Man Utd Transfers: 10 Talented Players Who Utterly Failed At Old Trafford

When good prospects go bad.

When you think of Manchester United, you think of a club with a rich history of trophies, glory and some of the best players to ever grace a football pitch: Beckham, Scholes, Keane, Yorke, Van Nistelrooy, Cantona, Ronaldo, Rooney. The list of stars who came and conquered at the illustrious club is as memorable as the goals and performances that lead to those successes. On the way to the club becoming the most important in Premier League history, transfer fee records have been continually shattered with reckless abandon, in order to capture the upcoming stars or the best players in the world and turn them into United greats and continue the culture of winning. Sometimes, those expensive gambles paid off and United reaped the benefits on the pitch, but inevitably, that was not always the case, and it wasn't always down to players simply being terrible. After all, anybody given the heady accolade of a United squad number must have impressed the scouts or the manager at some stage, so their problems on the pitch must have been down to something else entirely - whether because they were signed at the wrong time, for the wrong system, or just weren't up to the pressures of the Premier League and the Theatre of Dreams. There are many United flops who shouldn't have been signed in the first place, but they aren't as interesting as the ones who looked promising and utterly failed to live up to their billing, which is precisely the unlikely lot we're looking at.

10. Gabriel Obertan

The French winger arrived at Old Trafford following the departure of Cristiano Ronaldo to Real Madrid - hardly an easy act to follow for any player, never mind for a relatively unknown Ligue 1 youngster with little experience. However, Obertan had bags of potential having starred for Bordeaux in the previous season before arriving at United: he was versatile enough to play on the wing, in an attacking midfield position as well as up front and possessed bags of skill and tricks with a football, just like Cristiano. Almost at least. His talent was demonstrated briefly in a red shirt, as he set up a few goals and showed his footwork ability, but he spectacularly failed to light up the wings consistently, and ultimately the former France youth player managed 14 Premier League appearances for United, with just one goal coming in the Champions League against Bursaspor. Perhaps too much pressure was thrust onto his young shoulder, but Obertan failed to become a United anything, let alone a great and moved to Newcastle United in 2011, where he fails to regularly feature in the first team to continue his Premier League woe.

9. Paul Pogba

To be fair on Pogba, it wasn't his fault at all that he failed to display his talent at Manchester United. That talent was obvious, as highlighted beautifully when he scored what has been described as a 'piledriver' against Portsmouth in the FA Youth Cup. The French wonderkid starred in United's youth system and became an integral part of an under-18s squad, which won the 2011 Youth Cup. He was called up to the first team at the start of the 2011-12 season by Sir Alex Ferguson, playing in the reserves before making his first team appearance against Leeds United in the League Cup. Following that, Pogba was only given the chance to show his ability four more times before upping sticks and moving to Juventus after being offered £20,000 a week. Sir Alex initially had too little faith in Pogba's potential brilliance, which is mind-blowing given his credentials at spotting talent and Pogba left under a cloud, having felt 'disrespected,' and is now worth an estimated £60million and could potentially be one of the world's best midfielders after starring for France at the recent World Cup. It is thought that United are interested in bringing the midfielder back to Old Trafford for another go, no doubt for a monumental salary and bonuses galore, but they will always be haunted by their failure to recognise his talent straight away.

8. Alan Smith

An extremely passionate Leeds United player, Alan Smith won the 'Supporter's Player of the Year' award two years running in 2003 and 2004 at the Yorkshire club before it imploded. His goal tally wasn't brilliant for a striker, but his willingness to give his all and his determination meant he was an excellent squad player and that clearly caught the eye of Sir Alex Ferguson. But then, Smith went from hero to villain when he signed for bitter rivals Manchester United for £7million at the end of the 2004 season. As a striker, he scored ten goals in his first season, but when Wayne Rooney and Van Nistelrooy are your positional competition, not many players would stand a chance in getting a regular first team place, and he found himself quickly relegated to the bench, where his passion for football seemed to evaporate before his very eyes. For some reason, Sir Alex then tried him in midfield as the 'new Roy Keane,' but that failed miserably, and unfortunately for Smith and for Newcastle United (who later signed him) the tactical tinkering meant he was never really sure how to play in either position any more. Ultimately, after an injury-laden few years, including months out with a horrendous broken leg cause by a rifling free kick from Liverpool left-back John Arne Riise, Smith failed to recapture the passion and talent he had shown at Elland Road, and left for Tyneside after just three years.

7. Eric Djemba-Djemba

This wouldn't be a list of Manchester United flops without possibly the most famous of all - Eric Djemba-Djemba - and it really isn't a simple case of saying he was just too poor to play for them. The Cameroonian footballer showed plenty of talent and promise at French club Nantes - and clearly enough to attract interest from Manchester United at least, for whom he was purchased for £3.5million as a future replacement for the 31-year-old Roy Keane. No pressure then. He was considered a feisty and fearless player with a great tackling ability, but all Premier League fans and players saw was a relentless, aggressive player who fouled anything and everything with comical over-enthusiasm. His form was atrociously inconsistent, and whilst he has passion, he demonstrated it in all of the wrong ways. After disappointing, Djemba-Djemba was shipped off to Aston Villa, where he also failed before moving to several other clubs including in Qatar, Hapoel Tel Aviv and Partizan. Most recently he turned up playing for St Mirren last season, with the hope that his performances would earn him a place in Cameroon's World Cup squad but somewhat inevitably was released after making just two appearances for the Scottish side.

6. Ashley Young

The former Aston Villa winger had an explosive first couple of months for United, earning a man of the match award and creating numerous assists as well as bagging a couple of brilliant goals, but the former Watford man - who was signed for a fee thought to be between £15-£20million - quickly failed to maintain his performances. An injury kept him out of action for a few months and he returned a different player, seemingly far more frail and diving at almost every opportunity. He was a brilliant player at Villa and seemed to be England's answer to that ever-elusive left wing problem, but he couldn't keep up his performances at Old Trafford, and he has faded into another nearly man. Young probably won't be a United player for much longer, as it's hard to see a place for him in Louis Van Gaal's new-look side following his sketchy form over the past three years. The England winger was recently mocked by Manchester United fans for posting a tweet about United's opening game against Swansea. A number of Red Devils fans calmly let Young know that he may no longer be at the club come the opening day.

5. Anderson

Brazilian midfielder Anderson arrived at Old Trafford with bags of potential and promise from Portuguese side Porto: he came billed with excellent passing ability and was thought to be strong in the air and at just 19, he had the potential to become a great player for a long time at Old Trafford. United had so much faith in him that they doggedly appealed for his work permit application, which had failed, to be accepted due to his exceptional talent and the size of the transfer fee - £20million - which made him the second most expensive Brazilian player (behind Kleberson of all people) and giving him a lot to live up to. Anderson was given numerous chances to justify a first team place at Manchester United, but he failed to make the grade, with just five goals in 104 appearances, and again it doesn't seem like he'll be a United player for much longer. He was poor at tackling and overall looked lost in a sea of talented United players with accusations perpetually following him that he was overweight and under-motivated. He went on loan to Serie A side Fiorentina last season but a more permanent move away from Old Trafford seems more than likely this season.

4. Juan Sebastian Veron

The most expensive flop in Manchester United history, Veron had all the makings of a great player with so much talent, but it all failed to materialize. He was a great passer of the ball from the centre of midfield, and he could find space whenever he wanted to and was a strong player, which is exactly the ability that saw him attract United's attention, and plaudits as one of the most talented midfielders in the world at the time. United paid through the nose for his services, but it was £28.1million down the drain, which at the time made him the most expensive transfer in English football history and ended with him becoming the most expensive flop in history. Veron failed to adapt to the fast-paced English game and seemingly lost the ball every time he got it, looking powerless and lost as games regularly passed him by. Sir Alex stuck by the Argentianian, calling him a 'f*****g great player,' and though he hasn't been wrong many times, this time he got it monumentally incorrect. Veron was sold to Premier League rivals Chelsea for £17million in a move which seemed to cut United's losses (though the fact that they got that much for him is incredible). He played a little better in a blue shirt, but still failed before moving back to Italy and Argentina into football obscurity to be forgotten by all United fans.

3. Bebe

Bebe was a monumental gamble from Sir Alex Ferguson, who had unbelievably never seen him play after he was recommended to him by his assistant Carlos Quieroz, and unfortunately it turned out to be a colossal mistake from the seasoned boss. The former homeless boy from Lisbon was signed just five weeks after signing for Vitoria, where he scored five goals in six games, and he's now one of the poorest footnotes on Ferguson's illustrious career. The £7.4million gamble which United had paid didn't pay off at all: Bebe trained with the first team and was even a part of the 25-man Champions League squad, making just two Premier League appearances in a United shirt and the over-riding feeling from all sides was that he was obviously well below the standard of a Manchester United player. It was too much too young for the Portuguese striker as his goalscoring touch seemed virtually non-existent. The former Vitoria player has been on loan to three other clubs since signing and actually showed a bit of promise whilst at Portuguese First Division club Pacos De Ferreira, scoring 14 goals. He has now been signed to Benfica, where he can only hope to rebuild is poor reputation caused by his failure to deal with the United pressure.

2. Nani

The tricky Portuguese winger occasionally justified his monumental £17million pricetag, but sketchy form and inconsistent performances has cause him to become a United flop. He arrived from Porto in 2007 to join compatriot Cristiano Ronaldo at Old Trafford full of hope that he could emulate his teammate's performances in a Manchester United shirt. Nani had a decent couple of seasons for United to begin with, but that all fell through when Ronaldo left, and the weight of expectation fell with a large thud upon the bit-part midfielder's shoulders. Again, he sometimes showed glimpses of exceptional talent, but these became rare, which is unnacceptable at Manchester United. He often loses the ball and shoots from unfathomable distances, and his dribbling skills have declined incredibly. He signed a new contract last year, but he may not be a United player much longer with speculation of a move away from the club, with Premier League rivals Arsenal thought to be interested and Louis Van Gaal deeming him surplus to requirements. Nani threatened to become one of the best wingers in world football, but his talent never came to fruition.

1. Marouane Fellaini

Panic buy? Fall guy? Simply never good enough? David Moyes brought Marouane Fellaini with him from Everton for a fee of £27.5million in a last-minute deadline day deal after the Belgian had been brilliant under the Scotsman, dominating play in midfield and helping the club perform brilliantly in the league. But Manchester United was a completely different proposition for both Fellaini and Moyes. Expectation can be a powerful impediment, and at United the big-haired midfielder looked clumsy, frequently losing the ball and failing spectacularly to be the formidable force in the air he was for the Toffees and looked completely uncomfortable in the United midfield. He made just 16 appearances in the his first season at United, and was named in The Daily Telegraph's '10 Worst Buys of the Premier League Season.' The central midfield role is an important one at Manchester United, and whilst hardly any of United's players performed this season, Fellaini seemed to stick out like a sore thumb and not just because of his hair, which rather unfortunately seemed the appropriate clownish crown as he fluffed his lines again and again. Rumour has it that the Belgian looks set to join Napoli on loan - with a view to a £15m permanent deal later - a brilliant price given his awful performances for the Red Devils last season and the club will be lucky to be getting over half of what they paid for the midfield flop. Which other talented players flopped at United? Share your own picks below in the comments thread below.

Contributor
Contributor

Journalism and English graduate from Northumbria University. Now a freelance sports journalist. Nottingham Forest fan. Owner of beard.