Premier League: 5 Worst Transfers of 2012

In each club's quest to unearth the next hidden gem, or to recruit a superstar marquee signing, something has gone horribly wrong. For whatever reason, a number of players signed this summer have not had the desired effect, unless they were signed by Gareth Southgate, the genius who brought you the footballing revelation of Afonso Alves. For a club record of more than £10 million. And we let him. Here, we'll list the 5 players that have done their utmost to emulate former players who just couldn't cut the Premier League, such Veron, Reyes, Morientes and Shevchenko. And Afonso Alves. I really can't emphasise enough how awful he was. As usual, they're in no particular order.

1. Ivan Ramis (Wigan, ‚4.5 million*)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AkVjaW5VG8M Lovely tackle. During the summer, West Ham battled hard with Wigan for Ramis, but ultimately lost out. Yet after paying over £4 million, and costing the Latics a penalty after an awful challenge in their first game against Chelsea, the Hammers must have been breathing a sigh of relief, who by the way now sit sixth in the table with 11 games gone. While his performances have marginally improved since then, it's more the fact that Hugo Rodallega, Mohamed Diame, and partially Victor Moses, were moved on to finance the signing of him and others. He has slightly improved of late, and even scored a goal at the right end a few weeks back, so credit where it's due. I'm yet to be convinced whether it's the start of a good run of form, or a footballing miracle. Rating: 2 / 10 Makes David Luiz look reliable. *Transfer fee courtesy of Sky Sports

2. Fabio Borini (Liverpool, £12 million*)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wdh6BwYmBWs I know it was only his debut, but it's still funny how badly he played. Having left Chelsea as a youngster without really leaving his mark, Borini was threatened with fading into obscurity. Unfortunately, this hasn't happened, and somehow 9 goals in 20 league games in Serie A for Roma last season has merited a transfer fee six times bigger than for Swansea's Michu, who has scored 6 goals in the league already. Go figure. Borini hasn't scored in the league, yet, producing 0 goals, from 9 shots, in 5 games. His versatility means he can be equally useless on the wings as well as in a central position up front. While he does have youth on his side, he does have a general lack of quality against him, and a broken leg for the next couple of months won't help the situation. He does still have youth on his side though, so we can at least be disappointed for another 10 - 15 years. Rating: 2/10 Might play better with a broken leg. *Transfer fee courtesy of The Mirror

3. Rob Green (QPR, Free)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eo5GyRnDtMY It pained me to watch that again. While he hasn't cost QPR anything except wages and the pure indignity of signing Rob Green, he has already cost them a number of clean sheets. Already conceding 9 goals in just 3 league games, Green has done nothing so far to rid himself of the stigma surrounding him, and it wasn't just the fans that took notice of this. After just four games, Mark Hughes and Tony Fernandes decided that, in addition to the 8 other new signings, they should get a new goalkeeper to replace the one they brought in only two months prior. So, having been rendered moot with the addition of former Inter Milan goalkeeper Julio Cesar, who incidentally kept a clean sheet against Chelsea on his debut for his new club, Green now spends his time sitting on the bench looking sullen, where he can't do as much damage. However, despite Julio Cesar keeping a clean sheet and making 16 saves in 4 games, QPR have still conceded 8 goals in their last 4 games, suggesting the entire defence should also make it into this list. Rating: 0/10 Laughable.

4. Jack Rodwell (Manchester City, £15 million*)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bAJIciNHpaE Lovely pass from Rodwell to Reus. I know it's petty, but it does make a point. To be fair, I used to sing his praises more than most while he was at Everton, especially when he hadn't really broken into the first team. However, there's a certain amount of time I can defend someone by saying "they've got potential, wait until next season." There comes a time when you have to admit, yes, they had potential, but it doesn't look like they'll be as good as we thought. In my mind, Rodwell has become one of those players. Having always had injury and fitness problems, which regularly kept him out of the Everton squad for long periods of time, it's also prevented him from maturing through on-the-pitch experience. His performances have never been as good as they should be by now, so when City came knocking over summer with a bid of £15 million, David Moyes must have been laughing as he helped the lad pack his bags. I don't see what he adds to the City squad either. He now fills the De Jong role, which is to be the replacement of Gareth Barry, the world's slowest man. He has looked timid for City, and at times has looked just plain panicked. Hopefully, he will get better, and first-team football in that squad will certainly improve you as a footballer, but it will take time, and that is one thing City players are not allowed, unfortunately. Rating: 3/10 The next Gareth Barry is not a good title. *Transfer free courtesy of Daily Mail

5. Scott Sinclair (Manchester City, £6.2 million*)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iul1KanySRc Unbelievable, Jeff. Becoming what I like to call 'the new Adam Johnson,' Scott Sinclair is the latest young winger to make the career-stalling move to the Etihad stadium. Surely he can see the role he'll fill? I don't understand why young players feel that it's a good decision to join City, when their current transfer policy is to buy ready-made talent. Maybe in a few seasons when it quietens down under UEFA's Financial Fair Play, and they have to start bringing through their promising youth prospects. Coming off the back of a highly successful season with Swansea last year, he was part of a team that out-played many established teams, and out-passed Arsenal. His record so far isn't exactly unimpressive, with 1 goal from just 1 shot, considering he's appeared in 4 league games, but played under half of the match most of the time. It's just disappointing to see a player know full well he'll be used as an 89th minute substitution. Rating: 3/10 Cue the chant, 'You've only gone for the money.' *Transfer fee courtesy of The Daily Mirror

Contributor
Contributor

English undergraduate, betting man and football fanatic with more opinions than Joey Barton. Hails from Manchester-ish. Occasionally blogs at http://rionbarker.wordpress.com/ Football Manager addict, household FIFA champion, and other titles I shouldn't be proud of.