5 Reasons Steve Bruce Will Fail At Aston Villa

Those who don't learn from the past... 

Steve Bruce Aston Villa
2016 Getty Images

There is no doubt that Steve Bruce is a great manager and has expertise in the Championship. However, his decision to take the Aston Villa job could well turn out to be career suicide. First of all, he is too good of a manager to take over a club in such a mess.

The second problem he has is failure in this job could result in him struggling to find work again if he isn’t successful. There are certainly plenty of managers that have had a hard time getting a decent job again after taking an opportunity that they shouldn’t have.

Aston Villa fans will certainly see this as a negative appraisal, but in the article my reasons will be given in why it could be a big mistake. So, if this sounds like the sort of thing that appeals to you – then please read on…

5. Surely There Won’t Be Money To Spend In January!

Steve Bruce Aston Villa Manager
2016 Getty Images

The problem when managers change is that the new man may not be keen on the squad he has to work with. However, it’s hard to believe that another war chest will be handed out In January, so Bruce may have to get the best out of the current squad.

Of course, there is quality in the squad and different managers are sometimes able to get things out of players whether that be good or bad. Nevertheless, a manager likes to be judged by his own group of players. Given the other points made here, Bruce may never get that luxury.


4. Steve Bruce Won’t Be Given Time And Will Be Judged On Results

Roberto Di Matteo
John Walton/EMPICS Sport

As mentioned, Bruce has quite the reputation in the Championship and certainly was successful with his last job at Hull City. However, the new Aston Villa owner doesn’t look to be in the mood to give a manager time. Roberto Di Matteo had a poor start, but most people expected that; nevertheless, he wasn’t going to be given time to turn things around despite being backed in the transfer market in the summer.

Bruce has come in with the club in a poor position in the league, so it’s unclear what the expectations are for him. My gut feeling is though he may have to get the club into the top six to stay in the job. Yet, it may be more realistic for them to consolidate in the Championship this season which may well serve them well going forward into next season.

It's unlikely to be a situation that the Villa owner will settle for though, especially after the summer transfer spend. No one really knows why Steve Bruce left Hull, but you’d expect interference was part of the reason and he may well find similar problems at Villa. So, all in all given time and control could be factors that could see Bruce’s spell being shorter than he would like.


3. Aston Villa Didn’t Spend Wisely In The Summer

Aaron Tshibola Aston Villa
2016 Getty Images

Aston Villa’s summer transfer activity was strange to say the least. It almost seemed like they were toying with the Financial Fair Play regulations with the £50m spend. Other teams in the past have certainly been hit with problems with less obvious transfer spending so problems are surely coming Villa way. However, that is something for another day – now it’s all about what kind of impact those players can make this season.

Well, the early signs this season aren’t exactly good and others have said that the club look well short of best teams in the league despite that spending. For me, there have been out to impress with some of their signings – especially with the two lads up front. Clearly, they have made some decent signings in other areas as well. However, maybe the balance of the team and how it would work together hasn’t been taken into account as much as it should have been.

Getting rid of the negativity from last season is also a problem and that doesn’t seem to have happened yet. I’d also say that there is a lot of pressure being put onto certain players without necessarily having the experience to make that kind of impact. An obvious example here is the £5m spent on midfielder Aaron Tshibola; he is a good player but still very young and inexperienced to make a big impact this season.


2. Getting The Best Out Of Kodjia And McCormack Will Be His Biggest Challenge

Ross McCormack Aston Villa
2016 Getty Images

I’ll come onto this in more detail a bit later, but signing both Jonathan Kodjia and Ross McCormack was clearly a mistake. Obviously, the club felt that they needed firepower to get out of the Championship and that is a logical thing to do.

However, the most successful teams in the Championship have a balanced squad and hardworking players. The problem with Kodjia and McCormack is they both want to be the centre of attention and both want to be the main striker. It’s also the case that the fees involved means they both really need to be in the starting eleven.

As mentioned, this problem is going to make getting the balance of the team right and that is a big problem. Furthermore, trying to get the best out of Kodjia and McCormack may mean that the club aren’t able to get the maximum out of even one of them – and that certainly seems to be the case so far this season.


1. Has Steve Bruce Been Seduced By The Size Of The Club And Forgotten The Size Of The Job?

Aston Villa manager Tim Sherwood during the Barclays Premier League match at Villa Park, Birmingham.
Nick Potts/PA Wire

It’s funny the way Aston Villa are talked about by people in the media. Let’s be honest here, the club have been in a real mess for several years now. However, the focus on a lot of discussion usually focuses on their past success as a steady team in the top six of the Premier League.

It has been a long time since those days though and currently the club find themselves in the bottom half of the Championship. Nevertheless, managers are constantly attracted to the job based on the history. It certainly seemed that was the case when Paul Lambert made the strange switch from Norwich City to Villa.

Equally, Steve Bruce had joined the club and talked a lot about the history and size of the stadium. All of which counts for very little right now in a very competitive league. The big question remains on how much Bruce has considered the size of the task rather than focus purely on the potential for him if he is successful.


Contributor
Contributor

James Kent is a freelance writer published on Yahoo! Sports, Bleacher Report, FTBpro, Bloomberg Sports and many others. He has also been featured in the Daily Telegraph, Zoo Magazine, MSN Sport and the Manchester Evening News. His role on What Culture is currently to produce compelling football articles that nearly always use of combination of stats and strong opinion. Feel free to connect with James via Facebook, Twitter and Google Plus.