Stoke 1-0 Newcastle - Player Ratings

As the cliche goes, let's see how they played at Stoke on a cold Wednesday night.

After an 18-day enforced break, Newcastle returned to action at the Britannia Stadium knowing that any points put on the board would lift them out of the relegation zone following Tuesday night's results. With Fabricio Coloccini ruled out, Jonjo Shelvey was handed the captain's armband - just as he was in La Manga - but it was the same old story for the Magpies as we lost yet again away from home. On a night in which the blustery conditions played their part, we hardly looked like threatening Stoke City goalkeeper Jack Butland - who had produced a masterclass in the reverse fixture at St James' Park. After a pretty tame 80 minutes in which the home side had dominated the play without really creating any chances, Xherdan Shaqiri unleashed a piledriver from just outside the box which rifled into Rob Elliot's net. Although the 'keeper could argue that the wild weather caused him problems, the Toon Army can feel disappointed in the shotstopper's efforts as he stood routed to the spot as the ball whistled past him. The home side looked more likely to clinch a second as the all-too-often Magpies capitulation threatened to set in, but a snapshot by loanee Seydou Doumbia in the dying stages produced the only save worth mentioning that Butland had to pull off all game before Marko Arnautovic rattled United's woodwork at the other end. The result piles more pressure on the club whose away following were once again in full voice and the home game against Bournemouth is surely now a must-win clash if we are to stand any chance in surviving the dreaded drop. From a total Newcastle bias, here's the match ratings from last night...

Goalkeeper...

Rob Elliot - 4

The shotstopper could be questioned about his part to play in Shaqiri's goal after he was static when the shot fizzed past him. After dealing with the blustery conditions well in the first half, playing against the wind in the second 45 appeared to cause Elliot some problems, with many kicks getting nowhere near the halfway line.

Defenders...

Paul Dummett - 5

The Welsh defender had a bit of a busy night faced against Xherdan Shaqiri and while the tricky winger skipped past him on several occasions, Dummett produced a few well-timed tackles as well as a vital header to defend a dangerous ball into the Magpies' box in the first half. Unfortunately for Dummett and Newcastle, Shaqiri skipped further into the field of play to get the all-important winning goal.

Daryl Janmaat - 5

The Dutch full back must have been expecting a busy night as Arnautovic looked bright in the early stages of the game. However, in a game which lacked any real spark, Janmaat's defensive duties were never really pushed to their limits. Normally an attacking threat in the opposition's half, Janmaat - like his team-mates - offered very little going forward.

Jamaal Lascelles - 5

Still a novice in the Premier League, the former Nottingham Forest man didn't have much to do in what was a quiet game for both sets of strikers until the goal.

Steven Taylor - 5

Taylor tried to play the ball out from the back at every opportunity, often running into the opposition half. Had control for the majority, but as with all the defence, he appeared to panic after the goal had gone in.

Midfielders...

Yoan Gouffran - 3

The Frenchman received a rare start for the Magpies this term and offered the sort of average performance the Toon Army have come to expect from the fringe player - plenty of running with no real quality. An injury to his calf cut his night short, with Emmanuel Riviere replacing him with 16 minutes left on the clock.

Moussa Sissoko - 3

His team-mates were always on the lookout for the powerful Frenchman in order to start an attack. However, when he was able to get on the ball, Sissoko often wasted the ball by trying to play lofted balls in wet and wild conditions that were not suited to that style of football Although looked upon as being an attacking threat, he rarely looks a danger in the final third and tonight was no different.

Jack Colback - 4

Sitting on nine yellow cards for the season, Colback wasn't letting a potential two-game ban change his style of play - fouling time and time again. However, the midfielder failed to get anywhere near close enough to Shaqiri and allowed Stoke's playmaker the time and space required to rifle passed Elliot. Replaced by Seydou Doumbia on 84 minutes as the Magpies chased a goal to get them back into the game.

Jonjo Shelvey - 5

The weather severely limited his top attribute - his passing. The stand-in captain tried to play a few nice through balls along the ground, but the Magpies forwards weren't able to capitalise.

Gigi Wijnaldum - 5

Wijnaldum often looked for the ball and his quick footwork got the Magpies out of difficulty and helped build a few potential attacks in the first half. However, after receiving a booking near the end of the first 45, the Dutchman struggled to get into the game after the restart.

Strikers...

Aleksandar Mitrovic - 3

The Serbian sruggled as the lone striker. His usually excellent hold-up play was rarely on show as the conditions played a huge part in the Serbians inability to control the ball. A tame header in the first half his only half chance on goal. Replaced by Ayoze Perez in the 84th minute.

Emmanuel Riviere (74 mins) - 3

The French forward tried to make a nuisance of himself when he first came on the pitch, but made a mess of a through ball by Wijnaldum and had no other input.

Seydou Doumbia/ Ayoze Perez

The pair were thrown into the game on the 84-minute mark in an attempt to claw back the one-goal deficit, but failed to add a real spark to a lifeless Newcastle. Doumbia nearly claimed his first Magpies goal, but was foiled by a fabulous save by Jack Butland.

Contributor
Contributor

Geordie journalist with itchy feet having lived in Tenerife, France, Belfast and Australia.