Manchester United can still win the Premier League. That's the opinion of legendary former manager Sir Alex Ferguson, speaking yesterday at one of many Q&A sessions at a sold-out Lowry Theatre in Salford. To many, this is a statement that pangs of fervent loyalty to the club he so heroically served for a quarter of a century. For surely there is no way United can retain their title. The Red Devils have made their worst start to a Premier League season ever and their worst start to any league season since 1989. Defeats against Liverpool, Manchester City and West Brom, coupled with draws against Chelsea and Southampton have left the champions eighth, and eight points off the pace of leaders Arsenal. If manager David Moyes had been hoping for anything remotely close to a smooth transition after replacing Ferguson, he hasn't gotten it, and has yet to win over certain sections of the Old Trafford support. A poor pre-season mixed with a poor summer transfer window have proven costly for the Reds, while their rivals have strengthened in key areas. All of which, as we explain here, means United will not retain their title this season. Here are 5 reasons why.
5. An Ageing Back Line
Three of Manchester United's first choice back four are over the age of 31. Rio Ferdinand, Nemanja Vidic and Patrice Evra are still proving to be a big part of United's defence this season under David Moyes despite all being shadows of their former selves. With a combined age of 98, is it really any coincidence that together, they have marshalled a backline this season that has conceded more goals (12) than any side currently in the top 10? Of the sides currently above the relegation zone, only Newcastle in 11th place have let in more goals (16) than the defending champions this season. Title defences are built from the back as much as they are from the forward line and the Red Devils just can't seem to keep a clean sheet these days - they haven't kept a shut-out in the league since September 14, a run of five matches. It's perhaps little wonder then that Moyes tried to bring in defensive reinforcements over the summer in Leighton Baines and even Fabio Coentrao, which brings us to...
4. Inactivity In The Transfer Window
...A woeful period of inactivity in the transfer window. Following the retirement of Sir Alex Ferguson and the appointment of David Moyes, the former Everton boss had an opportunity to bring in new players and stamp his own authority on the side. Instead, he has inherited a squad from Ferguson that has been on its last legs for a number of years now and whom only won trophies due to Ferguson's uncanny knack to milk the best out of them, and has barely added to it. United have been screaming out for reinforcements for years. A new left-back to cover for the and one day replace the ageing Evra, a new centre-back to do the same for Ferdinand and Vidic, and a creative midfielder have been on many supporter's wishlists for ages. Instead, only Marouane Fellaini came in. Not exactly the creative dynamo fans had hoped for, nor even the rock-solid, assured defensive midfielder he was at Everton since switching Merseyside for Manchester - so far at least. Moyes has an opportunity to make amends in January and strengthen the side and welcome in the much-needed cavalry, and if he doesn't, this is going to be a painful next seven months for the Red Devils.
3. A Shocking Midfield
Michael Carrick aside, this is one of the poorest Manchester United midfields I have ever seen. New signing Marouane Fellaini has thus far failed to replicate the form he enjoyed at Everton last season, where he was the club's top goalscorer, while Tom Cleverley has taken a giant step backwards. Once heralded as the future of both United, and England's midfield, there are very few who hold such optimism for the 24-year-old these days. With Paul Scholes gone and Ryan Giggs surely in his final season as a player, this is a United midfield that has been stripped down to the bones and one that is finding itself too ruthlessly exposed. Against Manchester City, United were swept away with consummate ease in the middle of the park, batted away like an annoying fly by the marauding Yaya Toure. And, creatively, there's no spark, with Moyes's men finding it increasingly difficult to unpick opposition's defences. Top of the table as things stand are Arsenal, boasting arguably the best Premier League midfielder in their ranks in Mesut Ozil. And that's the difference between the two sides right now.
2. Lack Of Quality In Wide Areas
As well as being light on quality in the middle of the park, United also look pretty desperate in the wide areas, too. Sir Alex Ferguson's Manchester United always attacked with width, but too many wide men have lost form since then for that to work as an effective strategy for David Moyes. Ashley Young has been dreadful all season, the worst player on the pitch in the 4-1 humiliation at the hands of Manchester City, and still failing to live up to the hype that surrounded his move from Aston Villa two years ago. Antonio Valencia, sadly, has been a shadow of his former self ever since suffering a horror leg break against Rangers in September 2010, and the less said about Nani, the better. The Portuguese is far too lightweight, was easily shoved off the ball against Stoke, and always contrives to waste chances from set-pieces. United's wingers are in a period of total disarray and there isn't one exception to that statement.
1. David Moyes
Much of the reason why United won't retain their title however is David Moyes himself. Sure, an ageing, creaking defence, a lack of creativity in central midfield and a total lack of quality on the wings aren't helping, but it is Moyes's inexperience in title races that will ultimately prove costly. The Scot has never been in a title race before, and unlike his contemporaries Jose Mourinho, Manuel Pellegrini and Arsene Wenger, has never won a championship. The Community Shield back in August is the single piece of silverware Moyes has ever lifted in a 15-year managerial career, and it is this absence of top-level experience that is going to hinder United this season. Predecessor Sir Alex Ferguson had the nous and canny wit to outfox rivals in the latter stages of the Premier League, when dropping points becomes really costly, and that's something Moyes, crucially, lacks. Disagree? Can Man Utd still win the title this season? Let us know in the comment section, below.
Joseph is an accredited football journalist and has interviewed nearly all of the current 20 Barclay's Premier League managers. He is also a correspondent for Bleacher Report and has written for Caught Offside and Give Me Football.