10 Star Trek Characters Who Died Off-Screen
For some, death was just the start but these characters never got to finish their story onscreen.
Star Trek has a propensity to kill off characters to then bring them back to life, be it on-screen or in Beta canon - looking at you Trip Tucker.
There has been several occasions when the deaths of characters have taken place off-screen, leaving fans questioning whether or not they've gone to meet the Great Bird of the Galaxy. However, one must always remember - no body, no death. All we need to do is look to Lower Decks' resurrection of Shax, or Picard's shock return by Ro Laren.
This does not include those characters who have been confirmed dead on-screen, only to 'somehow return' moments later.
We have assembled ten characters who may never get their swansong proper. The lack of ceremony at their demise leads to all sorts of possibilities and who knows, any one of those on this list could soon be unexpectedly stepping out of a shower to make an unexpected (but very welcome) return to the franchise.
10. Zhaban
The Morecambe to Orla Brady's Wise, Zhaban was a key member of Jean-Luc Picard's household in the first season of Picard, so much so that the prequel graphic novel to the series covered the pair's backstory.
Both Zhaban and Laris were former Tal'Shiar operatives involved with the events of the Romulan resettlement. They would eventually settle in La Barre with Picard, and the married pair managed his household while also providing next level security on the estate.
But season two dropped a huge bomb in the opening episode: Zhaban had died off screen some 18 months prior to The Star Gazer. This would be one of only a few mentions of the character in the second season, with most of those being in the opening episode. Though this left Laris open to a more personal relationship with Picard, it was a sudden, anti-climactic departure for an important character.
While the plan was to allow Picard to be open to new romantic possibilities, it wrote out one of the new and interesting characters created specifically for Picard and which related directly to events before the first season.
9. Gabriel Lorca
Season one of Discovery promised a captain who was going to be very different to any that fans had previously experienced. It's safe to say that the writers didn't slack there.
Gabriel Lorca was a cutting and cold captain, far moreso than Star Trek had ever portrayed in the centre seat, Edward Jellico notwithstanding.
The Mirror Universe reveal was a big swing for the show and in this case it certainly made contact. After teasing the audience for the first half of the season as to his true identity, they were then left with a single question:
Where's Prime Lorca?
The on-screen answer was that he was killed when the USS Buran was destroyed. However, remember that addage: no body, no death.
There's never been confirmation that Lorca was onboard at the time or that his remains were found. There have been repeated calls from the fanbase to reveal what exactly did happen to Prime Lorca and if he is indeed still out there, somewhere. With the 1000 year shift and soft reboot of Discovery for its third season that may well be one question that is never answered.
8. Ben Sisko (Mirror)
This one's in a similar vein to the "is he, isn't he" Lorca Factor but the opposite way round.
Deep Space Nine's second season episode Crossover dropped Kira and Bashir into the fabled Mirror Universe for the first time since 1967's Mirror, Mirror. A lifetime of changes had seen the Terran Empire fall and the rise of the Klingon/Cardassian Alliance. Kira is now in command of Terok Nor as the Intendant. Among her minions is one privateer Ben Sisko. That Sisko would swap sides and assist Kira and Bashir in returning to their universe. This would be his only appearance.
By the time that viewers took a second trip Through the Looking Glass, the Terrans needed Prime Sisko to step into the place of their Ben, following the latter's apparent death during an attempt to convince his estranged wife to leave Terok Nor.
While his ship was destroyed and lost with all hands, there's still no absolute proof of his demise. This means one simple thing - Mirror Sisko is still alive and well, potentially sipping jippers away from the front lines of the conflict.
7. Weyoun Five
Four was blasted by his own Jem'Hadar troops at the conclusion of To the Death, Six would die in the arms of Odo, hunted down by his successor, Seven would reach the end the line at the hands of Worf, while Eight would find himself on the wrong end of Garak's disrupter, bringing the Weyoun family to an ignoble end.
Perhaps the Weyoun with the most influence over the early days of the Dominion War, the fifth iteration of the Vorta overseer would first be seen in Ties of Blood and Water, returning later in the season as part of the force that took control of Deep Space Nine in Call to Arms. In total, Weyoun Five would appear 11 times across three seasons before being the victim of an off-screen transporter accident. A transporter accident that may or may not have been the work of Damar.
Now whether he was beamed somewhere utterly random or ended up in a similar situation to the unfortunate Commander Sonak in The Motion Picture is open to debate. However, the precedent of there being two clones of the same individual active at the same time was to be set in the seventh season of Deep Space Nine with Treachery, Faith and the Great River which would also help flesh out the back story of the Vorta race as a whole.
As there has never been any onscreen evidence of his remains, this Vorta may still be out there... somewhere.
6. Marla McGivers
The loss of your wife, much of your crew and being marooned for 15 years at the centre of a dead planet are never going to be good for the soul.
The story of Khan Noonien Singh is well told in the annals of Star Trek lore but it is sometimes forgotten that the 20th Century's engineered superman took a member of the Enterprise's crew with him to Ceti Alpha V.
Lt Marla McGivers was swayed by Khan to join Team Botany Bay with such wonderful requests as to "Sit and entertain me". However as The Wrath of Khan would reveal, McGivers would not long survive her new love affair.
She was among the 15 people killed by the Ceti eels, and thus would not appear in the movie sequel. Her fate would later be told through the graphic novel series recounting the experiences of the genetically engineered group's exile.
Actress Madlyn Rhue was confined to a wheelchair by 1982, suffering from multiple sclerosis, and was thus unable to appear. Sadly, she would receive no more mention than Khan exclaiming 'my beloved wife'.
Still, fans of Space Speed knew it was Marla, so she was remembered all the same.
5. Hoshi Sato
Here's the curveball entry for this list.
The communications and linguistics expert on the NX-01, Hoshi Sato would be a key part of the crew for the duration of the prequel series.
During season four's In a Mirror, Darkly, a graphic aboard the captured, universe-hopping USS Defiant confirmed that Sato died on Tarsus IV when starvation - and then genocide - ravaged the population.
Viewers accepted that most of the crew of the NX-01 would not still be alive in the time of The Original Series - almost one hundred years had passed after all - though is a rare occasion where the passing of one of said characters was confirmed.
Tarsus IV was the realm of one Kodos the Executioner. He acted to "save" as many as he could during the famine that swept the populace by killing those he saw as unfit to survive.
This information would only show up on this one graphic, though it still cements a horrid fact that Sato and her family died while one James T. Kirk would be among those who lived to tell of the events.
4. Ambassador Krajensky
Odo may indeed be the first Changeling to ever harm another but the shapeshifters aren't afraid to do some dirty work when the mood takes them.
A prime example is Ambassador Krajensky, played by Lawrence Pressman. From the jump, the ambassador has already been replaced, ready now to get to work on the Defiant. As the story comes to a close, there is no sign of the original man anywhere.
He gets a place here thanks to the fifth season's In Purgatory's Shadow and By Inferno's Light two-parter. They show that both General Martok and Doctor Bashir were replaced by Changelings with their "real" versions holed up on a prison asteroid.
This in turn suggests that instead of killing anyone they decided to impersonate, the Dominion were capturing anyone they saw. As Ambassador Krajensky's abduction occurred some 18 months to 2 years prior to this, his fate seems a little at odds with their usual MO.
Having said that, the Changeling who did replace him was more than willing to injure Odo aboard the Defiant, despite the assurances that 'no Changeling had ever harmed another.' Could this have been a rogue agent, acting outside the norm? Only the Founders truly know.
3. Sarek
The Vulcan ambassador has been a part of Star Trek lore since the second season of the classic show, appearing for the first time in Journey to Babel, reprising the role in The Search for Spock some 16 years later. It would be a role Mark Lenard would inhabit for a another two movies and two The Next generation episodes. The character would then go on to appear in the 2009 reboot, played by Ben Cross, and on Star Trek: Discovery, played by James Frain.
For now, wind the clock back to Unification. The seminal Spock-led story was produced as part of the 25th anniversary celebrations in 1991. In an attempt to understand why Spock has apparently defected to Romulus, Picard travels to see a dying Sarek, effectively making Unification Pt 1 a sequel to the third series episode Sarek. In that episode, Picard and the famous ambassador shared a mind-meld, cementing a close relationship for the rest of the Vulcan's life.
It is only when Picard and Data are ensconced within Romulan territory that they learn of Sarek's passing. It's almost second-hand news but as a viewer there is no absolute certainly that Sarek has passed. In this case, however, despite the rule we have been following, there is little doubt as to the truth of his death.
The death of the character was thematic. It was an on-screen depiction of the (then recent) passing of Star Trek creator Gene Roddenberry.
2. Calvin Hudson
Ben Sisko's old academy friend and Starfleet liaison to the Federation colonies on the Cardassian border, Hudson's loyalties to the Federation were pushed beyond their limit.
Turning to the Maquis, the former commander stunned his friend (literally) before heading off into the Badlands to fight the good fight.
Hudson himself would never be seen again onscreen. His fate was revealed in Deep Space Nine's fifth season episode Blaze of Glory. The equally side-switching Michael Eddington tells Sisko that Hudson was killed in action by the Jem'Hadar.
This incident is never seen on screen, and what is little more than a throwaway reference to a character they hadn't seen for three years accidentally becomes a tease for a shadowy return. Stranger things have happened, haven't they, Commander Ro?
If the character were to return, the show would have to recast, as actor Bernie Casey passed away in 2017.
The character had originally been slated for death at the end of The Maquis two-part story. It was originally a much more Hudson-centric story than filmed. In the end, Hudson would live for another day, not least since the opening of the season had seen the arrival, and equally quick demise, of Li Nalas.
1. Spock
Probably the only one on the list who actually died on-screen, returned, and then died off screen.
Spock's iconic demise in 1982's The Wrath of Khan was mirrored by Kirk's own death in 2012's Star Trek Into Darkness but the focus here is the third of the Kelvin Timelines series, Beyond.
Arriving at Starbase Yorktown, Zachary Quinto's Spock is approached by two robed Vulcans who inform him that Ambassador (Prime) Spock has passed. While this is a brilliant, deserved nod to the real life death of Star Trek veteran Leonard Nimoy, Spock has been "dead before" to quote The Undiscovered Country . There's no depiction of the event and while Vulcans don't lie, they do make errors or omissions, so this could well be an open book. After all, Spock is Patient Zero when it comes to returning from the beyond.
They literally made a film about it.
Spock Prime's on-screen passing could not be realised due to real world events. In a way, this is a shame, not to be ghoulish about the fact, but the franchise has handled death well time and time again. In any case, his appearances in both the 2009 reboot and Into Darkness secured the link between universes, providing a fitting epitaph for the most famous Vulcan - in any timeline.