Newcastle United PREDICTED XI (And Score) Vs Man Utd

Daryl Janmaat is suspended and Moussa Sissoko will miss the game with a groin injury.

There was something unsettling about Steve McClaren's team selection last weekend. Not to judge the former Derby boss too quickly but surely it was either extremely naive or painfully ignorant to believe that the side who scraped a messy draw with a lacklustre Southampton side could adequately compete at the Liberty Stadium. McClaren doesn't have the excuse - as other Newcastle bosses perhaps have done - of not having a relatively healthy squad size and last weekend he failed to demonstrate being tactically capable of using his. The identical side and 4-2-3-1 formation was rolled out with Georginio Wijnaldum being used as a #10 and both full-backs instructed to play vey high up the pitch. It didn't work and despite the Magpies being manipulated by Jonjo Shelvey and hypnotised by Jefferson Montero for 45 minutes, no first half changes were made. Like a young whippersnapper who enters a smokey billiards hall only to find out that after having a great result in his first game, the opponents were mysteriously a lot tougher second time around. Newcastle were well and truly hustled by Swansea who had revised the footage, brought their own cue and made you buy them an expensive three-point cocktail. This week they're entering an even more intimidating arena; imagine saloon doors, tankards and Memphis Depay with a handlebar moustache. A flickering sign outside reads 'Old Trafford' and Louis van Gaal is propped up at the bar laughing as he clocks McClaren's arrival. "Try playing that side again, if you dare..." he whispers as the Magpies' boss and Ian Cathro order a drink... After that threat, WhatCulture.com/NUFC have predicted the starting eleven for Saturday€™s fixture (We've decided to make a couple of changes), outlined their specific duties and given our opinions on the scoreline...

1. Goalkeeper - Tim Krul (Swansea Rating - 5)

Tim Krul has already conceded four goals this season and although not being majorly at fault for any of them the goalkeeper's leadership and kicking qualities are starting to be questioned. He simply has to start, no-one is close to rivalling the #1 jersey and the Dutch shot-stopper is one of the much-needed names in the starting eleven. The Magpies' goalkeeper will hope that Wayne Rooney's goal-drought continues...(It won't)

2. Right-Back - Chancel Mbemba (Swansea Rating - 4)

Slightly worrying that the player likely to fill Daryl Janmaat's undisciplined boots is the man who played almost as bad in that position as the Dutch defender minus the double yellow. Chancel Mbemba is a centre half and does not have the pace or technical attributes to impact any game from right-back but Newcastle's options are limited. The other choice is to play Vurnon Anita at full-back and bring Cheick Tiote or Georginio Wijnaldum into the holding midfield position but given that the lucky man who plays in Janmaat's position is up against Memphis (who scored two beautiful goals against Club Brugge mid-week) it seems too much of a gamble.

3. Left-Back - Massadio Haidara (Swansea Rating - 4)

Paul Dummett still isn't fit so Massadio Haidara has another chance to prove his worth to Steve McClaren. If the defender continues to play in the way that he has during the first two games of the season then unfortunately it will show he is still a long way from a permanent slot a left-back. The 22-year-old has had a hard job having to mark, Dusan Tadic and Andre Ayew over the last month and will have a similar task against Juan Mata on Saturday but he needs to remain composed and demonstrate the strong performances that he showed pre-season.

4. Centre Back - Steven Taylor (Swansea Rating - 4)

Daryl Janmaat's dismissal could come as a blessing for Steven Taylor should he put in a good performance against Manchester United. The centre back positions are still up for grabs and the English defender will be looking to regain a place in the Magpies' starting eleven. The dilemma for McClaren will be whether to maintain the partnership of Chancel Mbemba and Fabriccio Coloccini and play Vurnon Anita as right full-back therefore leaving Taylor out of the line up.

5. Centre Back - Fabricio Coloccini (Swansea Rating - 4)

Huge game for the skipper after another dismal display last weekend. Fabricio Coloccini forgot to jump as 5ft 9 Andre Ayew towered above him and nodded home Swansea's second goal of the evening. The Argentine appeared to be still finding his full fitness and looked sluggish on the ball. More worryingly, his leadership and organisational skills are distant (although very fond) memories and he simply isn't the player he once was. Coloccini will have another big test this Saturday when he is faced against Wayne Rooney who isn't shy of scoring against the Magpies.

6. Midfield Pivot - Jack Colback (Swansea Rating - 5)

Jack Colback will start once more against Manchester United as he is currently unrivalled for his position but the midfielder hasn't impressed during the first two games of the season. The 25-year-old couldn't make any impact on last weekend's game and let Jonjo Shelvey gracefully roam around him as he leisurely set up Bafetimbi Gomis for the first goal of the afternoon. The Red Devils' rejuvenated central midfield has looked sturdy this season and Morgan Schneiderlin, Michael Carrick and Juan Mata will present Colback with his toughest game of the season.

7. Midfield Pivot - Georginio Wijnaldum (Swansea Rating - 4)

Georginio Wijnaldum was distinctively average at the Liberty Stadium. The new signing is undeniably a fine footballer when Newcastle have possession and against Swansea (through no fault of his own) they simply never had the ball. In order to prevent this Steve McClaren may (should) look to play the former PSV Eindhoven captain alongside Jack Colback as part of the pivot and use his technical ability to start quicker counter-attacks. Vurnon Anita - who may play right-back- was very poor against the Swans and was unable to get anywhere near the game, playing him against Louis van Gaal's well-oiled midfield would be football suicide.

8. Attacking Midfield - Gabriel Obertan (Swansea Rating - 6)

Gabriel Obertan has done enough to earn himself another start on the left hand side of the attacking three. The pacy winger was Newcastle United's only attacking option against Swansea and was involved in the few positive passages of play that the Magpies managed to create. Ayoze Perez and Rolando Aarons are waiting for their chance, although it's difficult to know if Steve McClaren has faith in the pair after limited involvement so far.

9. Attacking Midfield - Florian Thauvin (Swansea Rating - N/A)

There is no better place to make your debut than Old Trafford and due to Moussa Sissoko's groin injury it's likely that Florian Thauvin will do just that. Sissoko's woeful performance against Swansea will not be missed and it will be refreshing to have a more natural winger playing on the right-flank. The French midfielder will have to track Luke Shaw and Memphis throughout the game and it will be interesting to see how industrious the 22-year-old will be. Thauvin will add a more compact and direct attacking threat, something the Magpies have lacked during their opening two Barclays Premier League games. The Frenchman can operate on either flank and likes to dribble, take on defenders and can be highly effective on the counter-attack.

10. Number Ten - Ayoze Perez (Swansea Rating - N/A)

Ayoze Perez is yet to be used by Steve McClaren this season but could be given a start this week as Newcastle look to improve on their midfield performance. The Spanish attacker played in a deeper midfield position during a number of pre-season friendlies and would offer a more compact central three alongside Georginio Wijnaludum and Jack Colback. The 22-year-old can offer a lot going forward and could combine well with Florian Thauvin and Gabriel Obertan as the Magpies look to break on the counter-attack. If Perez isn't selected this week then it sparks further concerns that McClaren doesn't trust him and we could see another naturally talented footballer heading out of St James' Park.

11. Striker - Aleksandar Mitrovic (Swansea Rating - N/A)

It's time to unleash Aleksandar Mitrovic from the first whistle. The 20-year-old has now been booked twice despite only playing 20 minutes of football and clearly needs to settle down as he looks to establish himself as Newcastle United's first-team striker. Papiss Cisse was invisible against Swansea and the Magpies will need a stronger presence up front against Manchester United. Cisse's hold up play and general contribution was shocking and Mitrovic deserves a chance to prove his worth. At least the Red Devils won't know what to expect if the Serbian lines up from the start...(fingers crossed it's not a red card). Click the next button to the 'Top Options From The Bench'.

12. Top Options From The Bench

Vurnon Anita

It still remains to be seen if Vurnon Anita will start the fixture but if not he can represent a good option if Newcastle need to hold on for a draw or if Chancel Mbemba is struggling at right-back.

Siem de Jong

Siem de Jong has admitted that he is raring to get going this season and offers Steve McClaren a great option off the bench against Manchester United if he has fully recovered from his shin injury.

Rolando Aarons

Steve McClaren could possibly start Rolando Aarons behind Aleksandar Mitrovic or Papiss Cisse as he did experiment with in a more central position against Swansea. Click on the next page to see our writers€™ predictions for the game€

13. Swansea City Vs Newcastle United €“ Our Writers€™ Score Predictions

Chris Waugh (NUFC Editor) | @ChrisDHWaugh

The games are simply not getting any easier for Steve McClaren, and it looks like things will get worse before they get ant better for the Magpies. Wayne Rooney is bound to end his scoring drought against a Newcastle side low on confidence defensively - he will probably grab two - while Memphis will have a field day due to the lack of Daryl Janmaat in the Toon side due to suspension. Aleksandar Mitrovic could well grab his first NUFC goal on a quick counter attack, but it will be a case of damage limitation once more for Newcastle.

Prediction: Manchester United 3-1 Newcastle United

Matt Smith (NUFC Writer) | @ElasticoChop

Unfortunately Newcastle United are without Daryl Janmaat and Moussa Sissoko. Now, even if the pair had been included in Steve McClaren's squad the Magpies would have struggled against Manchester United's well-oiled defensive unit. Memphis will be up against either Chancel Mbemba or Vurnon Anita which will be about as competitive as me playing tennis against Roger Federer and Steven Taylor versus Wayne Rooney will be a blessing for the England Captain. Nine games without a goal certainly won't expand to ten.

Prediction: Manchester United 3-0 Newcastle United

Ross Tweddell (NUFC Writer) | @TwedzTweets

Wayne Rooney will return to form. Of course he will. Nine league games without a goal? That doesn€™t matter - The Red Devils€™ captain couldn€™t have picked a better opposition for him to get back into form. Rooney has scored 12 goals against Newcastle - he will probably have 15 by the end of play on Saturday. How many times will BT Sport show that volley from 2005? Urgh.

Prediction: Manchester United 4-0 Newcastle United


Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-accredited football writer with an MA in Sports Journalism. What Culture football editor. Write for the official Newcastle United programme. Former video reporter at North News. Featured and published in the Sunderland Echo, Shields Gazette, Mail Online, The Mirror, The Sun and others.