Newcastle United took on Man City in an enthralling encounter at St James' Park yesterday afternoon. The pulsating match ended in a 2-0 win for the Sky Blues, but the score line only tells half of the story. The match was full of controversy and drama; with a packed stadium witnessing sublime play, disallowed goals and some abysmal refereeing decisions. City took the lead early through Edin Dzeko's close range finish, the Bosnian striker profiting from a fine Kolarov cross. Newcastle worked hard to get back into the game and around the half hour mark the home fans thought that Tiote's sweet strike had drawn their team level. After deliberation the officials bizarrely ruled the goal to be offside, causing much uproar amongst the fans and the home team bench. Buoyed by a sense of injustice the Magpies threw everything at City in the second half, with Tiote in particular impressing, but their valiant efforts came to nothing. A rash tackle on Samir Nasri towards the end of the game saw the Frenchman stretchered off with what looked like a serious injury. As the game moved towards the final whistle Fernandinho saw his headed effort hit the bar, before Alvaro Negredo took advantage of the seven minutes stoppage time to fire the Citizens into an unassailable two goal lead. Read on to find out what we've learned from the epic encounter...
5. Joe Hart's Back
A clean sheet away from home will have done Joe Hart the world of good and Manuel Pellegrini must be delighted with the manner in which the England shot stopper kept Newcastle at bay. He pulled off a string of fine saves, notably from Cabaye and Remy, to keep the score at 1-0 at a crucial stage of the game. His extended absence from the team has been a success and he looks to be reinvigorated. After Pantilimon's recent run in the team, Hart is in no doubt that there is competition for the number one jersey and this appears to have had a positive effect on his game. England manager Roy Hodgson has a lot to thank Pellegrini for, the Chilean's handling of the goalkeeping situation has been first rate. With City set to face Cardiff in the next league outing Hart will be looking to build on a good performance today and turn in another clean sheet.
4. Officially Clueless
Cheick Tiote's ferocious screamer was controversially ruled out in the first half, just when Newcastle were beginning to find a way back into the game. The Ivorian's shot from the edge of the box powered through a crowd of bodies, untouched, before nestling into the far corner of Joe Hart's goal. Cue wild celebrations, but they were short lived as the officials consulted with each other before agreeing to rule the goal out for offside. Replays showed that Yoan Gouffran had been retreating from the six yard box and whilst he was standing in an offside position, he didn't touch the ball or obstruct Hart's view. This opens up the old argument about what constitutes an 'active' player? Technology has already been brought in to deal with goal line incidents this season, could Tiote's disallowed goal spark a further call for the use of replays to help officials make the correct decision in game changing moments?
3. Newcastle Need A New Defender - But Don't Expect Anyone Soon
With injuries and suspensions to key defenders, Pardew had to field a makeshift back line for the City game. Steven Taylor made his first league start of the season but was found wanting when Dzeko nipped in to tuck away Kolarov's cross for the opener; this was after Yanga Mbwia had gone AWOL down the flank. If Newcastle are to push for European football they desperately need to add better defenders to their squad as back up for the first team. Unfortunately, Joe Kinnear, newly appointed director of football, has made it clear that there is likely to be little investment over the next month. In the match day programme notes he advises that "if the right player becomes available for the right price then we may do business. If not, then we won't." Newcastle splashed the cash 12 months ago to ensure that they preserved their top flight status but it looks like the purse strings are being tightened on Tyneside this January. Many will question the club's long term ambition, anxious to stay in the Premier League but not willing to invest and make the jump to push for a place near the top of the table? The Magpies have been linked with Joleon Lescott in recent days, surely he would bring so much needed stability to their back line?
2. City Are The New Chelsea
City were on the back foot for the majority of yesterday's game, soaking up pressure and hitting Newcastle on the break when possible. They scored against the run of play early on and then worked tirelessly to protect their lead as Newcastle tried to turn the screw in the second half. The centre half pairing of Kompany and Demichellis stood solid against the Magpie's onslaught and all of City's players worked for each other in pressing their opposite number. Pellegrini has instilled a real togetherness in his team, something which was so blatantly lacking at the club under Mancini's management. Very much like Mourinho's Chelsea of old, City were confident in their ability to see a game through once they had the lead and their hard work was rewarded in the final minutes, Negredo wrapping up another fine display on the road for the Citizens.
1. Be Cool Alan!
Alan Pardew was incandescent with rage on the touch line when he realised that Tiote's goal had been ruled out. A heated exchange with Manuel Pellegrini followed, with Pardew appearing to launch into a foul-mouthed tirade at the ice-cool Chilean. The Newcastle boss admitted in his post match press conference that his actions were somewhat uncalled for and offered an apology to his opposite number. However, there is no doubt that Pardew lost a small piece of managerial street cred today. His rant did not appear to ruffle the feather's of Pellegrini but the Newcastle manager's outrage reflected the pressure he is feeling, after all his side were on a three game losing streak coming into today's game. Instead of trying to get a rise out of opposing managers, Pardew should concentrate on the job in hand and set an example for his players to follow. In the minutes that followed Tiote's goal that never was, Sissoko was booked for kicking the ball away in frustration. Pardew was in no position to complain to his player.