Southampton New Manager: 6 Candidates To Replace Mauricio Pochettino

Amongst the widely speculated impending departures of hugely talented young left back Luke Shaw and complete midfielder Adam Lallana, the one loss that Southampton may shortly come to feel worse than any other is that of manager Mauricio Pochettino. Having arrived under a cloud of suspicion and bad blood barely over a year ago after the seemingly misjudged sacking of predecessor Nigel Adkins, Pochettino has come to be a greatly loved and admired figure among the St. Mary's faithful. Now his success at building a relegation battling team into a comfortably top half side, playing good to watch football and beating the likes of Chelsea, Liverpool and Manchester City, has resulted in Pochettino's departure for Tottenham this week. Southampton will have to move swiftly and decisively to find a replacement that can maintain the optimism of this year's campaign and prevent a mass exodus of young talent. The more conservative pundits have suggested Southampton look to their past with Glenn Hoddle and Alan Pardew, managers who did a reasonable job for the Saints but have suffered mixed fortunes at best since, both apparently in the running, as is the unreliable and uninspiring Steve McClaren off the back of one good year with Derby. Fortunately, Pochettino has left a legacy of a club in largely good health, whose roster of quality young players emerging from an ever-productive academy (James Ward-Prowse, Harrison Reed, Calum Chambers, Sam Gallagher) and established top class talent (Dejan Lovren, Morgan Schneiderlin) should make them an attractive prospect for many ambitious young managers with an eye on a Premier League future. Here are six of the best up and coming managers that Saints could turn to before they resort to anyone who has tried and failed at a higher level.

6. Eddie Howe

AFC Bournemouth have always had a friendly link to the bigger club just up the south coast and have often functioned as a de facto feeder club for Southampton, with the Cherries' better young players ending up transferring over to Saints, while Saints Academy players who never quite made it (Leon Best, Drew Surman) go the other way. Most notably, the current (for the time being anyway) Saints idol Adam Lallana left the Bournemouth Centre of Excellence to join the Saints Academy as a 12 year old and returned to the club as a promising 19 year old in 2007. At the same time Bournemouth's hugely popular but injury prone Eddie Howe was made a player coach by manager and former Saints defender Kevin Bond. By 2008 Howe became Bournemouth's manager, pulling a team whose league status was at threat out of the relegation zone in League 2. The following season Howe's Bournemouth were promoted. After a brief spell at Burnley, Howe returned to Bournemouth in 2012 to guide the team to promotion to the Championship, only the second time in the club's history that they found themselves in the second tier. Having consolidated Bournemouth's Championship status with an impressive 10th place finish last year, Howe is in demand with a number of bigger clubs and Southampton's good relationship with the Cherries should see the young manager (still just 36 even after 6 years of management) clear to a big move that would not be too disruptive to someone who is such a Bournemouth icon that he played 271 games of his 273 match playing career for his hometown club and has spent most of his managerial career there. Indeed, the only time he has even moved away from a small area of the south of England was just over a year as manager of Burnley in which he did not impress. In a sense, then, Southampton offer Howe the only plausible big move while still staying close to his roots. However, the Premier League club may worry about Howe's ability to step up much in the same way that former Saints manager Paul Sturrock failed to adjust to the top level. Howe's commitment to playing stylish, fluid and attacking football would be a perfect fit for the way that Southampton have played under Pochettino and he has an undoubted ambition and interest in building for the future.

5. Dan Petrescu

Often a club can turn to a former player in a time of managerial need and, although old Saints favourites Mark Hughes and Kevin Keegan seem like yesterday's men, they are by no means the only options for a club that has had an enormous number of players pass through their doors, many of whom have since become highly rated managers. Dan Petrescu arrived at Southampton in 2001, bought by Glenn Hoddle the manager who signed him for Chelsea. Petrescu had five extremely successful years in the Premier League with the Blues, but his playing career was beginning to wind down when he played for Southampton as he slipped out of the first team after a strong start. Still, if the Romanian, who remains an admired player in England, is looking for a Premiership return as speculated when he was linked with the Crystal Palace job last year, then he could be said to have more to prove for Southampton. A season after leaving Saints, Petrescu retired to pursue a career as a coach, eventually winding up at Unirea Urziceni, newly promoted to the Romanian top flight. Under Petrescu's guidance the small club would win first the Romanian Cup, then qualify for the UEFA Cup where they beat Rangers and Sevilla, and finally win the Romanian title. On leaving Unirea, Petrescu joined Russian club Kuban Krasnodar, taking the club up from the Russian First Division with a comfortable title win in which the Cossacks only conceded 20 goals. In their first year back in the Russian Premier League, Kuban finished 6th in the regular season and Petrescu moved to the more traditional challengers Dynamo Moscow, the first significant failure of a successful managerial career that suggests Petrescu may do better at unfancied clubs than those with high expectations. Petrescu credits his success at taking teams from a lower league and establishing them as top flight contenders, something Pochettino has done at Southampton, as coming from what he learnt playing in England and his application of a hands on English style training routine. Perhaps now is the time to try that in England itself.

4. Uwe Rosler

Another of Glenn Hoddle's Saints signings, former Man City striker Uwe Rosler arrived at Saints in 2000 in the hope that he could provide the goals that would eventually come from a blossoming James Beattie (himself now a manager who kept lowly Accrington Stanley in the league this year). In fact Rosler's only goal of his Saints career was a sentimental one in the celebratory final friendly before the closure of The Dell. Based on his managerial career so far, though, he has a great deal more to offer his former club as a manager than he did as a player. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer won himself a Premier League managerial contract on the strength of his success at Norwegian club Molde, but it was only after Rosler on a short term contract managed an unbeaten run that saved the club from relegation. Since leaving Molde, Rosler has established himself as one of the top managers in the Football League, turning Brentford from a mediocre League 1 club into promotion challengers before leaving for Wigan where he took the club to the Championship play-offs and the cup semi-finals, beating his former club Man City along the way. Rosler has made no secret of his desire to return to the Premier League as a manager. Having narrowly missed out on that possibility with his current club, Saints could provide their former player with just that opportunity. At Brentford, in particular, Rosler enjoyed success with limited resources through strong organisation and structure and good man management that allowed young players to flourish much as Pochettino has done. His commitment to working with experts and sports scientists helped bring out the best in his team and can do the same at St. Mary's.

3. Michael Laudrup

Easily the most familiar name on this list, Michael Laudrup is not just the only one here with Premier League managerial experience, but he was also one of the greatest players of his generation. With the likes of Juventus, Real Madrid and Ajax, Laudrup learnt from the best managers in the business, but the most significant part of his playing career saw him as part of Johann Cruyff's all conquering Barcelona Dream Team. Just as Cruyff established the free flowing, short passing Barcelona style as he guided the team to their first European Cup, so can his legacy be measured in the players from that team who are now top level managerial talent: Pep Guardiola, Txiki Begiristain, Ronald Koeman and Laudrup. Like Cruyff and those others, Laudrup has won games playing positive, attacking football. His preferred pressing and passing style is well suited to how Southampton played under Pochettino. In 12 years of management Laudrup has proved himself at a number of clubs in different countries, winning the Danish double with Brondby, and pushing Getafe and Mallorca to perform well beyond expectations in La Liga before he arrived in Britain. At Swansea he won the club their first major trophy and last year's sacking seemed harsh given a solid mid-table position and progress in cup competitions both in Europe and at home, knocking Man Utd out of the FA Cup. Failure to progress very far in either cup, and not seeming especially bothered about it, was one area where Pochettino disappointed Saints fans, so if Laudrup could deliver this he would definitely make himself popular at St. Mary's. His ability in the transfer market is another plus with his time in Spain enabling him to spot Michu as the bargain signing of the last few years and his high status from his playing career able to attract players who are personal admirers to clubs they might not otherwise be interested in. Despite a bitter end to his Swansea career, Laudrup remains one of Europe's highest rated young managers and will surely be in line for a top flight job soon, why not Southampton?

2. Murat Yakin

Murat Yakin, a big centre back in Switzerland's Euro 2004 squad, has been installed as the early favourite for Pochettino's vacated seat after another successful season in charge of hometown club Basel. A solidly good player, Yakin enjoyed the best years of his playing career as captain of Basel in the early 2000s. After retiring as a player, he gradually worked his way up through the ranks as a manager from the Swiss lower leagues. In 2012 he took unfancied FC Luzern to second place in the Swiss Super League and a narrow defeat on penalties to Basel in the Swiss Cup final, which saw him given the top job at his former club. In just two years at Basel, Yakin established himself as one of the most highly regarded coaches in Europe, not only by winning back to back league titles, but also through the quality of the team's progress in European competition, especially against English clubs. On course to the 2013 Europa League semi-final against Chelsea, Yakin masterminded victories against a number of clubs with far greater resources, including Zenit St. Petersburg and Tottenham. Last year's home and away wins against Chelsea in the Champions League, not to mention beating Ajax en route to the Europa League quarter-final, proved 2013 was no fluke and drew the admiration of Jose Mourinho. In May Yakin left Basel, clearly feeling that he had accomplished everything he could there and ambitious enough to want to achieve the same in a big league. Having already masterminded the defeat of Spurs and Chelsea, it seems likely that Yakin would enjoy the opportunity to do the same on a weekly basis in the Premier League with Saints. Like Howe, however, Yakin has enjoyed the vast amount of his success with his hometown club, a team that he understands instinctually. As a player, leaving Switzerland for brief spells in Germany and Turkey did not work out so well. It is possible Yakin the manager may equally struggle far from home.

1. Oscar Garcia

The previous five options would all have the potential to take on the challenge of managing Southampton and building on Pochettino's legacy, but one man combines the best features of all of them: Oscar Garcia. Like Petrescu and Yakin his reputation was built on success in a lesser UEFA league (winning Maccabi Tel Aviv their first Israeli title in ten years), like Howe he has enjoyed recent success at the helm of a Football League club on the south coast of England (Brighton), like Rosler he has guided that club to within inches of the Premier League by making it to the Championship play-offs, like Laudrup he is a protege of Johann Cruyff and the Barcelona style, and like Yakin he is available and out of contract. He even provides a sense of continuity with Pochettino as they both played for Espanyol at the same time in 2004. A talented youngster produced by Cruyff's La Masia youth academy, Oscar never quite lived up to his promise as a player, eventually leaving Barca when he failed to hold down a first team place. Nevertheless, Cruyff remembered him when he took on the job managing the Catalonia national team for a series of exhibition matches, appointing Oscar as his assistant before the latter took the job as Barcelona youth coach. At Barca, Oscar worked with such emerging talents as current first team defenders Martin Montoya and Marc Bartra and Everton winger Gerard Deulofeu. This background should give Oscar an ability to work with Saints' own successful academy talented and even give him an insider knowledge of up and coming Barca talent like Deulofeu. Since then his rise has been rapid, winning the title with one year at Tel Aviv, getting Brighton to the play-offs in one year there, and now, having quit Brighton, he is looking to achieve the same at a higher level. His next club may well worry that he will only spend one season with them as he has at his previous clubs, but if he can bring a little more Barcelona to Saints then maybe one season will be all he needs.

Contributor
Contributor

Loves ghost stories, mysteries and giant ape movies