5 Reasons Why Andy Carroll’s Return Would Be Good For Newcastle (And 5 Why It Wouldn’t)

4. The Team Could Become (Even More) One-Dimensional

The drawback of having a battering ram up front that can help the team play a more direct football is precisely that - they continuously play direct. During Andy Carroll€™s first spell with the club, there were some who were sceptical about his technical ability on the floor and it is debatable whether he has improved this area of his game significantly. While not as bad with the ball at his feet as some claim, it€™s a clear weakness and his return would do nothing to help the club to change to a more progressive style of play. With Remy Cabella and Siem de Jong showing little of their playmaking talents thus far - albeit for varying reasons - there is a temptation that the Magpies will continue to bypass the midfield and look to play basketball with the big man, forcing Carroll to battle for jump balls all game. Strength and physicality are good in moderation but would a Carroll return make Newcastle more predictable?