Man Utd: Worst Ever Premier League 11

veron Manchester United have been the dominant force in the English Premier League ever since its origin in 1993. They have set the standard for consistency, stability and maintaining a persistently strong squad of players with a togetherness and unbreakable winning mentality. The Red Devils are often very determined to ensure that only the best will ever pull on the famous shirt, as it is rightly considered to be the shirt of champions. However, every now and again, a player will bear all the outward signs that he fits into the mould of greatness, only on further examination looked more out of place than Victoria Beckham at an all-you-can-eat buffet. The most successful club in the history of the EPL, it would be remarkable to consider that a team that has finished at least third in every season of the last twenty years will have signed a few no-hopers into their squad. Even the great and celebrated Sir Alex Ferguson got it wrong occasionally, and whilst he more than made up for a few lost millions on a clueless signing with a truckload of medals and trophies, it at least gave the rest of the country a chance to mock the greatest team to compete in the competition. The trouble with playing at Manchester United of all clubs is that as soon as a player enters the club, one's expectations of his ability skyrocket. Players that have succeeded at the club have thrived on the expectation to do well and do not show the fear to disappoint; these players had that fear branded on their faces. A number of these players had successful career records prior their arrival at United, and others went on to great things once they left. But, their time at Old Trafford seemingly left them like a herd of deer in front of a fleet of Range Rovers.

Goalkeeper: Massimo Taibi

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=esFAGx7RDL4 If we are being honest, if there is one role that can be considered the perennial problem position of Manchester United, it is goalkeeper. In the two decades that they have ruled the roost in the Premier League, they have had a total of two world class keepers - Peter Schmeichel and Edwin van der Sar. Surrounding these two are a number of players that were brought in to fill the void left by these two legends, only to disappoint the fans hungry for success. Schmeichel in particular seemed to be succeeded by a string of poor quality shot-stoppers, as if he had left a curse in between the sticks. Players like Ricardo, Roy Carroll, Mark Bosnich and even World Cup winner Fabian Barthez all couldn't hold a candle to the Great Dane. But none live as long in the memory for all the wrong reasons than Massimo Taibi. Arriving from Venezia for £4.5 million, he was an experienced Italian goalkeeper that appeared to be competent and consistent when push came to shove. He was competing for the No.1 shirt in the first year post-Schmeichel against an overweight Bosnich and out-of-favour Raimond van der Gouw. And his first performance proved to be his best, as despite being at fault for a Sami Hyypia headed goal, a string of fine saves saw him earn Man of the Match in the victory over Liverpool. However, it can be fair to say that it all went downhill from there, and remarkably quickly. In his third outing against Southampton, late in the game Matt le Tissier hit a daisy-cutter of a shot straight at Taibi. He immediately pounced on the ball, getting his entire body to block the ball trickling into the goal. Except the gap between his legs, as the ball somehow squirmed under him and found the back of the net. It is one of, if not the most, replayed goalkeeping blunders in history. When he followed up this performance in the woeful 5-0 defeat against Chelsea where he looked all at sea and petrified of catching the ball. These two performances were a glaring blip on an otherwise strong career, where Taibi showed he had elements of Schmeichel when he became one of only two goalkeepers to score in Serie A from open play. However, the unfortunate truth is that his legacy at United is one of the worst of any keeper in the club's rich history.

Right-Back: Michael Clegg

Clegg The Manchester United youth team of the early 1990s was a fertile breeding ground for quality British players that would go on to become key fixtures in the first-team squad in their dominance of the Premier League title race. When Alan Hansen famously suggested that the club would win nothing with kids, players such as Paul Scholes, David Beckham, Nicky Butt, Gary and Phil Neville all were able to roll up their socks and show that they were both good enough and old enough to take on the best the league could offer in opposition. Oh, and how could I forget the influence of Michael Clegg? Never heard of him either? Quite frankly, nobody would blame you. Following his part in the 1995 FA Youth Cup victory, Clegg would turn professional at Manchester United, deciding that he would fight for his place in a squad filled with strong, consistent defenders. This decision would prove to be misguided, as in his eight years under contract at the club he played 24 games, nine of those in the Premier League. It is not as though Clegg was a bad player, but it would be easier to leave him off of this list if he hadn't stayed for so long, as it made him appear as someone desperate to make his mark at the club, and consistently coming up short at every chance he made. Simply put, he was not good enough for the club and should not have held a wage there for as long as he did, and following two more years at Oldham Athletic, he retired from football aged only 27.

Left-Back: Quinton Fortune

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w3kCNk-nhWA The South African Quinton Fortune is an example of a player that was adequate enough, but could not live up to the expectations of Manchester United. Initially brought in by Ferguson from Athletico Madrid as cover for Ryan Giggs, Fortune proved to be versatile in a number of positions, probably because he was desperately looking for a way into the team. He was employed as on the left and in the centre of midfield, but his most prominent position was a left-back, and from his signing in 1999 to his departure in 2006, he made 126 appearances, scoring ten goals. It actually feels quite harsh to put Fortune on this list, because he was by no means a bad player. But, unfortunately, playing for United means that even being good is not enough to cement a place in the team. Frankly, during his stint at the club they won three Premier League titles, but in each of those seasons, he did not make enough appearances to merit a winners' medal. In the following years, he was able to make a few more appearances, but his misfortune was apparent as this was during a three-year barren spell from the title. Fortune was unlucky in that he was only ever good enough to make cover for the United first-team, and also being employed in a position that has seen some great players such as Denis Irwin, Mikael Silvestre and Patrice Evra.

Centre-Back 1: David May

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vZUrTKBSVm8 Perhaps the position that has seen the most consistently brilliant players for Manchester United in the Premier League is in the heart of defence. Though other players will grab the headlines through their goals and silky skills, United would not be the force that they are considered today without their rock solid back-line. From their first title victory with Steve Bruce and Gary Pallister, to the European influence of Jaap Stam and Laurent Blanc, to the recent forceful pair of Nemanja Vidic and Rio Ferdinand, the basis of United's success has always been the strength of their defenses. However, not all of their centre-backs were up to the correct standard, and David May is probably the most prolific of these. Signing for United from boyhood club Blackburn Rovers in 1994 after playing a significant role in Blackburn's promotion to the Premier League and their challenge for the title, May was brought for a number of reasons. He had proven to be competent and reliable, long-term centre-back Bruce was approaching the twilight of his career, and the club needed to sign English players to ensure that they didn't break restrictions for playing in Europe. Due to the strong partnership of Bruce and Pallister, May was employed mainly as a right-back, but his less than impressive performances contributed towards United losing the title to his former employers, and the fast-tracking of Gary Neville into the first-team squad. In spite of this lacklustre start to his Manchester career, he was able to establish himself in the first-team in the next two seasons with the departure of Bruce, scoring a crucial goal in United's final game of the 1995/96 season and playing in the FA Cup Final victory against Liverpool. However, unfortunate timing of injuries and the signings of Stam, Henning Berg and the growth of Wes Brown limited his chances of return to the first-team. He played in the 1999 FA Cup Final, but only because the club was resting its main stars for the upcoming Champions League Final. May exuberantly celebrated the European victory, despite not playing a single minute of the campaign, and led many United fans to grow attached to May, taunting opposition fans by saying that even he had won more medals than Alan Shearer. As the final four years at the club saw him play a grand total of twelve more games for the club, and he left for Burnley in 2003. A testament to his reserve status at the club is demonstrated by his two Premier League winners' medals, despite being a squad member for six triumphs.

Centre-Back 2: William Prunier

William_Prunier When one types into your preferred Internet search engine "Worst ever United signing", William Prunier is one of the most prominent results that would appear. Whilst I have decided to add him to this team of misfits due to the strength of anti-Prunier feeling among United fans, it is fair to say that he wasn't really given much of a chance by the fans. Signed on trial for the 1995/96 season, he was forced into the first team due to a defensive injury crisis. Bruce, Pallister and May were all out of action, and Prunier was drafted like a naive teenager for front line warfare, and unsurprisingly, the Frenchman went missing in action. Though his first match against QPR was a generally good performance for the player, it is following fixture versus Tottenham that really demonstrated his unsuitability for the job he had been selected for. With the entire preferred back-line injured, including Schmeichel in goal, a makeshift and inexperienced defence were cut to ribbons by Spurs, with the final result of 4-1. Despite the injuries and other players around him not exactly playing at their peak, Prunier was chiefly singled out as a target for abuse, and despite being offered a trial extension by Sir Alex, he wisely decided to close this brief chapter of his career and decided to attempt a revival of his career at FC Copenhagen. A player that is lambasted and considered one of the worst in United history for a single performance, it is certainly unlucky for Prunier that he joined the club when he did, or it could have been a completely different story.

Right-Midfield: Bebe

Bebe The only player on this list that is still under contract at the club, Bebe is one of the more expensive flops that Sir Alex brought to Manchester United. Seemingly desperate to secure the services of this player despite him having little experience or widespread reputation, they paid Vitória de Guimarães £7.4 million, after he had only signed for that club five weeks earlier. Ferguson seemingly had very little knowledge of the player, only having met him the day before he signed. But, chief executive David Gill firmly stated that Bebe would stay with the first-team squad rather than get experience on loan, and he was placed in the Champions League squad for 2010. He played for the club mostly in the cup competitions against lower-league opposition, and has so far in his United career played in two Premier League games. This has raised numerous questions from United fans, such as "Who is this guy?" and "If this guy can get in the first team, when is it my turn?". Nothing particularly distinctive or impressive has come from his handful of appearances for the club, and the only real mention of Bebe in England revolves around his inability to settle in the country due to lack of support, or his disbelief that he is not a permanent component of the match-day squad. Now on loan back in Portugal, he has since displayed an interest in making that transition permanent, which would certainly not upset any United fans in the slightest. A fair number probably don't even realise he still plays for them, or that he signed in the first place.

Left-Midfield: Juan Sebastian Veron

veron There is a great deal that can be said about Juan Sebastian Veron's stint in the English Premier League, very little of it positive. He was very highly regarded for his time in Argentina and Italy, where he was the driving force behind Lazio's treble of 2000. This prompted Manchester United to break the bank to sign the talented Argentinian, with the transfer believed to be just shy of £30 million. Veron is part of an exclusive list of players to be signed for the club for that kind of money, alongside Wayne Rooney, Rio Ferdinand and Dimitar Berbatov. And it is fair to say he was the worst of those players. Frankly he is one of the worst United signings over £20 million, £10 million, or even £1 million. The slower, more methodically dull pace of the Italian League allowed Veron a considerable amount of space and time on the ball. This gave him opportunity to pick his passes and line-up his fearsome long-range efforts. In the Premier League, as soon as he saw the opposition goal, a defender had nipped the ball from under his feet and had launched the counter-attack. Veron was just too slow and rushed in the Premier League to be considered anywhere near as skilful or imposing as he did in Serie A. His first season aptly displayed this lack of speed, but the second season was considered his chance to show he had evolved and improved after a testing debut year. And he was able to show this by getting injured for the second-half of United's title winning 2002/03 season, just as he was getting some consistency. I guess if he was injured, at least he wouldn't be under-performing. He ended his career at United when he was transferred to Chelsea for £15 million, as they had only just come into the Abramovich money. Veron was essentially the equivalent of a golden-plated toilet seat bought by a lottery winner. United were probably astounded by the amount they recouped for a player that will go down as one of the most expensive flops in footballing history.

Centre-Midfield 1: Kleberson

kleberson When Manchester United were looking for some more midfield options after winning the Premier League in 2003, they couldn't really do any better than a World Cup winner. Kleberson played an integral role in Brazil's triumph in 2002 in the latter stages of the competition, and was attracting a great deal of attention from across Europe. Leeds attempted to sign him in 2002, but he refused to leave Brazil due to his girlfriend being unable to marry until she was sixteen (Kleberson incidentally was 23 at the time). Kleberson was signed as a replacement for the outgoing Juan Sebastian Veron, and both of their presences on this team displays that this must have been a seamless transition. Kleberson was anything but a World Cup winner at Manchester United, as after signing for over £6 million he was badly injured in his second appearance, and these injuries and inconsistent form meant that he only played twenty league games for the club. With a team of superstar midfielders, Kleberson simply wasn't able to make the grade. But, he could smugly look at United legends like Beckham and Scholes when he showed them his World Cup winners' medal.

Centre-Midfield 2: Eric Djemba-Djemba

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aefvaddanu0 With Sir Alex Ferguson preparing for the imminent retirement or nervous breakdown of captain Roy Keane in 2003, he splashed £6.5 million on a relatively unknown Cameroonian defensive midfielder in the form of Eric Djemba-Djemba. The move was immediately pounced upon as questionable by pundits and the media, as Djemba-Djemba had little experience or reputation, and were probably annoyed that they would have to write the same surname twice in newspapers. Fortunately, in his eighteen months at the club, he did very little that journalists would feel the need to report on. Djemba-Djemba was in the unfortunate position that he was at the club during a time of transition, where he was unable to get an unbroken run in the first team as Ferguson tested others as potential understudies for Keane, and was also unfortunate that his stint saw United take a break from winning the league championship. In big matches he had a tendency to go missing, lacking the same bite and influence as the Irishman, so it was decided that he would not be up for the challenge as he left for Aston Villa. He will mostly be remembered for his great goal against Leeds in the League Cup, and the expense that parents had to pay for the few fans that sought his name on the back of their replica shirts.

Striker 1: David Bellion

Bellion It is actually quite surprising that Manchester United, in their time, have had a number of poor strikers on their books, with the likes of Dong Fangzhuo, Mame Biram Diouf and Michael Owen not living up to the heroics of Mark Hughes, Andy Cole, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, Ruud Van Nistelrooy and most recently Robin Van Persie. However, David Bellion proved to be somewhat unique in being touted as the next Thierry Henry, but unfortunately his appearance proved to be deceiving. In fact in front of goal he was something more of a Bell-End. Signed from Sunderland amidst a alleged tapping-up scandal, Bellion scored two Premier League goals in his first season of the club, and by the time he left in 2006, he had managed to only double that achievement. Bellion was pacy, but was unable to display a killer instinct that would have complimented that speed effectively. His chances were limited when the club signed Wayne Rooney and Louis Saha, so he was loaned to West Ham to get some experience, only to find that he wasn't good enough to cement a first-team place there either. He soon returned to France having made little-to-know impact in Manchester, apart from a minor blip in the finances.

Striker 2: Diego Forlan

It seems unthinkable that Diego Forlan would be on this list of worst ever Manchester United players in the Premier League. However, on the flip side it could be said that when he left the club in 2004, if you were to say to anyone he would one day win the European Golden Boot Award, they would have told you to lay off those chunky homemade cigarettes. But Forlan, who has recently terrorised defenses across Spain and Brazil and has become Uruguay's second highest ever goalscorer, it was his time at United that proved to be the darkest spell in his career. Forlan signed for United after a successful time at Independiente, and with a large following in Europe after his prized signature, that came at a price of £7 million. The Red Devils beat the opposition to the punch as they so often do, and he joined a team that had just lost a prize partnership in Andy Cole and Dwight Yorke. The arrival of Forlan and Ruud Van Nistelrooy was deemed as the way to provide the same amount of goals, but unfortunately only one was able to deliver, and it was not Forlan. Forlan didn't score for the first eight months of his time at the club, although in fairness to him he was unlikely to get many chances in the close season. When he did score famously against Southampton, he was so unaccustomed to the feeling that he was unable to get his shirt back on after celebrating. He was unable to score in the prolific manner as Van Nistelrooy, Solskjaer, Saha or even midfielders like Giggs and Scholes. Simply put, as his duty to the club was essentially to score goals, it is a duty at which he failed, and that is the reason why he is a necessary component of this regrettable line-up. So that's my choices for the worst eleven. What are yours? Feel free to comment!

Contributor
Contributor

I am a British student currently studying at the University of York, and have a passionate interest in WWE, English football (soccer) and video gaming.