5 Reasons Why The O'Neill/Keane Dream Ticket Has Its Risks For Ireland

Martin O€™Neill€™s appointment as the new Republic Of Ireland manager is one that has set tongues wagging across the country. That may seem strange to some observers, as O€™Neill is one of the UK€™s most highly respected managers, but his choice of Roy Keane as assistant is one that raises several questions.

The news was officially broken during ITV's coverage of Real Sociedad's clash with Manchester United this week, and an initial two-year deal has been agreed with both men. The length of this contract is ideal as it allows job security for throughout the attempt to reach Euro 2016, yet also an easy way out should the duo of Keane and O'Neill fail to meet expectations.

This is a recognition by the FAI of the dangers of such a bold move. While football has seen some strange management teams work throughout history, this one has some challenges to overcome.


5. Keane May Be Too Aggressive

The former Manchester United captain boasts a controversial career, both in domestic and international football. Keane left a huge print on the game as the on-pitch driving force behind United's dominance. He also left his prints on Alf-Inge Haaland's right knee with a tackle that the Norwegian believes ended his career. That challenge in 2001 left a black mark on the midfielder's reputation that he never really shook off. While Keane was always an integral part of the well-oiled Old Trafford machine, his eventual departure betrayed a tendency to fly off the handle with little thought for the consequences. In November 2005, in the aftermath of a 4-1 defeat at Middlesbrough, Keane gave a never-to-be-aired interview to MUTV, the club's official TV station, where he heavily criticised his team-mates. The details of the transcript led to a showdown with Sir Alex Ferguson - one that ended with the Irishman's exit by mutual consent. Such a turn of events would be as shocking today as it was then, as player and power and dissent never go down well at Old Trafford, although Wayne Rooney's recent behaviour is evidence that even those standards are starting to slip. However, we had already seen similar impulsiveness from Keane at international level.

4. Keane Disgraced Himself At Ireland's Last World Cup

-->

-->

On the international scene Keane was a committed captain for his beloved Ireland, but even that provided fireworks, which neither he nor then manager Mick McCarthy will ever forget. At a training camp in preparation for the 2002 World Cup in Japan/Korea, he had some unkind words to say about the managerial prowess of McCarthy, as well as the alleged sub-standard training facilities.

The resulting bust-up led to the skipper being sent home in disgrace, and attracted a media circus for all the wrong reasons. Keane, having played in USA 1994, was at least able to count himself as a participant in a major tournament, unlike his Man United team-mate Ryan Giggs, but he would surely have loved to add to that. Instead he was reduced to taking potshots at the chief executive of the FAI, John Delaney. Delaney still holds that position, which would suggest interesting times lie ahead.

Arguably, after Keane€™s exile, the team was able to form a tight-knit bond that aided their eventual run to the last 16, but it would be foolish to claim that Keane would not have added to Ireland€™s on pitch weaponry. There are one or two in the current dressing room that will remember all too well the media circus that his actions attracted.


3. Keane's Past May Undermine His Authority

Eleven years on, and Keane will be attempting to exert some authority of his own over a squad that still contains Richard Dunne and Robbie Keane from the group that he left in the lurch all those years ago. Don€™t be surprised to see this pair announce their retirement sooner rather than later, being aged 34 and 33 respectively.

The pair are undoubtedly professionals of the highest order, and will not publicly reveal any existing dissent towards their assistant manager, but other younger members of the squad may not be too thrilled at the appointment. If nothing else, Roy Keane is a man who inspires strong feelings one way or another.

Martin O'Neill is a manager who will undoubtedly have thought this through, and should he run into any disciplinary problems with his squad, there may be some matters best dealt with himself. Having said that, I'm sure Keane will feel no qualms about laying into anyone he feels is not giving 100% to the Ireland cause, although he should expect an occasional brave riposte.


2. Keane Is Still Unproven As A Coach

Another huge question mark rests over Keane€™s management career to date. At Sunderland he was the choice of then owner Niall Quinn, showing that he at least forgave him for his international actions. Keane was a storming initial success in the Championship, reviving a struggling side and turning them into promotion winners.

However, the Premier League proved a step too far at that early stage in his career, and a rather bedraggled looking Keane stepped down in the November of that debut top-flight season in 2008. On news of his resignation, it was even reported that some Sunderland players celebrated, as they were not a fan of his no-nonsense methods.

Ipswich soon gave him a managerial lifeline, but Keane never threatened a repeat of his early Sunderland success in his 20 months in charge. A sacking followed, with Ipswich lying in 21st position in the Championship at the time of his departure.

One positive way to look at this is the fact that Keane will not have overall control over the Republic of Ireland squad, and many would say that O€™Neill is the perfect man for Keane to learn from €“ the fellow former Sunderland manager being of similarly eccentric but much mellower temperament.


1. Is O'Neill Still Hungry For Success?

O€™Neill€™s own managerial trajectory has reached what could end up being a logical conclusion, with international football seen by many as the old folks home of management. He has seemed somewhat burnt out of late €“ his final days at Sunderland saw a manager many tipped as a potential Man United manager struggling to keep an expensively assembled side in the Premier League. It would not be harsh to deem his time on Wearside an overall failure.

There will be inevitable questions as to whether O'Neill still has the hunger for management, as he has seemed rather cosy in his punditry roles of late, yet O€™Neill still has years of success at Celtic, Aston Villa, and two League Cup triumphs to fall back on. Make no mistake €“ he will carry the respect and attention of the dressing room. Perhaps more importantly after the Trapattoni era, there is no chance of anything being lost in translation.

Keane should watch and learn from a master. He will not carry the can should Ireland fail to qualify for Euro 2016, but when he returns to full management €“ which he will €“ whoever takes a punt on him will possibly have their faith rewarded.


Contributor
Contributor

I am from Bangor, aged 24, and possess an MA in Journalism from The University Of Ulster. I have had work published in the Belfast Telegraph and interviewed several local footballers and Olympic athletes. I also run my own sports blog, 'Sporting Thought' in addition to contributing to What Culture.