10 Problems Steve McClaren Doesn't Want To Admit About Newcastle

Yes, just ten, for now...

What seems to be the problem at Newcastle United? Last season there was a plethora of excuses to choose from and each would swerve attention away from the first team squad and instead splat the blame all over Mike Ashley's perverse desire to see his staff at Sports Direct work harder than his under-performing number nine. Ashley's cavalier approach was a welcome distraction that deflected attention away from the ninety minutes on the football pitch and savagely etched its narrative into Newcastle fans' minds. Tyneside became infected with commercial bile, sub plots and cries of revolution and left football - the one thing that once brought the whole city together - gasping for air as it slipped into John Carver-induced coma. Ashley agreed to bring in some urgent medical attention but rather than shelling out for some premium overseas healthcare he turned to an unemployed Derbyshire professional who despite being fully-qualified hadn't operated at the highest level since he messed up a relatively simple procedure at Wembley in 2007. Like a shot of Botox, the initial response was good but you're left craving another perhaps more substantial dose further down the line. McClaren's appointment (alongside the signings of Aleksandar Mitrovic, Georginio Wijnaldum, Chancel Mbemba and Florian Thauvin) breathed life not only into the club but across the city as well. Football talk had returned and it was now down to the manager and players to get fans excited again but after eight games, zero wins, three draws and five defeats it seems a disconnected, ambitionless, money-saving chairman wasn't the only problem. So what is?

10. McClaren Wasn't The Right Choice

Steve McClaren's appointment this Summer was met with a unenthusiastic shrug and hollow stare by most. It was hard to get excited about a manager who had seemingly failed to even get his well-backed Derby side into the Championship playoffs and who had flopped at the last fives sides he had been at. Mike Ashley's lethargic decision to appoint McClaren only escaped fan backlash because most supporters were so relieved that John Carver was no longer in charge. The change represented a new era but while everyone celebrated the fresh start most failed to realise that the Newcastle chairman had appointed a man who wasn't anywhere good enough to take charge at St James' Park. Everyone has realised now...

9. Half The Team (If Not All) Don't Want To Play For The Manager

The problem with appointing a manager who hasn't managed at the top level for a long time and isn't highly regarded is that he immediately loses the respect of the players. Newcastle have a lot of seasoned internationals, including Moussa Sissoko, Papiss Cisse, Georginio Wijnaldum and Aleksandar Mitrovic and it takes a certain type of manager to be able to manage the egos of that calibre of player. Steve McClaren isn't that man and it has been noticeable in the players' performances that they haven't bought into the former Derby boss' philosophy or tactics. Half of the side (if not all of them) believe they know better than the man in charge and that's when problems occur. On a number of occasions already this season, Sissoko and Wijnaldum have become visibly frustrated by McClaren's commands.

8. They're Playing Worse Than When John Carver Was In Charge

Despite a recognisable change in their philosophy, Newcastle United's result are worse than when John Carver was in charge of the club. How can that be possible? Well, Carver actually won a game, three in fact and after 20 games in charge he had a win ratio of 15%. McClaren's win ratio is currently 9.09% after beating Northampton Town in the cup he has one win, four draws and six defeats. It's amazing that anyone could be worse than Carver's performance last season and McClaren's 9.09% is currently the worst out of any full-time Magpies' boss throughout the club's entire history. Give him some slack though, he's only been in charge for 11 games...

7. They Have Won Just One Premier League Game In Their Last 19

Newcastle have now won only one of their past 19 league games and their failure to find a victory in any of their first eight matches of this campaign makes this their worst start to a season since 1898-99. It hasn't been all bad and there have been positives during the Magpies' performances against Manchester United, Arsenal and Chelsea but their complete collapse at the Etihad Stadium last weekend will have killed any momentum they had going into the Norwich fixture.

6. Spending £50m Has Not Eradicated The Problems

Spending £50 million on Aleksandar Mitrovic, Florian Thauvin, Chancel Mbemba, Georginio Wijnaldum and Ivan Toney was a pleasant surprise for Newcastle fans but it isn't the answer to Newcastle's problems. Firstly, the manager isn't good enough to manage the personalities that he has acquired and secondly when has signing a handful of players and chucking them all into the first team ever worked? The Magpies have now lost all of their confidence and have developed a losing mentality and if McClaren doesn't correct that against Norwich and Sunderland then he will never be able to. Once more it boils down to Ashley's (or Lee Charnley's) slap-dash decision to appoint a manager who isn't the man to take the club forward (a mistake the club have made each time they have recruited a new coach).

5. They're Running Out Of Time

The Premier League is unforgiving and stats show that in 15 of the 23 (65%) Premier League seasons the team who are bottom of the table after eight games have gone on to be relegated. On a lighter note, six sides who have had three points or fewer after eight games have gone on to survive at the end of the season. Notably, four out of those six changed their manager before November. Are you reading this Mr Ashley?

4. Florian Thauvin Is Useless And Was A Disgraceful Bit Of Business

Florian Thauvin cost Newcastle a reported £12 million (plus Remy Cabella), a figure that was described as laughable by French media. After backing Thauvin's transfer since he signed this summer, I have now resigned to the fact that they were very much right about the player's inflated price tag and although looking more robust than Cabella, he certainly doesn't offer much more. He doesn't seem capable of beating a full-back or crossing the ball, he isn't pacy or skilful and despite an amazing home debut (against Northampton) where he scored a goal and grabbed three assists he screams of an unforgivable panic buy.

3. Pre-Season Negligence Has Cost Them

Steve McClaren's pre-season coincided with Newcastle broadcasting a lot more 'behind-the-scenes' footage on NUFCTV and social media outlets such as Twitter and Periscope. The response to the club's change of philosophy and focus was extremely positive and McClaren's 4-2-3-1 system and possession based style sparked a large amount of fan optimism. Unfortunately, now that pretty much every single bit of the former Derby boss' tactics having failed by October it has now became apparent that his naivety create a plan B has proved costly. McClaren is now stuck with what looks like a messy last-minute job of attempting to play a 4-4-1-1 formation with Ayoze Perez (a player who he discarded pre-season and played centre midfield) as his latest project.

2. Steve McClaren Probably Regrets Taking The Job

Steve McClaren's immediate concerns to take over Newcastle United as they battled to avoid relegation towards the end of the 2014-15 season will have resurfaced. Failure at St James' Park will be sixth successive blemish on the former England boss' CV and a move back down to the Championship would be highly likely. Still winless in the league, McClaren has not had the start he would have hoped for, despite the club spending almost £50m in the summer and is probably regretting his move to Tyneside. The manager had worked hard to develop his reputation during his time at Derby County and he was starting to become known for his attractive, possession-based football with the Rams.

1. The Squad Won't Play For Him And He Can't Motivate Them

As you can probably tell from my earlier entries, I don't believe that Steve McClaren has the ability to motivate the current Newcastle squad. I believe that his appointment has given the players another excuse to under-perform due to his managerial reputation and credentials. Based on what I have seen so far, the players (especially the bigger names) seem frustrated by his animated body language on the touchline and aggrieved by his tactical commands. What do you think are the main problems at Newcastle this season? Let us know in the comments below?

Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-accredited football writer with an MA in Sports Journalism. What Culture football editor. Write for the official Newcastle United programme. Former video reporter at North News. Featured and published in the Sunderland Echo, Shields Gazette, Mail Online, The Mirror, The Sun and others.