Manager Alan Pardew made a clear statement of his priorities this season ahead of the game, talking about how the Premier League and FA Cup are his two biggest concerns this season, followed by the Europa League and the League Cup, and his squad and team against Maritimo confirmed his sentiments. With the back four necessarily preserved from the Everton game thanks to limited options, Newcastle made huge changes from the Premier League fixture, bringing in back-up players like Romain Amalfitano, Gael Bigirimana and Shola Ameobi. It seems Pardew would not be testing his first-team to ensure the first European victory of his reign. And though some have openly criticised the club's supposed lack of ambition in fielding a weakened team for their trip to Maritimo's aging stadium, the decision to do so, and preserve the majority of the first team's midfield and attack ahead of Sunday's visit of Norwich City to St. James' Park, will be justified by a good result against former manager Chris Hughton's new team. Newcastle's treatment of the Europa League as a secondary concern might seem frivolous and frustrating to the fans who remember the "good old days" of European Competition at St. James' Park, but it is the right decision for this season. The way the transfer policy works, if the Magpies fail to finish strongly in the league, and bring European qualification again by the end of the season through that avenue, they face the prospct of losing their key squad members. And if that were to happen, no amount of moaning about not trying our best to win the Europa in the early stages will matter, even to those fans currently kicking up a fuss about it. Plainly, Newcastle cannot afford to over-extend what is a thin squad, and compromises have to be made, otherwise the fans and the club will face the prospect of the kind of league performance and squad condition that Stoke and Fulham have suffered in their own European campaigns recently. Short-term success is not an antidote to long-term stagnation, and league progress and stability is a far better prospect, even for a fan-base starved of silverware. Middlesbrough won the League Cup and almost won the UEFA Cup not long ago, after all.
2. A Draw Was Probably Fair
Newcastle hit the woodwork three times last night, and Shola Ameobi should probably have scored at least once, if not twice past a 'keeper who was apparently not too keen on leaving his goal-line, but Maritimo were impressive at times, and though they were reduced to a handful of long range efforts and one that Davide Santon saved off the line, they can be happy enough with their showing. With a striker who could have gotten on the end of their crosses, or offered a more killer outlet to their progressive passing game, the Portuguese side could well have hurt Newcastle, who were far less impressive in their build-up play, but were mostly wasteful when it came to the final moments of attack. All in all, the result was a fair reflection of what happened on the pitch, and the two teams put out, with Newcastle's better players being let down by some poor individual performances (Williamson and Obertan above all), and both sides thwarted in the six yard box - Maritimo by an impressive Rob Elliot, and Newcastle by the woodwork. Not a great deal to complain about really, though there will no doubt be an element of fans who will say that the first-team could have brushed Maritimo aside a lot easier. I'll refer those lot to the first point in this article.
3. Rob Elliot Proved His Worth
Since coming into Newcastle from Charlton from a relative pittance, and the collected ambivalence of the Newcastle faithful, Rob Elliot hasn't had much chance to show exactly why he is rated by manager Alan Pardew, fluffing his debut against Nottingham Forest in the League Cup last year, and generally sitting quietly in the background since then. But after a pre-season that saw him pull off a couple of reasonable performances, and the injury that has kept Tim Krul out recently, Elliot now has a chance as the current number 2 'keeper, and on last night's showing, he probably isn't as uninspiring an option as some might have previously suggested. On four occasions last night, Elliot proved his worth with a host of stops, with his hands and feet to keep Newcastle in the game, most notably with his first stop for which he had precious little time to prepare himself. Unfortunately his final major act of the game was to fudge what should have been a reasonably simple take into his chest, which on another day might have sneaked under him and into the net, but for the majority of the game, the former Charlton 'keeper looked good for his place in the side. His kicking was strong and mostly accurate, even under pressure, and his decision-making excellent, particularly when diving out at an attacker's feet at exactly the right moment to halt a potentially dangerous one-on-one situation. And while he won't be pushing Tim Krul too hard for the number 1 shirt he has today professed intention to claim his own, Elliot's stock as a back-up 'keeper has suddenly risen overnight.
4. Bigirimana Continues To Impress
Despite being one of the back-ups included in last night's game, Gael Bigirimana stood out as the best player on the park last night, again cementing his growing reputation as an excellent upcoming talent. In signing the former Coventry player for around £1m, Newcastle have again unearthed a gem for relatively very little cost, and it isn't hard to see why the Burundi national is drawing comparisons to team-mate Cheick Tiote despite his young age. Against Maritimo, Bigirimana rarely looked under pressure on the ball, turning confidently and passing well, and his yellow card was both unfair and ridiculous, given the drop-ball farce that had come before it. That tackle was well-timed and aggressive, without any malice, and the fact that the referee chose to penalise it for being from behind, despite it being perfectly safe, is a worrying indictment of what we can expect to see increasingly as the game moves away from being full contact to protect the highly-paid assets of big spending football clubs. Bigi is going to be a massive player for the club, particularly if Tiote moves on at the end of this season, with Chelsea still sniffing around and the inevitable links to Arsenal and Manchester United likely to rear their heads again come January and the summer, and this European competition might be the perfect opportunity to give him a chance to mature into his greater role at the club.
5. Shola Still Offers A Threat
All of the talk about strikers these days at St. James' Park tends to be about whether Demba Ba's agents are happy with Alan Pardew's tactics, or when Papiss Cisse is going to take up his a goal a goal ratio he hit last season, and the situation has allowed Shola Ameobi to quietly get on with his work without the kind of focus that used to affect his confidence. Now part of the furniture at St. James' Park, Shola has amassed a serious amount of performances for the club without ever being heralded as a favourite, and now, thanks to his ability to score against sunderland, he has graduated to bona-fide Newcastle legend. But in the past two fixtures, Shola has proven that he still has something to offer to the club - his unbelievable chest pass to Demba Ba for the equaliser against Everton was one of the single greatest moments of skill I have seen from a player in black and white, and his all round performance against Maritimo was to be commended. He chased the ball, despite his now-ageing legs not really being up to pace, and on the ball he is still the strongest player at the club and appears almost untacklable. That he didn't cap his performance with a goal has more to do with the width of the woodwork than with his actual effort, and there was a lot to suggest that if Alan Pardew wants to bench either of his bigger star strikers to encourage the kind of response he got from Ba against Everton, Shola might just be worth giving an opportunity to yet.
6. The Officials Should Never Be The Stars
Though it is something of a cliche to criticise the over-zealous whistle-blowing of European referees unfamiliar with the more robust English game, last night's officials were inconsistent at best and just plain inept at worst. In the first half, any time a Maritimo player hit the floor (followed by unwelcome histrionics), the referee blew his whistle, meaning perfectly fair aerial challenges went punished with a free-kick that would never have been given in the Premier League. And that could have been justified by the difference in refereeing culture, if it weren't for the fact that the referee and linesman conspired to miss the three biggest incidents of the game, and then book Gael Bigirimana for a perfectly reasonable tackle that should never been necessary. The referee missed Steven Taylor's first half elbow that would have usually brought a red card, as well as a fairly blatant back pass from Mike Williamson, which were of course good for the watching Newcastle fans, but then the linesman also managed to miss a hand-ball by a Maritimo defender that should have brought the Magpies a penalty. But the worst instance of all was that Bigirimana booking, which came after the referee awarded a drop-ball after a clash of heads involving James Perch, and which saw Maritimo ignore the gentlemen's rules of the situation and try and attack straight from the drop-ball. Bigirimana's subsequent challenge was tough, but it was fair and should never have been punished with a card, particular as the ref should have used his common sense in a situation that was messed up by Maritimo's eagerness to profit from a usually uncontested moment. That lack of sense lead to an entirely unnecessary heated moment on the pitch which spilled out onto the sideline between the coaching staffs, and though it came to nothing and blew itself out, the fact that it boiled down to the failure of a referee to take charge of a situation says a lot about his performance last night. So, Newcastle United fans - what do you think? Were there any other positives from the Maritimo game? Should Newcastle be going for this competition no matter what the effect progress might have on Premier League form? Share your thoughts below.