England vs Montenegro: 5 Reasons Fraser Forster Should Replace Joe Hart
has his full backing as England keeper for the crucial upcoming World Cup qualifiers against Montenegro and Poland, but should he? Hodgson's squad for the qualifying games also includes Celtic's Fraser Forster and Norwich City's John Ruddy. Is there enough reason to drop Hart in favour of one of these two? Here are five good reasons why Hodgson should start with Forster rather than Hart against Montenegro on Friday.
5. To Provide A Credible Threat To Hart's Starting Spot
When Hart first cemented his place as England's number 1 there was generally a feeling that it would be good for the young goalkeeper's confidence and security and the team's stability to have a regular definite starter behind them. Now, however, when looking for reasons for Hart's decline in form, his lapses of concentration and silly errors, many pundits have pointed to the possibility that he may be a little too secure in his position in the starting line up. Hart's deputy at club level Costel Pantilimon, now in his third season with City, has yet to play a league game for the club. The means that Hart is no longer kept on his toes by a plausible threat to his place. He can make errors because he knows he will keep playing anyway. Across the other side of Manchester, United keeper David De Gea also committed a series of blunders when he first arrived, but United had a good enough reserve keeper in Anders Lindegaard for the Dane to come into the team instead. The competition for a starting place resulted in a great deal of improvement in De Gea's consistency with the young Spaniard turning out to be one of the Premier League's top keepers last season. Forster has the potential to provide a similar competition for Hart's starting place, but the only way to ensure that he is a credible challenger is to give him the opportunity of playing some real competitive games. People may claim that these qualifiers are too important to be making changes in key personnel, but the only way that Forster will seem like a realistic option is to play him in games that matter, not just friendly matches. This is not so much about replacing Hart permanently, more about doing something that should improve both Hart and Forster as they both have something to fight for.
4. To Ensure That There Are Other Goalkeepers With England Experience
Regardless of whether you think Hart should be dropped completely, be given competition for his starting place, or remain indisputable No.1, there is always a possibility that injury or suspension will make him unavailable at the crucial point. If that does happen, the worry would then be that England don't possess another goalkeeping option with sufficient international experience. If Hart were to get a serious injury during or right before the World Cup itself, the options to replace him with a player who's played for the Three Lions before are pretty scarce. Aside from Hart, the only goalkeeper with significant England experience who is still playing is Blackburn's Paul Robinson. Robinson, who retired from international football three years ago anyway, lost his place after winning 41 caps because he, like Hart, was making bad errors at crucial moments. QPR's Robert Green is the most capped player still available for selection with 12 appearances. The only keepers playing in the top flight with England experience, though, are Hart, West Brom's Ben Foster (six caps), Ruddy (one cap) and Man City's third choice Richard Wright who played twice for England over ten years ago. Forster has managed to become England's number two goalkeeping option without ever playing. England are going to want to give him a game at some point - preferably at a moment of Hodgson's choosing rather than when forced into it on the biggest stage of all. Once again, if you really want someone you can rely on, someone whose England experience is useful, then that means that you have to play them in an important competitive match, not just a friendly.3. His Form is Extremely Consistent
While Hart has shown an alarming lack of consistency over the last few months, Forster has been a solid and reliable presence in goal throughout his career. Whether at Norwich in the Football League or Celtic in the Scottish Premier League, Forster has always kept clean sheets. His entire career record is 211 games and 106 clean sheets, meaning he doesn't concede in 50% of games. If it's impossible for the team to lose half the time then that's a pretty solid starting point to build on. In terms of saves, Forster's save percentage over the period 2010-2013 is an impressive 80.9% (compared to Hart's 74.4%, which has dropped to 63.2% for this season, placing him 16th in the Premier League goalkeeper table). Of course you could point to how Hart is competing in the higher standard English Premier League, but let's not forget that Rickie Lambert was able to carry his good League One scoring record up to the Championship, the Premiership, and an England career that features two goals in three games. Stepping up a level doesn't automatically mean a decline in quality of performance. Looking at the one competition in which both Forster and Hart competed together, the Champions League in the 2012-13 and 2013-14 seasons, Forster has kept 9 clean sheets in 20 games, conceding 19 goals, while Hart has kept 2 in 8 games, conceding 14 goals. This gives Forster a 45% clean sheet record to Hart's 25% and all this with Hart playing behind a much stronger defence.
2. He Comes Recommended By The Best
It's one thing for pundits and lists like this to single Forster out for praise, but his performances have also been drawing attention from those in the know within the game. During his final year as Man United boss, Sir Alex Ferguson reportedly held Forster in high enough regard that he was keeping tabs on the keeper as a possible replacement for David De Gea before the latter's good run of form saw him cement himself in the team. Meanwhile, after Forster's Celtic faced Barcelona in the Champions League, Barca's Brazilian right back Dani Alves was effusive in his praise of the English goalkeeper. Alves described Forster as "fantastic" and suggested that the Catalan giants were, like Man United the year before, seriously considering bringing Forster in as their new keeper. "Only the club can answer how accurate the reports are on the interest in Forster but if they are true it doesnt surprise me," Alves told assembled press after the game, suggesting that Forster would be an ideal replacement for current Barca shot stopper Victor Valdes when the latter leaves at the end of this season. Forster's biggest admirer, though, is the man regularly described as the world's best goalkeeper for the best part of a decade: Gianluigi Buffon. In the build up to the Champions League match between Celtic and Buffon's Juventus last year, Buffon suggested that Forster had the potential to be one of the best young keepers in the world, describing him as a keeper with authority and confidence who didn't look like making any mistakes. With mistakes being the big talking point after Hart's performance against Bayern Munich, Buffon has once again weighed in this week to say:"I think it is time now for England to give Forster a chance. He has proved he can handle the big games and the pressure situations. If the England coach is picking his team on form then Fraser is his only option".
1. He Has Performed Exceptionally In Big Games
The last couple of entries have touched on this, but it bears a bit of greater focus. The biggest argument against playing Forster in the games that will decide whether England make it to the World Cup is that, with no previous England caps and a regular job in the Scottish Premier League, he doesn't have the necessary big game experience. Sure, the Scottish league has managed the remarkable feat of being even less competition for Celtic since Glaswegian rivals Rangers were forcibly relegated in 2012, but Celtic's Champions League campaigns have allowed them to compete at the highest level. While Hart's Man City crashed out of the 2012-13 competition without winning a single game, it was Celtic that progressed from the Qualifying Rounds to the Last 16. In particular last season's campaign was memorable for a brilliant 2-1 victory against Barcelona. Forster was the hero on that occasion, making a string of superb saves to preserve the Bhoys' lead. Forster was so unbeatable that the Spanish media dubbed him "La Gran Muralla", "The Great Wall". This wasn't a one off performance either. While Hart was blundering his way through the Bayern Munich game, 10 man Celtic were given a rematch against Barcelona. Barca dominated possession but were held to a single goal, winning 1-0. It could have been more but for Forster whose impressive double save from Neymar and Alexis Sanchez in the dying minutes strengthened the case for his England inclusion at just the right moment. Given this kind of major international experience, the ability to handle Neymar, Messi and company, Forster should be pretty prepared for whatever Montenegro could throw at him. The former Yugoslav state's star player is centre forward Mirko Vucinic who plies his trade for Juventus. Forster will already be well familiar with the six time Montenegrin Footballer of the Year. After Celtic's game against Juve in the last 16 of last year's Champions League, a disappointing 3-0 defeat at Celtic Park saw Vucinic score the third goal, the result more of weak defending from Celtic than any fault of Forster's. Hopefully playing behind the slightly stronger defence that England can put together would be enough for Forster to keep out Vucinic, whose fitness remains in doubt for the game anyway. Do you agree? Let us know in the comment section, below.