10 Most Frustrating Decisions WWE Have Made This Year (So Far)

2025: the year in which WWE showed the difference between getting over and staying over.

WWE Elimination Chamber 2025 The Rock John Cena Travis Scott Cody Rhodes
WWE

What a difference a year makes.

Back in 2024, WWE looked untouchable. Cody Rhodes was riding high as the company's most popular babyface champion since Daniel Bryan, veteran performers like Liv Morgan and Jey Uso were having breakout years, and new signings to the roster were getting over faster than you could say "all gas, no brakes".

Halfway through 2025, however, it's becoming increasingly clear that WWE are starting to run on fumes.

To be fair, no promotion stays hot forever. However, WWE's cooling off period is all the more frustrating for how easily it could have been avoided. Rather than building on the success of the previous year, the company have allowed themselves to make the same mistake of every market leader in history: forgetting the practices that put them on top in the first place. Between dethroning popular champions, cooling off molten-hot heels and failing to capitalize on new signings, 2025 has seen wrestling's biggest promotion zig when it should have zagged, turn right when it made more sense to go left, and generally acted like the people in charge took their business lessons from a screening of The Producers.

However, while the leads in The Producers failed in their quest to create a flop, WWE have managed to one-up them by succeeding in their apparent quest to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory. After all, that would certainly explain decisions like...

Get 76% off, four free months, and a free Amazon gift card when you sign up to NordVPN here: http://go.nordvpn.net/aff_c?offer_id=564&aff_id=3013&url_id=31010&aff_sub1=WhatCulture

10. Doing Practially Nothing With IYO

WWE WrestleMania 41 Night 2 Iyo Sky
WWE

If you'll indulge a little workshop talk, the photos used in WhatCulture articles come from a carefully curated media library. As time marches on, new photos are added to the archive for authors' use - for example, there have been 10 new Liv Morgan photos added since WrestleMania weekend, and over a dozen ones featuring Rhea Ripley.

IYO Sky, on the other hand? Two. Two new photos in three months - a depressing statistic that sums up just how much WWE haven't been using one of their greatest performers (and RAW Women's Champion as of July 10, no less).   

Fresh off having the best WrestleMania match for the second year in a row, you'd think WWE would want their most in-form wrestler in action every single week. Yet in the past three months, WWE have barely given IYO screen time, let alone ring time. Yes, WWE have finally got the ball rolling by having her interact with Liv Morgan and Rhea Ripley recently, but that doesn't excuse the previous months of near-inactivity. What was the point of having IYO win at WrestleMania if the plan was to treat her like an afterthought?

IYO is arguably the best in-ring talent in the entire WWE, which makes it all the more baffling the company have kept the Genius Of The Sky grounded for so long.


9. Rushed NXT Call Ups

Roxanne Perez Giulia Iyo Sky
WWE

Oh right, IYO has actually wrestled since 'Mania- a tag team bout against NXT call-ups Giulia and Roxanne Perez. As the above photo implies, the encounter didn't end well for IYO as G N' R ran through her like a night train.

You'd have thought this would have led to a lengthy tag team run for the newcomers, but it was not to be. Giulia was sent to Smackdown, Roxanne went to RAW, and everybody apparently agreed to pretend the whole tag team thing never happened.

As time passes, it's more and more obvious that WWE didn't have a plan for the uber-talented duo when they made the decision to bring them to the main roster. They may be doing well individually - Giulia is now the United States' Women's Champion and Roxanne has embedded nicely into Judgement Day - but that just makes it all the clearer that WWE had no idea what they were doing when they brought the pair in as a tag team.

It's a trend that has unfortunately continued as the year's worn on. Fraxiom have gone from being presented as the world's greatest tag team on NXT to getting mired in the midcard morass that is Smackdown's tag divison. Meanwhile, Stephanie Vaquer's shocking call-up may have been great for her, but it left NXT's women's division far worse for wear as WWE hadn't built up a suitable replacement for her before she left.


8. Muted Returns

Aleister Black The Miz
WWE.com

The above photo sees Aleister Black wondering if it was worth burning every bridge he built in AEW to be stuck in a feud with The Miz. To quote Bart Simpson, "You can actually pinpoint the second his heart rips in half".

To be fair, Black did quickly move on from WWE's resident punching bag. But two months into his return, one of the company's most prodigal sons hasn't exactly set the world alight despite rumours of a big push. Here's hoping his upcoming feud with Ron Killings leads to better things.

As for Rusev, WWE's other returning wanderer, things aren't much better. Since returning in April he's been lost in the midcard shuffle on RAW. His recent battle with Sheamus was a definite plus, but one highlight every couple of months doesn't exactly scream "Marquee Star" - and the fans in the building didn't care much for it. 

Having said that, of all the entries on this list this is the one where WWE's logic is easiest to parse. Given both stars' propensities for complaining about the grass being greener on both sides of the AEW/WWE jump fence, you can understand why the latter company would want to make sure the pair are committed for the long haul this time around.


7. Poorly Thought Out Releases

Carlito WWE
WWE.com

And so we go from returns to releases. But in this case, WWE's actions are far harder to understand.

Let's get the obvious one out of the way - R-Truth should never have been released. WWE's resident national treasure is beloved by both the crowd and damn near everyone in the locker room, and the people in charge had to have been entirely divorced from reality to think nobody would notice if he was released. Thankfully, those people changed their mind sharpish when they realised the depth of their mistake. R-Truth/Ron Killings is back on TV.

One person who won't be returning, however, is Carlito. The Puerto Rican superstar's departure may not have been as explosive as R-Truth's, but in terms of displaying the company's current storytelling weaknesses, it's arguably more potent. 

Despite starting a will-they, won't-they romance with Raquel Rodriguez, Carlito was quietly dropped with nary an explanation.  Despite the storyline perfectly teeing up Carlito's departure - Raquel rejects Carlito, beats the crap out of him and powerbombs him through a table/off the stage - WWE inexplicably failed to follow through on the one-inch putt they'd set up. 

The fact Carlito was simply let go with no closure to his run is a worrying indicator of WWE's increasingly blasé approach to hiring and firing its talent - not a great look for a company that's supposedly undergoing a renaissance boom period.


6. Dropping Big E From The New Day Storyline

Big E
WWE

WWE's woeful handling of New Day's heel turn is going to be the subject of many an article in the future. But while thousands of words could be written on the subject, let's keep this article entry brief by focusing on the major point of contention:

What the hell happened to Big E?

Big E was the crux for New Day's descent into heeldom, as Kofi and Xavier turning their back on the universally loved Large Epsilon was what transformed them into the most despised act in the WWE. Yet New Day's newfound heat dissipated with alarming rapidity as WWE quickly forgot about the pair's spurned former partner.

Without Big E, New Day's turn floundered, and the duo have been struggling to connect with the audience (check out their largely heatless 'Mania match for proof, or the non-event that was them losing the titles to Judgement Day). Yes, Big E can't take a bump, but there are any number of ways WWE could use him. Have him manage an opposing team. Have Kofi and Xavier invade his family home. Heck, simply have New Day slap the mic out his hand at a press conference. That didn't happen, and now New Day are just another member of WWE's lukewarm tag roster.


5. Everything About Travis Scott

Travis Scott Cody Rhodes
WWE

Travis Scott's relationship with the WWE has been one of the worst celebrity collaborations in the history of the company.

Things didn't get off to a great start with Travis Scott breaking Cody's eardrum during John Cena's heel turn, but that can be explained as an unfortunate byproduct of having a non-wrestler not knowing how to throw a worked slap. Far less excusable is the decision to have him out there in the first place, which generated the same level of bafflement WrestleMania XVII would have if the closing image of that show had been Britney Spears standing in the ring and nodding approvingly at Stone Cold and Vince McMahon's handshake.

Then there was the decision to have Scott involved in the main event of WrestleMania 41, which pissed off the fanbase no end. The rapper's involvement was a blatantly transparent effort to generate a buzz that failed to materialize, and achieved little more than irritating the people who watch WWE for the actual wrestlers. 

And now, with Travis Scott having gone MIA in the months since, his involvement is looking less Rock N' Wrestling and more Marcus the PSP Kid.


4. Pushing Charlotte. Again.

WWE Royal Rumble 2025 Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

For years, Charlotte Flair was one of WWE's most polarizing wrestlers. Some fans believed her phenomenal in-ring talent warranted her astonishingly high number of individual title reigns (16 at time of writing), whereas others felt that her ridiculous number of championship wins made her wrestling's answer to Poochie.

Nowadays, things are much more simple - everyone just wants her to stay firmly in the midcard.

To be clear, this isn't a knock on the woman behind the character (If you haven't read it already, Ashley Fliehr's moving Player's Tribune article makes it abundantly clear why fans need to separate the wrestlers we see on TV from the people portraying them). However, Charlotte's decade of dominance means that most fans are ready to see other wrestlers replace her in the spotlight.

WWE Creative, however, are not most fans. 

Instead, they booked Charlotte to win the Royal Rumble immediately after returning from a lengthy injury lay-off - complete with pyro for her entrance, no less. Unfortunately, rather than making the audience bow to the returning queen, the pageantry immediately turned WWE fans against Charlotte as they revolted against the idea of WWE once more forcing Charlotte into the title scene. What followed was a fiasco of a feud with Tiffany Stratton, as Charlotte failed to adjust to the fact the audience viewed her as the bad guy. The result? 

Some of the most awkward promos in professional wrestling history, and a match that failed to live up to the level either women is capable of.


3. Women's United States Championship Is The New 24/7 Belt

Chelsea Green Piper Niven
WWE.com

When Chelsea Green triumphed in the tournament to crown the inaugural Women's United States Champion, the future of the new belt looked brighter than the night sky on the fourth of July. Chelsea was - and is - an utter treat of a performer who guarantees entertainment whenever she's on camera, and WWE couldn't have asked for a better advertisement for the new belt (look at what she's wearing in the above photo for proof).

And then she lost it on free TV to Zelina Vega four months later, in a move that has only made less and less sense over time.

Why did WWE create a new faction for Chelsea in March (the brilliantly named Secret Hervice), only to strip her of the title in April? Why was the switch done on free TV, instead of a PPV/PLE? Why did WWE take the belt off one of the most over women on the roster to give it someone who doesn't share Chelsea's connection with the audience?

Ending Chelsea's championship run in such an anticlimactic fashion only weakened the title's credibility in the eyes of the average wrestling fan (compare and contrast with the Women's Intercontinental Championship, which changed hands at Money in the Bank and was won by legitimate megastar Becky Lynch). Rather than building the Women's US Title up to mean something, WWE's slipshod treatment of the belt has already devalued it into a prop to pass among midcard talent with nothing better to do.

Here's hoping Giulia's run can imbue the strap with some much needed gravitas, or the Women's United States Championship is going to be merged with its Intercontinental sister faster than you can say "24/7 Championship".


2. 51 Days

WWE Raw Jey Uso Gunther
WWE

On the subject of disappointing championship reigns...

Rikishi may have been too close to the subject, but he was right to blast WWE for showing a baffling lack of faith in Jey Uso as a champion (hell, even Kofi Kington managed to get past SummerSlam before getting screwed by the booking committee). After becoming arguably the most over wrestler on the roster, Jey's ultimate reward was a reign that lasted less than two months and saw him dropping the belt back to the guy he beat at WrestleMania. 

Again, WWE's logic is hard to parse here. Yes, Jey's in-ring abilities aren't on the same level as the majority of his main event peers. But he's a fantastic promo, and Triple H actually defended Jey's rise to the top by stating his connection to the crowd superseded his relative lack of ability. Apparently, WWE's CEO changed his mind in the two months between making that argument and booking Jey to drop the title...

Given that Jey's connection with the audience remains as strong as ever, it's hard not to come to the conclusion that WWE demoted him solely due to a lack of faith in his wrestling abilities. Which is especially remarkable when you consider who's holding the other major men's championship belt... 


1. Turn Cena Heel ---> ??? ---> Profit!

John Cena CM Punk Pipebomb 2025
WWE.com

To screw up one heel turn may be regarded as a misfortune. To screw up two looks like carelessness.

Yes, the sole positive of John Cena's heel turn is that it takes some of the heat off WWE's inability to capitalize on New Day's descent into the dark side. Which is a bit like breaking your nose to distract from the pain of a twisted ankle, but such is the state of WWE booking these days - a relentless series of self-inflicted injuries.

The longer John Cena's heel run has lasted, the more evident it's become that there was no plan beyond the initial turn. The Rock, the man who convinced John to turn in the first place, has been inexplicably absent since (and no, his excuse of not wanting to upstage John and Cody doesn't wash - if that were true, he shouldn't have been part of the storyline in the first place). Cena's heel promos have been woefully inconsistent, and his ability to work matches as a heel is questionable at best.

It's telling that the only positives to come from Cena's work the past few months are when he's teased turning back to the light side. WWE may have a happy ending in mind for the Cena saga, but it's going to have to be one hell of a conclusion to justify the months wasted on a heel turn that the fans didn't want and the people involved couldn't execute.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Hello! My name's Iain Tayor. I write about video games, wrestling and comic books, and I apparently can't figure out how to set my profile picture correctly.