Man Utd 1-2 Swansea: FA Cup Player Ratings

Swansea made history by winning at Old Trafford thanks to Wayne Routledge's early chip and a late Wilfried Bony header. Manchester United fell at the first FA Cup hurdle despite Javier Hernandez scoring as substitute Fabio was sent off. Defeat for the Red Devils €“ their fifth at home in all competitions this term €“ increases the pressure on David Moyes. United are still in the Capital One Cup, but look short of strength to defend their Premier League title and make a big splash in the Champions League. Wayne Rooney joined a lengthy injury list for the hosts as Moyes made six changes from the home loss to Tottenham Hotspur on New Year's Day. Defenders Nemnaja Vidic and Patrice Evra were rested completely whilst Michael Carrick, David De Gea and Adnan Janzuaj dropped to the bench. The Red Devils handed rare starts to Anders Lindegaard, Rio Ferdinand and Alex Buttner at the back. Shinji Kagawa, Hernandez and Darren Fletcher also came into the XI. Swans manager Michael Laudrup rotated his fullbacks in two of five alterations to the home defeat by Manchester City last time out. Ashley Williams and Jose Canas also dropped to substitutes. Winger Pablo Hernandez missed this match through injury. Jordi Amat, Leon Britton, Alejandro Pozuelo, Neil Taylor and Dwight Tiendalli got run-outs here. But who impressed the WhatCulture sports team? Click next to read our player ratings starting with United.

Man Utd

Anders Lindegaard: Got something on Routledge's chip, but fault for conceding the opener is squarely at the central defenders' door. Similarly, he could do nothing about the winner. Had little else to do here, but let down badly by the back four in front of him. 5/10. Chris Smalling: Got up from right back well enough, but desperately needs to work on his crossing. Moved infield to centre half for the last 15 minutes due to Ferdinand's injury and did not do well on the near post for Bony's winner. 4/10. Rio Ferdinand: Red Devils stand in skipper failed to cut out Pozuelo's ball to Routledge. Injured in a coming together with Bony and limped off disconsolate. You wonder how many more outings he will have. 4.5/10. Jonny Evans: Caught out for the Swansea opener too. Moyes favours the Northern Irishman and he did keep Bony quiet for long spells until the Ivorian found easier prey. 5/10. Alex Buttner: Best of a bad bunch in the United defence. Put in delicious deliveries from the left in the first half and one of those was the assist for Hernandez's leveller. 5.5/10. Antonio Valencia: Ecuador captain blazed over at 1-1, but that apart kept quiet by Swans left back Taylor. Subbed. 4.5/10. Darren Fletcher: Energetic in midfield and had to drop in at right back when Fabio saw red. His performance is the only substantial positive to come out of this game for Moyes. 5.5/10. Tom Cleverley: Upstaged by Fletcher €“ a player who has spent over a year sidelined. That speaks volumes about Cleverley. A second half free kick hit the wall. That was the only thing of note he did. 3.5/10. Shinji Kagawa: Never provided any real width on the left. Playing narrow, but industry alone does not win games of football. 5/10. Danny Welbeck: An afternoon where nothing really came off this versatile forward. 4.5/10. Javier Hernandez: Poached an equalizer made by Buttner to end his goal drought. Had very little supply otherwise. 5.5/10. Subs: Adnan Januzaj: Talented teenager got half an hour, but rarely saw the ball. 4.5/10. Fabio: Had to come on for the last 15 minutes when Ferdinand got injured. Only on pitch a matter of moments though as Brazilian fullback was sent off for a studs-showing challenge on Canas. 2/10. Click next for Swansea player ratings.

Swansea

Gerhard Tremmel: Never had a save of note to make. 5/10. Dwight Tiendalli: Failed to stop the supply coming down the United left for Hernandez's goal. Booked for dissent. 4/10. Chico Flores: Asleep to Chicharito's movement for the equalizer and the predatory Hernandez punished that. Not, as the BT commentators kept suggesting, the best player on the pitch for Swansea. Booked for foul on Hernandez. 4.5/10. Jordi Amat: Booked for a foul on Hernandez, but Welbeck was kept very quiet. 5/10. Neil Taylor: Got back at Valencia to turn his cross behind just before the hour mark on the most notable instance of keeping the United winger on the fringes of this one. 6/10. Leon Britton: Diminutive pass master worked his magic in midfield today. Ensures United had long spells without the ball. 6.5/10. Jonathan De Guzman: Freed up to play further forward for the last 25 minutes by Canas's introduction. Fluid as he played central midfield, out on the right and then in an attacking role later on. Subbed. 6/10. Alejandro Pozuelo: Assisted Routledge's goal with a lovely reverse pass, but did not track back to stop Buttner. 5.5/10. Jonjo Shelvey: Like Cleverley this English central midfielder rather let the game pass him by. He never once fed Bony. Subbed. 4/10. Wayne Routledge: Our man of the match. Chipped Lindegaard to give visitors the lead after leaving the Red Devils centre backs for dead. Winger then assisted Bony's winner. The most influential player in determining the outcome. 7.5/10. Wilfried Bony: Had very little service, but did not take up good positions. Only thing of note he did was get in a tangle with Rio Ferdinand until he headed in a near post winner. Jury very much still out on the Ivorian striker despite his key contribution here. 6/10. Subs: Jose Canas: Played 25 minutes in place of ineffectual Shelvey. On the end of a studs showing challenge from Fabio that resulted in a sending off. Settled into midfield well. 5.5/10. Alvaro Vazquez: Thrown on for five minutes by Laudrup when United were down to ten men. Rating N/A. Who was your man of the match? Have your say below.

Contributor
Contributor

Jamie Clark is a qualified Web Journalist after undergoing professional training at the University of Sheffield. A prolific and accredited sports writer, he also enjoys classic comedy, historic fiction, 80s music and heritage.