FIFA Team Of The Year: 11 Overlooked Players Who Deserved Inclusion

Amongst all the end of year awards announced in the last week, FIFPro have selected their team of the year for 2013 and it is: Manuel Neuer; Dani Alves, Thiago Silva, Sergio Ramos, Philipp Lahm; Andres Iniesta, Xavi, Franck Ribery; Cristiano Ronaldo, Lionel Messi, Zlatan Ibrahimovic. Naturally the reaction in the British press has been to question the lack of Premier League players in the team, but that is just a reflection of the poor performance of English teams in the Champions League compared to previous years. What is more noteworthy, though, is that the selection reflects an accepted wisdom of previous years with regard to the dominance of La Liga and Spain's Golden Generation. In a year in which Barcelona were thoroughly outplayed by Bayern Munich across two legs in the Champions League and Spain well beaten in the Confederations Cup Final, should we still be considering the Xavi-Iniesta midfield axis to be the best of them all? This list considers an alternative 11 drawn from the FIFPro shortlist to explore some choice performers of 2013 that have been overlooked in favour of the more obvious choices. According to the votes counted by FIFA, the reserve line-up of players closest to making the team was: Iker Casillas; David Luiz, Gerard Pique, Marcelo, David Alaba; Mesut Ozil, Yaya Toure, Gareth Bale; Neymar, Radamel Falcao, Robin van Persie. Some of these have made our list, while others have missed out. Let us know in the comments if you think this alternative 11 would stand a chance against the FIFPro team or if you think of a player glaringly ignored in both.

Goalkeeper

11. Gianluigi Buffon (Juventus & Italy)

FIFPro's choice of Manuel Neuer in the goalkeeper slot is fairly hard to dispute. Long considered one of the most promising talents between the sticks, Neuer has matured into an excellent all round player that few forwards would care to play against. The alternative choice is a much more established great who began the year with a Goalkeeper of the Century award. Even so, 2013 has been a particularly good year for Gianluigi Buffon. That he lifted his first Scudetto trophy as Juventus captain is a testament to his leadership ability. That he did so conceding just 19 goals all season is indicative of how essential he was to Juve's triumph with a team that is not one of their best. The opening months of the new season have seen Buffon hit his 500th Serie A game on his way to a run of 745 consecutive minutes without conceding (beating his previous record of 568). He has led the Old Lady to the top of the league, with just one defeat in 20. 2013 also saw him become Italy's most capped player with 138 appearances. He was named the national team's Player of the Year after leading them to qualification for the 2014 World Cup and keeping a clean sheet against the Spanish in the Confederations Cup Semi-Final before saving three penalties against Uruguay for his country to finish third.

Defence

10. Pablo Zabaleta (Manchester City & Argentina)

While he may be a slightly surprising choice to represent the Premier League in the World XI, there can be few better right backs to challenge Dani Alves' slot in the FIFPro team than Pablo Zabaleta. If the Premier League went by calendar year, as these awards do, then Man City would be champions by some margin, while their impressive win against Bayern Munich in December shows that they can beat anyone. While some may point to the defensive solidity of Kompany, the quality of Yaya Toure in the middle, or the attacking prowess of "Kun" Aguero, it is Zabaleta who has most consistently impressed during this period. Despite finishing league and cup runners up for 2012-13, Zabaleta was City's only representative in the PFA Team of the Year and won the club's own Player of the Year award. Had he not been sent off in the Cup Final, the Citizens might not have ended the year trophy-less. This year Zabaleta, often the stand-in captain in the absence of Kompany, has impressed greatly, both flying forward and tracking back, having already picked up five Premier League assists, his best ever total in just half the season and delivering a superb performance in the 6-3 demolition of league leaders Arsenal. Meanwhile, for Argentina Zabaleta has fought back from being excluded completely from Diego Maradona's 2010 squad to become a fixture in, and occasional captain of, a team that comfortably won the South American qualifying section and must be many people's favourites to triumph in Brazil next summer.

9. David Alaba (Bayern Munich & Austria)

While the FIFPro team's choice of left back, Bayern Munich's Philipp Lahm has undoubtedly been one of the key players in the Bavarian club's incredibly successful year, a year that has seen them win virtually everything, part of what has worked so well has been the 30 year old's switch to a central midfield role. Meanwhile, young Austrian utility player David Alaba discovering left back as his best position has been one of 2013's biggest success stories. Alaba was one of the clear stars of Bayern's Champions League win this year. The Quarter-Final saw the 20 year old score one of the fastest goals in Champions League history, putting Bayern ahead against Juventus in just 25 seconds. In the semi, Alaba's superb link up play with Franck Ribery down the wing tore Barcelona apart. Alaba set up goals in both legs of Bayern's 7-0 aggregate win. Picking up his third consecutive Austrian Player of the Year award in 2013, despite his young age Alaba's exceptional performances for the national team pushed them to just three points off play-off qualifiers Sweden. Despite playing most of the campaign at left back, Alaba was Austria's top scorer for the qualifiers with six goals, five scored in 2013. Despite not making the FIFPro Team of the Year, Alaba was selected in UEFA's Team of 2013, an almost equivalent honour given that the entire FIFPro shortlist currently play in Europe.

8. Raphael Varane (Real Madrid & France)

As with the choice of Lahm over Alaba, the FIFPro team's selection of Real Madrid's Sergio Ramos at centre back feels more like a selection based on general quality than one specific to performances this year. Ramos' team mate and defensive partner Raphael Varane, however, is a player who has emerged from being a promising youngster to a world class player almost completely in the last season and a half. Having really only played a handful of games for Real, the former Lens centre back started the Copa del Rey game against Barcelona at the start of the year and was completely unintimidated. After clearing a shot from Xavi off the line, Varane went on to score the Meringues' only goal of the game. From then on he became more and more of a fixture in the Real defence, keeping the highly regarded Pepe out of the team with a series of great performances, particularly in the Champions League. His performance in the Quarter-Final against Galatasary was especially impressive, utterly keeping Didier Drogba in check. Not only did Real keep a clean sheet, but every one of Varane's tackles was successful and every one of his passes found its man. His positional sense, technique and ability to read the game have had many at Real comparing him to club legend Fernando Hierro and suggesting that Varane could become one of the club's great players. Pro-Real newspaper Marca even named Varane in their best ever foreign players XI alongside the likes of Zidane, Di Stefano and Ronaldo.

7. Mats Hummels (Borussia Dortmund & Germany)

The complete absence of a single player in either the FIFPro team or its reserve selection from Jurgen Klopp's Borussia Dortmund in a year in which the Ruhr Valley club were only beaten by the brilliant Bayern to both Bundesliga and Champions League titles seems odd. It is especially odd when you consider that the FIFPro team does contain two players from the Real Madrid side defeated by Dortmund in both the Champions League Group Stage and then again in the Semi-Final. While Real conceded 18 goals in their Champions League campaign, Dortmund let in just 14 and progressed one round further. If there is one reason for that better defensive record it's Mats Hummels, who, since being rejected by Bayern Munich at the age of 20, has gone on to establish himself as one of the most consistently excellent defensive players in the world. Strong in the tackle, Hummels is also an old fashioned libero in Franz Beckenbauer mould, capable of bringing the ball out of defence and starting attacks. En route to the Champions League Final last year, Hummels played 11 games in which he made 30 tackles (2.7 per game) and 117 clearances (10.6 per game). This compares favourably with the stats from the same competition from the FIFPro selection: Thiago Silva with 2 tackles and 5.7 clearances per game and Sergio Ramos with 2.9 tackles and 5.1 clearances per game. This year's competition, in which Dortmund topped a tough group with Arsenal and Napoli, has an even more marked difference with Hummels' 4.3 tackles per game compared to Ramos' 1.3 and Thiago Silva's 0.7.

Midfield

6. Bastian Schweinsteiger (Bayern Munich & Germany)

In a year that has seen the balance of power in world football switch from the Spanish league to the German, there must be a place in the team for the German Player of the Year. Last month FIFPro midfield selection Franck Ribery was beaten to this award by his Bayern Munich team-mate Bastian Schweinsteiger, an indication, perhaps, that the Bavarian central midfield player may also deserve Ribery's place in this team. While wingers and flair players like Ribery or Robben may be a more glamorous selection, it is Schweinsteiger (along with Lahm) who really makes both Bayern and the German national team tick. An incredibly hard working player in the middle of the park, "Schweini" has benefited greatly from switching from a wide role to the engine room and is now able to take control of a game. That was very much part of the reason for Bayern's utter dominance over Xavi and Barcelona in the Champions League. With 9 goals and 7 assists, 2012-13 was Schweinsteiger's best season for Bayern in terms of scoring and creating goals, but he offers much more than that in terms of his positioning and precise passing. The 2013-14 season has so far seen him make 83.6 passes per game with a hugely impressive 92% pass success rate.

5. Isco (Malaga, Real Madrid & Spain)

Another one of the leading lights of the current generation of German stars, Mesut Ozil, made the FIFPro reserve team and his transfer from Real Madrid to Arsenal has transformed a team that struggled for 4th place last year into the Premier League leaders. Why, then, would the Madrilenos let a player of his calibre go? The answer lies in Francisco Roman Alarcon Suarez, better known as Isco. If there is, rightly, some concern that Xavi and Iniesta may not for much longer be the unstoppable force of tiki-taka that they once were, fans of the Spanish national team can take heart in the emergence of a midfield talent of this quality. 2013 saw Isco make his debut for the national team, while at the same time being the stand-out player at the European Under-21 Championship, which Spain won and in which Isco was second top scorer with three goals from midfield. Beginning the year with Manuel Pellegrini's Malaga, Isco's skill and vision saw the club progress through the knockout stages in their first ever Champions League, with the young midfielder scoring a goal that helped eliminate Porto and put Malaga through to the Quarter-Finals. Joining Real in August, Isco marked his debut with a goal and an assist in a 2-1 win over Real Betis and has become an immediate fixture in the first team. In the first half of the season he has already played 25 games in all competitions, scoring 8 times and picking up 5 assists.

4. Gareth Bale (Tottenham Hotspur, Real Madrid & Wales)

There was a bit of an odd backlash against Gareth Bale after his world record transfer to Real Madrid - a suggestion that the Southampton Academy graduate was in no way deserving of being the world's most valuable player, that he was overrated and overexposed. However, it doesn't take much observation of the quality of his performances throughout the year for both Tottenham and Real to disprove that. With the former left back gradually moving further and further up the pitch, 2012-13 saw a player who had never previously hit double figures for Premier League goals in a season score 21 in 33 games, easily more than Spurs' recognised strikers. These weren't ordinary tap ins either, with multiple Goal of the Month awards a testament to Bale's ability to carve goals out of situations that other players couldn't. Only his new team-mate and Ballon d'Or winner Cristiano Ronaldo had previously won the PFA Player of the Year, Young Player of the Year and the FWA Player of the Year awards all in the same season. Any further need for indication of just how single handedly he was responsible for Spurs' form last season is clear in how, despite spending an inordinate amount trying to replace him, they have struggled this season. Bale, meanwhile, has impressively set about proving the doubters wrong in Madrid. His hat-trick against Real Valladolid featured goals with both feet and his head, something of a counter argument to those who view him as too one-footed. Now with 10 goals in 20 games for the Meringues, Bale is continuing to impress as 2014 begins.

Forwards

3. Neymar (Santos, Barcelona & Brazil)

The FIFPro shortlist, and the eventual team selection, was predictably Europe focused. There is, however, one exceptional player who played at least some of 2013 outside of Europe. Neymar began the year with his boyhood club Santos, scoring 12 times in 18 games in the Sao Paulo state championship, before making the move to Europe with his transfer to Barcelona. Since joining Barcelona, Neymar has netted 11 times in 26 appearances and you get the impression that he's only just settling in. A superb performance against Celtic in the Champions League last month saw him tear the Glaswegian club apart and score three times in Barca's 6-1 win. More games like that and he could eventually rival Lionel Messi as the team's star. His best performances have been for the biggest occasions, though, proving the key man in the first Clasico of the season as he scored the opener and set up Alexis Sanchez's winner in Barca's 2-1 league win over Real. Neymar really deserves a place in the team, however, for his performances for Brazil in the build up to the world's greatest football nation hosting the World Cup. With the Confederations Cup the only even vaguely noteworthy international competition this year, there was a chance to show how the rest of the world had caught up with the previously dominant Spanish. With a dominant 3-0 win over the World Champions at the Maracana, Brazil established themselves among the World Cup favourites. Neymar's goal in the final added to three more he'd scored in the tournament. More than that, though, it was clear to anyone that, against Spain or anyone else, he was the best performer on the pitch, winning the Golden Ball for Player of the Tournament.

2. Arjen Robben (Bayern Munich & Netherlands)

In his time at both Chelsea and Real Madrid, Arjen Robben often proved a frustrating presence. Indisputably talented, Robben's arrogance, selfishness with the ball and inability to see beyond his own part of the game meant that he was far from a team player. At the current best team in the world, however, Robben seems to have found more of a place for his talents. His link up play with Lahm and fast paced incisive runs, cutting in from the right wing onto his left foot to release a powerful shot, have been key in Bayern's rise to the top of world football. In the Champions League Final it was Robben that made the difference between the two teams. Robben's assist for Mario Mandzukic gave Bayern the lead and then it was his impressive winning goal in the 89th minute that won them the day. After the game Robben picked up a well deserved Man of the Match award. As the star of the year's biggest game, Robben is well qualified for a place in any Team of the Year. Meanwhile, if anything, this season has seen the Dutch winger step his performance up another level under new manager Pep Guardiola. Already in just 19 games in all competitions Robben has banged in 13 goals, his total for all of last season.

1. Robert Lewandowski (Borussia Dortmund & Poland)

Finally, then, we come to the centre forward. The FIFPro team selected Zlatan Ibrahimovic in this position. But, however successful Ibrahimovic's scoring record for PSG over the last year has been, Borussia Dortmund's Robert Lewandowski has been just as good. In 2012-13 Ibrahimovic managed 35 goals in 46 games, while Lewandowski netted 36 in 49. It's also worth remembering the higher standard of opposition that Dortmund were facing while Lewandowski scored these goals. In the UEFA coefficient that ranks the quality of national competitions, Germany was top for 2012-13 with France equal fifth alongside Portugal. As a result, Lewandowski's goals can be seen as a greater achievement. Nowhere is this more apparent than in Lewandowski's superb Champions League campaign. While Ibrahimovic's three goals helped PSG make the Quarter-Finals, Lewandowski scored 10 in a run that saw him propel his team into the final. His performance in the Semi-Final against a highly fancied Real Madrid team was one of the best individual games of any player, becoming the first man ever to score four times in a Champions League semi as Dortmund won 4-1. His recent agreement to sign with Bayern Munich at the end of the season should make opposition defences very worried indeed as he teams up with the likes of Ribery, Robben and former Dortmund team-mate Mario Gotze. Which players do you think should have made the FIFA World Team of the Year? Share your picks below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

Loves ghost stories, mysteries and giant ape movies