10 Biggest Doctor Who 'What Ifs'
Doctor Who infinite possibilities. Ten 'what if' scenarios that could've happened!
It's always a fun notion delving into 'What if'. You're literally peeking into the wild imaginings of the mind-boggling multi-verse. Every decision we make could potentially create an entire sub-universe that revolves around that different outcome. The same can be said for a television series, especially one that prides itself in dabbling within the fourth dimension like Doctor Who.
There are many possible scenarios that can be altered if the opposite took place. Things that could literally change the course of Doctor Who as we know it. Scary really when you think too hard about 'what could be'. You only have to look at Turn Left, for instance, and see the damaging implications of what would've happened had Donna not been there to tell The Doctor to stop. In short, the world went to pot, and many of The Doctor's companions suffered as a consequence.
Things became even more frightening when delving into Big Finish's Anti-Genesis. In the fourth box set featuring Derek Jacobi's War Master, we saw what the universe would look like if the sadistic renegade bent reality to his design, namely altering the events of Genesis of the Daleks. Yeah, that storyline got dark pretty quickly. A lot of horrific scenes, and darkening imagery told within the audio format, demonstrating the harsher nature of 'what ifs'.
For better or for worse (or just plain curiosity) here's ten reality bending scenarios that ponders on different outcomes that could've fundamentally reconstructed Doctor Who into a completely different product. And, in some cases, create a very different journey for The Doctor to undertake.
10. What If The First Doctor Regenerated In The Celestial Toymaker?
It's no secret that William Hartnell became incredibly difficult to work with during his latter years on Doctor Who. Illness began to become a crux in his performance, toppled with his increase in frustration towards higher management. This reached its heights when John Wiles took over as producer from Verity Lambert. To put it bluntly, the two of them got on like a house on fire.
In fact, it got so bad that John Wiles couldn't even speak directly with William Hartnell. Tensions just kept rising as William Hartnell's difficulty became almost unbearable, making producing the show a headache inducing experience for John Wiles. This made him want to outright get rid of William Hartnell all together. In essence, this was the birth of regeneration. At least as a concept.
John Wiles tried to use Brian Hayles script, The Celestial Toymaker, to write out the star by having him become invisible due to the villain's fantastical powers within his imaginary reality. Upon returning to screen in a physical form William Hartnell was to be replaced by another actor, with the narrative reasoning explained as a by-product of the Celestial Toymaker's games. However, this idea never came to fluwision, forcing John Wiles to leave as producer after his failed attempts to rid William Hartnell from the role.
Things certainly would've been interesting had John Wiles had his way, kicking William Hartnell out the TARDIS five stories prior to his inevitable exit. Plus, regeneration wouldn't have been an established element, nor a reasoning behind The Doctor's sudden change, meaning the longevity of Doctor Who would be left in the air, with future producers being forced to come up with other bizarre scenarios to recast the pivitotal role.
9. What If The Tenth Doctor Regenerated In Journey's End?
One can't deny that the cliff-hanger to The Stolen Earth still stands as one of the greatest WTF moments on Doctor Who. Disappointingly, the entire scenario was just a rouse to get bums on seats the following week. Dick move Russell T Davies.
Basically we all thought that he'd committed a ballsy act. Tragically, he fell through on the promise of a surprise regeneration, and copped out within the first few seconds of Journey's End. So wouldn't it have been amazing had Russell T Davies actually gone through with recasting The Doctor during the Series 4 finale.
Sure, it would've been annoying on the part of David Tennant. I mean, The Stolen Earth isn't exactly a swansong. He'd literally go out like a bitch, as he clumsily ran towards Rose like a teenager in love, failing to remember that there's literally a Dalek invasion going on. Oh, wait, he's been shot. Had he then died, essentially the Tenth Doctor would've perished before he'd completed his end goal of saving the day, becoming a first for Doctor Who; having a Doctor go out in the midst of battle.
Again, a crap conclusion for David Tennant, but a fascinating advancement of the ongoing plot, especially with the notion of The Doctor caught in the middle of post-regeneration whilst trying to prevent realities destruction. At the very least the Tenth Doctor got to see Rose one last time (thus cheering him up after his long slump of depression) even if it did cost him his life. That and it would've cured his vanity issues.
8. What If The Ninth Doctor Returned For The Day Of The Doctor?
During the build up to the 50th Anniversary Steven Moffat stupidly ended up overworking himself. He was show-running Doctor Who and Sherlock at the same time! That's utter madness. At the very least the quality of Sherlock wasn't affected. If anything, Series 2 still remains the height of its popularity, before quickly sliding down a deep pit filled with mediocre writing. Then again, Doctor Who didn't fair up much better.
It's no surprise that the writing process for The Day of the Doctor became a nightmare for Steven Moffat. Heck, at one point he didn't even know whether he would have a single Doctor onscreen. So it could've easily become Clara Who (although it was already well on its way to becoming that). Christopher Eccleston naturally became the most challenging actor to get onboard, what with his notorious past experiences on the show.
A lot was riding on his decision to come back and reprise his role. In the end, sadly, Christopher Eccleston backed out of the project. This led to Steven Moffat panicking further, and becoming utterly desperate, resulting in him creating his own Doctor to fill in the void left by Eccleston's absence. Even though Paul McGann could've easily been brought in. But I digress.
Had the Ninth Doctor stood with his future selves, there would be no need for the late John Hurt to appear in the special. It's depressing when you consider his presence was only required due to a last minute change to the script. He wasn't originally intended. Just forced in due to circumstance. I guess it would've been nice to have Christopher Eccleston back onscreen with David Tennant and Matt Smith. At the same time, it would've been a saddening loss not having John Hurt appear as the War Doctor. Talk about a catch 22!
7. What If The Eighth Doctor Refused To Become A Warrior?
One of Steven Moffat's most disappointing decisions was retroactively taking the Eighth Doctor out of the Time War. Despite never being confirmed, it was always the natural assumption that Paul McGann's incarnation did in fact do battle with the Daleks. I mean, it made more sense than presuming that an unknown Doctor would be wriggled into pre-existing canon.
Luckily, Big Finish have done much to rectify this creative outcome by dabbling with the early years of the Time War. They've carefully got around Steven Moffat's alterations to the lore by having the Eighth Doctor get involved on his own terms. He never becomes a warrior. That becomes his stance on the situation, and his number one reasoning for not wanting to get dragged into the trenches.
The Eighth Doctor continuously chastises the Time Lords (particularly Cardinal Ollistra) for their participation within the ongoing conflict, particularly when he witnesses the carnage they cause, and the innocence that are forcefully caught in the middle. Time and time again he's shown how far they've fallen, becoming no better than the Daleks. In turn, he tries desperately to remain 'a good man', helping those in need.
Had he kept to his principles in The Night of the Doctor, thus refusing the Sisterhood of Karn' offer to make him a 'warrior', then it's fair to say that the universe would be in complete disarray. As history has told us (with some delves into the War Doctor's adventures via Big Finish) the Time War wouldn't have been resolved without The Doctor becoming the monstrous.
Maybe the Daleks would've eventually taken over all of reality. More likely, however, the Time Lords would've grown uncontrollable, finding more destructive, and hades ways of winning the Time War, without The Doctor being able to stop them.
6. What If The Daleks Never Existed?
It's difficult to contemplate a world without the Daleks. Ironically, they became the very essence that made Doctor Who popular. Sure, the creativity of the show's originality, and it's fantastical concepts certainly made it something worth checking out. But it wasn't until the Daleks arrival in the second serial that made Doctor Who a household name.
Their very presence has kept viewers coming back to Doctor Who for nearly six decades. For instance, everyone is always excited to see when a new Doctor will be pitted against the deranged pepper-pots, as this usually establishes what kind of Doctor we will be in for. It's almost like a rite of passage each incarnation must go through. Literally, each new actor who takes on the role await in anticipation for their chance at defeating the Daleks.
In another universe this may not have happened. Sydney Newman initiated Doctor Who when he was Head of Drama for the BBC, wishing to bring something new to the table, something that the corporation had never dared to do before. But he expressed that the newly formatted science-fiction series should avoid becoming dependent on bug-eyed monsters, straying away from the clichéd, and concentrate more on being an educational show that challenged the viewers.
Had Verity Lambert not been able to defend her case to allow Terry Nation's bold script to be produced, then the Daleks would never have seen the light of day. In turn, Doctor Who may not have held the longevity that it gained through the success of The Doctor's dreaded enemy.
5. What If Dr. Who Was Canon?
Strangely enough, they're actually fans out there who indulge in the idea that the Peter Cushing movies fit into the Whoniverse. Even though this is theoretically impossible due to some obvious semantics. Not to mention that the films are re-treads of previously established events, rather than an actual expansion of the show. Then there's the simple fact that Dr. Who isn't a Time Lord.
Although it's an exciting prospect to wonder what could've been had Peter Cushing been considered an actual Doctor. Considering Human Nature established the concept of Time Lords being able to lock away their Time Lord consciousness, whilst hiding away in a human body. The most likely way of this being considered canon is by establishing Dr. Who as an alternative version of the titular character from a parallel universe.
If you want to take it further, maybe Dr. Who is one of the thousands of potential pre-Hartnell Doctor's. Considering the Morbius Doctors have now been made canon, anything seems possible at this point. Failing that, you could say that somebody modelled the films off The Doctor's actual adventures, which happened to be released within the Whoniverse. Either way, it's actually a massive shame that the talents of Peter Cushing couldn't have been taken much further within the universe of Doctor Who.
4. What If The Second Doctor Wasn't Well Received?
This is actually a scary 'what if' scenario. The concept of regeneration was risky business for the producer Innes Lloyd back in 1966. As mentioned in a previous entry, the idea of changing the lead actor was pushed forward due to William Hartnell's uneasy working relationship on set with both the cast and crew.
Despite initially being discarded, the idea was kept on the table as William Hartnell's health didn't improve, and the new production team felt it was time to let their star go, as his acting ability gradually declined, to the point where he couldn't remember his lines. Not to mention his own wife worried about the strain Doctor Who was having on him.
Naturally, a huge burden was placed on Patrick Troughton's shoulders. Essentially, the future of the show rested on him. It was all riding on his ability to help ease the audience with this revolutionary transition, helping them to understand that The Doctor was still the same character, despite the glaring differences. Obviously, we know Patrick Troughton nailed it, and demonstrated that regeneration could work, allowing Doctor Who a new lease on life.
Unfortunately, like all decisions, there has to be a universe out there driven by the opposite course of events. One in which the Second Doctor was hated by audience members, sealing Doctor Who's fate, as BBC executives determined regeneration as a commercial failure. Had the ratings dropped I very much doubt Doctor Who would've been renewed for another season, thereby cancelled by 1967 after Season 4 came to a conclusion. A world were Patrick Troughton didn't succeed scarcely bares thinking about.
3. What If The Timeless Child Was The Master?
I can't seem to stay away from The Timeless Children. If you've read my previous articles, then you'll know I don't think too highly of Chris Chibnall's retcon. For me, the whole notion of the Time Lords being corrupt bastards is nothing new, and the addition of them stealing the powers of an innocent child is rather compelling to their shady background.
Unfortunately, the entire ordeal came crashing down when it was revealed that The Doctor is 'the Child'. This felt incredibly dumb to me, and undermined nearly sixty years of development for the iconic Time Lord. Oh wait - they're not a Time Lord anymore. Sigh...
If Chibnall was intent on having 'the Child' be revealed as an important character, why not have it be The Master instead? That, to me at least, could've served a greater meaning. Similar to how The Master became disgusted with knowing he held the same DNA as his sworn enemy, imagine how much worse it would've been for The Doctor. Having the blood of their greatest enemy flowing through their veins. That'd certainly shake things up for them.
Not to mention they'd be mortified by the mere notion that their gift of regeneration was at the cost of their old friend's suffering, adding on top of the cruel actions the Time Lord's had already publicly dealt The Master back in The End of Time. It may even make The Doctor sickened to their core that they've existed this long on the back of such hidden travesties, and even cause them to doubt ever regenerating again.
2. What If The TV Movie Was Successful?
I know for a fact that I'm in the minority when it comes to liking The TV Movie. Yes, I'm well aware of its flaws, and clear attempts to Americanise Doctor Who for a US based audience. But, in the films defence, it was being produced by an American network, with the intent to be shown on American television. It'd seem a bit strange making it appeal to an entirely different demographic, thus potentially alienating your primary viewers.
Had Paul McGann's original outing panned out well in the US then Doctor Who would certainly be a completely different beast today. Say goodbye to the 2005 reboot. That never would've happened. America would've gone full steam ahead and made it their own. If you're aware of the hellish pre-production The TV Movie went through, you'll know how much producer Philip Segal desperately wanted to pick up the series after its cancellation in 1989.
They went through multiple stages of development. If you look at the suggested proposals by writer John Leekley on how their rendition of Doctor Who was going to turn out you'd be blown away by how out there it was. To summarise, The Doctor and The Master were going to be revealed as brothers. Then the latter took control of the presidency, whilst the former searched for their father, Ulysses. Also, there were Spider Daleks! And other weird stuff.
Honestly, it's a miracle in itself that The TV Movie ended being as good as it did, with Matthew Jacobs taking things back to its roots, and away from the crazy bastardised reboot it could've easily become under 'the Leekley Bible'. However, it seemed likely that a lot of the earlier ideas probably would've remained had this variation of Doctor Who been allowed to move forward. Needless to say it would've been a rather interesting experience had this transpired - for better or for worse. Probably the latter.
1. What If Doctor Who Wasn't Cancelled?
Similar to my last entry, it's a question of 'what could've been' had behind-the-scenes drama ended on different terms. The former was it's damaging ratings. Okay, that can be said for the 1989 cancellation as well, but it's far more complicated than that.
This can all be pinned on Michael Grade. Not gonna lie, this guy infuriates me. He was supposed to be running the programming for the BBC, under the pretence that there must be something for everybody. After all, we all pay our licence fee. Well, maybe not so much now, but you get the point.
But, as it turns out, Michael Grade abused his position of power to eradicate Doctor Who, on the simple basis that he didn't like the show (or sci-fi in general). Everything that happened with Doctor Who in the late 80s felt so petty, resulting in Colin Baker being fired, an 18 month hiatus, budget cuts, and a reduced episode count. It was all so pathetic!
Despite Doctor Who getting its groove back during the Sylvester McCoy era, it was deemed productive to pull the plug entirely. Put the old Doc to sleep after he'd spent the last few years practically limping in order to live another day.
It's a shame really. Doctor Who could've gone to some interesting places. In fact, history would've repeated itself, as The Doctor's origins became the focus point of the storytelling moving forward under Andrew Cartmel (only with a bit more thought and care put into it). Not to mention that Ace would've been taken to the Academy to become a Time Lord, as well as a cat-thief becoming the next companion. Talk about a missed opportunity...
But then we wouldn't have been graced with the Virgin New Adventures novels. Paul McGann's Eighth Doctor. Big Finish. Russell T Davies' revival. All of these expansions would never have happened had Doctor Who continued in 1989. It's a case of apples and oranges, and which you'd rather have. Maybe a dip into the multi-verse might straighten out which timeline got the better deal.