Felix Magath, and Fulham were on a downward slide. In four months at the club this season the £12 million man played a grand total of 3 games, staying on the pitch for all of 151 minutes (that's £80,000 for each minute he played). Mitroglou did not score once and Fulham only picked up one point from those three games (and they were winning that one when he came on) before getting relegated. Injuries and fitness worries have played their part in Mitroglou's failure in Fulham, but he has obviously been fit enough to take part in Greece's three recent World Cup warm up friendlies. If anybody is likely to get the goals that will allow the Greeks to progress to a potential Second Round match with England, the man that scored three in their 4-2 qualifying playoff victory over Romania is likely still to be the one.

7. Marouane Fellaini - Belgium

For much of his Premier League career Marouane Fellaini was anything but a Premier League flop, but this season he has transformed into a shadow of the player he was last year. David Moyes splashed out a club record £15 million to bring the bustling Belgian box to box midfield prodigy to Everton in 2008 and, despite the hefty expectations such a transfer fee might command, it proved to be a shrewd move with Fellaini developing to become the heart of almost all of Everton's play. It is understandable, then, that Moyes should want to bring his Everton star along with him to Manchester United, but everything about Fellaini's move to Old Trafford smacked of desperation. From his hugely inflated £27.5 million fee, to the late rush to push the deal through after attempts to acquire more obvious targets like Cesc Fabregas had failed, Fellaini was bought out of a need to buy someone, anyone, not out of consideration of how he would fit in the team. After just 12 Premier League starts in a series of lacklustre performances in which Fellaini appeared to have no concept of his role in the team, Moyes was fired. The failure of Fellaini in particular probably did much to speed up that decision and now the Belgian is rumoured to be available for half what United paid for him just one year ago. Belgium remain many people's outside tip for World Cup glory with a young, keen and talented side qualifying for the first time since 2002. Even while he has struggled at United, Fellaini has made himself more and more of a part of the Belgian set up. Even having to fight for a place with Spurs' Moussa Dembele, Fellaini has played a key role as Belgium's playmaker in recent friendly wins against Tunisia and Luxembourg and came off the bench in a strong win over Sweden. He even scored earlier in the year against Cote d'Ivoire, something he managed 11 times for Everton last year, but not at all for United.

6. Gervinho - Cote d'Ivoire

One of a long line of highly regarded promising young forwards signed by Arsene Wenger to partner Robin van Persie in the Arsenal attack, Gervinho arrived at Ashburton Grove in the summer of 2011 for a hefty £10.8 million fee. As a pacy wide forward playing for Lille in France Gervinho had scored 15 times the previous season, helping his club to their first Ligue 1 title in over 50 years. His Premier League debut was inauspicious, Gervinho was sent off for violent conduct when slapping Newcastle's Joey Barton. From then on he never looked comfortable or confident in an Arsenal shirt. In two years at the Emirates Gervinho's total goals in all competitions failed to match his league goals in that one final season at Lille. In all the Ivorian forward made 63 appearances for the Gunners and only managed 11 goals. Since being sold last summer to Roma at a loss of around £3 million, however, Gervinho has rediscovered his best form. With 9 goals and 10 assists in 33 Serie A games Gervinho was instrumental in the club's strong second place finish. Manager Rudi Garcia, who Gervinho played under at Lille and who brought him to Roma, has observed that Gervinho is very much a confidence player and at the moment his confidence is sky high, which bodes well for him at the World Cup. As if to indicate just the kind of confidence Gervinho has right now, the forward scored the winning goal in Cote d'Ivoire's final warm up friendly last week against El Salvador. Perhaps opponents who are looking for the threat to come from the more established Premier League great Didier Drogba will be surprised by Gervinho.

5. Giovani dos Santos - Mexico

A product of Barcelona's famed La Masia academy, winger Giovani dos Santos arrived in Englan widely regarded as one of the world's top teenage talents. In the 2007-08 season he had been a semi-regular player for Barca and joined Tottenham for 6 million Euros (plus a potential 5 million more in add-ons) in the hope of holding down a more regular first team place. At White Hart Lane, however, the Mexican never seemed like making it as a first team player. Accumulating just 15 Premier League appearances in four years, manager Harry Redknapp suggested that Giovani was more keen on late night clubbing than training and sent him out on a series of brief loan spells. A return to Spain in 2012, however, has seen the forward rediscover his early promise. He finished the 2012-13 season as relegated RCD Mallorca's top scorer and moved on to Villarreal who had come up in Mallorca's place. Last year was Giovani's best season yet, scoring 12 goals and contributing 8 assists in 31 games to drive the newly promoted team to 6th. More pertinently, Giovani, like Chicharito, has always performed for the national team. Nominated for Young Player of the Tournament at the last World Cup, Giovani went on to score the 2011 CONCACAF Gold Cup's Goal of the Tournament to win Mexico the final against the United States and play a key part in Mexico's 2012 Olympic Gold Medal. Like the rest of the Mexico team, Giovani struggled in World Cup qualifying, but a goal in last month's comfortable 3-1 warm up win against Ecuador suggests he may be finding his best form at just the right time.

4. Jo - Brazil

Yet another forward on this list that was at one time a Premier League club's record signing, Jo was one of the last players to arrive at Manchester City in the era when the club was owned by controversial Thai tycoon Thaksin Shinawatra. The 21 year old striker was signed from CSKA Moscow for £19 million, but a month later the club was bought out by Sheikh Mansour and his Abu Dhabi group and they shattered that earlier record through buying Robinho for £32.5 million. The young Brazilian struggled to hold down a first team place, scoring just once in 9 Premier League appearances. As more and more forwards arrived in the shape of Carlos Tevez, Emmanuel Adebayor and Roque Santa Cruz the following summer, there was never going to be a place for Jo with the Citizens and he moved on loan to Everton. In his final two Premier League seasons Jo played 15 games with no goals for Everton in 2009/10 and 12 games with no goals for City in 2010/11, after which he was sent packing back to Brazil. Since joining Atletico Mineiro and forming a partnership with 2002 World Cup star Ronaldinho, Jo has matured into a top class striker. A regular goalscorer throughout the 2013 Copa Libertadores, Jo's goals helped the club become champions of South America for the first time and helped him play his way into the national team. At last year's Confederations Cup, probably the best indicator of Brazil's competitive ability at home, Jo scored in group games against Japan and Mexico. Although Fred is likely to be Brazil's starting centre forward, he has been replaced by Jo in the recent warm up games so the former Man City man is likely to get his chance at some point.

3. Jozy Altidore - United States

Paolo Di Canio's very brief spell at the helm of Sunderland saw him essentially buy a whole new team as 13 players arrived at the Stadium of Light through the summer. At £6 million American striker Jozy Altidore was the most expensive of these and, with 23 goals in 33 appearances for Dutch club AZ last season, was expected to be the big goalscoring forward that the club was lacking. Altidore, however, struggled to settle or make a difference as the club went on an 8 match winless run to kick off the season. After Di Canio was fired and Gus Poyet took over Altidore eventually opened his account in December with a goal in the 4-3 home defeat to Chelsea. And that was it. Appearing in 31 games this season, Altidore managed just that one goal. The Haitian-American forward fared no better in his previous spell in England, as a 20 year old on a season's loan at Hull City in their Premier League relegation season in 2009/10. In that year Altidore scored 1 goal in 28 games, making the striker's total Premier League scoring tally 2 in 59 or 0.0338 goals per game. For his national team, though, it's a different story. Manager Jurgen Klinsmann has turned the Americans into a strong and plausible challenger at the World Cup with a very real possibility of causing an upset against a Portugal team that may have the best player in Europe but look weak elsewhere. Klinsmann caused a stir when leaving America's greatest ever forward Landon Donovan out of his final squad, which just goes to show the faith that he has in Altidore. Altidore has repaid that faith with goals and lots of them. This week alone he has matched his tally for his entire 59 game Premier League career with two in the 2-1 friendly win over Nigeria. In 2013 he scored 8 in 14 internationals, including a crucial goal in the 4-3 win over Germany and an impressive hat-trick against Bosnia in Sarajevo. Don't bet against Altidore beating his season's Sunderland goal record in just three World Cup group games.

2. Fernando Torres - Spain

To some Fernando Torres may be remembered in years to come as one of the great Premier League players. He was unusual in moving from one of Europe's other major leagues at the peak of his form and fitness and became one of Liverpool's greatest ever strikers in four years of extremely regular goalscoring. Since Chelsea spent an enormous £50 million on the man they call El Nino back in January 2011, however, it's hard to view Torres as anything but a Premier League flop. At Chelsea, struggling with fitness, confidence and the weight of expectations, Torres has only occasionally looked like the player that lit up the Premier League in previous seasons. In three and a half seasons at Stamford Bridge he has managed a mere 20 league goals in 110 games (for comparison he scored 24 in the league in just his first season at Liverpool). However, there are signs that Torres might have more to offer at the World Cup. For a start, although he has struggled for goals in the league, European competition has still proved fruitful for Torres in front of goal. In 2012/13 Torres scored 3 in 6 in the Champions League and 6 in 9 in the Europa League, including in the final as Chelsea lifted the trophy. This year he scored 4 in 9 in the Champions League and ended the season scoring against former club Atletico Madrid in the semi-final and in the final league game against Cardiff. He is on form and obviously prefers to play oversees opposition and big games, all of which may suit the World Cup. Even during his failing spell at Chelsea, Torres has always impressed for the national team, winning the Golden Boot at both Euro 2012 and the 2013 Confederations Cup. This previous international experience is what has ensured a return to the national team, selected in the final squad ahead of Fernando Llorente and Alvaro Negredo and scoring in the recent friendly against Bolivia. All of which may stand him in good stead against Diego Costa who lacks international experience having never scored for either Brazil or Spain.

1. Shinji Kagawa - Japan

In the past the purchase of an Asian player by a top Premier League club was viewed as a way to tap into valuable markets for fans and merchandising. Shinji Kagawa, however, was brought to Manchester United to win things. A skilled and creative attacking playmaker Kagawa had been a driving force behind Borussia Dortmund's 2012 double in one of the world's top leagues. Scoring and creating goals in his link up with centre forward Robert Lewandowski (13 goals and 8 assists and one of each in the Cup Final win over Bayern Munich) made Kagawa an in demand player and United snapped him up for £12 million. Arriving at Old Trafford at the same time as Robin van Persie, Kagawa was overshadowed by the new striker and United under both Alex Ferguson and David Moyes seemed to have little idea of how to use their Japanese star. With Wayne Rooney, and now Juan Mata, preferring to play in Kagawa's best position tucked in behind main striker Van Persie, Kagawa has instead found himself lost out on the wing. His first season with United saw flashes of his creative genius and 6 Premier League goals, but overall was a disappointment. Under Moyes he was more and more marginalised. For a goal scoring midfielder not finding the net once in the 2013/14 Premier League is a real failure. Kagawa seems to have little Old Trafford future and Dortmund, for one, would love to see him return there. For Japan, however, Kagawa continues to be given the freedom he needs to play his game and continues to make a difference playing that way. Alongside Japan's other star, AC Milan's central midfielder Keisuke Honda, Kagawa has even excelled as a wide forward by being given the freedom to cut inside and switch things up in a way that he isn't at Man United. If any Asian team is likely to progress in Brazil then Japan are by far the best equipped to do so, especially with an in form Kagawa. The Man United flop scored in both this month's final warm up games against Costa Rica and Zambia and his excellent performance in the latter turned around what could have been an embarrassing defeat into a 4-3 win. Any one of these Premier League failures could prove World Cup stars, but will that result in a boost to their Premier League form next season? No, probably not, but it could at least increase their transfer value for a fresh start.

Contributor
Contributor

Loves ghost stories, mysteries and giant ape movies